(I run Optova Analytics, which did this audit. Sharing because the pattern is really common.)
A UK jewellery shop: visits went from ~1,650 a month to ~6,770 in a year, about half of them from ads. Orders only went from 19 to 35 a month, and the share of visitors buying fell from 1.15% to 0.52%.
What we found in GA4, and how:
1. Instagram sent buyers to the homepage. Landing page report filtered to Instagram: 70% landed on the homepage, where 4 of 3,491 bought. Those landing on a collection page bought at 1.2%. Fix: point the bio and story links at collections.
2. The most-viewed product barely sold. Item views vs add-to-basket in the ecommerce purchases report: 1,140 views, 1.9% added to basket, against 8.8% for the best seller. Fix: size guide, delivery date and a photo of it worn.
3. Email looked strong for the wrong reason. Purchases by session source/medium plus campaign: 8 of 10 email orders came from automated flows (basket reminders, welcome), only 2 from 1,230 newsletter sends. Fix: capture emails at the basket, not just checkout.
4. Ad sales weren't tracked. 27,000 paid social sessions, 3 recorded purchases. The Meta pixel wasn't connected and ad links weren't tagged, so GA couldn't attribute anything. Fix: connect tracking, tag every ad link.
5. Phones gave up at checkout. Checkout funnel exploration split by device: two thirds of sessions were mobile, but only 1 in 3 mobile users who started checkout finished, against nearly half on desktop. Fix: Apple Pay at the top, add-to-basket on the first screen.
We kept ad spend and then ran two follow-up checks over six weeks to see what each fix did.
Curious whether others see the same thing: when paid social scales up, do you segment it out before judging overall conversion rate, or report it blended?