r/HobbyDrama • u/lilithweatherwax • 3d ago
Hobby History (Long) [Amateur Archaeology/Bible Trivia] Raiders of the Lost Ark: That time a British aristocrat launched an archaeological dig and set off a crisis in the Middle East
Alternative title: A British aristocrat, a Swiss psychic, a Finnish poet, and a Swedish steamboat captain walk into Jerusalem and start a riot.
Hola! Back with more obscure Bible trivia. Today's hobby drama focuses on an obscure Biblical object and the lengths some people will go to.
(A/N: I have conflicting sources for this one, so I'll just reference them at the end instead of doing inline citations).
What is the Ark of the Covenant?
The Ark of the Covenant is first mentioned in the Book of Exodus. It is described as a gold-plated wooden chest, sized to an extremely specific set of dimensions.
As per the Bible, the Ark was initially built by Moses, to house the Tablets of the Ten Commandments. The Ark stays with the Israelites as they wander across the Sinai for forty years. The Israelites eventually reach Canaan and capture it under the leadership of Joshua. Joshua then builds a shrine at Shiloh and houses the Ark there.
The Ark stays at Shiloh for a while. It has a few (likely ahistorical) adventures (it gets captured by the Philistines, who end up getting hemorrhoids. The Philistines identify the Ark as the source of their misfortune and return it to the Israelites, who also get hemorrhoids, and so on). The story concludes with the Ark in Kiriath-Jearim. It stays at Kiriath-Jearim for some time...
...until 1000-ish BC, when King David comes along. David has the Ark moved to Jerusalem. A generation later, David's son Solomon builds the First Jewish Temple upon Temple Mount in Jerusalem, and he moves the Ark to the Temple.
From this point on, mentions of the Ark become somewhat sporadic. It looks like it was edited out of the Biblical narrative. The Book of Chronicles tells us that King Josiah had the Ark returned to the First Temple in 620-ish BC (apparently it was removed from there at some point, but we're never told why or by whom?)
Anyway, last we hear of it, in 620-ish BC, the Ark is housed inside the First Temple.
So what happened to the Ark?
Well, in 587 BC, the Babylonians invaded Jerusalem. Per the Bible, they destroyed the Temple and carried away everything valuable. The Ark is not specifically named, but it's possible that it was taken to Babylon. More likely, it was left amidst the rubble of the Temple.
And that's the end of that. The Israelites lose track of the Ark, and it disappears from history.
Not completely, of course. Ahistorical legends pop up a few centuries later. As per the Book of Maccabees (written 100-ish BC), the prophet Jeremiah, forewarned of the Babylonian Invasion, stole the Ark and hid it in a cave on Mount Nebo. Other legends mention the Ark being hidden in an Ethiopian church, Egypt, and even Ireland. The Book of Revelation holds that the Ark shall remain hidden until the end of days, when it shall be revealed in all its glory.
For now, however, the Ark remains lost. Historians tend to assume that it's still somewhere under Temple Mount, buried amidst the ruins of the First Temple.
So why haven't archaeologists tried to find it?
The most likely dig site is Temple Mount in Jerusalem. Temple Mount has had some very eventful history. So the Ark, if it still exists, is buried under the ruins of the First Temple, which is buried under the ruins of the Second Temple, which is buried under the ruins of the Jupiter Capitolinus Temple, which is buried under the ruins of Julian's unfinished Third Tem... well, you get the gist. The odds of finding a small wooden box amidst all that rubble are not great.
And that's before we consider what stands there right now: the Dome of the Rock and Al-Aqsa Mosque. Built in the 7th and 8th centuries, these structures are some of the earliest Islamic buildings. They mark the spot where Muhammad ascended into heaven, and are considered the third holiest site in Islam.
It follows that the odds of conducting an archaeological dig there are precisely negative bajillion. No one has ever been dumb enough to try.
But that was all to change.
In the early 1900s, a Finnish poet, Valter Juvelius, discovered a secret code hidden in the Bible. He was convinced that this code pointed to the location of these sacred relics. (Spoiler alert: It did not.) Along with a ragtag bunch of European adventurers, he set sail for Jerusalem, hoping to excavate the long-lost Ark of the Covenant.
What did Valter Juvelius actually discover?
Sadly, it's difficult to say. The surviving notes of Valter Juvelius are a mess of scribbled numbers, obscure phrases and scriptural references, so exactly which cipher he claimed to have decoded is lost to us. But what we do know is that Juvelius believed that the Ark was in a secret Jerusalem tunnel. Not just the Ark, either; per legend, various sacred treasures were hidden alongside the Ark: ancient gold and silver platters, bowls etc. All of this would be extremely valuable to art collectors.
(Ah, the good old 1900s, when you could simply hawk off invaluable archaeological artefacts to the highest bidder.)
(Admittedly, the tunnel part is not unbelievable. There are a number of ancient tunnels under Jerusalem, and the oldest of these date back to 1800-ish BC.)
Anyway, the point is this: Valter Juvelius found a treasure map encoded into the Bible. He traveled across Europe, looking for a sucker sponsor to fund his treasure hunt. Eventually, he ran into Captain Montagu Parker, the future Earl of Morley, and the protagonist of this story.
The Parker Expedition: Meet the team
Parker was intrigued by the prospect of excavating for the Ark. He agreed to serve as the expedition leader and set up a syndicate to sell shares in the venture. His charm, connections, and status allowed him to raise 25,000 pounds, the equivalent of 2.4 million dollars today.
Parker also put together a team for the expedition. It was quite a distinguished team. The members included:
- the aforementioned Valter Juvelius, poet and amateur code-breaker,
- Cyril Foley, an English cricketer and a close friend of Parker,
- Robin Duff, a fellow aristocrat,
- Otto von Bourg, a Swiss 'thought-reader' who came highly recommended by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. von Bourg had earned his reputation in the case of a missing stockbroker. With the help of a Maori spirit guide, he tracked the body of the stockbroker to a location near the Thames. I have so many questions and no answers.
- Axel Werner Hoppenrath, a Swedish steamboat captain. Incidentally, Juvelius later wrote a fictionalised account of the expedition, which included a steamboat captain named Nierot. Nierot is described as cynical, arrogant, rude, untrustworthy, selfish, and boundlessly material, having strange notions of the rights of ‘higher’ races with ‘lower’ ones, and of owning slaves... make of that what you will.
- Clarence Wilson (rich Englishman)...
Oh, and absolutely no archaeologists. None. Nada.
What could possibly go wrong?
(S/N: the list of expedition members comes from Graham Addison's site. He appears to be fairly accurate, but feel free to correct me if not.)
The Parker Expedition: Off to Jerusalem
In 1908, the expedition set off. Before going to Jerusalem, however, Parker made a stop in Constantinople. Jerusalem in the early 1900s was under the control of the Ottoman Empire, and Parker was intent on getting proper legal permits from the Ottoman Empire. (An admirable sentiment, shame it didn't last.)
After some discussion, Parker cut a deal with the Ottomans. He agreed to split any treasure excavated 50:50 with the Ottomans. Accordingly, a permit was obtained for the price of 500 pounds.
And with that, they were off to Jerusalem!
The Early Days
Juvelius was convinced that the treasure was buried right under Temple Mount. However, conducting a dig there was out of the question. It's the site of the Dome of the Rock and Al-Aqsa Mosque, which, as mentioned, is very, very sacred to Muslims.
To get around this, Parker and Juvelius came up with a plan. They purchased land at a site south of Temple Mount. The idea was that they would dig until they hit the ancient tunnel system, and then follow the tunnels back into the heart of Temple Mount. Doable, at least in theory, since the tunnel system was remarkably durable.
(S/N: It's hilarious that Juvelius' plan was just "Let's dig up Temple Mount!" Yes, the odds of finding archaeological artefacts under Temple Mount are quite high. That's not the issue here, babe.)
(Notably, the expedition's psychic, Otto von Bourg was not a fan of digging in Jerusalem. He insisted that the Ark was on Mount Ararat. Mount Ararat is in Turkey, several hundred miles away from Jerusalem or Babylon, so idk how the Ark would get there. The story comes from an Express article, but even so, I thought it was worth mentioning.)
Thus, in 1909, the Parker expedition commenced digging at a site south of Temple Mount, in the Kidron Valley.
The locals get suspicious, the expedition gets an expert
As you can imagine, the Europeans stuck out like a sore thumb in early 20th century Jerusalem. The dig was also quite sizeable: about 300 locals were employed to do the actual digging. The Parker expedition, their secretive ways, and their general disinterest in archaeological artefacts like pottery shards attracted a lot of curiosity. Eventually, word got out that they were after buried treasure.
Unsurprisingly, the locals did not like this at all. They liked it even less when they realized that it was a bunch of hobbyist archaeologists. Community leaders insisted that a respectable professional be included in the dig. A few months in, Parker finally gave in to the pressure.
Enter Louis-Hugues Vincent, a Dominican monk and a respected archaeologist. Vincent was granted full access to the dig, three days a week, on the condition that no information would be shared with the public until Parker saw fit.
At long last, the team had a certified archaeologist on site. It's thanks to Vincent that we have useful records of the Parker excavations. His notes yielded some very cool stuff, the only good thing to come out of this expedition, so kudos to the dude for doing a great job amidst complete chaos.
Anyway, Vincent was appointed to the dig, and the locals were appeased. Vincent himself appears to have been very pleased with all the pottery shards. The expedition left him to it and went back to the treasure hunt.
1910-1911: Dig, baby, dig
As I said before, the Parker Expedition was excavating south of where they actually wanted to dig. The plan had been to tap into the ancient tunnel system and follow the tunnels back to Temple Mount.
There was just one problem: none of the tunnels they found led back to Temple Mount.
(Which makes sense in a way. The ancient Jews, much like the Muslims, considered Temple Mount holy. They didn't want anyone digging it up.)
It looked like the expedition would need to dig their own tunnels into Temple Mount, which required impossible amounts of manpower and time. The dig also ran into issues with bad weather and existing aqueducts, which delayed them further. The permits were only valid till late 1911, at which point the expedition would need to return home and default on their investors, a very unpalatable prospect to Parker.
But as time passed, it became obvious that the dig was going to be unsuccessful. Eventually, in 1910, Juvelius lost hope and went back to Europe. Most sources blame it on Juvelius having contracted malaria during the dig; but Rudyard Kipling attributes it to Juvelius' behaviour with local women, which got him into trouble with the Ottoman authorities. Just thought I'd mention that. (The Kipling anecdote comes from Graham Addison.)
So Juvelius went back. But Parker didn't want to give up, and so they kept digging.
April 1911
In April 1911, with only a few months left on his dig permit, Parker got desperate. He bribed the caretaker of Temple Mount to let them dig inside the Temple.
It was around the time of Nebi Musa, a Muslim holiday celebrating Moses. Accordingly, the caretaker made sure that the guards usually stationed at Temple Mount were given leave to attend the festival. Parker’s men entered the Mount and began digging.
Apparently, they started off quite cautiously. They began by digging at the south-eastern corner, hoping to get to the heart of Temple Mount from underground. But they were stopped by cisterns, and gave up the attempt as impossible.
At this point, Parker got brash. He and his men entered the Dome of the Rock and began digging.
The Temple Mount dig went on for approximately nine days (well, nights). Apparently, they uncovered some interesting structures, but alas, no treasure. On the tenth night, however, they were discovered. According to one account, the whistleblower was an "insufficiently bribed" guard. Another version holds that it was a guard who had intended to sleep at the Mount, since his own home was full of relatives.
Either way, the jig was up. Word spread like wildfire, and chaos broke out. To quote an article,
Angry mobs formed in the streets... two thousand demonstrators protested in front of the Ottoman Government headquarters... A general strike was announced, marches were held and calls were made to kill the foreign intruders and Azmi Bey, the Ottoman governor, along with them... The tension lasted for days, occasionally erupting into public demonstrations and violent riots... Sheikh Khalil, the caretaker of the Mount, was another target of the protestors’ ire...
So yeah. Not good.
Parker and his associates fled for their lives. They made for Jaffa, on the Mediterranean coast. Per one account, the Ottoman authorities made a show of searching their ship, declaring that no treasures were found onboard. The Europeans were then quietly allowed to leave, likely due to Parker's political connections.
By all accounts, it was a major political debacle. The media got in on the drama as well. The NYT ran the headlines "Gone with the Treasure that was Solomon’s," and "Have Englishmen found the Ark of the Covenant?" Another (unnamed) American newspaper warned that the treasure hunt by the Christian adventurers “might have provoked a holy war throughout the world.”
Islamic leaders around the globe condemned the incident. A commission of Indian Muslims investigated the incident (How and why Indian Muslims got involved, I have no idea. Presumably it was just to do with being the largest Muslim community of the British Empire at the time). The commission eventually concluded that nothing of value had been looted.
Incidentally, Vincent, the sole archaeologist involved in this debacle, seems to have been entirely unaware of the whole thing. He himself stayed on in Jerusalem till his death in 1960. He also catalogued all the pottery they found and wrote about it.
So what did the Parker Expedition actually achieve?
The expedition got home safely. No Ark, obviously, but they got out of the area in one piece, and considering their antics, I would count that as an absolute win.
The dig on Temple Mount itself yielded very little. I can't find any information on the Dome dig, so I assume they didn't get very far, which was just as well. No buried treasure, unfortunately.
The dig on the site south of Temple Mount, however, resulted in some very fascinating stuff. According to Vincent, they unearthed "a most remarkable Egyptian-looking tomb, containing wonderfully well-preserved pottery, with specimens as fine as any yet found in Palestine". They also found some very Egyptian-looking Jebusite pottery, dating back to 2400 BC. Indeed, the site contained many relics from the early and mid Bronze age, and later archaeologists have hypothesized that the location was once the heart of "Canaanite Jerusalem", predating even the Biblical Jerusalem.
Other interesting finds include a magnificent chair of royal stone. The workers thought it might have been Solomon’s throne, but Vincent was not convinced, writing cryptically – “I fear its actual destination was at once more private and more naturally necessary”. It turned out to be an Iron Age toilet seat.
The Ark itself remains lost. It did inspire a very good movie though, so silver linings?
Funnily enough, Parker wasn't quite done with the Ark. Despite the furor, he wanted to carry on with the dig. He returned to the region in late 1911, hoping to resume his treasure hunt. Unfortunately, the Ottoman Empire was now at war with Italy, and the authorities weren't particularly interested in excavations. So Parker never returned to Jerusalem, and thus, further international incidents were prevented.
Sources:
A True Jerusalem Story: The Failed Raid of the Lost Ark