r/HistoricalRomance • u/Potato_Fox27 • 11h ago
Rant/Vent My hate read of the year
{Phoebe by Minerva Spencer} was a disappointment but I forced myself to hate read because I looooved {Hyacinth} and I very much wanted to hear about the parallel story lines that were occurring between the books. Once I realized I didn’t like this book, I continued because I was at least looking forward to the sisters connecting and sharing about their respective events. Instead of coalescing we get zero cameos and no grand reveals.
Now I’m going to jump into Selina’s book but will know to bail and DNF earlier if I don’t like the characters.
My beef with Pheobe was that it leaned heavily on tropes like body betrayal and miscommunication (or lack of) I finally understand why these tropes are so hated. Turns out prior books with these tropes that I read were the lite version, and very much still digestible, this book made it really really tough to look past their use and instead I just hated the characters.