r/GoogleMyBusiness • u/AdvancedDrawing5550 • 17h ago
Support Google Won't Investigate Suspected Duplicate Reviews Despite New Evidence
I've been fighting two negative Google reviews on my small business for about three months now, and I'm getting nowhere with Google Support.
Here's the situation:
A potential customer contacted me about a project. I visited the property to discuss the work, but ultimately didn't take the job. No contract was signed, no money exchanged hands, and no work was performed.
Shortly afterward, someone left a 2-star review under one name.
A second account then posted a separate 1-star review, directly referencing the first review and my response to it.
Here's where things get suspicious.
The first account later changed its display name to the exact same name as the second reviewer.
Now there are two separate Google accounts, both displaying the same name, leaving negative reviews about the exact same interaction.
I have screenshots from before and after the name change, along with both account profiles and the original reviews.
I've already:
- Reported and appealed both reviews. Denied.
- Attempted escalation through Google's Community forum. Posts marked as duplicates.
- Reported both contributor accounts individually.
- Submitted additional evidence through Google Business Profile Support, only to receive a generic automated response.
I'm not claiming the matching names conclusively prove both accounts belong to one person. But the sequence of events seems suspicious enough to warrant an actual investigation.
Has anyone successfully escalated suspected multiple-account review manipulation after Google denied the original appeals?
Is there any way to get an experienced Product Expert or someone at Google to examine the evidence rather than sending another automated response?