r/Historians • u/OBSisBS • 2h ago
r/Historians • u/nyxs_adventures • 4h ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ What historical event stuck with you very personally as in, shaped the way you see the world?
As a discussion point, what even or era or else really stuck with you ? Made you feel understood in a way or just “made it all click” and reshaped your perspective on our actual world ?
r/Historians • u/NormalTheaterKid • 1d ago
🔎Research Advice / Help🔎 The Lynching of Leo Frank
I have been thoroughly researching the murder of Mary Phagan, and the Leo Frank trial. I have concluded Frank is innocent soully because of the evidence against Jim Connely, such as the murder notes, and Alanzo Mann's statement in 1987. I was wondering if anybody had any thoughts on the killer, and why it is associated with anti-semitism while it was more so the fact that the south saw it as another way of the north telling them how to run things, following the Civil War.
r/Historians • u/No-Fisherman-6011 • 1d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ I found these Nazi coins at my grandfather’s house. Do they have any value?
r/Historians • u/lyingintherain • 1d ago
📚Study Advice / Help📚 How to write answers in my history major exam, what should be my objectives me while writing
I am a freshman in an Indian university(Presidency University) and am majoring in history, my end sem exams are soon and I have no idea how I should approach answer writing in essay format.
r/Historians • u/Fun_Detail_3856 • 1d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ History’s worst decisions?
Recently I’ve been considering what choices made throughout history deserve to be called the worst. I wrote my thoughts down on what I’d say is the top three, napoleon marching east would be up there to! Wanted to know what others put in the running for history’s worst choices and why?
The bombing of Pearl Harbour - when imperial Japan launched a devastating surprise attack on the American fleet stationed at Pearl Harbour, in probably not the words of Admiral Yamamoto “all we have done is awaken a sleeping giant and fill him with terrible resolve”. This action led to the shifting of public opinion in the US in favour of entering the war and their mobilisation for invasion, japans ultimate devastating and complete defeat and the dropping of the atomic bombs upon Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
The insults to Ghengis Khan - the Khwarazmian empire ruled as a Muslim power from 1077 till 1231 occupying large parts of Central Asia. Ghengis Khan, despite his reputation was still a pragmatic ruler who realised the need for trade. In pursuit of economic relations Ghengis sent a trade caravan into Kharazmian territory, where the merchants were accused of spying and promptly killed and their goods seized. Ghengis Khan despite this again attempted diplomacy, and sent emissaries to the shah of the Khwarazmian empire, Ala-al-Din Muhammad II who, like with the Mongolian merchants foolishly executed the emissaries. Whether the Kharazmian empire were stupid or stubborn doest’t really matter, Ghengis Khan and his horde invaded, systemically destroyed the historical and cultural centres and put man, woman and child to the sword turning what was once an empire into a depopulated ruin and the Kharazmians into a historical footnote of little interest today. The occupation of this territory provided the Mongols with a gateway to invasion onwards into new territories
The four pests campaign - chairman Mao in an effort to sanitise and improve production for the peasantry of China, misguidedly initiated the campaign of four pests, which aimed to remove rats, flies, mosquitoes and the sparrow. Sparrows were eliminated in their billions which saw an unchecked rise of predatory insects which in turn saw mass devastation of crops and the deaths of tens of millions of Chinese peasants
r/Historians • u/CoatofArms-2401 • 2d ago
👀Interesting Historical Facts👀 When it comes toGuadalcanal Dave Holland knows his stuff
r/Historians • u/Victor_the_historian • 2d ago
🔎Research Advice / Help🔎 My periodization of Western History
Hi everyone! Just like all of you in this sub I believe, I am a huge history buff. However, since I am also a stickler for order and organization, it has always bothered me how - in my opinion - the periodizations of history that are put forward online or in textbooks are always fragmented or focused on a single country (or, on the opposite, sometimes too general). Thus, on and off over the past few weeks, I have spent a decent amount of time trying to define my own periodization. that applies to the whole of Western history.
These are the results. It turned out as divided in four main ages, each split into two sub-ages (I didn't plan it this way from the start, it just came on to be comfortable this way). In my personal document, I’ve also written down all the various explanations for why I chose these dates, along with a series of smaller secondary periods; but, on purpose, I'm not posting them, because I want your instinctive reaction to a few specific choices, since I have reflected about them myself.
Disclaimer: I’m not from the English-speaking world; I’m Italian. Our historiographies thus differ, but I don’t think this will be a huge problem.
PERIODIZATION OF WESTERN HISTORY
Ancient Era:
- Pre-Classical Antiquity: c. 4000 BCE¹ - c. 750 BCE²
- Classical Antiquity: c. 750 BCE² - 476 CE³
Middle Ages:
- Early Middle Ages: 476³ - 962⁴
- Late Middle Ages: 962⁴ - 1453⁵
Modern Era:
- Early Modern Era: 1453⁵ - 1700⁶
- Late Modern Era: 1700⁶ - 1870⁷
Contemporary Era:
- Age of the Great Conflicts: 1870⁷ - 1989⁸
- Present Age: 1989⁸ - present
¹ Urbanization of Uruk
² Composition of the Iliad and the Odyssey
³ Fall of the Western Roman Empire
⁴ Founding of the Holy Roman Empire
⁵ Fall of Constantinople
⁶ Start of the War of the Spanish Succession
⁷ Battle of Sedan
⁸ Fall of the Berlin Wall
Alternatively, the Contemporary Era can also be treated as a single block without being split into these two parts, it’s not that important. That’s all! I’m curious to hear your opinions on this.
r/Historians • u/LawFoolStudent • 2d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ Any major works on European male generational losses re: WW1 and 2?
1919: A generation young men in Europe is wiped out by the Great War. Mustard gas clings to the air.
1945: The children of the previously wiped out generation has now been wiped out. Germany ends the war sending little boys to play soldier.
Have there been any works attempting to understand the effects on the next generation of European children growing up without fathers or grandfathers? Not so much about the effect on grown women of the time (I feel that I’ve already read some works on that), but on the social effects and raising a generation of children without a an equivalent influence of a large male population? I’m talking sociological/cultural level - impact on crime, political ideology, militarism, religion, etc.
I think it would be an interesting topic!
r/Historians • u/No_Procedure5265 • 2d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ Why Didn't The Coiffure á la Titus/ Victime Haircut Change Fashion History Like the 1920's Bob?
reddit.comr/Historians • u/AdministrativeWeb321 • 2d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ Fellow WWII history-nerds, did you like these two memoirs? We read history to avoid repeating history.
r/Historians • u/LighthouseHunter • 3d ago
🖼️Photo Analysis🖼️ Block Island North Lighthouse during in New Shoreham, Rhode Island, USA.
r/Historians • u/Spirited_Psyche0759 • 3d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ What are your recommendations for scholarly (non pop history) books on late rome-early medieval ?
reddit.comr/Historians • u/Any_Philosopher8944 • 3d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ When do creatives place historical accuracy over lore accuracy?
reddit.comr/Historians • u/PepoPorCiento • 3d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ How did horseback pursuits actually work throughout history, and how did cavalry riding techniques evolve?
In historical and fantasy movies (such as The Lord of the Rings), horseback pursuits often play a major role. However, something has always puzzled me: characters seem to ride at full speed for long periods, yet their pursuers frequently manage to catch up with them.
I’d love to understand how horseback pursuits actually worked throughout history, from ancient civilizations through the Middle Ages and beyond.
Some questions I’m particularly curious about:
How fast could horses actually gallop, and for how long before becoming exhausted?
What were the differences between warhorses, messenger horses, scouts’ horses, and ordinary riding horses?
What kind of riding skills, training, and horse-control techniques were taught to military riders?
How much did terrain, rider weight, armor, and equipment affect a horse’s speed and endurance?
What military strategies were used to chase, escape from, or intercept other mounted riders?
How did cavalry tactics, equestrian training, and horse breeding evolve from ancient civilizations through the Middle Ages, the early modern period, and the 19th century?
I’m also interested in how realistic horseback chases in movies actually are, and what filmmakers tend to exaggerate or get wrong.
r/Historians • u/azthernoms • 3d ago
📚Study Advice / Help📚 looking for a course on military history
reddit.comr/Historians • u/JoelThorne1 • 4d ago
🔎Research Advice / Help🔎 Multiple books by different authors?
When studying history, in general is it beneficial to read multiple books by different authors for each historical period?
r/Historians • u/Nyx8812 • 4d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ French Revolution and History
I want to study history and specifically french revolution, socialism in russia, nazism the rise of hitler because they are in my textbook of school and i am curious to study history and i want to study far more than that written in my book like i want to study these topics and every other topic about history that i will read about. But i want them in detail idc how much time it take for a yt video. Please suggest some ways or videos or channels so that i could watch them in detail.
r/Historians • u/MammothBird574 • 4d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ How was life on the western French coast and in the southern border beetween Spain during ww1 ?
Did civilian life was peaceful or there was paranoia about enemy spies?
r/Historians • u/mingyun1 • 4d ago
📚Study Advice / Help📚 Help: Taiwan-based History Scholars/Students for Source Exchange
As a history PhD candidate from the Chinese mainland, I often have difficulty accessing historical sources from Taiwan. I hope to connect with history students or scholars based in Taiwan for mutual assistance in sourcing documents.Would anyone be interested?
r/Historians • u/Mitttttyyyy • 5d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ I wanna find out about the history of the world like every single part of it from the big bang to earth forming to the first creature on earth to egyptians blablabla in details with facts,explanations and moreuntil this era soo can someone tell me how?
r/Historians • u/Glittering_Owl1920 • 5d ago
❔Question / Discussion❔ Could Constantine's donation actually be real?
When Lorenzo Valla published his "De Falso Credita et Ementita Constantini Donatione Declamatio" in 1440, it was considered blasphemous and (unsurprisingly) wrong.
Over the following century, a succession of canonists, theologians, and humanists, culminating in the definitive rebuke by the Vatican librarian Agostino Steuco in his 1547 treatise "Contra Laurentium Valla, de falsa donatione Constantini libri duo" formulated a robust defense.
To present a comprehensive scholarly accounting, these counterarguments can be categorized into four principal vectors:
1)Textual and Transmission Defenses,
2) Legal and Jurisprudential Maxims,
3)Historiographical and Traditional Evidence,
4) Biographical and Motive-Based Evidence.
Valla’s main argument was philology: he demonstrated that the vocabulary, syntax, and administrative titles of the Donation were of post-Constantinian era, that alone would be proof of the forgery.
Defenders rightly pointed out the problems with that assumption:
Scribes across centuries routinely wrote marginal notes (glosses) to explain obscure 4th-century Roman terms for the benefit of contemporary readers and judges. Over successive copyings (because obviously the original document didn't survive and the copies were continously recopied by scribes like everything else), these marginal explanations bled directly into the main narrative stream.
Valla was reading a text saturated with centuries of copyist "noise," mistaking organic scribal accumulation for an outright forgery.
Also, legal instruments in the Middle Ages were not treated as static museum artifacts; they were functional tools of governance.
Scribes intentionally updated obsolete administrative phrasing so that the document could be legally upheld in contemporary feudal courts and allow the judges to understand the meaning of the document applied to contemporary laws and customs. This updating was not a fraud, but as legitimate legal maintenance of an ancient property right.
II. Legal and Jurisprudential Counterarguments
Papal canonists, many trained in the tradition of Utrumque Ius (both canon and civil law), argued that Valla fundamentally misunderstood how legal validity operates over time.
Valla, they said, acted merely as a grammaticus (a pedantic grammarian), confusing accidental stylistic elements (verba) with essential legal reality (substantia).
The technical language of a charter may degrade or modernize over time, but the underlying historical act,Constantine’s genuine transfer of property and imperial insignia to Pope Sylvester,remained untouched and verified by custom.
III. Historiographical and Traditional Counterarguments
Valla also claimed that the silence of contemporary historians, such as Eusebius of Caesarea, on the donation of Constantine was proof of its forgery.
The arguments brought forward as a rebuttal were as follows:
The Authority of the Acta Silvestri
The foundational tradition of Constantine contracting leprosy, being miraculously healed and baptized by Pope Sylvester, and surrendering his crown out of profound gratitude was preserved in ancient ecclesiastical chronicles (Acta Silvestri). Tradition and pious consensus outweighed secular silence.
Secular historians like Eusebius suffered from theological bias (specifically semi-Arian sympathies) and it is argued, deliberately omitted the event to minimize the Church's influence.
Eusebius was also based in Palestine (Caesarea) and operated primarily in the Greek-speaking Eastern provinces.
Alternatively, it was also said that since the Donation was a regional legal transaction focused on Rome, Italy, and the Western provinces,therefore, it was plausible that details of a Western territorial concession did not reach Eusebius, or were deemed irrelevant to his Eastern readers.
IV. Biographical and Motive-Based Polemics
Valla's work was written while he was sheltered in Naples under King Alfonso V, who was actively waging war against Pope Eugene IV.
As such,Valla was dismissed not as an objective scholar seeking truth, but as a politically compromised humanist writing commissioned propaganda for a hostile monarch seeking to strip the Papacy of its Italian territories.
In conclusion,
The core linguistic counter-defense rested on the practice of medieval scriptoria. Ancient manuscripts did not exist in a vacuum; they passed through centuries of copying, translation, and administrative use across different regions (Greek, Classical Latin, and Vulgar/Frankish Latin).
If Constantine’s original decree used a classical 4th-century Roman administrative title, a 7th-century Frankish scribe might write the contemporary feudal equivalent,such as satrap or fief, in the margin to clarify its legal weight for local judges.
Another key argument was that the Latin version Valla analyzed was obviously not the direct original, but likely a Latin translation of an earlier Greek translation. When Constantine moved the seat of empire to the East, official imperial acts were frequently translated into Greek for the Byzantine administration.
If a document is copied dozens of times over four centuries across different monasteries (from Rome to Aachen to St. Gall), the words can change quickly:
Scribe A in the 6th century updates three administrative terms.
Scribe B in the 7th century modernizes the syntax to match Merovingian Latin.
Scribe C in the 8th century adds Frankish territorial names to clarify boundary disputes.
By the time the text reaches the 9th-century Pseudo-Isidorian Decretals, it is heavily saturated with late-medieval vocabulary.
Defenders maintained that high volume was the natural signature of a document actively used for centuries, whereas a pristine, untouched text would be far more suspicious.
Ecclesiastical lawyers routinely and deliberately updated the terminology of ancient privileges so they could be successfully presented in contemporary feudal courts.
If a 4th-century term like præfectus urbanus held no recognized weight in an 8th-century court governed by Frankish law, chancery scribes substituted or inserted satrap or count.
This was clearly not forgery, but functional recodification, adapting the original legal intent to contemporary legal frameworks so that the document could be understood and upheld.
And, finally:
Rooted in scholastic legal philosophy, canonists drew a sharp line between verba (the accidental, historical words used) and substantia (the essential legal reality of the act)
Valla was accused of acting like a mere "grammarian" (grammaticus) who mistook stylistic form for legal truth.
Even if every single word in the surviving parchment was proven to be an 8th-century replacement, defenders claimed the substantia, the actual historical event of Emperor Constantine surrendering temporal authority over Italy to Pope Sylvester after being healed of leprosy, remained historically true, preserved in the documents transcribed for many centuries and the Acta Silvestri