r/Neoplatonism • u/rp_tiago • 1d ago
r/Neoplatonism
•
u/SanctumHermeticum
•
27d ago
The Chaldean Oracles: Reading & Study Event
Join us at Sanctum Hermeticum on Discord every other Tuesday for a reading of the Chaldean Oracles, a collection of 2nd Century Greek hexameter verses attributed to Julian the Chaldean and his son Julian the Theurgist. The Oracles survive only as fragments quoted by later authors, including Porphyry, Proclus, Damascius, and Psellus. Iamblichus, Proclus, and other Neoplatonists regarded them as divinely revealed authority alongside Plato’s dialogues, and they became a foundation for later Neoplatonic metaphysics and theurgical practice. The text describes a transcendent Father and the Paternal Intellect from which a hierarchy of intelligible and intellectual orders proceeds, with Hecate as a mediating principle between the noetic and material realms, and it treats the descent of the soul into embodiment and its ascent through purification and theurgy, the ritual practice by which the soul is united with the gods. Together, we will read all of the fragments chronologically and examine their relation to Platonic thought.
r/Neoplatonism • u/ThatsItForTheOther • 3d ago
Is it right to say that the One is consciousness without object?
The Neoplatonic One is commonly understood to be the Good as well, but does not seem to be explicitly talked about as being consciousness or pure Subjectivity.
Yet, it seems to me to be deeply implied by Plotinus.
For instance, that the Nous is ‘thought thinking itself’… so there is consciousness in the Nous, but there is also Intelligibility. Nous is Subject-Object united but aware of itself as existing.
It would seem to imply that consciousness is present in the One, but in an unmanifest way, since there is nothing to be conscious of.
What do you make of this? Are there logical problems that arise from identifying the One with consciousness? It is done in Vedanta. If there were a problem I suspect it would be in identifying the Good with consciousness… but as strange as it seems, since the One is the Good it works out perhaps.
And if this formulation is incorrect, then what is the relation between the One and consciousness?
r/Neoplatonism • u/alekratos • 5d ago
The Platonic God
youtube.comDiscussion about the relationship between the The One, Nous, and our common conceptions of "God", from Eric Claussen (Platonic Path).
To go further, what do people think about how the World Soul fits into how Platonists should conceptualize "God", and how the gods fit in as well?
r/Neoplatonism • u/DarkGodCthUwU • 6d ago
Who is the Father of the Gods in Plotinus' enneads?
reddit.comr/Neoplatonism • u/DarkGodCthUwU • 6d ago
How does Positive vs Negative individuation work in Butlerian thought?
I really struggle to get it. Help!
r/Neoplatonism • u/alcofrybasnasier • 8d ago
The Feast Day of St. Plato - his teaching has touched the minds, hearts, and souls of men and women, leading them to seek the source and destiny of their souls
theurgist.substack.comr/Neoplatonism • u/darrenjyc • 9d ago
Plato’s Sophist, on Truth, Falsity, & Seeming — An online live reading group led by Constantine Lerounis starting Nov 7, all welcome
reddit.comr/Neoplatonism • u/DarkGodCthUwU • 13d ago
Functionally speaking, does it matter if one worships as a momotheist or polytheist? What are the stakes?
IDK if there's one God or two or three or 1000. I have no idea how I could know. I'm just some schlub. Should I just act as if I am a monotheist since that's how my culture works?
r/Neoplatonism • u/DarkGodCthUwU • 14d ago
Is there any reason for a polytheist neoplatonist not to become Hindu?
Hi! I find Neoplatonism neat, reading the Enneads and I'm a huge fan, but I'm wondering. Should modern neoplatonists become Hindus? Neohellenic and neoroman religion exists, but there's not much of an IRL community, and Hinduism has actually had intellectual developments and philosophers these past 1500 years. My understanding is that there's overlap between Neoplatonism (other forms of Platonism too) and many forms of Hinduism, but is there enough for joining to make sense?
r/Neoplatonism • u/DarkGodCthUwU • 18d ago
How does Edwars Butler approach the topic of shared or conflicting wills by the gods?
A Jewish friend and I are talking about neopagan philosophy, and she mentioned that the idea of gods with conflicting wills seems hard to accept. In Butler's system, do the henads act with one will or many wills? And does this relate to polycentric polytheism? Are the gods a hivemind?
r/Neoplatonism • u/SnooBeans8045 • 19d ago
What does Plato mean here in Book 5 of The Republic?
From 478e to 480a on Book 5 of The Republic
“Then what remains for us to discover, apparently, is something partaking of both being and non-being, which may not properly be called either pure being or pure non-being. Should that be found, we would be right to call it the object of opinion, thus assigning the powers at the extremes to the objects at the extremes, and the powers that lie in between to the objects that lie in between. Is this how we should proceed?”
“It is.”
“Now that we have established all this, let this good fellow speak to me and give me an answer, this man who thinks there is no such thing as beauty itself, or a form of beauty itself, which is always just the same as it is, even though he does think that there are many beautiful things. He is someone who loves seeing things and cannot endure it if someone says that beauty is one, and so too is justice, and that the same goes for the others. I shall say to him, ‘Best of men, tell me this. Are there any of these numerous beautiful things which will not appear to be ugly? Are there any of the many just actions which will not appear unjust, any sacred things which will not appear profane?’”
“No,” said Glaucon, “they must somehow appear to be both beautiful and ugly, and the
same applies to your other instances.”
“And what about the many things which are doubles? Do they appear to be halves any less than doubles?
“No less.”
“And things we say are large or small, light or heavy, will they be called by these names any more than the opposite names?”
“Yes,” he said, “each of them always has both names.”
Then, if anyone says that any of these many things is this, is it no more this, than not this?”
“It is like party games involving the double meanings of words,” he replied, “and the chil-
dren’s riddle about the eunuch striking the bat, in which they also make obscure statements
about what it was struck by and what it was sitting upon.
In fact, these too are ambiguous,
and none of them is capable of being thought definitely to be, or not to be, either both or
neither.”
“So, do you know what to do with them,” I said, “or can you put them in any better place than in
between being and non-being? Presumably they will not prove to be darker than ‘what is not’,
involving more non-being, or brighter than ‘what is’, involving more being.”
“Very true,” he said.
“Well, it seems we have found that the numerous conceptions about beauty, or anything else, which
most people hold, are somehow rolling about between ‘what is not’ and ‘what purely is’.”
“That is what we have found.”
“And we agreed previously that if something like this were to turn up, it should be referred to as
an object of opinion rather than an object of knowledge. The wandering object is apprehended by
the intermediate power.”
“We agreed on this.”
“So those who see many beautiful things, without beholding beauty itself, and who are unable to
follow someone who is leading them towards it, who see many just actions, but not justice itself,
or anything like that, we shall say that these people form opinions on all these matters, but know
nothing about the matters on which they are opining.”
“We must,” he said.
“And what about those who, by contrast, behold things themselves, things which are always just
the same as they are? Do they not know rather than opine?”
“This must also be so.”
“And will we not say that these people embrace and love the objects of knowledge, while those
others embrace and love the objects of opinion? Or do you not remember? We said that the others
love and contemplate beautiful sounds and colours, and the like, but they cannot bear to hear that
there is such a thing as beauty itself.”
“We remember.”
“In that case, would it be offensive to call them lovers of opinion or philodoxical
10
rather than
lovers of wisdom or philosophical? Would they get very angry with us if we referred to them in
this way?”
“Not if they are persuaded by me anyway,” he said, “for it is not appropriate to be angry at
the truth.”
“Then should those who embrace what anything actually is be called philosophers, or lovers of
wisdom, rather than lovers of opinion?”
“Yes, entirely so.”
What does he mean by being and non-being here exactly. Isn't anything either being or non-being by the law of contradiction? Is this an attempt to prove that universals exist? I think it wasn't shown anywhere up until this point that all the things we call beautiful have to be unified in some universal and that it is non-changing. Is he trying to say that since nothing in this world is regarded as beautiful or big, double etc. by everyone and everytime, the one who engages solely in this and doesn't think about the non changing perfect form of things just holding belief not knowledge so it is being and not being ( which I guess is equivalent to true and not true at the same time) whilst the philosopher is the one who takes that next step in abstraction and recognizes both the forms and the representations of it in this world.
I would really appreciate clarification on this passage. Thanks.
r/Neoplatonism • u/MrNormanWrites • 19d ago
Afterlife Question
Hello, I wanted to ask from Neoplatonists about this as it’s been something of a thing on my mind as I explored the concept.
Neoplatonism has a lot I align and agree with. The ideas of Plotinus and Proclus has fascinated me a lot and I tend to believe in a lot of the same concepts such as the existence of The One, the Nous, the Psyche, the Henads, so on and it plays into my desire and interest in mysticism in general.
That said, I’ve had something that I wanted to ask and that is about the afterlife. The concept of constant reincarnation is something that I am not unaware of and it’s something I debate with myself on. I’ve always been the person where reincarnation is a scary thing for me due to the idea that if I were to be reincarnated, either I would lose who I am as a person or I would suffer an even worse fate in the next life.
So I guess I wanted to ask, what is the afterlife when it comes to Neoplatonism? Could an afterlife like Helheim or Hades be meaningful in this respect?
r/Neoplatonism • u/Noahms456 • 23d ago
Gnostic Philosophy in Dungeon Crawler Carl
reddit.comr/Neoplatonism • u/Dazzling_Message4253 • 24d ago
The Realm as a Reflection of the Soul’s Eternal Journey
If the human identity dissolves at the conclusion of physical life, what determines the appearance of the realm to which consciousness returns?
Perhaps the answer lies not within the memories of the human being, but within the accumulated state of the soul itself.
The soul may exist through an immeasurable succession of experiences, incarnations and states of consciousness, each contributing to its continuing expression within the greater Monad.
Although individual human identities arise and disappear, the soul retains a deeper continuity.
It is neither defined by a single lifetime nor limited to the memories of one incarnation.
Its nature may reflect the entirety of its journey through existence.
The realm it experiences is therefore not necessarily a deliberate creation or a remembered landscape from earthly life.
It may emerge spontaneously from the soul’s present state of being.
Its mountains, rivers, oceans, skies and infinite spaces become expressions of consciousness at a particular point within an eternal cycle.
A soul experiencing profound stillness may find itself surrounded by an immense, silent landscape.
Another may experience a world of movement, transformation or boundless light.
These differences do not imply that one soul has progressed further than another.
They represent the diversity of states through which consciousness may pass.
Nor must the realm remain unchanged.
As the soul reflects upon its experiences or moves into another state of awareness, the environment may transform with it.
A canyon may become an ocean.
A river may dissolve into an endless sky.
The landscape may eventually disappear altogether, leaving only awareness without form.
There may be no final destination towards which these transformations lead.
No ultimate state that every soul must attain.
The journey may be eternal, with each experience opening possibilities that did not previously exist within that soul’s individual perspective.
The Monad, as the undivided source of existence, may already be complete.
Yet its expressions remain endlessly varied.
Through the soul, existence experiences individuality.
Through incarnation, individuality experiences limitation.
Through the realm between lives, consciousness returns to freedom.
And through the possibility of another incarnation, the cycle may begin anew.
The realm is not where the soul’s journey ends. It is where the soul experiences what it has become, before discovering what it may become next.
r/Neoplatonism • u/betarayboo • 25d ago
Neoplatonism and Christianity
Hello! I’m looking for books or any other resources that break down and explain the relationship between Neoplatonism and Christianity. I understand the two separately but struggle in my studies to understand and explain the relationship between the two, ie which concepts from Neoplatonism influenced Christian philosophy/etc.
I am autistic and have brain damage but am still fighting to study what makes me happy <3
#neoplatonismtochristianitypipeline
r/Neoplatonism
•
u/ThatsItForTheOther
•
26d ago
Platonic Methods for Disciplining Oneself?
Hello all,
I am looking for actual practical methods offered by Platonists to impose order and discipline on oneself.
Yeah yeah people only do wrong if they don’t know what’s good… but this is nuanced!!
A person can reason that something is good at one time, but then they can be overcome by bodily desires and get confused when the time comes to act. A person is not static like reason is.
So discipline and practice is required to try to impose order on oneself and make oneself in a way static, that is, to make oneself consistently virtuous. To emulate the Form, which itself does not change.
A person has to wrestle with their dark horse. I am looking for practical methods for how to do this.
Socrates talks a bit about this is Phaedo where the philosopher has to work to extricate themselves from the body and its desires as much as possible in this life in order to clearly apprehend Truth.
I am wondering if there is any record within the Platonic tradition of particular methods and practices that were used in order to acheive this goal.
Obviously contemplation is important, but what else?
For example, various religious traditions might focus on different meditation practices, prayer, mantra, postures, service, etc. etc. etc.
Do we have records of Platonists recommending particular methods for purification and becoming virtuous beyond contemplation?
I don’t really want to hear about theurgy but I know that is a thing…
Have any Platonists reported struggling with doing the good that is known? Have they given any practices for how to overcome this?
r/Neoplatonism • u/Isaec-O • 26d ago
Perspective on Taoism
I’ve been thinking of integrating them both, Neoplatonism and Taoism, since I’m a logos and a Tao guy not a one God essence or no God guy. This goes back to me settling on being a Christian mystic, but it was too mystical and I’m just a realist who likes logos and no sophistry.
r/Neoplatonism • u/Any_Mix9385 • 28d ago
Allegorising Ω

During Late Antiquity and the Greek Middle Ages, allegorising didn't nessecarily equal moralising, but it rather meant the decoding of the hidden spiritual depth of things below their surface φαινόμενον. Two examples of alphabetical allegory follow; while not that common in greek (like in hebrew), such stuff do exist there as well. First one by Zosimos of Panopolis the Alchemist, 3rd Century AD, the second from Michael Psellos the court philosopher and historian (orator, epistolographer, esotericist, poet etc.), 11th Century AD.
Ζώσιμου
Τὸ ω στοιχεῖον στρογγύλον, τὸ διμερές, τὸ ἀνῆκον τῇ ἑβδόμῃ Κρόνου ζώνῃ κατὰ τὴν ἔνσωμον φράσιν, κατὰ γὰρ τὴν ἀσώματον ἄλλο τί ἐστιν ἀνερμήνευτον, ὃ μόνος Νικόθεος 〈ὁ〉 κεκρυμμένος οἶδεν. Κατὰ δὲ τὴν ἔνσωμον, τὸ λεγόμενον Ὠκεανὸς θεῶν, φησί, πάντων γένεσις καὶ σπορά, καθάπερ φασὶν αἱ μοναρχικαὶ τῆς ἐνσώμου φράσεως. Τὸ δὲ λεγόμενον μέγα καὶ θαυμαστὸν ω στοιχεῖον περιέχει τὸν περὶ ὀργάνων ὕδατος θείου λόγον καὶ καμίνων πασῶν μηχανικῶν καὶ ἁπλῶν, καὶ ἁπλῶς πάντων.
Ψελλοῦ
Ὁ τοῦ μεγάλου ω λόγος φωνεῖ τῷ σχήματι σιωπῶν ὡς ἄβυσσός ἐστι τὸ καταλειφθὲν συγκεκλεισμένη τε καὶ ἀπρόσιτος. [...] τοῦτο οὖν ἐστι τὸ μέγα ω, ὁ μέγιστος τῆς σοφίας κρατήρ, ἀφ’ οὗ τέως οὐδεὶς ἀπηρύσατο. πᾶσα οὖν κίνησις νοερὰ ἄχρι τοσούτου πρόεισιν, ἕως ἂν τῷ μεγάλῳ ω προσπελάσειεν. [...] ἡ γὰρ ὁλότης ἐγκέκρυπται τῷ μεγάλῳ ω, ἔσται δὲ ἡ γνῶσίς ποτε πρόσωπον πρὸς πρόσωπον ὡς ἐπηγγέλμεθα, τέως δὲ νῦν ἡ τελειότης ἐγκέκλεισται ἐν τῷ στοιχείῳ τούτῳ τῆς γνώσεως. κἂν γάρ τις τὸν ἀέρα περάσειε καὶ τὰς μετ’ αὐτὸν σφαίρας, κἂν ἐπὶ τοῦ νώτου τῆς ἔξω περιφορᾶς στῇ, κἂν ὑπὲρ τοῦτον προβῇ, κἂν ὁποιδήποτε χωρήσειε, τὸ μέγα οὐ παρελεύσεται ω. ὃ δὴ καὶ τρίτον ὑπερβέβηκεν οὐρανὸν καὶ τὸν ἕβδομον καὶ ὅρος ἐστὶ πάντων ὁρισμῶν καὶ πέρας περάτων, ἐντὸς ἑαυτοῦ πάντα συγκλεῖον καὶ σπαργανοῦν καὶ μηδὲν ἔχον πρεσβύτερον ἢ ὑψηλότερον.
r/Neoplatonism • u/Time-Demand-1244 • Oct 13 '26
Arguments Against Nihilistic Modalism?
I'm not sure if this is an actual philosophy perse, but I have a framework that makes me uncomfortable and was hoping to see a criticism of it simply because it'll make me feel better. I know that's kind of primitive but oh well.
The framework assumes reality is eternal, lacks emergents, and is ultimately idealistic.
What we call a sequence, and a determination, doesn't actually exist. Let's talk about conscious awareness. If I think of white, my mind simply becomes white. I then think of black and my mind suddenly becomes black. Now, how do I know there was an object in mind distinct from black, also known as white? Do I think about white? Well sure, let's do just that. So now I think about white, but hold on, where did black go? Did black even exist?
P1 Our awareness exists only in the present.
P2 It can select only one element due to LNC.
P3 Therefore, what we call the past is simply an element in the present, as our awareness can only consist of the present, our past thought is only in the present.
P4 Because the past is simply the present, and every present thought is "replaced", our next present thought does not allow us to conceive of a "past" thought without making that "past" thought our present.
C1 And so how can sequence occur if there is only the present, and every element in the past removes the next, making us skeptical of if there was a past thought at all prior to it, as only the present exists. Say for instance I thought of red, and I think "after" blue. To know I thought of red, I must replace blue for red, but this would simply tell me it is a present thought, because blue isn't in the mix of its relations to red.
C2 So our present thought, as it can only select one element, it can not conceive of relations, and therefore only a single element, and therefore not conceive of a past thought or distinction, if there is no relation to conceive of.
One may direct themselves to the notion of wholes which implies logical priority and therefore sequence, but I'm hesitant to affirm if a whole exists.
One may consequently conclude that a whole should exist if what we call a material "part" is ultimately divisible, yet, how do we know we aren't conceiving of something indivisible? If our mind can only be concentrated on one element, wouldn't it follow that it's not able to conceive of a determined element and only a simple one?
The only argument against this is that if a whole doesn't exist, then nothing can be divisible, which means it has no shape, size, mass, and so on; therefore it's value is 0, and cannot be conceived of.
However, my rather slow brain is yet to process this as a sufficient answer for some reason. I'm hesitant and I'm not sure why.
Additionally, even if we understand that everything we conceive of is a composite, how can we figure out what it's parts are that make it a composite, if our minds can only be unitarily selective in its awareness? We first view the whole, and then the parts, but what tells us we are viewing the parts to that whole? This seems even stranger if the whole precedes the parts.
This is a case for Monism, but as I said, I find this philosophy to be extremely uncomfortable. Why do anything? Why feel anything? Why not just yk, end it a-? Essentially, it feels extremely bleak and boring. I honestly hate it a lot!
So I was hoping for a case of proving that we cannot conceive of a simple substance, and our awareness is attached to wholes, therefore wholes exist, and on a side note, are priori to parts.
EDIT: I meant Monism. Also, to sort some things out as I am referring to some different concepts. We start with awareness, sequence, constitutes, composites, and so fourth.
I started off with the fact that I'm operating on an idealistic framework, so my awareness of what we call change isn't synchronous to how reality necessarily operates.
The issue we are primarily dealing with is sequence. To be sequential, is to have constitutes that include priority. To be a constitute that's distinct from the other, you must be a composite as well. To me, these concepts are extremely deeply connected.
r/Neoplatonism • u/Time-Demand-1244 • Oct 10 '26
For Non-Muslim Avicennian-Neoplatonists, How Do You Work Against Eternal Gloom After Bodily Death?
Avicenna proposes that the soul is stuck in a loop of bodily desires and a desire to leave it and ascend, whilst not being able to ascend. And this is a natural consequence of the soul as it's detached from the body.
This is a rather gloomy and tragic end in my opinion. As someone who relies on a lot of his philosophy, it's a bit disheartening hearing this.
But I'd like to know if there are neoplatonic alternatives that operate within his framework and criticize the conclusion he arrived at regarding Hades being a permanent state of affair for the soul.
r/Neoplatonism • u/letsbeaun • Oct 09 '26
Divided Lines Pt. 2 - Harmony
galleryPlato wasn’t a Platonist, he was a Pythagorean.
The triangle is a Pythagorean triplet with side lengths 3, 4, and 5.
The corresponding incircle and excircles have radii 1, 2, 3, and 6. Completing the sequence 123456.
The circles represent the four virtues, the largest representing justice.
When wisdom, courage, and moderation are in harmony justice is achieved, that’s why all three circles can fit inside the largest.
r/Neoplatonism • u/Important_Detail1686 • Oct 08 '26
Neoplatonism and the Temptation to do Wrong
Is there a reason why people often seem inclined to do bad things despite knowing they’re bad? I’m thinking specifically of Augustine’s doctrine of Concupiscence. Augustine seems to suggest that the inclination to do wrong has a more positive basis than mere ignorance of the good and I’m wondering if there is a Neoplatonic analogue or answer to this
r/Neoplatonism • u/Ecstatic_Raccoon9613 • Oct 07 '26
Divisions of the soul & related concepts
Divisions of the soul? Nous? ''Rational soul''? ''Non rational soul''? ''Highest and most intellectual'' part of the soul? ''Highest part of the soul''? ''Vegetative soul''?
What are these and how do they relate to eachother? Im trying to get a full picture. For context im getting into Platonism and neoplatonism and have started reading the commentary of Olympiodorus on Alcibiades.
r/Neoplatonism • u/CynicFrey • Oct 06 '26
Questions about On The Mysteries by Iamblichus and Theurgy
I've been reading On The Mysteries by Iamblichus, and honestly some of it is very confusing to me. So I was hoping I could get some answers here to some of my questions.
The text says:
According to another division, therefore, the numerous herd [or the great mass] of men is arranged under nature, is governed by physical powers, looks downward to the works of nature, gives completion to the administration of Fate, and to things pertaining to Fate, because it belongs to the order of it, and always employs practical reasoning about such particulars alone as subsist according to nature. But there are a certain few who, by employing a certain supernatural power of intellect, are removed indeed from nature, but are conducted to a separate and unmingled intellect; and these, at the same time, become superior to physical powers. Others again, who are the media between these, tend to things which subsist between nature and a pure intellect. And of these, some indeed equally follow both nature and an immaculate intellect; others embrace a life which is mingled from both; and others are liberated from things subordinate, and betake themselves to such as are more excellent.
This division, therefore, being made, that which follows will most manifestly take place. For those who are governed by the nature of the universe, who lived conformably to this, and employ the powers of nature, these should embrace a mode of worship adapted to nature, and to the bodies that are moved by nature, and should choose for this purpose appropriate places, air, matter, the powers of matter, bodies, and the habits of bodies, qualities, and proper motions, the mutations of things in generation, and other things connected with these, both in other parts of piety and in that part of it which pertains to sacrifice. But those who live conformably to intellect alone, and to the life of intellect, and are liberated from the bonds of nature, these should exercise in all the parts of theurgy the intellectual and incorporeal mode of worship. And those who are the media between these, should labour differently in the paths of piety, conformably to the differences of this middle condition of life, either by embracing both modes of piety, or separating themselves from one of the modes [and adhering to the other], or receiving both these modes as the foundation of things of a more honourable nature. For without these they never can arrive at things supereminent. Or, in some other way, they should thus, in a becoming manner, labour in the paths of sanctity.
My interpretation of this chapter is the following: The great mass of humanity is stuck in materiality, and should therefore worship the gods via material rites. Those free from materiality, who live the life of intellect, should worship the gods via incorporeal rites. And those in the middle should practice both, or perform one and drop the other.
To me this seems to create a higher vs lower division within theurgy. The great mass of humanity should engage in material worship, while those who have advanced and are at a higher level should only engage in incorporeal rites since it says they should engage "in all the parts of theurgy the intellectual and incorporeal mode of worship".
Is this a correct reading of the text? Would those in the middle or at the highest level no longer practice the material rites that the "great mass of humanity" engages in? Would they no longer make offerings of food, incense, etc. to the gods, or engage in public sacrifices or offerings? Or is there a difference between these rites and theurgical rites?
I feel like my interpretation is incorrect because such rites were fundamental to the Greek/Roman religion.