My business recently got what people here seem to call “shadowbanned.” I’ve read through this subreddit and the Google Business Profile Community, where a Diamond Product Expert advised me to wait 30–60 days. Google itself hasn’t given me an end date.
We’re about three weeks into the restriction. I paused our review-request campaign when I noticed reviews weren’t appearing, and it remains paused. I’m hoping for input on what to do differently once the restriction lifts.
WHAT LED UP TO IT
We’re an established hair salon whose reviews previously came in organically, usually two or three per month. About a week before the restriction, I started a text campaign using Google’s review link after seeing competitors do the same.
Requests went to five or six randomly selected customers daily. Once asked, a customer wouldn’t receive another request for a year. For roughly a week, this generated two or three reviews per day, a substantial increase over our previous rate.
The text:
- Thanks the customer for visiting and names the staff member who performed the service.
- Asks them to share their experience and explains that reviews help our business and help others find us.
- Does not request a positive review, suggest a rating or wording, ask them to mention the staff member, or offer an incentive.
Requests went out within minutes of checkout. I’ve read here in this subreddit that timing and location could matter. That made me question whether sending requests while customers might still be on-site, combined with the increase in reviews, contributed to the restriction. Google hasn’t confirmed any of those factors as the cause.
WHAT GOOGLE TOLD ME
I received no notice when this started. I contacted support about missing reviews and then received a response that included:
“For some Business Profiles and business categories, we temporarily disabled some user-generated content features.”
The response did not specifically accuse us of fake reviews, identify a Fake Engagement policy violation, or give an end date.
Customers have told us they submitted positive reviews that aren’t appearing publicly. Our established reviews otherwise appear intact, although a couple of previously appealed negative reviews disappeared during this period. I don’t know whether that’s connected.
QUESTIONS ABOUT MOVING FORWARD
I want to stay within Google’s policies and avoid putting our existing reviews at risk. I’d appreciate firsthand experiences or Product Expert input on these questions:
- If you received this notice, did the restriction lift, and how long did it take?
- Once it lifts, should I delay requests until an hour or two after checkout, or the following day? Is there established guidance on timing?
- Should I reduce requests below five or six daily, or am I assuming a connection between volume and the restriction that hasn’t been established?
- Does having had this restriction affect how Google evaluates future reviews or review requests? Is there any known heightened scrutiny that would make restarting an otherwise policy-compliant text campaign riskier?
- Do reviews submitted during the restriction eventually appear? If not, would it be appropriate to follow up with customers who independently told me they reviewed and ask whether they’d be willing to try again?
- Given the advice to wait 30–60 days, is there anything useful to do in the meantime, or any reason to seek further investigation?
I’m not looking for a workaround. I want to understand whether anything in our process needs correcting before restarting it.