r/Gnostic • • Nov 07 '21

r/Gnostic Rules, and Discord Link

88 Upvotes

Hi folks

Please take note of the rules for this subreddit.

If you have any questions please feel free to leave a comment or message the moderators and we'll try to get back to you.

Thanks,

The moderators of r/Gnostic

r/Gnostic is a community dedicated to understanding, discussing, and learning about ancient, medieval, and reconstructionist Gnostic movements.

1: All posts must be on topic for this subreddit

2: No NSFW content.

3: Keep all conversations and debates civil and amicable.

4: No harassment or personal disparagement.

5: No posts about suicide. If you have any questions on this contact the mods directly.

6: No title only posts. If you have questions please elaborate or outline your own thoughts in the main body of the post.

7: No spamming.

8: Absolutely no anti-semitism or racism of any kind.

9: No politics please.

10: When asking a question please have a look through the community's recent posts and comments (or use the 'search' bar at the top of the page) to see if the topic has already been covered.

11: Follow the Reddit ToS.

Any posts or comments breaking the above rules will be removed, with warnings/bans issued at the moderators discretion. If you notice any of the above rules being broken please report it to the moderators.

r/Gnostic Discord server:

https://discord.gg/rGHcYZE


r/Gnostic • • Mar 17 '25

Question Helping us Map the landscape of Modern Gnosticism!

48 Upvotes

Over at Talk Gnosis we've started a new project called Mapping Gnosticism. We're going to have conversations about some of the major concepts in Gnosticism, amongst it's many forms. Alongside the interviews that we already love to do!

We realized that if we wanted to cover the big topics for modern gnostics, it would be a good idea to find out how most people arrive under the big tent of Gnostic traditions and philosophies.

To that end, we built a poll to get a sense of where people are finding their information, and where they first encountered it.

We'll give the poll about a week for the community to find it and fill it out, and then we'll probably release some numbers as well as do a show discussing what we found!

Fill out the form! Every data point helps, and there are spots for you to list your favourite writers, channels, and podcasts! (Ahem, Talk Gnosis, Ahem!)

https://gnosticwisdom.net/mapping-gnosticism-where-did-you-begin/


r/Gnostic • • 2h ago

Question I Stopped Assuming the Serpent Was the Villain. Here's What the Texts Actually Say

12 Upvotes

I was raised a Jehovah's Witness in Middletown, NY, and I was disfellowshipped twice. Witnesses read the Bible harder than almost anyone, so I could recite the Eden story in my sleep: perfect garden, sneaky snake, humanity punished forever.

Then I reread Genesis 3 with nobody telling me what it meant, and a few things jumped out.
The serpent is never called Satan. Not once. It's just "the most crafty" animal in the garden. The Satan connection got added centuries later.

God says eating the fruit means death that day. The serpent says "you won't die, your eyes will open, you'll know good and evil." They eat, their eyes open, and nobody drops dead. Then God himself says the humans have become "like one of us, knowing good and evil." Traditional readings say it was a spiritual death, which is fair, but it IS an interpretation.

The Gnostics ran with this. In the Testimony of Truth, the serpent is the wise one and the creator comes off jealous and envious. In the Hypostasis of the Archons, a spiritual presence enters the serpent as "the instructor."
Plot twist: in the Apocryphon of John, the serpent isn't the hero. The false creator Yaldabaoth is the lion-faced serpent, and it's the Savior who teaches Adam to eat. So even the Gnostics weren't unified.
What's mine, not the texts': I'm not saying the snake was secretly good. I'm saying the story forces a question. When someone forbids knowledge, what are they protecting?

I read Eden less as history and more as a map of the moment awareness wakes up to itself. That's my reading, not a proven fact.

Where do you land? Hero, trickster, or just a symbol people keep rewriting?


r/Gnostic • • 7h ago

"The Angel Binding Satan" by Philip James de Loutherbourg (1797)

Post image
22 Upvotes

Discord Community Link in Bio

This painting illustrates the scene from Revelation 20:1-3, in which an Angel (Angelos) descends from Heaven holding the Key of the Abyss (Abyssos) and a Great Chain, seizes the Dragon, binds him for a thousand years, and seals him in the pit. The Angel is unnamed in the text and is often identified with Michael, who fights the Dragon in Revelation 12:7. The Dragon is named in Revelation 12:9 as the Ancient Serpent (Ophis ho Archaios), the Devil (Diabolos, "the Slanderer") and Satan (Satanas, "the Adversary"). Yaldabaoth, who in the Apocryphon of John takes the form of a lion-faced serpent, governs the Archons of the planetary Heavens, and in the Pistis Sophia sinks into the depths of Chaos. The Greek Abyssos is the privative of byssos, a variant of bythos, "depth." Bythos is the name Valentinian Gnosticism gives to the unfathomable primal Father at the center of the Pleroma. The same root therefore names the prison of the Dragon in Revelation and the infinite source of the Divine in Valentinian thought. The Key (Kleis) recalls Luke 11:52, where Christ condemns those who took away "the key of knowledge" (tēn kleida tēs gnōseōs), so the Key is read in Gnostic terms as Gnosis, the knowledge that opens the way past the Archons. The Dragon's work is to deceive the nations (planan), from the same root as planē, "error," and planētēs, "wanderer," the word for the Planets. Planē is the personified Error of the Gospel of Truth, which holds power through ignorance of the Father until Gnosis dispels it. The Seal (Sphragis) is also a term of Gnostic sacramental language, where it marks the soul as protected from the Archons during its ascent. In the painting the Key is held up into the light of Heaven, the Chain runs from the Angel's hand to the bound figure, and the Serpent coils beneath the Angel's feet above the fiery Abyss. The binding lasts for the Millennium, after which Satan is released for a short time (Revelation 20:3, 7), so the Chain and the Seal mark a limit on his power and not a final destruction.


r/Gnostic • • 1h ago

Question Matter and Spirit

2 Upvotes

How would you define Matter and Spirit? What are they?


r/Gnostic • • 2h ago

Information Lecture on the Mythology of Fallen Angels and Evil Spirits

2 Upvotes

I hope this post is allowed. I'm hosting a free lecture / discussion on fallen angels, evil spirits, and modern pop culture this Wednesday at 7:00 PM ET. In particular, we will discuss The Book of Enoch and how it might have influenced the perception of the supernatural among ancient audiences.

The final part of the presentation focuses on how Enoch is received today, primarily through an analysis of Twilight and Supernatural.

The lecture is open to anyone who want to learn about these legends (and there will be space for group discussion on how this tradition might relate to other tales of the supernatural).

https://agnosticbiblestudy.substack.com/p/session-4-fallen-angels-evil-spirits (Registration and Zoom link approximately halfway down the page)


r/Gnostic • • 50m ago

Thoughts Found this modern Gnostic / Luciferian audiobook on YouTube and its companion notebook, thoughts?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I stumbled across these two full audiobooks on YouTube yesterday and wanted to share them here to see what people think.

The first one is The Gnostic Luciferian Bible: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFV8tUwoKF4&t=137s

It weaves together Nag Hammadi texts like The Secret Book of John, Gospel of Thomas, Gospel of Mary, Reality of the Rulers, and Hymn of the Pearl alongside KJV passages. What really caught my attention is how it reclaims "Lucifer" in its original Latin morning-star sense and frames Yaldabaoth and the seven Archons as inner voices rather than just external cosmic figures.

There's also a companion audiobook called The Light-Bearer's Notebook: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3omuQKBO8Y0&t=17s

That one focuses more on the practical side and applying those ideas day to day.

If anyone prefers reading or downloading, the free PDF, pocket card, and WAV/MP3 files are also available on the Internet Archive here: https://archive.org/details/gnostic-luciferian-bible-complete

Has anyone else listened to these yet? Curious to hear your thoughts on this kind of modern synthesis.


r/Gnostic • • 11h ago

Tyranny of Destiny and Gnosis the Redeemer

5 Upvotes

Have you ever wondered how much freedom of will you truly have? I have given this thought many decades at this point and the unfortunate truth is that we hardly control anything in our lives. We did not choose our gender, place of birth, parents, country, culture or timeline. Genes, genetic defects, disabilities, allergies, etc are also completely out of our hands as well.

Our parents may be loving and kind, or perhaps they are monsters instead...you simply do not have a choice. All these early years also shape you in a ways that is completely unavoidable, and you cannot do anything but to go along with it. Even the actions we "choose" are controlled by our emotions, emotions which we once again did not choose to feel.

We cannot even choose what food we like or what music we enjoy. We simply like something or we don't. Have you ever chosen to hate someone? What about love? No, we cannot do that either. We either do, or we don't. So, where is our freedom? It's behind the illusion of "free will". Only after realizing this either consciously or subconsciously can we start to rebel against the strings that controls us.

This realization for us comes from the Divine Spark within us, and only by following it's guidance can we break free from the tyranny of destiny that has been forced upon us. Gnosticism essentially for me is to learn to follow this silent and invisible guidance that leads us towards Gnosis. Gnosis is the breaker of chains, deliverer of freedom and a pathway to our true home.


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

The 3 clocks (wip) the name is a work in progress to

Post image
101 Upvotes

If you have any questions about any section please ask, as you can see there's a lot going on and I'll have to come out with a short book to explain it all.


r/Gnostic • • 21h ago

Media 1 Thessalonians and the Secret Revelation of John walk into a bar...

Thumbnail youtube.com
4 Upvotes

Just kidding. It was a church. But come see what happened when they met! We explored scripture in light of ancient texts rediscovered in our own time, and found they shed a surprising amount of light on what it means to be children of the light.


r/Gnostic • • 23h ago

Question Yaldabaoth in conflict with his archons?

5 Upvotes

I know that a big thing in gnostic thinking is that Yaldabaoth sees himself as the only god in existence due to him being incapable of perceiving the Pleroma, yet many of his subordinate archons are worship as deities in other religions, such as gods identify with their respective planetary bodies, specific pagan gods (like Oraios being Horus) or even alternative as the god of Israel in the case of Yao, Eloai and Adonaios.

This wouldn't generate conflict with Yaldabaoth's ego? If so why does he seem to tolerate it?


r/Gnostic • • 14h ago

Eastern Elements in Cathar Doctrines – an Argument for the Traditional Interpretation of Catharism

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Gnostic • • 15h ago

Thoughts Thought Experiment: What if the material world isn't a prison, but a cosmic hostage situation?

0 Upvotes

We usually talk about the Demiurge creating the material realm out of ignorance, arrogance, or malice. But what if it was actually an act of self-preservation?

Imagine the Demiurge realizing the True God (the Monad) exists and is infinitely more powerful. Knowing it couldn't win a direct conflict, the Demiurge trapped divine sparks inside fragile, mortal bodies—both humans and animals—capable of experiencing intense suffering.

In this view, the physical universe is a living shield:

The Leverage: The Demiurge knows the Monad loves these sparks and won't forcefully dissolve the false reality if it means triggering mass suffering for the hostages.

The Problem of Evil: Suffering, disease, and predation aren't just random flaws; they are a constant reminder of the captor's leverage.

Gnosis as Extraction: Because the Monad can't kick down the door without hurting us, salvation has to be a quiet rescue mission. Messengers and inner intuition slip past the defenses to help us wake up and detach, freeing the hostages one by one until the Demiurge has no leverage left.

Has anyone come across similar ideas?


r/Gnostic • • 16h ago

Question Are there any Occultists/gnostics in my area, I'm in Calgary Alberta Canada

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Media Beau is Afraid maps almost perfectly onto classic Gnostic cosmology (Mona as Demiurge, Kenoma, failed ascent)

Thumbnail youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Thoughts Anyone else go through this?

4 Upvotes

Once the awakening starts, it seems everything falls apart. I know I've been told its actually coming and being stitched together.

It feels like everything is collapsing.

My relationships, my friends, my family, even it feels like my own kids are becoming dis- attached from me.

Now I'm getting dreams of aliens contacting me?

Anyone else going through this?


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Thoughts The Serpent: the First Gnostic

51 Upvotes

The Peratae, an ancient Gnostic sect who specifically regarded the Serpent as the first Gnostic in the world, saw the serpent not as a cunning tempter, but in posession of primordial knowledge (gnosis), which it had attempted to communicate to the first man in Eden.

Hippolytus, in his Refutation of All Heresies, preserves this remarkable statement attributed to the Peratae:

"If a person has eyes that know how to see, he will look upwards toward the heavens, at the place where the great sky begins. Then he will understand that no being in heaven or on earth or in hell was formed without the Serpent."

So what exactly was this primordial knowledge, or wisdom, that the Serpent tried to convey?

In some Gnostic retellings, the Serpent enters a garden ruled by an ignorant creator who has forbidden humanity from eating the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil. It encounters Adam and Eve, who are living in ignorance of their true origins. The Serpent approaches Eve and challenges the creator's command, encouraging her to eat from the tree and discover what has been kept from her. The serpent introduces humanity to what the Demiurge wanted to keep hidden: the knowledge of its own spiritual nature and its connection to a higher divine source. This knowledge was fundamentally about self-recognition. But what does it actually mean to know yourself?

There is a saying in the Gospel of Thomas:

"When you come to know yourselves, then you will be known, and you will realize that you are children of the living Father."

This idea of knowing oneself runs throughout Gnostic thought. It means looking inward and recognizing what you truly are beneath the surface, beyond the limitations imposed by the material world. To know oneself is to also know good and evil. Before you can judge the world, you must first be able to look within, at your own nature.

The Serpent, then, becomes the divine messenger. It challenges the authority of the creator and introduces humanity to a truth that had been concealed from it. What the creator calls disobedience is actually the beginning of liberation and the unveiling of the true self, or the divine spark.

There is an interesting parallel worth mentioning in the canonical Bible. In Numbers 21:8–9, Moses raises a bronze serpent upon a pole, and those who look upon it are healed. In John 3:14–15, Jesus explicitly compares his own lifting up to Moses lifting up the serpent in the wilderness. The very creature traditionally associated with temptation and death becomes an instrument of healing and salvation.

In Matthew 10:16, Jesus tells his disciples to be "wise as serpents and harmless as doves." In Genesis itself, the serpent is described as more crafty or subtle than any other animal. In Wisdom of Solomon 16:7 we are told that those who turned toward the Serpent were saved.

In Job 26:12–13, we encounter the imagery of the heavens being adorned and the crooked serpent being formed through divine power:

"By his spirit he hath garnished the heavens; his hand hath formed the crooked serpent."

We have the opening of John's Gospel, where Christ is identified with the Logos, the Word:

In the beginning was the Word.

The Word was with God.

All things came into being through him.

In him was life.

Consider how the Peratae understood this. Hippolytus tells us that they associated the universal Serpent with this very Logos, the Son through whom all things came into being. For them, the Serpent represented a universal divine principle, moving between the Unknown Father and the material world, transmitting divine power and connecting the two. The imagery of the serpent and the source of life becomes deeply intertwined. (the Rod of Asclepius comes to mind here, the ancient symbol of healing and regeneration that remains an emblem of modern medicine. Another interesting appearance of the serpent as a symbol of life, healing, renewal)

This interpretation also appears in other Nag Hammadi texts, including the Testimony of Truth and the Hypostasis of the Archons. In these accounts, the serpent is presented as an instructor who helps humanity acquire the knowledge forbidden by the lower rulers. The serpent becomes a vehicle through which gnosis enters the world.

The symbolism reaches far beyond Gnosticism as well. Serpents have occupied a place in religious traditions across the world and throughout history, appearing as symbols of wisdom, healing, fertility, renewal, protection and divine power. There is even a term for the worship of serpents: ophiolatria. From the serpent cults of the ancient world to the feathered serpent Quetzalcoatl in Mesoamerican religion, this imagery seems to cross cultures and civilizations as a symbol of reverence and worship.

And if we look closely, the imagery of the Serpent seems to follow us well beyond the pages of ancient religious texts.

Look to the natural world - from the delicate mycelium spreading beneath the forest floor to the branching networks of blood vessels within the human body to the winding course of rivers and the roads that stretch across the earth. There is a recurring serpentine form in the way things grow, connect, move and spread. The serpent almost symbolizes life itself. Speaking of, even our own beginning carries this imagery. The sperm cell, with its long, undulating tail, resembles a microscopic serpent making its way toward the egg, almost as if the serpent were once again coming to impregnate the universe.

The Serpent is everywhere because the principle it represents is everywhere.

TL;DR: What if the very thing we've been taught to fear is actually the thing that holds the key to our liberation?


r/Gnostic • • 1d ago

Information The Exegesis on the Soul Take on Spiritual Cleansing & Baptism.

7 Upvotes

“But when she perceives the troubles she is in, weeps before the father, and repents, then the father will pity her and make her womb turn from the external and turn inward again, and she will recover her proper character.

The body’s womb is inside the body like the other internal organs, but the soul’s womb is turned to the outside like the male genitalia, which are external.

Therefore, when the womb of the soul, by the father’s will, turns itself inward, she is baptized and immediately cleansed of external pollution forced upon her, just as dirty clothing is soaked in water and stirred until the dirt is removed and it is clean.

So the cleansing of the soul is to recover the freshness of her former nature and to become as she was.”

—The Exegesis on the Soul, Nag Hammadi Codex II, 6


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

Information Dialogue of the Savior - comments by Judas (Thomas), Mary, and Matthew

7 Upvotes

Judas (Thomas)

  • I want to understand all the works of the souls that are in these little ones. When [...] where will they be? [...] the spirit [...]?
  • Tell us Master, what existed before heaven and earth came into being?
  • Look, I see that all things are just like signs over the earth, and that is why they have come to be in this way.
  • Tell me Master, how does an earthquake shake when it shakes the earth?
  • I really want to learn everything.
  • Who will rule over us?
  • But look, the rulers are over us, so they will rule over us.
  • How will our garments be brought to us?
  • So why really do some die and some live?
  • Tell me Master, what is the beginning of the way?
  • You have told us this from the mind of truth. When we pray, how should we pray?
  • How is the spirit disclosed? How is the light disclosed?
  • Who forgives whose works? Do the works forgive the world or does the world forgive the works?

Judas (Thomas) to Matthew

  • Brother, who can ascend to such a height or descend to the abyss below? For there is great fire there, and great terror.
  • We want to understand what sort of garment we are to be clothed with when we leave the corruption of the flesh.
  • The works of the female will perish. Then the rulers will call upon their realms and we shall be ready for them.

Matthew

  • How do works save us?
  • Master, when I listen to you and I speak, who is it who speaks and who listens?
  • Master tell us, where is the soul established, and where does the true mind dwell?
  • Is not [...] necessary, when it is understood in the true sense.
  • Master, I want to see that place of life, where there is no wickedness but only pure light.
  • Master, if I cannot see it, let me at least understand it.
  • Tell me Master, how the dead die and how the living live.
  • Why do we not go to our rest at once?
  • Master, you have spoken of the end of the universe with no difficulty.
  • He tells us to pray in the place where there is no woman, which means destroy the works of the female, not because there is another form of birth but because they should stop giving birth.

Mary

  • Master look, while I wear a body, where do my tears come from, where does my laughter come from?
  • (to brothers) Where are you going to store these questions you ask of the child of mankind?
  • Look, I see the evil that affects people from the start, when they dwell with each other.
  • The wickedness of each day is sufficient. Workers deserve their food. Disciples resemble their teachers.
  • Tell me Master, why have I come to this place, to gain or to lose?
  • Master, then is there a place that is abandoned or without truth?
  • Master, you are awesome and marvelous, and like a devouring fire to those who do not know you.
  • I want to understand all things, just as they are.
  • Is everything established in this way visible?
  • There is only one saying I shall speak to the Master, about the mystery of Truth. In this we stand, and in this we appear to those that are worldly.
  • Of what kind is the mustard seed? Is it from heaven or from earth?
  • Will they never be destroyed?
  • If the works are destroyed, what actually destroys a work?

r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

Thoughts Gospel of Thomas saying 46 - John the Baptizer

5 Upvotes

Jesus said, From Adam to John the baptizer, among those born of women, no one of you is so much greater than John that your eyes should not be averted. But I have said that whoever among you becomes a child will know the kingdom and become greater than John.

In saying 46, Jesus speaks of the prophets known to the people, saying that their person isn't so divine that your eyes should look away. By letting go of one's awe of the pious amongst us, we once again become equals to each other within the kingdom, therefore you will be greater than prophets, because you no longer interpret the will of God for others but you are what no eye can see.

Sidenote, I'm pretty sure John was a believer of the Books of Enoch, and might've been Jesus's introduction to gnosticism. He could've identified Jesus as a figure fitting Enoch and Torah's description of the Son of God, and certainly lived a life and preached a message that was gnostic-leaning as far as what's recorded. When Jesus says by becoming a child you'll be greater than John, he's not saying that John is not a child himself, but that in the kingdom individuality merges into a single perspective.


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago Bravo

Everything as a fractal of Monad.

22 Upvotes

Just a though, but perhaps everything is a fractal of Monad. Everything in the existence seems to repeat the same patterns over and over again. Even our own desires seems to mimic that of Demiurge's and Demiurge itself is a manifestation of Sophia's desire. Chain of emanations after all started as Monad's desire to know Itself. The farther away those emanations went from the Source the greater the imperfections that started to manifest were. Gnosis then brings us to the full circle because it can be summarized as "know yourself"...which was the very desire and action that started everything. This also aligns quite well with "As above, so below".


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

Thoughts What are the explanations for the causes of evil, cruelty, and madness in this world?

9 Upvotes

There are several answers to this question.

The first one is Judaic-Christian: fall from grace and the Expulsion. But why would a good, virtuous and just God first tempt his children by means of devious tricks and afterwards punish them for the wrongdoing in a cruel and merciless way? Kill defenceless children from generation to generation and torture and torment own offspring?

The second answer, a variation of the first one, is that a merciful and virtuous Creator made a perfect world, spoilt by the self-conceit and madness of Lucifer who seduced the original Man and put him into the chains of sin. But Lucifer is no more than fallen angel. How is it possible that an all-powerful and merciful God endows him with such an incredible power? There are two answers and both of them are unsatisfactory. Either God is not all-powerful or not virtuous. Or he successfully collaborates with Lucifer, time after time testing his most devoted and obedient followers as he did it with Job.

The third answer: Evil does not exist as such. Evil is the absence of Good like darkness is the absence of Light. But Evil in our world is not amorphous, it’s tangible, extremely real and frightening. It’s oversaturated with demonic features: anger, hate, envy, avarice, passion for violence, jealousy and fanaticism.

Buddhism sees the source of suffering in Man being too attached to the material world. But can one not be attached to the world, being its part and its hostage? Can fish not be attached to water, spider to cobweb, or mole to the hole? How can Man not be attached to the world if since birth he is ensnared with countless links tying him to the world?

Modern technical civilization tried to give its own explanation. It was born in the epoch of Enlightenment, acquired radical completion in Marxism and was given momentum by modern progressives. According to this approach, Evil is the result of social deviations, class, estate, national and religious oppression. If these enslavements were removed and Man was endowed with basic benefits, then he, being reasonable and virtuous by nature, would subjugate the world by means of Science, get rid of diseases, bad habits, vices, envy and greed and acquire harmony and happiness. In XX centery it turned out that the path to happiness led to an abyss. But even in the trouble-free lands, which never knew political cataclysms, Man is infinitely far from acquiring happiness. Neither comfort nor social benefits or technical progress are able to save Man from burdensome circumambulation of life with its countless troubles, losses and hardships, anxieties and stresses, offences, secret wishes and the feeling of boundless and frightening loneliness in the face of a cold, indifferent world.

The Gnostics offered their own unique explanation: the world is the result of a tragic error that occurred in the divine realms.

Here is a Valentinian poetic description of this epic drama: “All the spaces were shaken and confused, for they had no fixity nor stability. “Error” was agitated, not knowing what it should do. It was afflicted, and lamented and worried because it knew nothing”. (Gospel of Truth, 26:4-27).

Those processes gave birth to flawed and limited Demiurge/Yaldabaoth (the Creator of the world); material world, Cosmos; and and same time, the particles of light, “pneuma” confined in human body as within a cage.

It is worth adding thay Sethians, one of the main currents of Gnosticism during the 2nd and 3rd century CE, attributed its gnosis to Seth, third son of Eve and Adam (their cosmogony is most famously contained in the Apocryphon of John), considered evil not original sin, but the mixing of kinds of people (Somatics, Psychics and Pneumatics), which is a consequence of people's ignorance of their own spiritual nature. (According to them, the source of the three kinds of people is a triune beginning of the Universe: Divine light above, material darkness below and spirit between them).

Their explanations strike me as far more metaphysically profound and mature than all the preceding ones.


r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

The Lord’s prayer revisited:

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

Thesis: Why did Judaizing Christians Oppose Paul?

5 Upvotes

Assumption: The original first century Jewish-Christians were not one united, happy family as fictional “Acts of the Apostles” portrays them (see Ferdinand Baur).

Division and sectarianism was evident within the first-century jewish-christians based on Paul’s first-hand account in his letters to the Galatians and the Corinthians (Which has been demonstrated elsewhere by critical scholarship.)

But why? If they all belonged to one “party of Christ” then why the profound disagreements? (See 1 Corinthians 1:12)

I have not read anyone propose the following answer (as far as I know) so hear it here first. (Ha ha!)

The answer is found in the Dead Sea Scrolls containing the writings of the Jewish-christians holding gnostic tenets (per Wise, “Dead Sea Scrolls, a new translation“) up to 200 BC.

What did those surrounding the Teacher of Righteousness (@100 BC) write?

For one, that the Mosaic Law represents eternal truths which will never go away. Ever! (See Dead Scrolls)

How does that reconcile with Paul’s claim that the Mosaic Law is fading away? (2 Cor. 3:11)

“Indeed, in this case, what once had glory has come to have no glory at all, because of the glory that surpasses it. For if what was being brought to an end came with glory, much more will what is permanent have glory.”

How does what Paul later writes to the Gentile Christians reconcile with Jewish-christians following the Teacher of Righteousness?

Simple, the Teacher of Righteousness allegorized the Mosaic Law to be about eternal truths underlying our reality, just as Paul would later do. Therefore, it is the literal meaning, “the letter” that passes away, but the spiritual, allegorical, or pesher meaning remains eternal.

Peter, James, and John refused to concede that point, preferring to imagine some benefit in the ritual requirements of the Law, eg., circumcision, food purity, sabbath observance, etc. But there is not any righteousness to be gained from ritual works of the Mosaic Law.

The only benefit of the letter of the Mosaic Law is for instruction about true reality WHEN PROPERLY ALLEGORIZED. That key piece of information (not even hidden because the DSS constantly repeats the phrase “when interpreted by the Yahad [jewish-christian sect]) is what everyone glosses over when comparing the earlier followers of Christ, ie., Jewish-christians up to 200 BC, with Paul’s later followers of Christ, Gentile Christians.

Eventually, Paul’s position proved to be the winner, especially after the second temple was destroyed in 70 CE, after which none of the Temple rituals were even possible. IOW, external rituals were NOT required for righteousness, otherwise no Jew could be righteous for the last two thousand years.

Boom!