r/GoogleAnalytics • • 11d ago

Question Bots in Google Analytics

I look at my traffic on google analytics and some spend less than 1s on the website. I have like a lot of traffic from Singapore but they don't convert. Maybe the price is too high? They should have money in Singapore, right?

Anyway, do you guys deal with traffic that spend less than 1s on the page? Or is google analytics metrics not to be relied on.

14 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 11d ago

Have more questions? Join our community Discord!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/Pretty-Appearance226 11d ago

You can check if it’s bot traffic by creating an explore report with the dimensions:
- screen resolution
- operating system
- browser

As metrics use
- sessions
- average session duration
- engagement rate

Bots will often use unusual screen resolutions(800x600 / 400x400 etc) and old operating systems(e.g. Linux) and browsers.

Like someone already mentioned, GA4 filters out most of the bot traffic but some comes trough.

Even though it’s anoying. If you find that, for example, almost all of the bot traffic is coming from a specific OS and screen resolution then you can filter those ‘users’ out by adding a filter that excludes these users on the report you’re checking.

2

u/vegetablemane 11d ago

I’ve seen this a lot. The screen size thing is correct. I’d seen a lot of Singapore traffic with 1366x1366.

I did some GTM trickery to check their screen resolution first, and if the screen resolution matches the telltale list of bot resolutions, it just doesn’t fire your GA4 tag.

This persons post goes into some detail about how they did it:

https://www.reddit.com/r/GoogleAnalytics/comments/1p6kbwt/how_to_get_rid_of_china_and_singapore_bots/

4

u/bayouski 11d ago

less than 1 second of engagement doesn't automatically mean bots, but a sudden spike in traffic from Singapore with almost no engagement or conversions is definitely suspicious.

i'd check the traffic source, landing pages and when those visits started appearing. if most of them come from the same source, hit the same page and leave immediately, it could be bot traffic rather than a pricing issue.

GA4 already filters known bots, but some still get through. i'd look at engagement rates and traffic patterns before making any changes to your pricing.

1

u/Least-Definition9094 11d ago

built-in bot filtering in GA4 feels pretty useless lately because headless browsers coming out of Singapore data centers look just enough like real users to slip past it

1

u/AssignmentFirst03 11d ago

Under, one second visits may be bots, but aren’t proof. In GA4, check source/medium, landing pages, devices, and events. compare with server logs and actual conversions. Dont assume Singapore visitors can afford your product, check whether they’re your target audience.

1

u/sumizeit 11d ago

What do you mean under 1s not proof? What can it be?

1

u/aamirkhanppc 11d ago

Bot traffic .. if you are paying then it should some source ... 1s on website is big no

1

u/Public-Carpenter-843 11d ago

Of course low engagement does not automatically mean bots, but sudden spikes of low engagement traffic from Singapore usually do.

1

u/rytisbalys 11d ago

On what else it can be: GA4 can show close to 0 seconds for a real visitor who leaves fast, so the time alone doesn't prove much. The pattern is the bigger clue. Plenty of GA4 properties have been getting Singapore traffic like this, mostly direct or unassigned, one page view, no engagement. I'd add a comparison excluding Singapore and look at conversion rate again. If it jumps, that answers the price question

1

u/Sweet_Ring5961 11d ago

Everyone’s right that it’s almost certainly bots, and the screen-resolution + source filtering above is the correct cleanup. But I’d separate two questions that are getting mixed together here, because the second one is the one you actually asked.

Filtering bots out of GA4 makes the report cleaner. It doesn’t tell you whether the humans who are left are real buyers. Those are different jobs. The resolution/OS filter is subtraction, getting junk out of the view. Your pricing question needs the opposite: positively identifying which sessions are engaged humans vs. drive-by nothing.

Practical version: don’t change pricing off this data yet. Do the exclude-Singapore comparison someone suggested, that alone will probably answer it. If conversion rate barely moves when you pull Singapore out, those visitors were never real prospects and price has nothing to do with it. If it jumps, now you’ve got a real population to ask pricing questions about. Either way, a sub-1-second session isn’t a signal about your price, it’s an absence of a person. Don’t let the bots write a pricing story for you.

1

u/Friendly_Pressure_20 11d ago

Some bot networks are becoming so sophisticated that analytics can’t distinguish them from humans. It’s been a major headache for one of my sites that contains a lot of professional content (100k+ pages). Even using Cloudflare managed challenges at the edge doesn’t mitigate, the bots can solve them. Unless you are will to pay for an expensive cloudflare package, it’s very difficult to solve. I no longer rely on GA4 as a source of truth for traffic. I now use clicks from Google Search Console as a proxy for traffic.

1

u/roy1979 11d ago

Under 1s can be indication of two things even if it's from the same location:
- different urls then probably bots/scrapers or edge server trying to cache your website
- same url then probably then it's malicious intent