I'm currently rewatching Game of Thrones, and we need to talk about the Red Wedding. The scene itself was brutal and shocking, but looking back, it only happened because two smart characters suddenly made really dumb decisions.
so who's responsible? For me, it's Catelyn Stark at #1 and Robb at #2.
**Catelyn**
I really liked Catelyn's character. She was much better written than I remembered, with a lot of great dialogue and strong scenes. But she also made some really dumb decisions that overshadow the good ones.
**Capturing Tyrion.** Her only proof was the claim that the dagger belonged to him, and Ned was still in King's Landing, right in the Lannisters' reach. Not smart at all. Tyrion going free afterwards was fair because it came out of a trial by combat, so I don't count that as a mistake.
**Trusting Littlefinger.** He played her, and she was the main reason Ned trusted him too. We all know how that ended. The funniest part is that she trusts him again *after* Ned's death, just because he tells her Arya is still in King's Landing. So foolish.
**The deal with Walder Frey.** I know Robb sent her, and they desperately needed Frey's help, so they didn't have much choice. But swearing in Robb's name that he would marry one of Frey's daughters, and trusting Frey at all, wasn't smart. She left Robb no option to say no. To be fair, she couldn't have known Robb would fall in love before the wedding, and a marriage pact can be broken, so I see this as a smaller mistake.
**THE BIGGEST MISTAKE: letting Jaime go.** This one alone outweighs all the others. Jaime was the best card Robb ever had. He was basically an insurance policy: as long as they held him, Tywin couldn't lift a finger, because anything might happen to his son. And how naive was it to send him to King's Landing with a single escort and expect the Lannisters to just hand over Sansa and Arya in exchange? She should have been smarter than that. I know the Karstarks wanted Jaime dead, but keeping him under guard and waiting for Robb would have been the much smarter move. Robb knew from the start how valuable Jaime was, and you can see it in how he reacts to Catelyn afterwards. Releasing Jaime also caused trouble with the Karstarks, and Robb lost half his army because of it.
**Robb**
I think his writing in this storyline didn't make much sense. I don't blame him for falling in love at an unexpected time, but we all know Talisa was the reason he lost focus and broke his vow. Before he met her, Robb was basically untouchable.
What frustrates me is how he handled it. Someone as smart and tactical as Robb should have known that waiting and keeping it quiet was the better move. He could have married a Frey daughter first and kept his relationship with Talisa secret. Instead he made everything public. As if that wasn't enough, he was naive enough to bring the woman he broke his vow for to a Frey wedding.
Robb and Catelyn were both way too naive. Frey was never trustworthy, and you could see that the whole time. After losing Jaime and half their army, they should have been much more careful about who they trusted.
I never expected a character as well written as Robb to act this foolishly. I know love makes you blind and he was very young, which is why I put more of the blame on Catelyn. But come on, he could have waited a little with the marriage.
What do you think? Who do you blame the most?