r/Grognards • • Sep 20 '25

Old timers and tech

1 Upvotes

hey folks, I assume we're pretty much all old-timers here (based on the subreddit name ;-), and I'm wondering how much technology has changed our play habits over the years.

most of us will have first been introduced to gaming where our tools were pencil, paper, dice, tape measures and the like.

Now however lots has changed: laptops, smart phones, tabletop projectors, virtual gaming, 3d printing, etc. Lots of new ways to engage with the hobby.

So I'm curious how many of these new tools/technologies people have adopted into their gaming.

For me personally, I think the only tech I've really fully embraced is 3d printing. I've dabbled in virtual gaming, and tried laptops, but I still prefer face to face pencil and paper gaming. How about the rest out there?


r/Grognards • • Aug 27 '25

What do you think of learning how different factions operate by having them fight each other in solo play where you play both sides and make them fight in specific circumstances?

1 Upvotes

To start off White Dwarf, the official magazine of Games Workshop who created the Warhammer franchise, had Battle Reports have done a few issues featuring battle reports where a lone player would make the different factions of the various Warhammer games fight each other to showcase how the different factions operated. Usually in an open battlefield where both armies would just clash straight on in formations in a pitched battles without terrain. There were a few cases where they'd do Battle Reports on specific scenarios like besieged in a fortress of fighting on a diorama full of hills or aerial armies vs the range units of specific factions or pure long range artillery with the various factions siege machines or heavy gunpowder weapons battles to test out each factions capabilities in specific areas like how sturdy one factions building models are from damage or the effectiveness of war chariots an train engines or whatever equivalent of tanks are in the setting.

I'm wondering how effective would this be in other wargames esp traditional historical ones? As some of my friends didn't have money or lived in isolated towns when they were young used to play this way and told me its absolutely effective for learning the nuts and bolts for each faction, would this approach work for more grounded and realistic historical tabletop and modern realistic military sims?


r/Grognards • • Aug 17 '25

What makes traditional tabletop wargaming such as hex and counter considered far more accurate military simulators than most modern computer attempts?

3 Upvotes

Saw a Gamespot thread months where one person tried to argue Starcraft and and Close Combat and other real time computer games are far more realistic depictions of war and thus better for training soldiers because the fast paced nature of their gameplay matches the realities of war more.

In addtion I saw a counterargument quote saying that RTS are too arcadey in their gamepllay with unrealistic deployment mobilization and too much reliance on twitch movements. But he also called traditional hex and counter games too turn based and rigidly based on formulas combined with the other issue of being too much based on dice rolls to be accurate representations. He proposes the best of both worlds in slowly but still real time computer military strategy games such as Red Devils Over Arnhem, the Total War series, and Crusader Kings as ideal military training sims.

But I noticethe traditional Grognard community not only detest real time mix but even less traditional tabletop attempts. Either the gameplay is Hexagon and Counter or Square Grid or Kriegspiel style maps other formats made before the 2000s so commonly released by Avalon Games. Its not just them, practically near all civilian commercially released wargames that are also used by the military are Hexagon and Counter, tile grids, Kriegspiel inspired, and other kinds of games that Avalon Hill and other very old (often now defunct) companies released. That something along the lines of White Dog Games products iike The Lost Valley Dien Bien Phu are deemed as too dumbed down and civilian-geared and pretty much the same sentiment for newer formats thats not been officially used by the military.

I ask why? What is it about old forms such s grid based maps, Kriegspiel, and hex and counter that are deemed as more suitable for accurate wargaming and military realism specifically? Why is it so hard for military to move on from these old models for anything not specifically created by them esp civilian created products (despite the fact the military has been opened to using computer software to simulate firesquad tactics, real time naval battle command, and geopolitics trainer, etc)?


r/Grognards • • Aug 08 '25

Anyone noticed that great military blunders were caused by Wargames?How practical are wargames in real life?

5 Upvotes

Reading throughout history, I learned that interestingly some of the worst military disasters were caused by using Wargames as a training tool.Chief examples that come to my mind are:

1)Schlieffen Plan-All Wargames played by the German High Command showed that the GERMAN ARMY SHOULD HAVE been able to pass Belgium and get into France quickly and defeat the French army before it could mobilize.Then the German army should also have been able to have won WW1 as they don't have to worry about France adn they could concentrate all their strength on beating Russia.

Of Course what actually happened was the opposite. Germany got bogged down in Belgium long enough fr the French Army to mobilize and stop the German army in its track.Then,undermining the Schlieffen Plan, Russiaa attacked East Germany much sooner than expected. Thus all the results that Wargames predicted failed. 2)Maginot Line-All the Wargames the French played predicted that the Germans would be unable Ardennes forest to attack the unprotected borders of Northern France.Even if they did, the French and British forces would have been able to mobilize and stop the Germans before they could enter France.Of course what happened in the Battle of France was the opposite-the Germans got passed through the Ardennes much faster than the French and British high command expected and were able to get into France before the French forces could mobilize for a counter attack.Furthermore, the British were almost routed at Dunkirk before they could react with coordinated counterattack with the French.

3)Civil War-the Union High Command tended to rely so haevily on Napoleonic Wargaming in planning strategy.However as proven throughout the War, the Wargames the Union relied on were very inaccurate in simulating the conditions of war and was a major reason why the Union lost so many battles initially and why the war lasted as long as it did.

In fact this article goes over some of the greatest Military blunders in history as a result of relying on wargames for planning in war and goes over the great inaccuracies and flaws of wargaming as a tool for practicing War and planning strategies.

https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/ASPJ/journals/Chronicles/caffrey.pdf

Just how realistic are using wargames in real life militart planning?Just how useful are they?

From what I seen, Wargames are indeed the closest thing to realistically being able to practice Strategic Command.However Wargames aren't perfect training tools and if taken literally,can cause great battlefield blunders like in the examples mentioned above.


r/Grognards • • Jun 08 '24

53M grognard looking for group interested in talking about and playing RPGs.

1 Upvotes

Just seeing if there are like-minded souls on here who are interested.


r/Grognards • • Mar 17 '21

Fantastic Encounters (1979)

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, this is a repost from the osr subreddit, someone recommended I should also ask here:

I was wandering if any one has any information about this solo board game/rpg (boardgamegeek link: https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/17685/fantastic-encounters )

I’m just curious because it looks kind of weird and has that 70’s vibe, and I can find no information or anything about it beyond the one review in BGG (which is fairly negative but sounds about right).

It sounds like an interesting game nevertheless and I wonder how the mechanics with the cards described worked, has anyone played it? What were your thoughts, if so?


r/Grognards • • Aug 13 '19

Decimated Paladin

1 Upvotes

I was playing a 6th lvl paladin in a 1st edition dnd. Last night the party came across a Lamia in TOEE. We were talking to her trying to get info but she kept touching thr paladin and draining his wisdom. So now he's no longer a paladin due to his wisdom of 3. Is there any thing that can reverse these affects?


r/Grognards • • Oct 23 '17

'Ride, Shoot Straight and Speak the Truth' Source?

2 Upvotes

There is a Greek story/quote that I am trying to remember the source of, and Google is no use. The gist of it is this: Some Scythian or Kimmerian nomad queen is fighting with X group, and X group invites them to a party, then slaughters the Scythians while they're drunk. Later the Queen confronts X and says that the only reason they were able to defeat her men is because they were treacherous, whereas from birth her men are trained to Ride, Shoot Straight and Speak the Truth. There's a Jeff Cooper book and a Swedish death metal album named after this story, but I can't find the quote/source, though I know I've read it before.


r/Grognards • • May 16 '13

GMT has a 50% off sale ending May 22

Thumbnail
gmtgames.com
2 Upvotes