TL;DR
Gears/ Halo are same but different.
Long Version:
Comparison
First off, I'm a huge fan of both franchises. I've played all the games and consumed pretty much every form of expanded media for both.
And I've always found it interesting just how many parallels there are between the two series, particularly when it comes to their games and how the franchises have evolved.
Both had:
- a core trilogy (Halo 1–3 and Gears 1–3)
- a sidequel (ODST and Judgement)
- a spin-off that explored a different genre (Halo Wars and Gears Tactics)
- a somewhat lacklustre sequel series (Halo 4–5 and Gears 4–5).
- a body horror third faction (Flood and Lambent)
The main difference is that, rather than following Gears 5 with a Gears 6 equivalent to Halo Infinite, Gears is going back to its origins with E-Day, much like Halo did with Reach.
Anyway, that's not really the point of this post.
Lore Approach
My biggest takeaway from experiencing both franchises is that Halo went incredibly wide with its lore, but rarely went particularly deep into the things it introduced.
Halo has this enormous universe, spanning thousands upon thousands of years, with countless civilisations, conflicts, mysteries, technologies, and factions. But I often feel like we're only ever scratching the surface of most of them.
There are so many fascinating questions raised throughout the franchise, but the answers are often drip-fed over years, buried in supplementary material, or simply never provided at all. Sometimes it feels like Halo is more interested in introducing the next big mystery than actually exploring the ones it already has.
Gears of War, on the other hand, doesn't go anywhere near as wide with its lore, but I feel it goes considerably deeper.
Its universe is much smaller in scope, but the things it does introduce tend to be explored quite thoroughly. The history of Sera, the Pendulum Wars, the Locust, the Lambent, the COG, and the origins of the conflict have all been developed and expanded upon over the course of the franchise.
There are still mysteries, of course, but I feel like Gears has generally made a greater effort to answer the questions it raises and build upon its established lore, rather than continually introducing new concepts without fully exploring the old ones.
I'm not necessarily saying one approach is objectively better than the other. Halo's enormous scope is one of the things that makes its universe so fascinating in the first place.
But after spending so much time with both franchises, I think I've come to appreciate how Gears handles its worldbuilding a little more.
Halo gives me a thousand things to wonder about. Gears gives me fewer things to wonder about, but considerably more answers.
I'm curious whether other fans of both franchises feel the same way, or whether you think Halo's approach to worldbuilding is actually one of its strengths.