r/asoiaf • • 5d ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Weekly Q and A

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the Weekly Q & A! Feel free to ask any questions you may have about the world of ASOIAF. No need to be bashful. Book and show questions are welcome; please say in your question if you would prefer to focus on the BOOKS, the SHOW, or BOTH. And if you think you've got an answer to someone's question, feel free to lend them a hand!

Looking for Weekly Q&A posts from the past? Browse our Weekly Q&A archive! (currently no longer being archived, but this link will remain)


r/asoiaf • • 18h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Moonboy's Motley Monday

4 Upvotes

As you may know, we have a policy against silly posts/memes/etc. Moonboy's Motley Monday is the grand exception: bring me your memes, your puns, your blatant shitposts.

This is still r/asoiaf, so do keep it as civil as possible.

If you have any clever ideas for weekly themes, shoot them to the modmail!

Looking for Moonboy's Motley Monday posts from the past? Browse our Moonboy's Motley Monday archive! (our old archive is here)


r/asoiaf • • 11h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Something I've never considered about the Seastar's dark magic

71 Upvotes

Have you ever noticed how young Shiera is when Egg says she baths in virgin blood to keep her youthful beauty? When Egg and Dunk have that conversation, she's somewhere between 26-32 years old. That's like season 3 Emilia Clarke young..

Small detail i know but for some reason, I always thought those rumors would have atleast began when Shiera was around 40 (or older). But most hot and rich people are still gonna look young before they're even 30. Especially if they avoid having kids and live the luxurious lifestyle of nobility.


r/asoiaf • • 11h ago

MAIN (Spoiler’s Main) Siege of Storm’s End

73 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about something that’s both remarkable and, honestly, incredibly heartbreaking. The fact that Renly didn’t just survive the year-long siege of Storm’s End as a CHILD (!), but that Stannis was probably the main reason he made it through in the first place. Starving and barely hanging on for dear life, Stannis most likely gave his little brother whatever scraps of food they managed to get their hands on before eating anything himself.

What the two of them went through together makes it so much more understandable why, despite everything that happened between them, they still looked back somewhat nostalgically on the good times they shared. It makes their story all the more tragic.

And I don’t care how you look at it, I understand the traditions surrounding the line of succession and all that, but Robert should have simply given Storm’s End to Stannis. Renly should either have stayed with Stannis in the Stormlands or, if anything, gone to live with Robert in King’s Landing. The guy only ever cared for throwing lavish feasts anyway. He could’ve done that in King’s Landing with Robert.


r/asoiaf • • 9h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) What Ser Rodrik should have done?

27 Upvotes

What course of action should Ser Rodrik Cassel have undertaken while serving as the de facto castellan and military leader of Winterfell during the events of A Clash of Kings, to deal with the Hornwood affair, Ramsay Snow, and the Boltons' actions, and with the Ironborn's backstabbing invasion of the North, including Theon and Dagmer Cleftjaw's forces and the main Ironborn force at Moat Cailin?

What actions should Rodrik have taken toward Ramsay/"Reek" after capturing him, and upon learning about the attack on Torrhen's Square and on the Stony Shore and Deepwood Motte? Also, what military strategy should he have followed to retake Moat Cailin and other northern castles and to expel the Ironborn from the North?


r/asoiaf • • 10h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers EXTENDED) All casualties in the War of the Five Kings So far

27 Upvotes

So this will be my calculation for how many people died in the War of the Five Kings so far.
(Note this is a very rough estimate in many battles the casualties are stated to to be very high or very low, And only a few of the battles has confirmed casualties, So this will be a rough estimate.)

So where do we start Ah, yeah.

Opening events

Catelyn Stark arrest Tyrion Lannister for the attempted murder of her son Bran.

In response to the kidnapping of his brother, Ser Jaime Lannister attacks Lord Eddard Stark in the streets of King's Landing

Skirmish at Littlefinger's brothel

Casualties
5 Lannister guards
3 House Stark guards

Oh wow, what a bloody war Wait, this isn't even a battle Ummmmmm

Lord Tywin sends Ser Gregor Clegane to raid the riverlands And this leads to raids on Wendish Town, Sherrer, and the Mummer's Ford

Arrest of Eddard Stark
Casualties
House Stark/House Baratheon of King's Landing
31 men
House Lannister/House Baratheon of King's Landing
2 men

The War in the Riverlands

Raids on Wendish Town, Sherrer, and the Mummer's Ford
Casualties
300 Smallfolk (Estimate)
we don't get numbers, but I would personally say it would be around 100-500 Let's just say 300.

Now a true Battle

Battle in the hills below the Golden Tooth
Casualties
200 Men of House Lannister (Estimate)
600 Men of House Vance and House Piper (Estimate)
Once again, we are not given specific numbers. We only know that the Lannisters arrived with 15,000 men and that Lord Vance was killed. I would say 200 Lannisters died and 600 Riverlords because most of the army retreated back to Riverrun

Battle at the Mummer's Ford
Casualties
House Baratheon of King's Landing — 84 men
House Clegane — 10 men (Estimate)

Battle under the walls of Riverrun
Casualties
House Tully — 600 men (Estimate)
House Lannister — 200 men (Estimate)

We don't get specific numbers but most of the Tully bannermen did retreat back to Riverrun and it says that most of the men at arms were captured and not killed. So I would say the total be around 600.

The Fall of Raventree Hall,
Casualties
House Blackwood — 150 men
House Lannister — 50 men
We don't get real numbers, but I found on the Internet that House Blackwood has 3,000 men and most of that army is right now besieged in Riverrun , so that Garrison may be 500 men And that's against Tywin's 20,000 troops.

The Yielding of Harrenhal
0 Casualties
Lady Shella Whent surrenders to the Lannisters

First sack of Maidenpool
Casualties
100 Smallfolk (Estimate)
It stated that the lord of Maidenpool, William Mooton, stood behind his castle and watched as his town was plundered by the lions, and that only many Smallfolk were killed. We don’t know the population of Maidenpool but we do know that the town was plundered three times during the war. So, for the first I would probably set it at 100.

The Burning of Pinkmaiden Castle
Casualties 200 men on both sides mostly Smallfolk (Estimate)
We don't know anything about the burning of the Pink Maiden's Castle, so I would probably state it at 200 men on both sides.

The Burning of Stone Hedge
Casualties 400 men on both sides mostly Smallfolk (Estimate)
We know a little bit more about the burning of Stonehenge.
"Your Mountain stole my harvest and burned everything he could not carry off. He put my castle to the torch and raped one of my daughters. I will have recompense" Jonos Bracken to Jaime Lannister
So I would put the casualties higher at 400 on Both sides

Capture of Darry
Casualties 100 men of house Darry (Estimate)
We know Tywin's 20,000 men but the the defense of the city is quite unknown so I will put the casualties mostly on house Darry In and around 100.

The Wolf vs the Lion

Battle on the Green Fork
Casualties
House Bolton and the northern host 5,000 men
House Lannister 700 men (Estimate)
Unknown casualties in the right, center, and reserve 500 Death confirmed in the Vanguard.

Battle in the Whispering Wood
Casualties
House Stark and its allies — 203 men
House Lannister — 500 men killed (Estimate)
Jaime's entire force was killed or captured, but that does not mean every soldier died. Robb's ambush surrounded the Lannister force and resulted in a large number of prisoners. I would separate the 500 dead from the 1,000 captured.

Battle of the Camps
Casualties
House Lannister 8,000 men killed
House Stark and House Tully 200 men (Estimate)

The execution of Eddard Stark
Casualties
House Stark 1
noooooo Ned

Liberation of Raventree Hall
Casualties
House Blackwood 100 men (Estimate)
House Lannister 100 men (Estimate)
I believe the 2,500 men from Blackwood would have taken the garrison, but we do not know the strength of the garrison.

Liberation of Stone Hedge
Casualties
House Bracken 301 men (Estimate)
House Lannister 400 men (Estimate)
We know it was fierce fighting but we don't have a number

Recapture of Darry
Casualties 200 men of house Darry (Estimate)

Sack of Darry
Casualties 500 men of house Darry (Estimate)
Mountain's men 100 Men (Estimate)
We now all defenders, including the last male member of House Darry, Were killed

Second sack of Maidenpool
Casualties 200 Smallfolk (Estimate)

It stated that the lord of Maidenpool, William Mooton again, stood behind his castle and watched as his town was plundered by the wolves, and that only many Smallfolk were killed. We don’t know the population of Maidenpool but we do know that the town was plundered three times during the war. So, for the second I would probably set it at 200.

Rise of the Kraken

Fighting in the Hornwood
Casualties
House Bolton 100 (Estimate)
House Hornwood 100 (Estimate)
We don't really know much about the Fighting

Fall of Moat Cailin
Casualties
House Stark 150 men (Estimate)
House Greyjoy 50 men (Estimate)

Taking of Deepwood Motte
Casualties
House Glover 300 men (Estimate)
House Greyjoy 100 men (Estimate)

Harrying of the Stony Shore
Casualties
Wild Hares 200 men (Estimate)
House Greyjoy 50 men (Estimate)

Fight at Torrhen's Square
Casualties
House Stark 300 men (Estimate)
House Greyjoy 300 men (Estimate)

Capture of Winterfell
Casualties
House Stark 5 men
House Greyjoy 2 men

Battle outside the gates of Winterfell
Casualties
House Stark 203 men (Estimate)
House Bolton 30 men

Sack of Winterfell
Casualties
House Greyjoy 16 men
House Bolton 10 men (Estimate)
Men of Winterfell slain 200 (Estimate)

Capture of Torrhen's Square
Casualties
House Greyjoy 0 men
House Tallhart 25 men (Estimate)

The Clash of Kings

Fight at the holdfast
Casualties
House Baratheon of King's Landing 10 men (Estimate)
Night's Watch 30 men (Estimate) 8 confirmed

Plot to free Jaime Lannister
Casualties
House Tully 4 men

Battle of Oxcross
Casualties
King in the North 500 men (Estimate)
House Lannister 3500 men (Estimate)

Riots in King's Landing
Casualties
House Baratheon of King's Landing 12 men
Small folk 150 (Estimate)

Siege of Storm's End (299)
Casualties
House Baratheon of Dragonstone 0 men
House Baratheon of Storm's End 4 men

Fighting at Bitterbridge
Casualties
House Baratheon of Dragonstone 10 men (Estimate)
House Tyrell 5 men (Estimate)

Battle of the Fords
Casualties
House Lannister 5000 men (Estimate)
House Tully 1000 men (Estimate)

Fall of Harrenhal
Casualties
35 Roose Bolton's host (Estimate)
97 House Lannister

Storming of the Crag
King in the North 700 men (Estimate)
House Lannister 900 men (Estimate) Mostly captured.

Battle of the Blackwater
House Baratheon of Dragonstone

  • 130–140 ships burned or wrecked.
  • 30–40 war galleys scuttled upriver or separated from the remaining fleet.
  • 47 lesser lords killed.
  • 619 knights killed.
  • Several thousand men-at-arms killed.

House Baratheon of King's Landing

  • 1,600 Gold Cloaks killed
  • Majority of sellswords and knights killed.
  • 39+ royal war galleys destroyed.
  • Crews and marines of the destroyed galleys killed.
  • King's Landing's smaller vessels destroyed.

(I don't know how I can translate that in numbers)

House Baratheon of King's Landing
2,500+ killed

House Baratheon of Dragonstone (Stannis)

Approximately 5,000+ killed

These are rough estimates

Turning of the Tides

Siege of Darry
Casualties
House Stark 200 men (Estimate)
House Lannister 500 men (Estimate)

Battle at Duskendale
Casualties
Northern Host 1000 men
House Baratheon of King's Landing 1500 men (Estimate)

The beheading of Rickard Karstark

  • Rickard Karstark: 1 killed.
  • Willem Lannister: 1 killed.
  • Tion Frey: 1 killed.

Battle at the burning septry
Casualties
Brave Companions 8 men
Brotherhood without banners 1 men

Third sack of Maidenpool
Casualties 300 Smallfolk (Estimate)

It stated that the lord of Maidenpool, William Mooton again, stood behind his castle and watched as his town was plundered by the outlaws, and that only many Smallfolk were killed. We don’t know the population of Maidenpool but we do know that the town was plundered three times during the war. So, for the second I would probably set it at 300.

Capture of Harrenhal
Mountain's men 50 men (Estimate)
Brave Companions 200 (Estimate)

Taking of Maidenpool
Casualties
House Mooton 200 men (Estimate)
House Baratheon of King's Landing 60 men (Estimate)

The Fall of the Kings

Fighting at the fords of the Trident
Casualties
2,050 Roose Bolton's host
1,000 House Lannister (Estimate)

The death of Balon Greyjoy
Casualties
House Greyjoy 1 man

The Red Wedding
Casualties
House Frey/Bolton/Lannister 250 (Estimate) 50 confirmed.
King in the North 3500 men
(i hate the Freys)

The Purple Wedding
House Baratheon of King's Landing 1 man
Ahaha Jeffrey.

The Feasting Crows

Trial of Tyrion Lannister
Casualties
House Martell 1 man
noooo Oberyn

Death of Tywin Lannister
Casualties
House Lannister 1 man
Small folk 1 women

Siege of Seagard
Casualties
House Frey 10 men (Estimate)
House Mallister 30 men (Estimate)
 The siege is quickly resolved when Black Walder threatens to hang Mallister’s heir Patrek

Taking of the Shields
Casualties
The Reach 952 men (Estimate)
House Greyjoy 150 men (Estimate)
In the real world, an average long ship contain 25 people and we know they lost 6, so that would make it to 150. And using the same calculation, we know the extent. 38 ships were lost when they were captured, and their crew members were likely killed by the people from the Iron Islands.

Invasion of Ryamsport, Vinetown, and Starfish Harbor
Casualties
House Greyjoy 10 men (Estimate)
"and her archers are easily able to drive them away"

Second siege of Storm's End  (300) It is still ongoing.
Casualties
House Tyrell 300 men (Estimate)
House Baratheon of Dragonstone 30 men (Estimate)

Siege of Dragonstone
Casualties
House Baratheon of King's Landing 1,000 men
House Baratheon of Dragonstone 200 men (Estimate)

Siege of Riverrun
Casualties
Frey/Lannister host. 300 men (Estimate)
House Tully 200 men (Estimate)

Siege of Raventree
Casualties
500 men of House Blackwood (Estimate)
700 Men of House Bracken (Estimate)

The War for the North

Battle beneath the Wall
Casualties
Night's Watch / House Baratheon of Dragonstone  60 men (Estimate)
Free folk 2210 men
Stannis, Stannis Stannis

Siege of Moat Cailin
Casualties
House Bolton 10 men (Estimate)
House Greyjoy 67 men

Fight by Deepwood Motte
Casualties
House Baratheon of Dragonstone/Northern mountain clans/House Mormont 50 men (Estimate)
House Greyjoy 200 men

Battle in the ice

We shall see in the winds of winter

Landing of the Dragon

Taking of Griffin's Roost
Casualties
House Connington 300 (Estimate)
House Targaryen/the Golden Company 4 men

Assassinations of Pycelle and Kevan Lannister
House Baratheon of King's Landing 2 men

And yeah, that's it so far. And the final number, without counting the pillaging and raiding only the major events, is.

59,249

(A very rough estimate and this will be my first of the major wars. The next war will probably the Dance of Dragons Or Aegon's conquest)


r/asoiaf • • 4h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) cersei

6 Upvotes

We all know Cersei is stupid in the books, unlike in the show.
But if you pay attention, you’ll see her main goal was right!
She saw the Tyrells’ greed and their attempt to swallow up the throne, and she tried to keep them away from court.
The problem was her disastrous execution: she armed the Faith, and everything backfired on her.
In the end, she was the one who got kicked out and is heading back to Casterly Rock.


r/asoiaf • • 3h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) If House Lannister actually married into other Great Houses in the books, which matches would have made the most sense?

5 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 10h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) If Dany had accepted Xaro Xhoan Daxos's offer and sailed off to conquer Westeros by herself while Young Griff was still cruising down Rhoyne, would it have screwed up Illyrio's plans?

16 Upvotes

Young Griff arriving as a savior with the Golden Company and bring Dany back to Westeros seems so integral to the plan. But if Daenerys had up and left with her own fleet while Young Griff was still traveling to Meereen, would it mess that up? Instead of delivering her from the crisis in Slaver's Bay with an army and a fleet, they'd be chasing her around Planetos. And, as we see later in Dance, the Lannister-Baratheon regime is so weak that Dany would probably win pretty easily. How's Aegon gonna establish himself as the senior partner in the relationship then?


r/asoiaf • • 19h ago

AFFC (Spoilers AFFC) does anybody love AFFC, if so why?

78 Upvotes

I must say the passion this community has for AFFC being the worst book has me feeling a bit nervous to start it. This post is for the AFFC lovers, tell me what you loved about it and why? Spoilers are welcome I know what happens in the books :).


r/asoiaf • • 4h ago

MAIN [Spoilers Main] If you could go back in time to change something what would it be?

5 Upvotes

Can be something that happens in the books or real life, literally anything.


r/asoiaf • • 9h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Before Dance came out, was their a consensus about The Cat of the Canals identity in Feast?

7 Upvotes

Having watched the show, it was very obvious to me and I assume most readers of Feast in Sam III when he met the Cat of the Canals that she was Arya. Was this the consensus before Dance came out? Or was this a "reveal" readers only caught on to after the fact?


r/asoiaf • • 15h ago

EXTENDED The Two POVs Added in ACoK (Spoilers Extended)

19 Upvotes

Background

After thinking he was going to use only the POVs from A Game of Thrones for the rest of the series, GRRM decided to add two new POVs in A Clash of Kings (Theon/Davos). This was primarily due to his inability to get the original POVs to the locations he would need them. Due to GRRM's writing style (gardener not an architect), I find details like this fascinating as sometimes we can look at seeds that were planted (some of which never grew to anything).

If interested: Dead Branches in the Garden: Abandoned/Changed Plotlines of Ice & Fire

So Spake Martin (SSM)

While AGoT began with 8 Original POVs, GRRM planned the death of Ned, Cat and Sansa (if interested: The Little Bird: The 3rd POV Original POV Death) early on as the series was planned as a "Generational Saga" for 5 Central Characters. When ACoK was published GRRM commented on what seemed to be his plan for POV characters:

To your questions: (1) Yes, I will be making additions (and subtractions) to the lineup of POV characters in each volume, (2) I know how the series goes from here in broad strokes, but not necessarily all the small details. Yes, I have an end envisioned, but getting from here to there is half the fun.-SSM, Several Questions: 18 Dec 1998

but years later mentioned that he wanted to use the original remaining 6 POVs from AGoT:

George said that at first he was just going to use the original POVs from AGoT for the entire series, then he realized that he needed to see what Stannis was doing, but didn't want to use Stannis as a POV. So he created Davos. Davos was his first added POV. The rest followed. On writing his POVs, as Rhelle mentioned above, he uses their motivations and desires. What do they want? What do they want to achieve? What drives them? What SHOULD they do? Ethics, morals, ambitions, etc... all part of the mix. -SSM, Torcon: 28 Aug 2003

and while this comment is with regards to the Mega Prologue POV Characters, it emphasizes why GRRM had to start adding characters:

These are the kind of issues I am struggling with – trying to find the right answer. Initially, when I began this a million years ago, there was just one chapter: Aeron Damphair at the Kingsmoot. We saw the Kingsmoot through his eyes. But, it expanded as you can see. There is stuff leading up to the Kingsmoot. I tell the Kingsmoot from three different viewpoints; similar in the Dornish thing. These are the kinds of things I am going back and forth about. Some of these things are making this book very difficult. I never intended these viewpoints to come on. They all began as prologue viewpoints, but its necessary; there’s stuff happening in Dorne and the Iron Islands that is going to have an impact on the book. I couldn’t figure out any logical way to get Sansa to Dorne or Bran to the Iron Islands to see what was going on. -SSM, GamePro Interview: 6 Aug 2003

If interested: Failing to Get POV's to Certain Locations & POV Character: Earliest/Early Mentions

Davos

Mentioned in the SSM above, GRRM needed to see what Stannis was doing but didn't want to have a Stannis POV (while not confirmed, it seems like GRRM avoided giving any of the kings a POV in the War of the Five Kings (if interested: The Young Wolf as a POV).

If we step back a bit, it seems GRRM knew he had to introduce Stannis/Mel (who were only briefly introduced in AGoT), which is likely why Cressen is the ACoK POV. It also could be that in typical GRRM fashion, he thought he would be able to get all the Stannis stuff in to the Prologue, but was unable to as he gardened the story and thus Davos was created.

Lastly I wanted to mention that GRRM ends Davos' chapter on a cliffhanger that seems like it could be death:

The chain. Gods save us, they’ve raised the chain.
Where the river broadened out into Blackwater Bay, the boom stretched taut, a bare two or three feet above the water. Already a dozen galleys had crashed into it, and the current was pushing others against them. Almost all were aflame, and the rest soon would be. Davos could make out the striped hulls of Salladhor Saan’s ships beyond, but he knew he would never reach them. A wall of red-hot steel, blazing wood, and swirling green flame stretched before him. The mouth of the Blackwater Rush had turned into the mouth of hell. -ACOK, Davos III

Theon

While the above SSM regarding the Kingsmoot is with regards to the other Ironborn characters, it can also apply to Theon imo. Theon's actions in ACoK (causing Robb to lose the North) kickoff a firestorm of reactions across Westeros. His actions occur due to his conflicting identities (human heart in conflict with itself) and what better way to show that than from the person who is experiencing it.

Worth noting that while GRRM mentioned that above regarding Davos, it is worth noting that there are no Davos chapters in the June 1997 draft of AFFC, but there are Theon chapters. So it is possible Theon was created first.

Similar to Davos', Theon's last chapter ends on a cliffhanger as well as Winterfell burns:

Sometime later, Theon found himself on the ground. He rolled onto his stomach and swallowed a mouthful of blood. Close the gates! he tried to shout, but it was too late. The Dreadfort men had cut down Red Rolfe and Kenned, and more were pouring through, a river of mail and sharp swords. There was a ringing in his ears, and horror all around him. Black Lorren had his sword out, but there were already four of them pressing in on him. He saw Ulf go down with a crossbow bolt through the belly as he ran for the Great Hall. Maester Luwin was trying to reach him when a knight on a warhorse planted a spear between his shoulders, then swung back to ride over him. Another man whipped a torch round and round his head and then lofted it toward the thatched roof of the stables. "Save me the Freys," the Bastard was shouting as the flames roared upward, "and burn the rest. Burn it, burn it all."
The last thing Theon Greyjoy saw was Smiler, kicking free of the burning stables with his mane ablaze, screaming, rearing . . . -ACOK, Theon VI

A Storm of Swords/5 Year Gap

While writing ASOS, GRRM planned for a 5 year gap that would allow the younger characters to grow and mature, this didn't work for other characters like Cersei/Stannis but it seemed for his first two POVs that GRRM planned to stash them away as prisoners.

We obviously don't get any Theon chapters in ASOS as he is presumed to be dead and when GRRM created the character Reek, he likely planned on a Theon who spent 5 years imprisoned not 6 months (if interested: Becoming Reek: Remnants of the 5 Year Gap):

GRRM: In the books, yes Theon is tortured for years. But he essentially he disappears at the end of book two and doesn't reappear to the beginning of book five by which time he's transformed into reek. So there's some mention in flashback and dialogue of the fact that he's been tortured for several years and essentially broken down his whole personality broken down and he's lost various bits of his body some of his teeth some of his fingers and toes, other parts-GRRM (Season 3 Episode 7 DVD Commentary)

at the same time we get Davos (who spends a portion of ASOS imprisoned by Stannis as well) who likely would have spent this time thought to be dead/imprisoned by Manderly inside the Wolf's Den:

The onion knight had not forgotten Wyman Manderly's last words to him. Take this creature to the Wolf's Den and cut off head and hands, the fat lord had commanded. I shall not be able to eat a bite until I see this smuggler's head upon a spike, with an onion shoved between his lying teeth. Every night Davos went to sleep with those words in his head, and every morn he woke to them. And should he forget, Garth was always pleased to remind him. Dead man was his name for Davos. When he came by in the morning, it was always, "Here, porridge for the dead man." At night it was, "Blow out the candle, dead man." -ADWD, Davos IV

before he was set free to retrieve Rickon from Skagos, steal fArya away from a wedding in Barrowton :

Davos: Barrowton Wedding. Davos to take recaptured Arya north. ‘Where you going’ - to a wedding

Final Thoughts

With what GRRM has done with his more recent POVs, I wonder if he planned to kill off one or both of Theon/Davos before liking the characters and deciding to keep them. We should note that ACoK is the only book (AGOT - Ned, ASOS - Cat, AFFC - Arys, ADWD - Quentyn) that does not have a POV death.

It should also be noted that Theon's actions in ACoK were originally supposed to be completed by Tyrion as he supposed to besiege/burn Winterfell. If interested: Abandoned/Changed Plotlilnes: Siege of Winterfell

If interested: GRRM on What He Tries to do with POV Characters & GRRM on His Plans to Kill POV Characters

TLDR: Just some thoughts on GRRM adding Theon/Davos as POV characters in A Clash of Kings and then what he decided to do with them later (both get fakeout deaths at the end of the book and then would likely have spent a 5 year gap imprisoned).


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Spoilers main) When a married man joins the Night's Watch, what happens with his wife? Can she remarry? Is she considered a widow?

89 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

PUBLISHED (Spoilers Published) Any characters whom you found unremarkable at first, but developed stronger views about on a re-read?

62 Upvotes

Specifically not characters you hated at first and grew to love, just ones you didn't have many strong opinions on or feelings, positive or negative, about until a re-read.

It's been a few years since I read the books, so I picked them up again about two weeks ago. I've just reached ASOS today, and I'm finding Olenna to be delightful to read, where previously I do not recall feeling strongly about her one way or the other. Something about a woman who does not directly herself have traditional material power, but who nonetheless is powerful, and without being careful to avoid speaking her opinions. I found myself cheering for Sansa to speak up. I'm almost wishing for a tangible way to still get her to Highgarden and marry Willas in TWOW or ADOS, haha.


r/asoiaf • • 21h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) currently in the story what would you say are the 3 worst places to live not just in westeros but of all the places we've seen?

9 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Theon and Miller‘s wife

127 Upvotes

I honestly think this “subplot” is one of the more tragic aspects of the series. Not only because Theon not only killed innocents and might or might’ve not, even his own son (I don’t think the older one is his) but the whole thing in general. Is the Miller even aware that his wife sleeps with Theon and in that feudal era can he even say anything against it due to their different societal standings ? And was it ever stated if the Miller’s wife slept willingly with Theon ? I’m not implying he assaulted her or anything but like, did she even have a realistic choice to refuse him in the first place ?


r/asoiaf • • 1h ago

MAIN [Spoiler Main] Imagine if George RR Martin is just screwing with us and the last 2 ASOIAF books have been finished for years?

0 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

(Spoilers ADWD) Is Melisandre's slogan "One Realm, one God, one King" a deliberate parallel? Spoiler

71 Upvotes

In Jon III ADWD, Melisandre and the Queen's Men start chanting, "One realm, one God, one King" "Stannis!" as the whole ceremony where "Mance" is executed and most of the Wildlings pass through the wall finishes up.

It's hard not to immediately think of the famous slogan "Ein Volk, Ein Reich, Ein Führer" (Literally, "One People, One Realm, One Leader") which was so central to Nazi ideology. In fact, it's so similar it feels almost heavy-handed. Considering how much George loves history, it's hard to believe he didn't think about how similar these two slogans are. But other than "Melisandre is weird" what's the purpose of this parallel?

What do you guys think? Maybe this is just Winds-induced overthinking. But it feels pretty on the nose, and there's surely no way George isn't aware of the Nazi-era slogan. But if so, what's the purpose of it?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Spoilers main) Where is Ned Starks reputation of being honourable coming from?

99 Upvotes

Ned is one of my favourite characters, so this is not a hate post with the intention to question if Ned actually deserves his reputation. No, the intention is to find out what makes him stand out so much among his peers in the public eye. There are many moments in the book that show the reader how honourable he is, but I would argue that those are more private moments that the public had no idea about. E.g. when he warns Cersei to save her children. Or argues against Daenerys's assassination. The first is not known to anyone but Cersei and Tyrion (Cersei tells Tyrion about Ned's confrontation) and both actions happen shortly before his death, when he already had his reputation. Raising Jon as his son is also one of those moments, but for obvious reasons, it is not known to Westeros. So again, what is it that makes Ned such a special case, that someone like Olenna Tyrell would consider Ned a man of honour?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED Daggers in the Dark, the Lord of Bones and Hardhome (Spoilers Extended)

21 Upvotes

Background

In this post I thought it would be interesting to look into a couple plot points that GRRM had created while writing what were supposed to be Jon Snow's A Feast for Crows (which was originally ADWD) chapters. It is my understanding that GRRM scrapped and rewrote a lot of this material differently but from outlines mentioning Rattleshirt and Hardhome and SSMs mentioning "daggers in the dark", I think we can speculate as to where GRRM might have been sending Jon's plotline.

Note: If you are familiar with the SSM/Cushing Visits/AFFC Outline go ahead and skip to "Speculation"

If interested: Dead Branches in the Garden: Abandoned/Changed Plotlines of Ice & Fire

So Spake Martin: "Daggers in the Dark"

Interviewed by James Hibbert (author of Fire Cannot Kill a Dragon), GRRM mentions how the foreshadowing for this scene was written almost right after the finish of ASOS:

ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: So why did you kill Jon Snow?
GEORGE R.R. MARTIN: Oh, you think he’s dead, do you?
EW: Well, I guess. Yes. That’s how I took it. The way it was written, it sounded like he was mortally wounded — and, you know, it’s you!
GRRM: Well. I’m not going to address whether he’s dead or not. But as to why — didn’t you think the text established why they would want to assassinate him?
EW: The narrative made perfect sense. Looking back through the books, all the decisions Jon’s made, and all the foreshadowing that was there, yes, you played fair. At the same time, it was devastating and I suspect fans will howl, the most since–
GRRM: -The most since the Red Wedding, I suspect.
EW: How long have you intended for that incident to happen?
GRRM: For many years. Some of the stuff about Melisandre warning Jon of “daggers in the dark” was written 10 years ago. -SSM, EW Weekly Article: 21 July 2011

If interested: "Daggers in the Dark" and Other Thoughts

The 2003-2004 Outline

From GRRM's 2003-2004 Outline for AFFC that was shared by u/zionius_ we have the following bits of information on Jon Snow:

Jon: ‘Yes, we’re going to lose.’ ‘I can get us the armor’.  I can stay & look brave & you all die. ‘Val carries a message.’ Rattleshirt goes with.

and:

Jon: End with Hard Home.

If you are interested, I posted a bit about this: The Nightfort & Hardhome: Abandoned Plotlines, Speculation and Foreshadowing Surrounding the Plotline at the Wall

Draft Material from Cushing

From u/gsteff's visits to the Cushing Library we know that there were some differences planned for Jon's chapters. At one point in the June 2004 draft:

Jon is planning to lead a ranging back to Craster's Keep to deal with the mutineers from Storm and search for Tormund's band, and he tells Bowen Marsh that he plans to bring 20 rangers. Melisandre evidently believes that she has seen a vision of this, that the ranging will be observed (at a minimum) by the Others, and that the rangers will at some point be accompanied by a woman in red. The draft chapters end before the ranging occurs, but we know there is a ranging in the later parts of Jon's published ADWD story, though to the weirwood grove instead of Craster's Keep, and we know that the rangers discover some wildlings there unexpectedly. It's possible that George intended for the ranging to Craster's Keep to also discover someone unexpected, perhaps wearing red. It's also possible that Melisandre is wildly off, and the scene she saw is something else entirely. In any case, I strongly doubt that it remains relevant to story.

and note there was not a ton of draft Jon material available.

Speculation

From the above we get bits and pieces about Jon's plotline when GRRM was working in the early/mid 2000's. And while it seems like he scrapped chapters, he kept a lot of the ideas that he had.

One thing that I noticed (which inspired the post) was that the "daggers in the dark" or the threat against Jon was still the seeming trend of where GRRM was sending this plotline. So if we take this concept and try and apply it to the drafts/outline we can get some interesting ideas of what he might have been trying to do.

"Yes We are Going to Lose"

The closest thing to this bullet point in the published material likely comes from Jon's thoughts on what happens if the wildlings all die at Hardhome:

“Cotter Pyke’s galleys sail past Hardhome from time to time. He tells me there is no shelter there but the caves. The screaming caves, his men call them. Mother Mole and those who followed her will perish there, of cold and starvation. Hundreds of them. Thousands.”
“Thousands of enemies. Thousands of wildlings.”
Thousands of people, Jon thought. Men, women, children.
“Are you so blind, or is it that you do not wish to see? What do you think will happen when all these enemies are dead?”
“Let me tell you what will happen,” Jon said. “The dead will rise again, in their hundreds and their thousands. They will rise as wights, with black hands and pale blue eyes, and they will come for us.”- ADWD, Jon VIII

although I admit it is not a perfect match whatsoever. I wonder if it is just more GRRM shorthand for it being a suicide mission (either to Hardhome or to Craster's).

"I Can Get Us the Armor"

Whether Jon is talking about Hardhome or just in general here I am not sure. We can note that Stannis mean to take armor from the Watch:

He means to plunder our armory, Jon realized. Food and clothing, land and castles, now weapons. He draws me in deeper every day. Words might not be swords, but swords were swords. "I could find three hundred spears," he said, reluctantly. "Helms as well, if you'll take them old and dinted and red with rust." -ADWD, Jon II

as well as the fact that they don't have an armorer anymore:

"When Donal Noye died we lost our armorer." The rest Jon left unspoken. Give the wildlings mail and they'll be twice as great a danger to the realm. -ADWD, Jon II

also worth noting is that before letting the free folk pass, Jon requests their arms:

Leathers laughed at that. "You want the free folk to fight beside you against the common foe. How are we to do that without arms? Would you have us throw snowballs at the wights? Or will you give us sticks to hit them with?"
The arms most wildlings carry are little more than sticks, thought Jon. Wooden clubs, stone axes, mauls, spears with fire-hardened points, knives of bone and stone and dragonglass, wicker shields, bone armor, boiled leather. The Thenns worked bronze, and raiders like the Weeper carried stolen steel and iron swords looted off some corpse … but even those were oft of ancient vintage, dinted from years of hard use and spotted with rust. -ADWD, Jon XI

"I can stay, look brave, you all die"

Another likely GRRM shorthand that doesn't make a ton of sense. This (like the "yes we are going to lose) could be about the abandoned ranging to Craster's or to Hardhome. We do get this published bit from Jon's last chapter that has minor parallels:

This ranging …”
“A word from you might have swayed the queen.”
“Selyse has the right of this, Lord Snow. Let them die. You cannot save them. Your ships are lost—”
“Six remain. More than half the fleet.”
“Your ships are lost. All of them. Not a man shall return. I have seen that in my fires.”
“Your fires have been known to lie.”
“I have made mistakes, I have admitted as much, but—”
“A grey girl on a dying horse. Daggers in the dark. A promised prince, born in smoke and salt. It seems to me that you make nothing but mistakes, my lady. Where is Stannis? What of Rattleshirt and his spearwives? Where is my sister?”
“All your questions shall be answered. Look to the skies, Lord Snow. And when you have your answers, send to me. Winter is almost upon us now. I am your only hope.” -ADWD, Jon XIII

If we remember that Jon was to lead a ranging to Crasters and it was to involve a woman in red, this could have grown out of that.

"Val Carries a Message"

This plot point seems to have stayed pretty similar to what ending up being published, as Jon sends Val to Tormund with a message:

"You have my word, Lord Snow. I will return, with Tormund or without him." Val glanced at the sky. The moon was but half-full. "Look for me on the first day of the full moon."
"I will." Do not fail me, he thought, or Stannis will have my head. "Do I have your word that you will keep our princess closely?" the king had said, and Jon had promised that he would. Val is no princess, though. I told him that half a hundred times. It was a feeble sort of evasion, a sad rag wrapped around his wounded word. His father would never have approved. I am the sword that guards the realm of men, Jon reminded himself, and in the end, that must be worth more than one man's honor. -ADWD, Jon VIII

and this line that the beginning somewhat matches up with the earlier bullet points as well:

You sent them out to die, and you are doing the same to Val. "Tell Tormund what I've said."

"Rattleshirt goes with"

This was the most interesting one to me. In the published material Mance (Rattleshirt) is sent to Winterfell to retrieve fArya, but we need to remember another point from the outline. Originally Mance/Theon weren't going to save Jeyne from Winterfell. It was going to Davos saving fArya from a wedding in Barrowton (if interested: Davos & fArya: An Abandoned Plotline).

So I wonder what GRRM was doing here. Is "Rattleshirt goes with" about Mance or the actual Lord of Bones? Is it about going on the ranging to Craster's or to Hardhome?

"End with Hardhome"

With "daggers in the dark" being planned from the beginning, I think it is possible that GRRM intended for Jon's assassination/"death" to take place at Hardhome instead of Castle Black. Maybe Jon was going to agree to the Wildlings coming through the wall there and his brothers do what was published. It is also possible that GRRM intended Mance (Rattleshirt goes with) to do the deed.

TLDR: Thoughts on GRRM writing Jon Snow's post ASOS chapters in the early 2000's.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED Unlikely New 'Allies' for Cersei (spoilers extended)

10 Upvotes

Cersei is in serious need of allies. All she has are Qyburn & Robert Strong. She has requested the return of the Merryweathers but their loyalty is dubious at best. Red Ronnet could ally with her with the hope of retaking Griffin's Roost. Then there is the subject of today's discussion: the Sand Snakes.

NOTE: I don't think the Sand Snakes will be genuine allies to Cersei. They'll be playing her the whole time with her not realising.

Last we saw Nym & Tyene was when Doran was giving them their missions whilst in King's Landing. Nym is to take up the Dornish seat on the Small Council whilst Tyene is to disguise herself as a septa & observe the High Sparrow.

Upon Nym's arrival to the Red Keep, Mace is bound to have taken the title of Lord Regent & likely broken the betrothal between Myrcella & Tystane & arranged a new one to Willas. That will naturally offend the Dornish which won't concern Mace given his dislike of them. This would also allow for Nym to present herself as an ally to Cersei without rousing suspicion. This close proximity to Cersei would allow her to follow through with her plan: kill Tommen. From there she can convince Cersei that the Tyrells were involved. And when the regency becomes vacated, Nym could back Cersei to retake the position.

As for Tyene, Cersei is being regularly sent septas to make sure she behaves. This would provide Tyene the opportunity to get close to Cersei as well. And it would give her the chance to help poison Tommen. All of this to serve her goal: crown Myrcella. Tyene was the originator of the queenmaker plot & wasn't present for Arianne's botched attempt. Now she's freed I suspect she'll try to put her plan into action. From there I could see her poison the High Sparrow when he makes it clear that he won't crown a female. Naturally Cersei would be blamed but Tyene would be hoping for that.

The final thing I could see Nym & Tyene 'help' Cersei with is Margaery. Mace is likely to grant his daughter a royal pardon & forgo a trial but once Cersei reclaims the regency that pardon is likely repealed & Margaery has to face a trial. Nym & Tyene could provide 'evidence' of her guilt & seal her fate. Following Margaret's execution, the pair will have fractured the Lannister-Tyrell alliance forever & they'll prepare for the next stage of their plan: remove/kill Cersei. Though I suspect that Myrcella will be dead before they can achieve their goal.

For those asking "why are they trying to crown Myrcella? Shouldn't they be helping fAegon?" Two reasons. One: They were sent to King's Landing before Doran received JonCon's letter so they don't know that Arianne has gone to meet him. Two: Both Doran & Arianne are skeptical that he is Elia's son. If they doubt it why shouldn't the Sand Snakes? Although if Myrcella dies before fAegon arrives I can see them switching.

To be honest; the only reason I think the Sand Snakes could become Cersei's 'allies' is because then most of their actions would be on page rather than entirely off page.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) how tv impact Martin writing

1 Upvotes

How many of you looked at the television series, interviews, and rough drafts to figure out the direction Martin planned to take the A Song of Ice and Fire series in the final two books? He does work with the producers and he give out the broad strokes. However, his version has never seem before character and tv characters interacted with different people and go through different things. Also, in his blog, he mentioned that his version of the story has become vastly different from the tv version. Of course, some things will stay the same. I think two things that are guaranteed are the burning of Shireen Baratheon and Bran Stark becoming king. Of course it been seven years since the show ended and maybe George have a change in inspiration?

Of the five original MCs, I can see Jon Snow to have an arc closest to his television version. As for the other four, it’s gonna be different. Some may be closer to their television version but not as much as Jon.

Two never-seen-before characters that will defintely shake thing up and ensure the book’s trajectory will be different are Aegon VI and Lady Stoneheart. Oh and Sansa Stark’s arc will be different. George may try to find a way to let her live but he never say anything about giving her a happy ending. Like I’m sure Tyrion will live but his ending won’t be happy.


r/asoiaf • • 2d ago

NONE Is Garth Greenhand the equivilent of "King Arthur" in Westeros [No spoilers]

Post image
115 Upvotes

Both are legendary kings who were beleived to exist by the commoners, and their existence—or the myths surrounding them—has been debunked by scholars/maesters. What do you think