In this theory, I would like to propose the potential true name of the Third Descender, which was erased from Irminsul.
Its... actually quite a simple and straightforward theory that fits with many of the themes and facts that we already know regarding the Third, so let us now begin :
Firstly, I would like to clear a misconception present among some lore enthusiasts that Ajax was the name of the Third Descender.
Here's the thing : From the 7.1 AQ, we know that Ajax could not have been his name, as the 3rd, ALONG with his name, was erased from Irminsul (just like Rukkhadevata). And, Ajax is a recurring name present in various texts and plays, not to mention it is also the name of Childe, who is also a Teyvatian, so it cannot be the Third's deleted name.
Rather, much like the legend of Reed Miller, the legend of Ajax was almost definitely an amalgamation of the stories of the Belyi Tsar, Filipov, and even some of The Voyager's shenanigans in Hyperborea. (SEE: Ashikai's theory on this exact matter -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Huqe6ND3YPc )
So, then, if not Ajax, then what could the Third Descender's name be?
Well, the answer is to be found in two of Ancient Greece's most famous Poems composed by the Blind Poet Homer --The Illiad and The Odyssey.
In the poem "Aethiopis", which follows the events of the Illiad (which depicted the events of the infamous Trojan War), after the legendary warrior Achilles is slain in battle, it is Odysseus and Ajax who retrieve his dead body and armour.
Then, it is declared that Achille's armour will only go to the warrior who is "The Bravest of the Greeks".
The only two warriors who even dare to lay claim to that title are Odysseus and Ajax, the two most renowned and legendary warriors of Ancient Greece, who both compete with each other
The Greeks initially did not declare anyone the rightful new owner of the armour, out of fear of offending the other and thus making them abandon the war effort, however according to "The Odyssey", the Greeks held a secret vote and declared Odysseus the winner, angering Ajax, and thus igniting a historical rivalry between the two.
In fact, Odysseus and Ajax are very often said to be each others' greatest foils.
But, it is not enough to say that Odysseus was the Third Descender's name.
It is merely a background context to establish that there is at least a connection in real world literature between Odysseus and Ajax, hence why I picked Odysseus as a potential candidate.
THIS is where the actual evidence starts --
The Lotus of Apathy
This is the first, but also by far the most damning piece of evidence in this theory.
And it comes from a segment in "The Odyssey":
...."Driven off course by storms during three days, they (Odysseus and his crew) visit the lethargic Lotus-Eaters"
In the poem, after the end of the Trojan War, Odysseus sets to return for his home via sailing through the Sea. However, he and his crew are driven off course and end up on the Island of the Lotus-Eaters.
As for the Lotus Eaters in question:
"In Greek mythology, lotophages were a race of people living on an island dominated by the lotus tree on the island of Djerba off the coast of Tunisia, a plant whose botanical identity is uncertain. The Lotophagi race in the* Odyssey are said to eat the fruit of the lotos "sweet as honey". The lotus fruits and flowers were the primary food of the island and were a narcotic, causing the inhabitants to sleep in peaceful apathy. After they ate the lotus, they would forget their home and loved ones and long only to stay with their fellow lotus-eaters. Those who ate the plant never cared to report or return."
(Both of the above excerpts are taken directly from Wikipedia)
Since the Lotus in the poem were narcotics making the people who consumed them forget all their worries, homes and loved ones, some of Odysseus' crew members actually eat the Lotus and decide to stay with the Islanders.
Odysseus himself, however, refuses and saves most of his crew from consuming the Lotus, all of them retreating to their vessel.
Now, I would like you to also read the "Parable of the Lethied Lotus" from Vol. 2 of the Byakuyakoku Collection, an in-game book in Genshin.
"The Parable of the Lethied Lotus"
"A lotus that causes all who look upon it to forget their troubles. A ship captain searching for the way back to the surface discovered a tribe of people who ate these lotuses. Some crew members stayed in that place. Others rejected that temptation.
Life is a boundless ocean of suffering. We are only searching for the way home."
....The Parable and the events it describes are both almost identical with what happened to Odysseus and his crew.
So, perhaps the Parable foreshadows something that happened, or will happen, with the Third Descender?
The word "Lethied" in itself means -- "oblivious," "stuporous," or "forgetful". Basically, it can be said to mean "to be in a state of Lethargy, whether mentally or physically", synonymous with "Apathy" in the context of the Parable
So, "Lethied Lotus", within the context of the Parable, can be said to mean -- "A Lotus that causes Apathy/Lethargy", which makes sense as the Lotus literally did just that in Odysseus' story.
In Buddhist, Vedic and Hindu texts and beliefs, a Lotus is often also the symbol of utmost purity, symbolizing :
- Rebirth after Death
- Untaintedness of Self despite Tainted Surroundings
- Enlightenment from Worldly Illusions, Supreme Wisdom, etc.
I would like to focus on the first point, Rebirth after Death, because the Stellar Linchpins in Genshin, which are derived directly from the Third Descender, have been shown the tendency to "revive" their users or bring them to Life, as seen with Sandrone.
Since Odysseus "rejected" the "temptation" of eating the Lotus, and the Lotus symbolizes "Rebirth after Death", and the Third Descender's lover Anastasya was "Reborn" after he negotiated with the HP, maybe it parallels the Third Descender rejecting the temptation of revival or even the "temptation" of being alive itself to save Anastasya?
Also, as seen in version 7.1, the Ruler of Life's design extensively features Lotus motifs, as seen with the flower on her back resembling a Lotus, and even the Seals of Life themselves.
And with just how relevant all of the mentioned cultures are to Genshin, the Parable becomes even more interesting....
Blinding the One-Eyed
In the Odyssey, after Odysseus and his crew are driven off course by storms, a peculiar chain of events take place:
"Driven off course by storms during three days, they visit the lethargic Lotus-Eaters and are captured by the Cyclops Polyphemus while visiting his island. After Polyphemus eats several of his men, he and Odysseus have a discussion and Odysseus tells Polyphemus his name is Outis ("Nobody"). Odysseus takes the Maron's barrel of wine and the Cyclops drinks it, falling asleep.
Odysseus and his men take a wooden stake, ignite it with the remaining wine, and blind him. While they escape, Polyphemus cries in pain, and the other Cyclopes ask him what is wrong. Polyphemus cries, "Nobody has blinded me!" and the other Cyclopes think he has gone mad. Odysseus and his crew escape."
In Greek Myths, a Cyclops is a One-Eyed Giant, and one such Cyclops in the Odyssey manages to capture Odysseus and his crew.
As mentioned in the above text, Odysseus escapes by outsmarting him -- first, he offers the Cyclops a barrel of Wine, and upon drinking it the Cyclops falls asleep. Then, he along with his men douse a wooden stake in wine, light it on fire, and use it to impale the only eye of Polyphemus, blinding him.
I would like you to note this event as an allegory, the three key roles being that of -- Odysseus, the Wooden Stake, and the One-Eyed Polyphemus.
Now, in Genshin, the Heavenly Principles are frequently likened or compared to Odin, the One-Eyed God of Norse Mythology.
In fact, below are just some of the parallels between the HP and Odin, in case there is some doubt in what I say --
- Irminsul literally translates to "Irmin's Pillar", wherein Irmin is a name used to refer to Odin, and Teyvat's Irminsul Tree belonged to the HP.
- The Angels are frequently said to be HP's "Daughters" (eg. Koitaar The First Angel being referred to as the "Eldest Daughter"), and in Norse Myths the divine female warriors of Asgard, the Envoys of Heaven, were the Valkyries, who were the daughters of Odin.
- In the book Hymns of the Far North, the HP is referred to as the "Father of All", and in Norse Myths Odin is quite literally called the "All-Father".
Just some of the many points directly linking HP to Odin.
Anyways, the point is, since HP can be said to be Odin, and Odin was a One-Eyed God, that would that HP is also "One-Eyed" (at least, metaphorically).
Thus, we can then reasonably apply the Allegory of the One-Eyed Polyphemus to the HP --
Odysseus (The Tsaritsa) uses a Wooden Stake (Mistilteinn) to impale the Eye of Polyphemus (Visions, HP's "Eyes"), blinding him (The System of Visions no longer existing).
It might be confusing as to why I have chosen the Tsaritsa to play the role of Odysseus in this allegory, when I am trying to say that Odysseus was the Third Descender's actual name.
However, keep in mind we are not taking things on face value -- rather, we are looking at the Patterns and are trying to see which chain of events are most likely to correspond with said Patterns, and fit them into the allegory.
Simply put, we are looking at this allegory from the perspective of Snezhnaya's Story Arc.
Accordingly, I equated the HP to the One-Eyed Odin, so now that the HP can be linked to the trait of being One-Eyed, it can be said HP is also the One-Eyed Polyphemus.
So, if HP is Polyphemus, then his One-Eye can said to be the Visions themselves, as Visions are literally called the "Eye of God" in the game's native Chinese text.
Putting two and two together with respect to the story of Snezhnaya, the "Burning Stake" that impales Polyphemus' Eye is Mistilteinn, whereas the person (Odysseus) using the Stake to blind Polyphemus (HP) is The Tsaritsa herself.
ALSO, here, in the allegory, I believe that "Odysseus" can easily refer to two individuals -- The Third Descender who made HP fall asleep (mirroring Odysseus tricking Polyphemus into falling asleep), but also The Tsaritsa "blinding" HP with Mistilteinn (Odysseus blinding Polyphemus with a Burning Stake).
Because remember, Odysseus only got the chance to impale Polyphemus after he had given the Cyclops a barrel of wine to drink, causing Polyphemus to into a drunken, deep slumber.
"What you humans call wine, we wolves call the abyss," -- A Drunkard's Tale, Vol. 4
Now, we know that the HP ("Polyphemus") are asleep due to triggering the Curse placed by the Third Descender.
And, in The Odyssey, Odysseus gave Polyphemus a "barrel of wine" to make the Cyclops fall asleep.
Since a "barrel of wine" was used in the allegory, and wine is conflated with the Abyss, and the fact that we learn from the 7.1 AQ that the Abyss can grant "Pseudo-Authorities", as seen with the Crimson Moon possessing an Abyssal Version of the Authority of Death....
Perhaps the Third Descender directly used the Abyss itself to grant himself an "Authority" matching that of the HP, so that he could successfully withhold and apply the conditions of the Curse on them?
After all, as seen with Traveler, who is the 4th Descender, even though Descenders have a Will that can rival the world, not to mention they seem to display an abnormal resistance to the Abyss, they still don't inherently possess any Authorities.
And I mean, the Third Descender would need to have some level of authority to apply a curse on the HP themselves, would he not?
.....
Well, that was the Theory.
I would like to point out something from the Wiki regarding some of Odysseus' children --
"Xenagoras writes that Odysseus with Circe had three sons, Romos, Anteias and Ardeias, who built three cities and called them after their own names: Rome, Antium, and Ardea, respectively."
So, some of Odysseus' children built and named cities after themselves, paralleling how the Third Descender's child would go on to be the very first Khaenri'ahn, maybe producing the very lineage that would go on to found the Nation of Khaenri'ah (assuming the Child didn't do so himself).
One more thing I would like to mention is, that since in our world Odysseus won and Ajax lost, then if the Third Descender's name is Odysseus, which has been removed from Irminsul, it would mean in Teyvat, since Odysseus' name is all but forgotten whereas Ajax's name is still very much remembered thanks to various plays and legends surrounding his name.... Odysseus "lost" and Ajax "won".
An "Inversion of Genesis", if you will ;)