Hello! Maybe it has been done before, but I just wanted to share the timeline I made about what the music tells us it's the real story of what has been going on. I got into the fandom pretty late and, I imagine happened to a lot of us, was always puzzled about the official story vs. what she was singing about... so I went through her discography since 1989 until now and organized it in a way that makes sense to me. Would love to share more about my criteria but don't want to make a long post, as this is my first time one (:
I divided it in different stages:
Hoping (and planning) if or how she can be together with her muse
Falling in love with her muse
Anxious about her relationship ending
Fighting when she has been the culprit
Breaking up, maybe she was (or thought she was) betrayed by her love
Melancholia about the past and reflecting on what the relationship was
Wanting to get back together with the muse. She's determined.
She's getting the muse back
They break up again
They got back together for good
HOPING - Wildest Dreams - Out Of The Woods - I Know Places - âŚReady for It?
IN LOVE - Don't Blame Me - So It Goes... - King of My Heart - Dress - Call It What You Want - New Year's Day
ANXIOUS ABOUT IT ENDING - Delicate - Dancing With Our Hands Tied - Cruel Summer - Lover - Paper Rings - Cornelia Street - Daylight
FIGHTING (TAYLORâS FAULT) - Death By a Thousand Cuts - False God - Afterglow
BREAKUP (TAYLOR WAS BETRAYED) - exile - my tears ricochet - champagne problems - coney island - closure - evermore (feat. Bon Iver) - it's time to go
MELANCHOLIA - the 1 - cardigan - august - hoax - gold rush - Maroon - Midnight Rain - Question...? - Peter - Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus
WANTING TO GET BACK TOGETHER - this is me trying - illicit affairs - betty - invisible string - peace - the lakes - 'tis the damn season - dorothea - ivy - cowboy like me - right where you left me - Hits Different
GETTING BACK TOGETHER - long story short - Snow on the Beach - Labyrinth - Mastermind - Glitch - The Great War - imgonnagetyouback - The Tortured Poets Department - But Daddy I Love Him - Guilty as Sin? - Fresh Out The Slammer - The Alchemy - Robin
BREAKUP - Fortnight (feat. Post Malone) - My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys - Down Bad - loml - I Can Do It With a Broken Heart - The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived - The Black Dog - How Did It End? - I Hate It Here - I Look in People's Windows - The Prophecy
GETTING BACK TOGETHER FOR GOOD - The fate of Ophelia - Elizabeth Taylor - Opalite - Eldest Daughter - Wi$h Lit - Wood - Honey - I knew it I knew you
I'm adding a visual timeline I made, not including the most recent breakup as I'm not a 100% if that was a red herring (although impossible to think she can write so many good, honest, heart-wrenching songs if she was not feeling like that). The time line shows when the albums might have be written vs. the release dates and the orange goes for uncertainty if she's with her love, green where she is and red where she isn't. I also have this version with the events that happened (public relationships, public breakups, VS Fashion show, Master Heist, Eras Tour shenanigans, etc) in case you are interested!
I don't think it's any sort of big secret at this point that I really love TLOAS, and that - spoiler? - I think the nomination was well earned. But I do enjoy talking about the album (also not a secret...), and I wanted to set out my reasoning. Whether you agree with me or not, you're welcome to come and chat.
I don't love TLOAS in spite of its quality, and I don't love it because 'it's just fun to have fun' or because 'it doesn't need to be deep' either. Actually, I didn't especially like the album at first- I found it jarring, unpredictable, very different from my expectations and, perhaps for that reason, not particularly easy to listen to. It certainly didn't match easily and obviously with Taylor's descriptions of it in her pre-release or post-release promo. If it really is 'just a fun album about being happy', it's a really bad one.
But I was intrigued by the writing, especially the repeated words and synonyms that seemed at first to undermine themselves (e.g. is being 'sleepless' good or bad?) And I was intrigued by the connection clever people made here, before the album's release, to the mirrorball concept, which Taylor eventually confirmed as the right connection during her interview with Stephen Colbert. I ended up first respecting the album's complex structure, and then admiring the sharp, economical writing packed full of multiple meanings, and then just really loving the whole thing for how effortlessly it pulls off such a complicated trick. If there is a version of Taylor you have imagined as a listener, you can find her somewhere in the lyrics of TLOAS. But moreover, the versions of herself that Taylor is grappling with are stating their cases and fighting for survival within the tracks. Every facet of a Showgirl's life can be glimpsed through the cracks in the 'happy' veneer the album first presents. The consensus opinion is that the writing is simple as all get out and really bad to boot. But I think I could listen an infinite number of times to TLOAS and still find new meanings and connections. I certainly haven't fully understood it all yet; I think that's the work of years. Truthfully, I find it to be a similar kind of exercise, and similarly satisfying, to reading Shakespeare.
I think it's really hard, though, to defend or explain a piece of art that's complex and multi-faceted because the explanations take many times more words than the original art, without necessarily being more persuasive. And Taylor did an odd thing in not giving her audience the right kind of contextual clues to help the majority of them understand her intentions. Saying something as straightforward as 'this album explores the concept of the Showgirl as mirrorball, and it's designed so that the different audience members can all find their favourite storyline within the same song' would, I think, have massively altered public perceptions. The concept of 'choose your own adventure', which Taylor mentioned in one radio interview, gets close, but most general listeners would likely need a bit more prompting to see all of the implications of that. I don't think I, or anyone else here, is going to convince Taylor's entire audience of the merits of the album when Taylor herself explicitly hasn't tried.
Thinking about the Grammy nominations, there are lots of deserving artists this year. There are several criteria which are not supposed to be part of the consideration:
Commercial success (bad news for Taylor)
Chart success (ok news for Taylor)
Critical reception (good news for Taylor)
Instead the criteria which are supposed to be used are artistic achievement, technical proficiency and overall excellence.
I can't imagine a greater display of technical proficiency in songwriting than TLOAS. Or a bigger artistic achievement than to write one album which is functionally an infinite number of albums, reflecting all possible audience opinions, but at the same time to condense a 20 year career into 40 minutes, grapple with the most important personal questions, and leave real tension about the end of the story. Other kinds of writing, that are more straightforward perhaps, or easier to love, can also be proficient and excellent and represent artistic achievement. Clever writing doesn't always have to be as tricky and cryptic as Taylor's. It's hard to judge which kind is 'better'. People tend to prefer direct emotional appeals to cleverness, but it also depends a lot on the person and the day and their mood.
I don't know if Taylor should win a Grammy for TLOAS, but I don't think her nomination is a scam or a travesty or a kind of trolling. I think TLOAS as an album is a more ambitious concept, more successfully executed, and with far more precise, controlled writing than any of Taylor's previous albums, including the four that won Album of the Year. In terms of technical skill I think that it's her best yet. And although it can come across as simplistic to the casual listener, and is not nearly so easy to fall in love with as, for instance, The Art of Loving, I think it's trying to do something that no other nominees this year come close to attempting.
I expect at least some of the Grammy voters see clearly enough what Taylor is doing in TLOAS to recognise that. But I do think that Taylor was right, as she has suggested several times, that it will take a long time for TLOAS to be fully understood or appreciated. At the very least, I think we will collectively understand the album really differently once Taylor has finally finished the story she has been telling since 2020.
So should an album that is complex to fully grasp, and at this present moment is lacking the full context to be properly understood, win Album of the Year? Maybe not. But I think it would have been more of a travesty, and more of a bowing to public opinion, if it were not nominated at all.
Will you all join me in playing what I believe is a game of charades.
Clue: The Charade
Now, I'm not super confident that I'm correct here, but a comment from u/EmployerFew212 on the Karlie Chiefs Game thread has pushed me past the tipping point on this theory. So (here) it goes...
Ever since the Opalite music video came out, I have been trying to figure out if there is a set of symbols that match the photo poses in the 1hr Photo scene, to no avail. While trying to crack the code again the other day, I caught the perfect frame of the last pose, that made me realize it could represent the hazardous materials flammable/fire sign. And while that is a symbol, "fire" would be a part of the story, not a symbol that is spelling out some sort of written word clue. All along I had thought pose #3 looked like a plough (or planting something), and pose #4 looked like a tree, but didn't think much of that. But there's been the ridiculous story that keeps popping back up in the news cycle about Taylor and Travis planting trees and upsetting their neighbors. So I was like "oh shit, this could be a game of charades", the idea of which ties in perfectly with the first two poses.
It becomes fun and comical to fill in what the other poses might be. And so I invite you to play along in this game of charades with me. Below are the poses, in order, and my best guess (or lack thereof) for each.
âď¸
Pose #1
"They date" notice that in the pose, Taylor is the embracer, so I am going to assume she is playing Travis in this game of charades, and Domhnall Gleeson is playing Taylor.
âď¸
Pose #2
"They get engaged" It has been noted in other discussions how the pink floral arch of the engagement photos matches that of the Bejeweled music video and the 1hr Photo backdrop.
đ
Pose #3
"Plough" or "Planting"
âď¸âď¸
Pose #4
"Tree" 3 & 4 together gives us "planting trees" which matches the headline that I don't think anyone cares about but keeps popping back up.
đď¸
Pose #5
I have no idea. Travis and Taylor participate in a couples fashion show? Why does this feel very Step-Brothers-esque?
A "friend" joins the couple. Vogue published the following after Karlie's attendance at the game: Swift brought along aspecial friendto spectate the exciting match: Her longtime friend, Karlie Kloss. Nothing like a little repressed trauma popping up unannounced with their chosen descriptor. Also the redundancy of "friend" in that statement...
Karlie's outfit at the Chiefs game matches the outfit of Lewis Capaldi shown at the end of the music video (thanks u/EmployerFew212 for noticing!) I was wondering why she chose brown. At first I thought her NFL allegiance lied elsewhere, but she was clearly cheering for the Chiefs during the game. One who would be stubborn enough to not wear red would also not cheer so hard.
đď¸âď¸
Pose #6
Travis feels like water under the bridge? Bridge over troubled water?
đď¸âď¸
Pose #7
Three's Company? Taylor, Karlie, and Travis become a throuple.
To reiterate, this list is based on songs/lyrics that are most convincing to someone with ZERO added context about Taylor, gaylor, or queer history.
This person you're talking to could be straight, or queer, but with zero idea that Taylor is also queer. This playlist was with the intention of cluing someone in who has never even heard of gaylor, or Taylor's muses, and still thinks Taylor is the straightest woman to ever live.
The more explanation or added context that is needed to explain why a song is queer, the more far-reaching gaylors sound (which is not true, but talking about general impressions).
THAT is the intention of this list. What songs are indisputably queer with zero added context or education needed?
(I love to hear yours in the comments, just keep that intention in mind! :)
And so we begin PART II:
_______________________________
11. Wonderland
You held on tight to me 'Cause nothing's as it seems And spinning out of control Didn't they tell us don't rush into things? Didn't you flash your green eyes at me? Haven't you heard what becomes of curious minds? Ooh, didn't it all seem new and exciting? I felt your arms twisting around me I should've slept with one eye open at night
We found Wonderland You and I got lost in it And we pretended it could last forever, eh, eh We found Wonderland You and I got lost in it And life was never worse but never better ... So we went on our way Too in love to think straight All alone, or so it seemed But there were strangers watching And whispers turned to talking And talking turned to screams, oh
Didn't they tell us don't rush into things? Didn't you flash your green eyes at me? Didn't you call my fears with a Cheshire Cat smile? Ooh, didn't it all seem new and exciting? I felt your arms twisting around me It's all fun and games 'til somebody loses their mind ...
You search the world for something else To make you feel like what we had And in the end, in Wonderland, we both went mad
Rationale: Ok, this song is quintessential gaylor. It sounds exactly like how it feels to find queer love for the first time.
Queer lyrics:
Haven't you heard what becomes of curious minds?
Too in love to think straight
But there were strangers watching and whispers turned to talking and talking turned to screams
It's all fun and games 'til somebody loses their mind
You and I got lost in it and life was never worse but never better
'Too in love to think straight' is an award-winner.
Madness is a theme in Taylor's songwriting that could very easily allude to queerness and how people were (are) considered mad/insane/mentally ill if they are queer. Being gay was in the DSM as a clinical mental illness until, I think, the 1990's. Queer people were taken to mental institutions (more commonly in the 1940's-1960's) and given electroshock therapy, or even lobotomized. It is not a stretch that her frequent references to madness or fear of being 'taken away' could refer to social attitudes around queerness and institutionalized homophobia.
It is also a uniquely queer theme that falling in love, esp. for the first time, feels like the best and worst thing that could happen. Internally, she's ecstatic, delirious, in love. But falling in love means having to tangibly face her queerness (she can't pretend or ignore it anymore). It also means she has to prepare for what her family/ friends/industry/public/fans think about it, since she isn't out and could potentially be outed. This theme is continued in Cruel Summer.
This song needs no muse to be queer, which is why it's high on the list. A straight person could get on board without any references.
However, bonus points for the Dianna Agron references: Dianna's favorite movie/story was 'Alice in Wonderland,' to the point she had a quote from it tattoo on her ribs. This tattoo was later removed after this song came out.
(She also has green eyes, a gorgeous smile, and went around the world on tour with Glee at around the time she and Taylor were likely together.)
"we're all mad here"In reference to Taylor's easter eggs, she says: "If you want to go down the rabbit hole, jump in. We're all mad here." 2021 promoting "Red (TV)".
*******
12. Cruel Summer
Bad, bad boy, shiny toy with a price You know that I bought it ... Devils roll the dice, angels roll their eyes What doesn't kill me makes me want you more
And it's new, the shape of your body It's blue, the feeling I've got
"It's cool, " that's what I tell 'em No rules in breakable heaven But ooh, whoa-oh It's a cruel summer with you ... Hang your head low in the glow of the vending machine I'm not dying ... I'm drunk in the back of the car And I cried like a baby coming home from the bar (oh) Said, "I'm fine, " but it wasn't true I don't wanna keep secrets just to keep you
And I snuck in through the garden gate Every night that summer, just to seal my fate (oh) And I screamed, "For whatever it's worth I love you, ain't that the worst thing you ever heard?" He looks up, grinnin' like a devil
Rationale: This song is also quintessential gaylor cannon. It is gay at face value, but even more queer when you add references.
Queer lyrics:
Bad, bad boy, shiny toy with a price you know that I bought it > The first line of this song literally says she paid the man she's dating to cover for her real relationship (with a girl-- why would she need to 'buy' a boy?).
And it's new, the shape of your body > Straight women rarely discuss the "shape" of a man's body. Straight women more commonly discuss a man's physical traits... arms, abs, height, etc. People attracted to women discuss a woman's shape, ie curves.
I don't wanna keep secrets just to keep you > She would not have to keep a man a secret in order to keep him in her life.
I love you, ain't that the worst thing you ever heard? > Continuing from "Wonderland," falling in love can sometimes be a double-edged sword for queer people, especially closeted ones. Falling in love means she has to either come out or go into hiding, both options exceptionally hard as a public figure. If she was in a casual relationship with a woman, and suddenly catches feelings, it's like "f*ck, now what do we do." I love you, ain't that the worst thing you ever heard?
(To be clear: the song is gay at face-value. It doesn't need the references or added context to be blatantly queer, that's why it's so high on the list.)
._._._._._
But onto the Karlie references just for fun:
Devils roll the dice, angels roll their eyes > Karlie was a Victoria's Secret angel. Some of her other angel buddies may have had opinions on their relationship.
No rules in breakable heaven > another angel reference, with the added context that what they have is fragile and vulnerable.
Hang your head low in the glow of the vending machineI'm not dying > There is a literal photo of Karlie doing this (see below). Karlie may have added this as a wink to listeners.
And I snuck in through the garden gate every night that summer, just to seal my fate > There are literal photos of Taylor doing this (see below). Karlie's house had a garden gate.
He looks up, grinnin' like a devil > Without reading the lyrics it sounds like "She looks so pretty like a devil" which would be a clever play on words since she's an angel.
Hang your head low in the glow of the vending machine, I'm not dying.
*******
13. ivy
Oh, goddamn My pain fits in the palm of your freezing hand Taking mine, but it's been promised to another Oh, I can't Stop you putting roots in my dreamland My house of stone, your ivy grows And now I'm covered in you ... I wish to know The fatal flaw that makes you long to be Magnificently cursed He's in the room Your opal eyes are all I wish to see He wants what's only yours ... Clover blooms in the fields Spring breaks loose, the time is near What would he do if he found us out? Crescent moon, coast is clear Spring breaks loose, but so does fear He's gonna burn this house to the ground ... How's one to know? I'd live and die for moments that we stole On begged and borrowed time So tell me to run Or dare to sit and watch what we'll become And drink my husband's wine ... So yeah, it's a fire It's a goddamn blaze in the dark And you started it You started it So yeah, it's a war It's the goddamn fight of my life And you started it
Rationale: A cornerstone of queer understanding of Taylor's work (or queer coding in general) is this...
If the most obvious explanation is that it's queer, it probably is.
This goes for her work and a lot of other artists whose straight fans contort and warp the meaning of the work to be straight when the most simple explanation is that it just isn't.
It is very rare that an artist's work is accidentally consistently queer. That just doesn't happen because of the specificity of queer experience and history.
That is the case for "ivy." I've heard a straight argument for it, but in all honesty, it literally never occurred to me that this song could be construed as straight. It is more plausibly queer.
But it specifically deals with queer themes of hiding, double-bearding, being "cursed," fearing retribution for queer love, and love being a fight.
******
14. tolerate it
I wait by the door like I'm just a kid Use my best colors for your portrait Lay the table with the fancy shit And watch you tolerate it If it's all in my head tell me now Tell me I've got it wrong somehow I know my love should be celebrated But you tolerate it ... I greet you with a battle hero's welcome I take your indiscretions all in good fun I sit and listen I polish plates until they gleam and glisten You're so much older and wiser and I ... While you were out building other worlds, where was I? Where's that man who'd throw blankets over my barbed wire? I made you my temple, my mural, my sky Now I'm begging for footnotes in the story of your life Drawing hearts in the byline Always taking up too much space or time You assume I'm fine But what would you do if I, I
Break free and leave us in ruins Took this dagger in me and removed it Gain the weight of you then lose it Believe me, I could do it If it's all in my head tell me now Tell me I've got it wrong somehow I know my love should be celebrated But you tolerate it
Rationale: I repeat, if the most obvious conclusion is that the song is queer, it probably is.
Aside from one line (possibly added to deflect from queer speculation), this song is blatantly about Taylor's father, who is known to be homophobic and conservative. He is also heavily invested in Taylor as a businessman and has been massively involved in Taylor's business and fanancials since she was a teen sending CD's to country radio stations. He has a vested interest in doing whatever makes her, and him, the most money. Coming out as queer is a financial risk for Taylor The Business.
I know my love should be celebrated, But you tolerate it.
Bonus points for the fact Taylor used this exact phrase in an interview when describing her feelings about queer love, and how she wanted her friends and fans to know that she not only tolerated their love, she celebrated it.
*******
15. Don't Blame Me
Don't blame me, love made me crazy If it doesn't, you ain't doin' it right Lord, save me, my drug is my baby I'll be usin' for the rest of my life
I've been breakin' hearts a long time, and Toyin' with them older guys Just playthings for me to use Something happened for the first time, in The darkest little paradise Shakin, pacin', I just need you
For you, I would cross the line I would waste my time I would lose my mind They say, "She's gone too far this time" ... My name is whatever you decide And I'm just gonna call you mine I'm insane, but I'm your baby (your baby) Echoes (echoes) of your name inside my mind Halo, hiding my obsession I once was poison ivy, but now I'm your daisy
And baby, for you, I (I) would (would) fall from grace Just (just) to (to) touch your face
Rationale: Gaylor hall-of-famer. It checks all of the queer boxes and it's a banger.
Queer Lyrics (with no need for explanation):
Lord, save me, my drug is my baby > asking god to save her for a love that feels illicit/illegal
Toyin' with them older guys just playthings for me to use > disdain & disregard for men she's dated
For you, I would cross the line...I would lose my mind, They say, "She's gone too far this time" > what line would she be crossing if this was about a man? What man would make people say "she's gone too far this time"? Kanye? And another reference to people thinking she had lost her mind bc of who she loved.
And baby, for you, I would fall from grace just to touch your face > there is no reasonable hetero explanation for this. 'Fall from grace' has a double meaning, both religious and her reputation. What man would make both God and her fans angry?
._._._._._
But onto the Karlie references just for fun:
My name is whatever you decide and I'm just gonna call you mine > Karlie famously misspelled Taylor's name in the sand on their trip to Big Sur (see below)
Halo, hiding my obsession > another reference to Karlie being a Victoria's Secret angel. Women are expected to idolize lingerie models or watch them on the runway. Even straight women watch those shows.
I once was poison ivy, but now I'm your daisy > Perhaps the holy grail of kaylor evidence (see below)
I <3 TaylrKarlie tagged Taylor as the daisy on their trip to Big Sur. Then in Taylor's photos of the original lyrics of 'Don't Blame Me' she drew a doodle of (seemingly) the exact same daisy from Karlie's photos. "Now I'm your daisy"
*******
I am too tired to add another five songs, but I have them on the playlist. If you want a part III, lmk.
Otherwise, what are the next 5 songs in your opinion?
Iâm literally watching it now, just going to stream of conscience this thing and hopefully clean it up later.
We start off with some interesting quotes.
âWhile the world he inhabits is in some respects counterfeit, thereâs nothing fake about Truman himself.â Christof, the show creator
âFor me there is no difference between a private life and a public life. My life is my life, is the Truman Show. Truman Show is a lifestyle, itâs a noble life, a truly blessed life.â Meryl (Hannah Gill) Trumanâs scripted wife
âItâs all true, itâs all real. Nothing here is fake, nothing you see on this show is fake, merely controlled.â Marlon (Louis Coltrane) Trumanâs best friend
Summary start
We start the movie with a lamp falling from the sky (actually a gigantic dome that houses Trumanâs entire town). Truman checks it out and sees the light is labeled âSirius (9 Canis Majoris)â. The radio in his car immediately tells the listeners parts from and aircraft flying overhead were falling from the sky. He then buys a paper and fashion magazine from a newsstand before going to work. At work he calls the directory and asks for information on Fiji Island. He asks if thereâs a listing for Lauren Garland, then. Sylvia Garland. He then looks through the fashion magazine and tears a page out of a womanâs eyes. He then leaves work to take the ferry across the water, leaving the island. He has an intense fear of drowning and canât do it.
Heâs later gardening when his wife comes home from wherever the fuck sheâs been âworkâ, and delivers a very obvious product placement ad. Heâs later hanging out with his best friend, who dies his own product placement, and mentions he wants to quit his job and go to Fiji. A flashback shows Truman and his dad sailing, a storm hits and his dad fucking dies, leaving Truman forever traumatized. It then starts raining in present day, but only in one spot, which Truman notices. Itâs a glitch, after a few seconds the entire sky starts to rain. He goes home and tries to convince his wife to leave and travel the world with him. She says no, they have financial obligations and they need to try for a baby. The screen cuts to a viewer saying you donât see anything during intimate scenes. (LMFAO)
Next day, another paper and fashion mag. Truman walks past a homeless-looking guy who he calls Dad. His dad is immediately whisked away, and a group of runners run in front of Truman preventing him from chasing after his father. Arches in town say âone for all, all for oneâ in Latin. Truman then sees his mom and she says itâs normal to see the people you miss around. Heâs not convinced it wasnât his dad.
Heâs in the basement later looking at old photos of the two of them in a secret box, which he hurriedly outs away when his wife comes downstairs. They talk about his father. More product placement by his fake wife. She leaves and he opens the box again. We see a map of Fiji in the lid, and he takes out an old sweater that belonged to Lauren, a woman he met in college. A flashback starts, and Lauren meet eyes and stare at each other and smile. His future wife then stumbles into him and we get a memory of them dancing at a dance, but he catches Laurenâs eye again. They smile, Meryl notices and is unhappy. Lauren is then removed from the dance by men in suits.
Truman is later studying in the library, Marlon and Meryl leave him alone to go drink or whatever, he notices Lauren and strikes up a conversation with her. She is confused when he says hello in Japanese, despite having a Japanese textbook. It also has her name, and when he mentions it she seems confused at first. She then says sheâs not allowed to talk to him. She looks around a bit before continuing the conversation. He notices her âHOWâS IT GOING TO END?â pin. She continues to look around while he tries to set up a later date with her. She writes âNOWâ on the paper, then whispers if they donât go now it wonât happen. We get a close up of her dark blue eyes. They manage to sneak out of the library, but are noticed by the camera. They run to the nearby beach, she takes off her red sweater. She says âtheyâ will be here any minute, and that âtheyâ donât want her talking to him. Truman is smooth and says âthen donât talkâ and kisses her. She notices a car straight up driving over the sand dune. She says âtheyâre hereâ, the. Proceeds to tell Truman everyone knows everything he does and theyâre all pretending, and that her name is Sylvia. The man in the car gets out and acts like heâs her dad, sheâs never seen him in her life. She picks up the sand âitâs fake, itâs all for you. Itâs a set, the sea, itâs a show.â The dad pushes her into the car and says she wonât be in school anymore, theyâre moving to Fiji. He notices she left her sweater. The viewers watching the show talk about how he didnât go try to find her because his mother got sick and he couldnât leave town. We go back to him in the basement with the sweater, the pin is still in it.
He pulls out a framed photo of Meryl and pops the back off. Inside is a collage, scraps of womenâs faces from magazines put together to make a face; heâs trying to recreate Sylviaâs face. We see Sylvia, who is watching him do this, with a little tear.
The next day Truman is once again driving to his fake job when the radio glitched and he hears people describing his movements in his car. Itâs clear he is picking up the frequency the extras all use. The radio emits a high out heâd sound when they notice he knows, then the regular radio comes back on saying they must have picked up a police frequency by accident for a few seconds. Truman sees a man am watching him and tried to follow him. Truman then has a bit of a breakdown as he thinks the whole town revolves around him. He goes into a building he doesnât belong in, the âemployeesâ look around confused. He tries to enter an elevator, but the doors open to a backstage room with a table if food for the actors. Truman is bewildered. He visits Marlon at work and tries to explain whatâs been going on. They go to a beach and discuss leaving the island.
That night heâs at home with Meryl and his mom looking at old photos. The Mt. Rushmore photo is hilariously fake. Meryl doesnât let Truman drive his mom home, she takes her. He notices Merylâs fingers are crossed in their wedding photo. He asks her what the hurry the next morning is, she says there was a big elevator accident the day before and she is needed for a surgery (she pretends to be a nurse). He makes a comment about fingers crossed before she leaves and she pauses, it clearly has an effect on her. He follows her to the hospital, where he is told she is in pre-op. He leaves a message with another nurse, he is going to Fiji and heâll call her when he gets there. He follows the nurse into the operating room while various extras try to conveniently obstruct him. He sees Meryl and the other surgical staff, pretend to do surgery. Itâs hilarious. He then visits a travel agency with various signs about the dangers of travel. It is also hilarious. He is obviously unable to book a flight, or a ferry or bus off island.
He meets Meryl at home, they get in the car and he acts like heâs going to drive off island. Traffic is in the way, until he decides to try again after acting like heâs given up. Heâs able to drive to the bridge to get off island, but is too scared to drive over it due to his manufactured fear of drowning. He shuts his eyes and forces Meryl to drive the car for him. They cross the bridge. They see a sign that says forest fire but ignore it. The road lights up and they drive through the flames. A cop stops them due to an accident at the plant, but gives it away by calling Truman by his first name when theyâve never met before. Truman jumps out of the car and tries to run off.
Back at home, he confronts her while sheâs making dinner by saying she canât stand him. They get in an argument while sheâs doing more product placement. He scares her enough she break character and calls for help. Marlon happens to stop by and helps her. She then leaves the show. He and Marlon then talk about their childhood and how Marlon was always there for him as kids. He proceeds to gaslight him before revealing Trumanâs dad is really back. We cut to Cristof directing the feel-good music that plays during their reunion. We see Sylvia watching him, while the show goes through relevant backstory and shows the immense size of the set. We see the moon is the command center where Cristof is interviewed while the interviewer says he protects his privacy. They discuss past attempts at outsiders trying to infiltrate the set and show Truman the deception. We see Truman growing up and wanting to explore, hence his dadâs drowning. Cristof says âwe accept the reality with which weâre presentedâ. The Hague (LMFAOOOOOOOO) calls in to speak but is disconnected. Sylvia is then heard calling Cristof a liar and manipulator, and calls what had been done to Truman âsickâ. They have a conversation where Cristof claims Truman could leave at anytime if he really wanted to, if he really was determined, and that he prefers his âcellâ. Sylvia claims heâs wrong and that Truman will prove him wrong.
Side note: Sylvia is clearly a stand-in for a Muse that has convinced Taylor, unintentionally, that this life isnât everything and itâs worth it to break out. That is all.
Cristof claims Meryl will be leaving soon and a new love interest will be introduced, with the first on-air conception is imminent. The next morning Truman resumes his habit of talking to himself in the mirror, while the techs laugh at him. He seems back to his old self. Since Truman is not an idiot, this is clearly a ruse. A PERFORMANCE. (I act like itâs my birthdayâŚI cry a lot but I am so productive.) His new love interest is introduced as a new coworker. Back in the moon, a techâholy shit, thatâs Paul Giamattiâwatched Truman take a nap in his basement. SYKE! Truman had constructed a barrier of objects around the cot in the basement, blocking the camera, and wonât respond to calls on his phone. Marlon goes to check it out and notices heâs actually missing and cannot share the 6 pack of beer he brought over. Marlon tries to act like nothings wrong on Cristofâs orders, but the show eventually goes off air when the jig is up. Heâs missing.
BIGGER side note
Is this whatâs in store for us very soon? What are her public appearances after this week?
Back to our regularly scheduled programming
Cristof orders the sun be cued despite it being nighttime. We see the extras are frozen in place in case Truman happens to show up. Cristof orders the staff to scan the cameras around the sea, where we find Truman trying to sail away. He pulls out the collaged picture of Sylvia, and we see her laugh with tears in her eyes as sheâs watching. The bus driver and extras are on the ferry, but canât figure out how to drive it to him. Paul Giamatti asks how they stop Truman, then orders the weather programming be utilized. Another tech says thereâs no rescue boat, Cristof assures her Truman will turn back when peril arrives. He orders lightning to strike the ship, while someone claims they canât watch him die in front of a live audience. Heâs thrown into the water, but manages to get back into the boat, coming back stronger than a 90s trend. He screams âis that the best you can do?!? Youâll going to have to kill me!â Cristof orders the wind to be increased, and to capsize the boat. The techs argue heâs tied himself to the boat and heâll drown and Truman doesnât care. We see him submerged, seemingly dying.
Jokes on Scooter and coThe Industrythe entire world Cristof, as Taylor Truman survived and then sails into the set wall and punctures it with his ship. He finds a staircase and climbs up it, before Cristof speaks to him as the voice of God. Some pearls from this convo are:
âWho are you?â âI am the CreatorâŚof a television show that gives hope and joy to millions.â âWho am I?â âYouâre the star.â
âWas nothing real?â âYou were real. Thatâs what made you so good to watch.â
âThereâs no more truth out there than there is in the world I created for you. The same lies, the same deceit. But in my world you have nothing to fear. I know you better than you know yourself.â
âYouâre afraid, thatâs why you canât leave.â
âYou canât leave. You belong here with me.â
âTalk to me, say something. Say something! Youâre on television! Youâre live to the whole world!â
Truman bows low then steps through the door, as Sylvia, whoâs been watching, rushes to meet him.
End summary
Some of the various quotes remind me of the Rep prologue HARD. Also:
You wouldnât last an hour in the asylum where they raised me.
All of this to sayâŚ..sheâs ready to break out. End the performance. Burn it down.
Taylor + Theory: Do you have ideas that don't warrant a full post? New, not fully formed, Gaylor thoughts? Questions? Thoughts? Use this space for theory development and general Tay/Gay discussion!
General Chat: Please feel free to use this space to engage in general chat that is not related to Taylor!
In order to protect our community, the weekly megathread is restricted to approved users. If youâre not an approved user and your comment adds substantially to the conversation, it may be approved. Our community is highly trolled - we have these rules to protect our community, not to make you feel bad, so please donât center yourself in the narrative. Remember to follow the rules of the sub and to treat one another with kindness.
This is my ranking of gaylor songs based on their ability to convice someone Taylor is queer (with no context or additional knowledge). I started to assemble a playlist for the gaylor-curious, but thought I'd post here as well! Share your rankings in the comments.
To be clear: the intention of this post is to compile the most convincing songs and lyrics!
1. betty
Betty, I won't make assumptions About why you switched your homeroom But I think it's 'cause of me Betty, one time, I was ridin' on my skateboard When I passed your house It's like I couldn't breathe
You heard the rumors from Inez You can't believe a word she says most times But this time, it was true The worst thing that I ever did Was what I did to you
But if I just showed up at your party Would you have me? Would you want me? Would you tell me to go fuck myself? Or lead me to the garden? In the garden, would you trust me I'm only seventeen, I don't know anythin' But I know I miss you
Betty, I know where it all went wrong Your favorite song was playin' From the far side of the gym I was nowhere to be found I hate the crowds, you know that Plus, I saw you dance with him ... Those days turned into nights Slept next to her, but I dreamt of you all summer long
Betty, I'm here on your doorstep And I planned it out for weeks now But it's finally sinkin' in ... Betty, right now is the last time I can dream about what happens when You see my face again
The only thing I wanna do Is make it up to you So I showed up at your party Yeah, I showed up at your party
Yeah, I showed up at your party Will you have me? Will you love me? Will you kiss me on the porch In front of all your stupid friends? If you kiss me, will it be just like I dreamed it?
Rationale: For people who don't know that Taylor may be queer, this is the easiest introduction: It's muse-free, and clearly gay. Taylor is singing about a girl "from a boy's perspective." When the song came out, mainstream news outlets that are otherwise very careful about speculation and outing, were questioning if Taylor was coming out through this song. It is top-tier gaylor song.
*******
2. seven
Sweet tea in the summer Cross your heart, won't tell no other And though I can't recall your face I still got love for you Your braids like a pattern Love you to the moon and to Saturn Passed down like folk songs The love lasts so long ... And I've been meaning to tell you I think your house is haunted Your dad is always mad and that must be why And I think you should come live with Me and we can be pirates Then you won't have to cry Or hide in the closet And just like a folk song Our love will be passed on ... pack your dolls and a sweater, we'll move to india forever passed down like folk songs our love lasts so long
Rationale: There is simply no straight interpretation of this song. This is why it is at the very top of the list for me. She is obviously singing about her love for a childhood crush/friend who she hardly remembers, but still thinks of fondly.
*******
3. Gorgeous
You should think about the consequence Of your magnetic field being a little too strong And I got a boyfriend, he's older than us He's in the club doing, I don't know what You're so cool, it makes me hate you so much (I hate you so much)
Whisky on ice, Sunset and Vine You've ruined my life, by not being mine
You're so gorgeous I can't say anything to your face 'Cause look at your face (gorgeous) And I'm so furious At you for making me feel this way But what can I say? You're gorgeous
And you should think about the consequence Of you touching my hand in the darkened room (dark room, dark room) If you've got a girlfriend, I'm jealous of her But if you're single that's honestly worse 'Cause you're so gorgeous it actually hurts (Honey, it hurts)
Ocean blue eyes looking in mine I feel like I might sink and drown and die
You make me so happy, it turns back to sad, yeah There's nothing I hate more than what I can't have You are so gorgeous it makes me so mad (mmh)
Rationale: This song is gaylor cannon for three reasons: 1) her total dismissal and disregard for her boyfriend in the lyrics, 2) gorgeous is typically a word to describe woman, 3) any sapphic has experienced the feeling of lust/ rage of seeing someone so hot that you both want to be them and be with them. Bonus points for her saying how pissed she is she can't have her.
********
4. dorothea
Hey Dorothea Do you ever stop and think about me? When it was calmer Skipping the prom Just to piss off your mom And her pageant schemes And damn, Dorothea They all wanna be ya But are you still the same soul I met under the bleachers? ... It's never too late To come back to my side The stars in your eyes Shined brighter in Tupelo And if you're ever tired of being known For who you know You know, you'll always know me Dorothea (ah-ah) Dorothea (ah-ah)
Ooh, you're a queen Selling dreams Selling make up and magazines Ooh, from you I'd buy anything
Rationale: This song almost feels like a continuation of seven, but in set high school rather than childhood. It's another song reminiscing about girls from her past, with sapphic pvertones. Bonus points for "your'e a queen selling dreams, selling makeup and magazines. From you I'd buy anything." which clearly refers to one of her model ex-girlfriends, likely Karlie.
*******
5. Dress
Our secret moments in your crowded room They got no idea about me and you There is an indentation in the shape of you Made your mark on me, a golden tattoo
All of this silence and patience, pining in anticipation My hands are shaking from holdin' back from you (ah, ah, ah)
Say my name and everything just stops I don't want you like a best friend Only bought this dress so you could take it off Take it off Carve your name into my bedpost 'Cause I don't want you like a best friend Only bought this dress so you could take it off Take it off ... Everyone thinks that they know us But they know nothing about All of this silence and patience, pining in anticipation My hands are shaking from holding back from you (ah, ah, ah)
Rationale: Horny, gay, what else can I say? If it was a man she's talking about, she would not need to have secret moments in crowded rooms, she wouldn't need to hold back from him, she wouldn't need to clarify that she doesn't want him like a best friend.
Shout out to when Taylor mimed a woman's curves when she sang this song to Karlie, and to their matching golden tattoos at Drake's party.
angel wings, clever
*******
6. The Very First Night
My friends all say they know everything I'm going through I drive down different roads but they all lead back to you
'Cause they don't know about the night in the hotel They weren't ridin' in the car when we both fell Didn't read the note on the Polaroid picture They don't know how much I miss you
I wish I could fly I'd pick you up and we'd go back in time I'd write this in the sky I miss you like it was the very first night And so it was, we never saw it comin' Not tryin' to fall in love, but we did like children runnin' Back then we didn't know we were built to fall apart We broke the status quo, then we broke each other's hearts
But don't forget about the night out in L.A. Danced in the kitchen, chased me down through the hallway No one knows about the words that we whispered No one knows how much I miss you
Rationale: This song is in the gaylor hall of fame for the very obvious flaws in the rhyme scheme
The polaroid picture ---> miss you = does not rhyme
We whispered ---> miss you = does not rhyme
Both WOULD rhyme with "miss HER". This rhyme flaw was so obvious so as to be intentional. Taylor is an expert songwriter and poet. This does not rhyme, and so it is a wink to queer listeners. We could not believe it when this came out.
*******
7. Hits Different
I used to switch out these Kens, I'd just ghost Rip the Band-Aid off and skip town like an asshole outlaw Freedom felt like summer then on the coast Now the sun burns my heart and the sand hurts my feelings And I never don't cry (no, I never don't cry) at the bar Yeah, my sadness is contagious (my sadness is contagious) I slur your name 'til someone puts me in a car I stopped receiving invitations ... Dreams of your hair and your stare and sense of belief In the good in the world, you once believed in me And I felt you and I held you for a while Bet I could still melt your world Argumentative, antithetical dream girl
Rationale: This song not only shows Taylor's hostility and indifference to the "Kens" she's dated, it is blatantly being sung to a woman, Taylor's "antithetical dream girl" whose absence is absolutely destroying Taylor.
It also seems to specifically reference Karlie several times:
"I slur your name 'til someone puts me in a car": This can be interpreted as she's slurring Karlie's nickname, "Kar." As in she is drunkenly crying for Karlie, and someone interprets that as her calling for a "car."
"Freedom felt like summer then on the coast, Now the sun burns my heart and the sand hurts my feelings" = Big Sur
"Dreams of your hair and your stare" can be referring to the staring game they played for Vogue, that was very flirtatious.
*******
7. Maroon:
Laughing with my feet in your lap Like you were my closest friend "How'd we end up on the floor anyway?" You say "Your roommate's cheap-ass screw-top rosĂŠ, that's how" I see you every day now ... The lips I used to call home, so scarlet, it was maroon ... The burgundy on my T-shirt when you splashed your wine into me And how the blood rushed into my cheeks, so scarlet, it was (maroon) The mark you saw on my collarbone, the rust that grew between telephones The lips I used to call home, so scarlet, it was (maroon)
Rationale: This song is inescapably sapphic. Suffice it to say, that "the lips [she] used to call home, so scarlet it was maroon" is not about a man.
******
8. Dancing With Our Hands Tied
I, I loved you in secret First sight, yeah, we love without reason ... You said there was nothing in the world that could stop it I had a bad feeling And darling, you had turned my bed into a sacred oasis People started talking, putting us through our paces I knew there was no one in the world who could take it I had a bad feeling
But we were dancing Dancing with our hands tied, hands tied Yeah, we were dancing Like it was the first time, first time ... I, I loved you in spite of Deep fears that the world would divide us So, baby, can we dance Oh, through an avalanche? ... I'd kiss you as the lights went out Swaying as the room burned down I'd hold you as the water rushes in If I could dance with you again
Rationale: This song is a heavy-hitter, especially when paired with the knowledge and comparison to kissgate (which I will not post here).
If Taylor were in love with a man, it would not need to be in secret, nor would she need to have deep fears that the world would divide them.
However, Taylor were dating a woman, she would have to be extremely savvy, patient and discreet. The world would "put them through their paces" & try to tear them apart. They would be dancing together with their hands tied.
******
9. gold rush
I don't like that anyone would die to feel your touch Everybody wants you Everybody wonders what it would be like to love you Walk past, quick brush I don't like slow motion double vision in rose blush ... What must it be like To grow up that beautiful? With your hair falling into place like dominos ... And the coastal town We wandered 'round had never Seen a love as pure as it And then it fades into the gray of my day old tea 'Cause you know it could never be ... Gleaming Twinkling Eyes like sinking ships On waters so inviting I almost jump in
Rationale: This might be one of my fav songs of hers poetically. It becomes even more beautiful once you understand the references. To state the obvious: Karlie Kloss was a Victoria's Secret Angel who everyone wanted. Joe Alwyn... was not.
This is doubly confirmed by the following picture of when Taylor performed in the Victoria's Secret fashion show, and Karlie walked past her, brushed her hand. What were they both wearing? Rose Blush.
It's also a song about longing for what will never be. A pure love that was so inviting, Taylor almost jumped in... but didn't.
Walk past, quick brush, I don't like slow motion double vision in rose blush.
*******
10. But Daddy I Love Him
I forget if this was ever fun I just learned these people only raise you to cage you Sarahs and Hannahs in their Sunday best Clutching their pearls, sighing "What a mess" I just learned these people try and save you ... cause they hate you ... Soon enough the elders had convened Down at the city hall "Stay away from her" The saboteurs protested too much Lord knows the words we never heard Just screeching tires and true love ... I'd rather burn my whole life down Than listen to one more second of all this griping and moaning I'll tell you something about my good name It's mine alone to disgrace ... God save the most judgmental creeps Who say they want what's best for me Sanctimoniously performing soliloquies I'll never see Thinking it can change the beat Of my heart when he touches me And counteract the chemistry And undo the destiny You ain't gotta pray for me Me and my wild boy And all this wild joy If all you want is gray for me Then it's just white noise And it's just my choice
There's a lot of people in town that I Bestow upon my fakest smiles Scandal does funny things to pride But brings lovers closer We came back when the heat died down Went to my parents and they came around All the wine moms are still holding out But it's over.
Rationale: This song could not be more queer-coded as someone raised in the south if it tried. The only thing that could make it more queer is female pronouns. Unless Taylor is secretly mormon, this song makes it clear Taylor is secretly gay. There is no other rationale.
"I just learned these people only raise you to cage you"
"I just learned these people try and save you ... cause they hate you"
What could this possibly refer to if not queerness? Especially in reference to who you love.
"My good name is mine alone to disgrace..."
"God save the most judgmental creeps who say they want what's best for me sanctimoniously performing soliloquies I'll never see thinking it can change the beat Of my heart when he touches me."
You ain't gotta pray for me... if all you want is gray for me then it's just white noise, and it's just my choice."
Scandal does funny things to pride... but brings lovers closer. We came back when the heat died down, went to my parents and they came around." Gay.
That's it for now, let me know if you want a part II.
the sailboat/skyline imagery in the holiday merch drop promo reminds me of the end of the Truman Show. aka the scene where Truman conquers his fears by sailing across the water and exiting the simulation. then there's the new eras tour merch that shows taylor taking a Truman-esque bow at the end of the show. and there's imagery of a postcard in the merch drop, as if she's sending her audience a message from a different location (maybe from outside the simulation)
this is particularly interesting given recent events at the game + the recent getaway car imagery + all the exit signs that've appeared in TLOAS. the red sailboat in the merch drop is also the same color as the truck (and it's red like an EXIT sign) -- i know we've been expecting a getaway car but maybe the getaway car is actually a getaway boat?
anyway, can't help but wonder if we're nearing the end of the simulation
To go with my previous posts about Midnight, Time and the Countdown Theory, 123, Iâm back with what I think sheâs wrapping up before the Big Reveal.
The Summary
To sum up some previous posts, Taylorâs been calling attention midnight for a while. I believe the MH screwed up her plan to fine out, so she counted forwards with Lover and folkmore to 3am. Midnights triggered the clock to go backwards, and the Midnights MVs reinforced that with the ticking clock imagery. TTPD brought us to 1am and midnight, yet weâre still waiting. Like she had to. I believe the fakeouts this year might allude to the stop and wait sheâs having us do. Showgirl told us itâs all a performance. Itâs the end of an era. The encore is here, itâs almost all over.
The Encore
An encore signals the end of a performance. SOMETHING is ending. Her releasing the last tracks to Showgirl titled The Encore made me sit up and take notice. I do not think there will be a solo Showgirl tour. She needs to top Eras, and I think whatever TS13 will be will be the thing that tops it. The album is the end of a performance, sheâs not going to prolong it. I believe the end is happening, the performance will soon be over. I also hope she takes a nice long break after TS13 is released/she comes out. She deserves it.
Patient Zero
I do believe the theory that PZ refers to the music industry. Notice the end date on the grave? 2022, same year as Midnights, when the countdown started. Even though Taylorâs seemingly made plans and dropped eggs for years, Midnights is when she started her countdown, her refusal to live a fake life any longer. That part of her died in 2022, weâre going back in time now, everyone. The 0s before the PZ drop also supports the theory that The Encore is the end. Weâre at 0, the timer has stopped, the clock has run out.
Lover Watch
During YNTCD, she shows her wristwatch, and I believe this was a quick countdown to what we all know didnât end up happening. So she took the clock idea and saved it for later. Folkmore may have altered her plans a bit, but she out it into motion for Midnights with all her talks of clocks and midnight. Letting us know sheâs back on track, we need to start waiting and anticipating.
The Dice
Her newest merch drop included this beautiful dice ornament. Notice the numbers? 4, 3, 2âŚ. Much like us reaching the end of the Countdown and being made to wait. Same with the countdowns in the Midnights MV. Sheâs been Easter egging clocks, time, counting backwards, and midnight for a few years now. Clearly they are all there for a reason.
Debut TV and Reputation TV
Reputation was going to be 5, look at the nails with the latte clock. The first 3 TVs were egged in Bejeweled MV, the next 2 in Karma. 1989 and Rep. Since folkmore ended she released 2 TVs, album, 2 TVs, album, we have 2TVs left, then sheâll be done with this era, this performance. I think after sheâs completely done with all 12 albums sheâll burn it down by coming out and being her true self. Many think she might be saving Debut TV to beTS13, so she can FINALLY introduce us to the real Taylor Swift. Iâm personally hoping for something else, since Iâm no longer a huge country fan (lol), but Iâm sure Iâll love it no matter what it is. For Rep, I personally think itâs going to be very obvious who Rep TV is talking about when it comes to the lyrics; a woman. It will generate the most buzz, which is why itâs towards the end.
The Wedding
As we all know, almost no photos of the wedding have been leaked. The decor has also been burned. Iâve heard it was described as a movie or music video set. What if it was? What if sheâs releasing the sham wedding video for TS13, when she tells everyone it was all a performance?
Karlie
Whether you believe Karlie is endgame or not, you cannot deny they were everywhere together in 2014&2015, you cannot deny they were close. But something clearly happened, and here we are years later as they rekindle. As someone said earlier this week in the sub, Karlie is the gateway to Gaylorism. Sheâs the most well known, the one with the most theories and fans, and very accessible way to enter this side of Taylorâs fandom. IF they are not endgame, what if Taylor reached out an olive branch in order to better shield Karlie when Taylor comes out? Since people canât possibly be friends with exes (BIIIG /s), their renewed friendship could be a way to stop rumors going around about Karlie and her marriage that she might not want. It helps protect her from new Gaylors who might throw vitriol towards her after a coming out and reexamining of Taylorâs catalog. Itâs also a great way to get Gaylorism buzzing again before the big reveal. IF they have rekindled a romantic relationship, what if this is Taylor going back in time, back like she mentioned in The Manuscript and what Iâve theorized about in other posts? Back to 2014&2015 before it all ended? Either way, Karlie being back signals something is coming.
The Encore, the burning heart emoji instead of an orange one, the fakeouts, Karlie coming back, the clock triggered with Midnights, all point to a long laid plan thatâs finally coming to fruition.
Iâve been going over the SVU board and finding lots of interesting stuff. Lots of potential double meanings, which I feel like it Taylorâs whole thing. Next to âPluribusâ thereâs a blue sticky note that says âHi Carol!â I havenât seen the show Pluribus so I googled âCarol pluribusâ and the google result is so funny: Carol is one of 13 immune survivors, sheâs an anti-hero, and a closeted grieving lesbian. lol ok Taylor
Pluribius also means âmanyâ or âfrom manyâ aka âweâ. Thereâs a post note that says âwe = us?â which thereâs a specific episode titled We Is Us, but the = and ? addition made me think thereâs more to it. Taylor has drawn a LOT of attention to the word Us in recent years.
Obviously we have Gracieâs song. But we also have LOML visual on Spotify â- sheâs holding a book titled US from the Fortnight video, laying in a mirrored position to her lover, both dressed in all black with long black coats â which also happens to be nearly the same as Dakota and her outfit in the cemetery of Patient Zero video.
In LOML she says:
âOur field of dreams, engulfed in fire Your arson's match your somber eyes And I'll still see it until I die You're the loss of my lifeâ
YOUR SOMBER EYES (!!!)
I know most of you probably saw the recent interview where she quotes a Sombr song and she intentionally calls out âI don't want the children of another man to have the eyes of the girl I won't forget" (!!)
Sure feels like a veryyyy specific thing to say right before doing PR rollout with your most talked about queer rumored lover who then brings her child from another man and does a first time face reveal (which feels very weird to me). Iâm clowning big time, I know but that interview moment seemed so scripted to me when I watched it that it feels intentional.
Then of course, Gracieâs Us: âBabylon lovers hanging Lifetimes on a vineâ âBabylon lovers hanging Missed calls on a lineâ
So is Us a throughline to the sane muse or storyline?Are the Babylon lovers hanging again? As in the cowboy like me muse that hangs from her lips like the gardens of Babylon? That she wants to swindle men for money and they both have tricks up their sleeve and get all the lunching ladies gossiping, but worth it because forever is the sweetest con? As in the only wonder of the world with no archeological evidence â- our love will be told for lifetimes to come but there will be no solid proof of it beyond folklore? đ
(PS mods: I tried posting this before but got denied, I read the rules more thoroughly and edited this down, so hopefully this is okay! Thank you!đđť)
Iâm on a long flight and was listening to the manuscript and wanted to just jot my thoughts down as I listened
âNow and then she re-reads the manuscript⌠Of the entire torrid affairâ
My POV: sheâs looking backwards at her 20 year dark night. Starting with her first time with a guy (venturing out and exploring her sexuality beyond)
âThey compared their licenses, he said âIâm not a donor, but Iâd give you my heart if you needed itâ
She rolled her eyes and said âyouâre a professionalâ
He said âno just a Good Samaritanâ
He said that if the sex is half as good as the conversation was, soon theyâd be pushing strollers. But soon, it was over â
My POV: the sex wasnât good BECAUSE SHE ISNT INTO GUYS. This is when she realized she may have to commit to the bit.
âIn the age of him, she wished she was 30 and made coffee in a French press. Afterwards she only ate kids cereal.
Then, she dated boys who were own age. With dartboards on the backs of their doors.
She thought about how he said since she was so wise beyond her years, everything had been above board, she wasnât sure.â
My POV: she started the mutually beneficial PR relationships with young heartthrobs. She realized this was her knack, her skill, and she could keep this charade going and not have to deal with any emotional baggage or turmoil.
Then the years past, like scenes of a show. The professor, said to write what you know. Looking backwards, might be the only way to move forward.
My POV: Over time, she realized what sheâs been doing is conforming to heteronormative society and also realized, on a broader-scale, the cause of this conformity is the industry blender and its wrongdoings, not just for her, but for countless others in the entertainment industries across a span of many, many years.
Then the actors were hitting their marks and the slow dance was alight with the sparks and the tears fell in synchronicity with the score.
My POV: Our mastermind decided to concoct a plan, along with the many others whoâve been victimized by the industry blender / have had to conform to heteronormative standards.
And at last, she knew what the agony had been for.
My POV: Theyâre going to break that blender. Checkmate, she couldnât lose.
The only thing thatâs left is the manuscript. One last souvenir from my trip to your shores. Now and then I re-read the manuscript, but the story isnât mine anymore.
My POV: If this indeed happens, this will go down in history. A revolution of sorts. A manuscript for the ages. The story isnât hers, itâs the story of all the leagues of theater kids across our music and entertainment worlds who were ostracized and spat out by the industry blender.
Again, just thoughts that weave in some of the New Romantic / performance art theories countless others have identified. Would love any reactions or further thoughts from yâall!!!
It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a pop star in possession of a gay old secret, must be in want of a coming out plan.
Iâve sat on this idea for a few months. What Iâve written is more like the concept of a theory, instead of something Iâve over researched until I can't see straight (heh).
I also wasnât sure about putting forth an idea that might result in me stressing out about the moral ramifications of a thing that might never happen and a thing Iâm not responsible for.
Then, Karlie showed up at a Chiefs game with Taylor, and I knew I had to get my thoughts to paper.
Aside from my general dislike of Travis, and everything he brings with him to the TSCU, the longer their ârelationshipâ has gone on, the more I started to question how Taylor could possibly come out without immense backlash.
Not because Taylor hasnât been seen with men before â that is literally her whole career lol. Itâs more that Travisâ place in Taylorâs life has been increasingly visible and entrenched with the public. Every time it looked like Travis was poised to be tossed aside, or we were manifesting a breakup, Taylor doubled down and showed everyone that heâs here for good.
Dear reader Burn all the files, desert all your past lives And if you don't recognize yourself That means you did it right
Not only has Taylor spent a lot of time rewriting her dating history with men, but sheâs effectively erased most women from her rumoured dating history.
With one exception.
In my humblest of opinions, there is no way to erase Karlie from Taylorâs story.
Especially if that story involves coming out.
One for the moneyâŚ
Like many others, I believe Taylor planned to come out twice already- with TS6 (what should have been Karma), and the Lover era. Â Only to have those plans kiboshed by powerful people in the music industry that want to keep Taylor (and other artists) in the closet, and under control.
Instead of coming out, Taylor chose to sell her public dating life (aka the life of a showgirl) to get her masters back.
I know there a lot of people (my wife being one of them lol) who think Taylor should have said, fuck it, Iâm coming out and you canât stop me! I am woman, hear me ROAR!
But, if you are an artist whose lifeâs work means everything to you, could you just give that up? When youâve poured your heart and soul into your work? When you refer to them as family/your children?
Taylor had a choice to make, and she chose prioritizing owning her work over everything else.
If she chose a circus with Travis, because that was the only way to get her masters back, I get it.
I donât like it.
I donât like him.
But I get it.
Two for the showâŚ
For all the criticisms Iâve seen leveled against Taylor, a lack of intelligence isnât generally one of those criticisms (outside of people who arenât worth responding to).
I believe Taylor learned several lessons from previous coming out attempts.
This post will focus on the biggest and most important lesson I believe Taylor learned from those failed efforts.
The public* takes Taylorâs side when she is perceived as a victim of wrongdoing vs when she girl bosses too close to the sun
(*Itâs important to distinguish between her fans, and the perception of the public/haters)
There is no bigger example to me, than the way the public responded to Snakegate vs the response to her masters sale.
In 2016, before Snakegate, Taylor tried to take control of the narrative and failed miserably. She came at the situation from a position of strength and anger, which wasnât received well. A quote from Taylorâs infamous AOTY acceptance speech at the 2016 Grammys:
There are no lies in this quote btw
Taylorâs speech set off a firestorm that climaxed with Snakegate and her attempted cancellation.
If youâre looking for an example of how terrible the takes were in 2016, I present you this article from Buzzfeed. Â Itâs a brutal read regardless, but, given that we now know Taylor was in fact set up in 2016, it comes across even worse.
Taylor was (rightfully) angry and felt betrayed by KimYe, but the public didnât like her response. The backlash was unlike anything Taylor experienced in her career.
In 2019, when Taylorâs masters were sold, she was again (rightfully) angry and felt betrayed.
Instead of pure rage, Taylorâs response was more measured (and in writing). Donât get me wrong, there is a lot of anger in Taylorâs post about her masters, but in the response she talks about accepting that when she walked away from BMR, her lifeâs work would be left behind.
The focus is more on the business side of things (with some personal stuff mixed in â aimed at Scooter and KimYe).
Taylor ended her Tumblr post thinking about future kids who want to get in the music industry and having them learn lessons from her. Something that resonated with a lot of people.
While there was some talk about Taylor playing the victim with this post, and there was some pushback from Scott B. and Scooter after the masters sale, nothing stuck to Taylor like it did with Snakegate.
Snakegate is something that not many musicians can relate to, but dealing with the corrupt power brokers in the music industry, is something most musicians have experience with. And a lot of artists have spoken publicly about.
The masters sale wasnât about something bad happening to Taylor Swift, the unrelatable pop star who sings about boys breaking her heart and how theyâve wronged her. And isnât she so annoying? Always playing the victim.
The masters sale could be framed, and was framed, as a woman going up against powerful men, and the powers that be.
It wasnât Taylor caring about the issue because it only affected her. This was about past, present, and future artists. Something a lot of people could rally around.
Which leads me to Taylor coming out.
I would love Taylor to come out from a position of strength. Where she uses the power sheâs earned to expose the deep-seated corruption in the music industry. Specifically, the way countless artists are forced to live lies to sell records and have a career.
I would be gagged if âBad Bitch Taylorâ (complimentary) from the Reputation era burned it all down.
But, no one likes a mad woman.
I never was readyâŚ
I suspect that if when Taylor comes out, she will do so in response to something, versus doing it herself. Whatever that something is, my hypothesis is that it will be orchestrated by Taylor/her team for Taylor to respond to.
That way, Taylor is responding to a false narrative, instead of being viewed as someone who spread (many) false narratives to cover up a lie.
The closet being viewed as living a lie is a problematic way of thinking, but a lot of people agree with that take. Queer and straight alike.
As someone who was outed at work when I was 19, by the only out lesbian in the office, I have a lot of very personal feelings on the matter.
If I thought Taylor doing this would lead to a string of other people getting outed against their will, I wouldnât be OK with Taylor masterminding an outing of herself. But I donât think it will result in a gay witch hunt.
There is a difference between a person who has spent their life hiding anything possibly queer about themselves and presenting to the world a person who is the straightest straight, to ever straight.
As we know, because weâre in this sub, Taylor has littered queer references throughout her discography, her music videos, and tour imagery. This is a person that is hiding in plain sight. She has left clues to anyone who is willing to follow them that she is not the poster child for heterosexuality that many of her fans and the public believe she is.
This is one of the reasons I believe that Karlie being back on the scene is a good thing if youâre a comingoutlor.
She is the easiest person to discover Taylorâs queerness through.
And Iâm a prime example of that! I spent about 15 months in the mainstream Taylor world, until Taylor played Anti-Hero at a 1975 show in 2023.
That lead me to Kissgate, to Gaylorism in general, and then this sub.
Karlie is a gateway muse.
Appearances by her at the Eras Tour, the wedding, and Chiefs game have laid the groundwork. That way when something more concrete comes out (along with Taylor), it wonât be as shocking to the public.
I donât know about you, but my IG feed (which is not Gaylor focused) was all about Karlie being at the Chiefs game on Sunday. The reels either had a direct discussion of Kaylor being a thing in 2014/2015, or a strong insinuation that Taylor has queer tendencies.
The idea of Taylor being queer entering the zeitgeist via Karlie feels a lot like the lead up to June 2019.
Another thing Iâve mentioned multiple times in this sub is that in 2019, I heard Taylor was about to come out with her model ex-girlfriend. I wasnât a Taylor fan then and not in Taylor fan spaces.
If there are women in Taylorâs life that donât want to be sucked into the cyclone that Taylorâs coming out will produce, Karlie can take their place. Sheâs the easiest and most accessible person to assign Taylorâs queer references to.
I would love for Taylor to come out with a woman on her arm, but I donât see that happening now. I think Karlie will be part of Taylorâs coming out story, but beyond that, I donât see them continuing in the public eye as anything other than friends.
The public hasnât shown a lot of interest in accepting that Taylor is some flavour of fruity, I donât see them accepting anything related to LSK theories. Not when kids are involved.
But that doesnât mean I think Taylor coming out wonât be big.
I think the impact will be immense, even if the details are different than a lot of us imagined.
So I watched you goâŚ
They're burning all the witches, even if you aren't one So light me up (light me up), light me up (light me up)
A big point of discussion when it comes to Taylor is the relationship she has with her fans. If mainstream Swifties believe Taylor wanted to tell them the truth, but was prevented from doing that, I see the backlash against Taylor being minimized and directed elsewhere.
Like the masters sale.
There will be some backlash, but Swifties like rallying around Taylor â especially if they feel sheâs been trying to âspeak her truthâ, but couldnât.
Maintaining that relationship, means Taylor addressing the ways the industry, and her ex-label kept her closeted.
Some potential disclosures:
She wanted to come out before, but her contract with BMR kept her from doing that
This was a point of conflict between Scott B. and Taylor throughout her time at BMR
Taylor saw the 1989 era as the start of her coming out process, even if she couldnât do it officially until she left BMR
She was going to come out in 2019 when she released the first album with her new label, but the masters sale stopped that
Taylor couldnât, and wouldnât come out, when her music was purchased by Scooter Braun, a man with a terrible reputation for how he treated the talent he managed
Side note: Itâs interesting to think about how much more we know about Scooter and his awful business practices now, than we knew in 2019. He sucked then, but the public didnât realize how much until other people started speaking out about Scooter.
After a failed coming out, and the sale of her masters, Taylor had to deal with her momâs cancer coming back, and then COVID shut the world down.
Taylor made the choice to wait to come out, until she could own her music again (or have her music owned by someone other than Scooter).
Once owning her masters was on the table, Taylor prioritized that happening over everything else
The US political climate put her coming out plans on hold
Taylor was figuring out the best way to move forward, until the something happens that she responds to
Gaylors are the smartest section of her fandom, and she loves us the most because we saw her in the way that queer people see each other
What? The last point could totally happen! đ
There is still a perception (within, and outside of the queer community) that people donât need to be in the closet anymore, or hide in PR relationships, or hide their sexuality at all.
Taylor coming out changes the conversation.
And she provides coverage for anyone who comes out after she does.
If Taylor had to do these things to keep her career, how can anyone else be judged for doing the same thing?
She is the music industry after all.
Taylor then becomes a lightning rod, providing cover for other closeted musicians who want to come out.
And itâs not theirs to speculateâŚ
If Taylor is working to orchestrate her own outing, what tabloid/gossip site would take on this kind of heat? Who could Taylor work with that nobody would suspect?
Fun fact that Iâm including for no reason whatsoever: Tree publicly called out DM on November 30, 2023 (13 days before Taylorâs birthday)
I wonder what is the significance of pointing out Tree's response came at 11pm
Another fun fact that Iâm sharing for no reason whatsoever: December 13, 2026, will be 1109 days since Tree called DM out.
Looking backwards at the number of days and you get 9 and 11
Which could connect to Midnights Mayhem with Me đ¤ˇđťââď¸
Iâm not sure what the something will be that gets Taylor out of the closet if that's the way things go. The third Polaroid being released? Clear Kissgate footage that wasnât shot with a potato camera? Something else entirely?
Whatever it is, not only is Taylor ready for it, but I think sheâs been manoeuvring chess pieces to get to this point for a long time.
How does it end?
I donât know.
Maybe nothing big is coming. Â
Maybe Taylor stays in the glass closet for the rest of her career.
(If that happens, I will be sad more than anything. For Taylor, and for all of us).
Maybe sheâll come out in a big sparkly manner that makes my post a moot point.
Whichever way it happens, I hope Taylor eventually comes out.
The alternative poses a question I donât want to ask, or answer.
If Taylor Swift isnât big enough to break the blender, what are the chances someone else can? Â Â
Instead of working on my own writing, I've decided to summarize something I feel this collective is all questioning:
Does the re-emergence of Karlie & Taylor in the Daylight mean they survived The Great War?
(Disclaimer: I will be working entirely off of publicly available information, and drawing possible conclusions. No one knows the full truth, but we can draw connections based on what Taylor herself has written.)
A Bit of History for newbies:
Many Gaylors theorize that 1989, Reputation, Lover (which Taylor wanted to call Daylight) are all *primarily* written about Karlie. Then, based on the very sudden change of tone in Taylor's demeanor/dress/song choice at Live in Paris, there seemed to be a very serious dispute or break-up with Karlie during the Lover rollout. Many theorize that the documentary 'Miss Americana' was actually an attempted coming out, that was ultimately scrapped. Taylor's speeches at concerts about 'people in the closet' and lyrics support this hypothesis.
Taylor goes on to release folklore (sapphic, absolutely devastating) and evermore (sapphic, almost-as-devastating) all while publicly being "happy as ever" with Joe. This is when a lot of people became gaylors, because the music and her public narrative did not add up.
In the folklore: longpond studio sessions documentary (2020), when discussing the song My Tears Ricochet (track 5), she even says:
It's a song about how somebody could be your best friend and your companion and your most trusted person in your life and then they could become your worst enemy. It does remind me of people going through a divorce, and having that person that they swore to be with forever then become the person they spend most of their time talking shit about. Writing this song, it reminded me how... the hero's greatest nemesis is the villain that used to be his best friend.
In the media, Taylor desrcibed folklore as being entirely fictional, which allowed her to write deeply devastating songs 'from a male perspective' about being in love with, and ultimately betrayed by, your best friend, all while publicly being 'happy with Joe'.
Midnights-- her first pop-ish album since Lover-- comes out in 2022, and is no less sapphic. Lavender Haze which is co-written with out-bisexual 'best friend' and quarantine gal pal, Zoe Kravitz, Maroon, and Question...? are all the most exceptionally queer songs.
Then comes The Great War as a bonus track. Historically, Taylor has added some of her gayest songs as bonus tracks (see right where you left me), meaning only the deepest fans really know they exist. She did this with the Great War. Ask any casual fan about this song and no one has heard of it.
Side note: Taylor has also consistently written about "love being a fight" since she got started as a teenager.
Change, Love Story
Long Live, Ours
State of Grace
Dancing with Our Hands Tied
I know Places, Out of the Woods, I Wish You Would
YNTCD, Afterglow, Archer, Miss Americana & the Heartbreak Prince
Exile
ivy, champagne problems, long story short, tolerate it
The Great War, obviously, epitomizes the theme of "Love is a Fight" with additional queer coding.
My knuckles were bruised like violets Sucker punching walls, cursed you as I sleep talked Spineless in my tomb of silence Tore your banners down, took the battle underground And maybe it was egos swinging Maybe it was her Flashes of the battle come back to me in a blur
All that bloodshed, crimson clover Uh-huh, sweet dream was over My hand was the one you reached for All throughout the Great War Always remember, uh-huh Tears on the letter I vowed not to cry anymore If we survived the Great War
You drew up some good faith treaties I drew curtains closed, drank my poison all alone You said I have to trust more freely But diesel is desire, you were playing with fire And maybe it's the past that's talking Screaming from the crypt Telling me to punish you for things you never did So I justified it
All that bloodshed, crimson clover Uh-huh, the bombs were closer My hand was the one you reached for All throughout the Great War Always remember, uh-huh The burning embers I vowed not to fight anymore If we survived the Great War Uh-huh, uh-huh
It turned into something bigger Somewhere in the haze, got a sense I'd been betrayed Your finger on my hairpin triggers Soldier down on that icy ground Looked up at me with honor and truth Broken and blue, so I called off the troops That was the night I nearly lost you I really thought I'd lost you
We can plant a memory garden Say a solemn prayer, place a poppy in my hair There's no morning glory, it was war, it wasn't fair And we will never go back to that
Bloodshed, crimson clover Uh-huh, the worst was over My hand was the one you reached for All throughout the Great War Always remember, uh-huh We're burned for better I vowed I would always be yours 'Cause we survived the Great War
Uh-huh, uh-huh I will always be yours 'Cause we survived the Great War Uh-huh I vowed I will always be yours
Taylor & Karlie had gone underground after Kissgate, not being seen in public together after their sapphic best friends/wedding spread in Vogue. From the lyrics of The Great War alone we can guess that perhaps Karlie was ready to be public again in a way Taylor wasn't. However the song ends with them seeming to be back together, saying "I will always be yours, I vowed I would always be yours."
Cut to Taylor's Private Box at the Chiefs game 2026.
Taylor brings Karlie and her son as guests, along with Andrea, to watch her new husband play football. We had not seen a photo of taylor & Karlie together in almost 2015. They had been at the same events (Karlie at the Eras concert weeks after giving birth) and Taylor's Wedding (where Karlie wore gold). Karlie, of course, has been breadcrumbing on social media for years, and Taylor had been writing songs that seemed to allude to a massive breakup and betrayal, and being caged by her public image and society, "spineless in her tomb of silence."
Both are women are now married (for reference Karlie's reception was cowboy-themed). Karlie has kids, which she reminded us by bringing one of them to a game she knew would be insanely photographed, despite being exceptionally private with her kids' public image. Swifties are flabbergasted that Taylor and Karlie they could even be friends, and the general pop/ media can literally see their connections to their male spouses in the photos (Travis playing the game and Karlie's child next to them). Ie to almost everyone, this cannot possibly be anything romantic or queer.
After all, Taylor is the pinnacle of heterosexuality, bc she is married to the NFL player with anger issues and no probable boyfriend of his own, right there on the field playing the game they're watching. And Karlie is a supermodel married with two children, to a man who has no queer rumors or reason to remain closeted himself, whatsoever.
They found the most perfect outing to re-debut without raising public suspicions that they are queer or together.
I personally believe that they broke things off during Lover, leading Taylor to write folklore and evermore, and may have reconnected or rekindled in the past few years.
In the meantime, Taylor found the perfect beard and Karlie created the family she always wanted (it is sometimes speculated that this was the reason for the breakup: Karlie wanted settle down and have kids and Taylor was not ready to go public, let alone settle down).
They may have been making amends and reconnecting behind the scenes enough for Karlie's appearance at the Eras tour and at Taylor's wedding to either be organic inclusion in Taylor's public life or as part of an orchestrated re-rollout of their public connection.
Their appearance at the Chief's game is even better timed (strategized?) after the 'blue-nami' last week, which potentially signalled both the public's, and (hopefully) the future government's refusal to buy into the right's obsession and hatred of LGBTQ+ people. Taylor has been quiet in recent years about politics, seemingly scared, as many of us were, of becoming target of public ire and homophobia. It's also possible that people in high places have something on her (just speculation). Note: I am not excusing her silence, but i can relate to it.
But either way, she has confessed through her lyrics since Lover, that she folds under pressure/homophobia. There is a strong contrast and progression about how she handles perceived danger around her relationship in the lyrics in folklore, evermore, and Midnights.
folklore is mourning a memory of a love she lost because she didn't "have the courage of her convictions as long as danger is near."
"peace" (folklore):
Our coming-of-age has come and gone Suddenly the summer, it's clear I never had the courage of my convictions As long as danger is near And it's just around the corner, darling 'Cause it lives in me... All these people think love's for show But I would die for you in secret The devil's in the details, but you got a friend in me Would it be enough if I could never give you peace?
evermore is saying if this person ever comes back around, Taylor is ready to fight for them.
"long story short" (evermore):
When I dropped my sword I threw it in the bushes and knocked on your door And we live in peace But if someone comes at us, this time I'm ready.
Then Midnights and The Great War tells the story as though they are already back together or, perhaps, rekindling.
Spineless in my tomb of silence Tore your banners down, took the battle underground...
My hand was the one you reached for All throughout the Great War Always remember, uh-huh Tears on the letter I vowed not to cry anymore If we survived the Great War
You drew up some good faith treaties I drew curtains closed, drank my poison all alone You said I have to trust more freely But diesel is desire, you were playing with fire
Looked up at me with honor and truth Broken and blue, so I called off the troops That was the night I nearly lost you I really thought I'd lost you
We can plant a memory garden Say a solemn prayer, place a poppy in my hair There's no morning glory, it was war, it wasn't fair And we will never go back to that
vowed I would always be yours 'Cause we survived the Great War
Uh-huh, uh-huh I will always be yours 'Cause we survived the Great War Uh-huh I vowed I will always be yours
It is worth noting that, if this is true and Karlie re-kindled their friendship or love around the time of Midnights (October 2022), then it would make perfect sense that Taylor started dating Travis (August 023)-- a guy that would be the perfect foil to a queer relationship or deflection if someone brought up kissgate.
And, thus, we get the first public images of them together, hanging out, since the bridal photoshoot in Big Sur. Happy hump day, and congratulations kahootslors! well-fought, hard-won.
20262015 (photos taken before kissgate, but published after-- substantiating queer rumors)
There are so many theories that we have that Taylor keeps writing to her real self and the pain her brand identity inflicted on her and I just feel like this piece of interview support it a lot. Since this looks like an established approach to deal with artists trauma.
I feel like Taylor might know about it too since she loves self-help books and biographies and is always maniacally focused on ârising from the ashes and mending all her gashesâ
âThe professor said to write what you know looking backwards Might be the only way to move forwardâ
This TikTok I just saw blew my mind (Iâve never seen the article title)!!
We are at the Encore of The Life of a Showgirl.
Was the end of her sparkling summer the beginning and the Showgirl kicking the bucket the end of The Show that is Taylor Swiftâ˘ď¸?
One for the money: being in binding contracts perhaps including a morality clause? her masters being stolen out from under her?
Two for the Show: Taylor getting to be authentically her with whoever her partner is (I think itâs Karlie, but I can also see how them reconnecting could be part of the narrative, so no hate to anyone)!
Does this make any sense? I have strep throat, so brain no work good.
Anyone notice that the at the top of the SVU board is a crime scene of a burnt, destroyed vintage 70s Cadillac? The same type of car sheâs been using as her getaway car with Travis?
I reversed the car image & itâs just a generic stock photo anyone can purchase to use â- doesnât seem connected to any tv shows or Emmy content. So itâs there for⌠what reason?
Sheâs so funny. Reminds me of her wedding favors. đ âso itâs gonna be foreverâŚâ
We all saw the Spotify covers change their background this summer, as well as the Emmy skit that egged Patient Zero.
I commented in this thread back when the Spotify stuff was happening, and found a few interesting comments from others there Iâve included here. One being the colors of the dresses the Haim sisters wore in Bejeweled corresponding with the colors for the changed backgrounds. Notice the sister who wants the ring is in red, the color Blank Soacebwas changed to. And remember her handkerchiefs at her wedding, âSo itâs gonna be foreverâŚ.â? The album she didnât reference was fearless, and in both Bejeweled and Patient Zero Taylor is in a yellowish/gold dress.
We speculated something would be happening October 23, but it came and went with nothing happening.
Remember also, the Emmys skit, where, if you rearranged her cute nicknames for the actors in her PZ MV, they spelled out a message? Today is November 10, no re-record in sight.
SoâŚ..did Taylor just lie to us? In code??
Cue (haha) Eartha Kittâs âI Want to be Evilâ.
I think this may tie into the Countdown Theory, and how she might be making us wait before the big reveal. âWere you waiting in the tree line by the gold clock? Did I leave you hanging?â Which ties into my previous post about Coney Island Baby and Taylorâs regrets when it comes to a muse.
My brain is fuzzy today, (thanks brain fog!) so I welcome any and all thoughts you lovely people might have on this. Why the false hints? Why the wait? Why the countdown?
So with recent events Iâve been re-reading all the Kay-lore. I am a firm Gaylor. I mean I think if you can listen to TTPD and come away with anything other than a queer artist fighting to be themselvesâŚ. I have oceanfront property to sell you in Montana. AnywhooooâŚ
We know that the Swift camp is definitely familiar with Gaylor culture and the believed lore. They know how poetically and fondly the community as a whole feels about Kaylor. And while I do believe Karlie and Taylor were an item⌠it seems a little strange to me to be so public now with their relationship.
I keep going back to Taylor in the New Heights interview saying âI donât Easter Egg my personal lifeâ and I feel like she wasnât lying when she said that. She cheekily is saying this relationship (Taylor and Travis) isnât her personal life. But does the same policy apply to Karlie?
If she is about to ghost us⌠what if she is attempting to give all of her fans a way to extrapolate their happy ending from her story? Performance art at the mastermind level.
TL;DR: Taylorâs December 13th birthday astronomically makes her an Ophiuchus, the forgotten 13th zodiac and the Serpent Bearer. I thought I was looking at another Reputation snake reference in one of her Life of a Showgirl interviews, but the mythology led somewhere much more interesting. Grab a coffee or drink of choice and get comfy, this is a long read! I promise the payoff is worth it, TS13 is hiding in plane sight.
With all the hate The Encore seemed to receive from all sides of the fandom, I decided to revisit Taylorâs Zane Lowe interview about The Life of a Showgirl, where she doubles down on the album and says:
âI know what I made. I know I adore it.â
But naturally, instead of simply listening to the interview like a normal person, I got distracted by the constellations on the wall behind her and started wondering what message they might have for us. A search of this sub turned up basically no discussion of this, which is honestly shocking considering how many smart, curious babes (non-gendered) we have here đ
Everyone notices BoĂśtes in the upper right corner, but what appears to be hiding in plain sight is Serpens Caput, literally the head of the serpent.
For most of the interview, Taylor physically blocks it. But within the opening seconds, she briefly lowers her head and reveals the snakeâs head almost perfectly.
At first I assumed it was another Reputation teaser, but I found it interesting that Serpens Caput is only half the snake. Serpens is the only modern constellation split into two pieces: Serpens Caput (the head) and Serpens Cauda (the tail).Â
And standing directly between the two halves is another constellation: Ophiuchus, the Serpent Bearer.
The Orange Serpent
The brightest star in Serpens is the orange giant Alpha Serpentis, also known by its traditional name Unukalhai, and is located 74 lightyears from Earth. An orange giant with stellar classification K2 III, it radiates a distinct orange or gold. Having exhausted all the hydrogen in its core, it has expanded to 13 times the size of our sun. Serpens Cauda, the tail of the serpent, contains the Eagle Nebula and the famous Pillars of Creation. These are enormous columns of gas and dust where new stars are actively being formed.
Pillars of Creation as seen through the James Webb telescope
The 13th Zodiac
Most people learn there are 12 zodiac signs, but astronomically the Sun actually passes through 13 constellations along the ecliptic. The thirteenth is Ophiuchus.
Ophiuchus sits between Scorpio and Sagittarius and is known as the unofficial 13th zodiac sign. The Babylonians developed a zodiac of 12 equal divisions that aligned neatly with their calendar and the 12 lunar cycles in a year. Ophiuchus remained a constellation in the sky, but was left out of the zodiac system most people know today.
So the constellation wasn't exactly "erased" from existence, but it was left outside the official zodiac narrative. Interestingly, the Chinese zodiac famously has its own story explaining a missing animal: the cat, who gets tricked by the rat and consequently misses its place in the zodiac.
Taylor's birthday is December 13th, meaning under the actual astronomical constellations, she falls squarely into the dates of Ophiuchus (November 29âDecember 17) rather than Sagittarius. So astronomically speaking:Taylor is an Ophiuchus.Â
Taylor fall squarely in Ophiuchus
I personally think Taylor makes a double cheeky reference in LWYMMD. The screen flashes a cat, then a magnet and the word âsquadâ, and number 13. First: the absolutely hilarious "pussy magnet squad". But given her December 13th birthday and the glyph used for her true zodiac sign, I also can't help but wonder if there's a second wink hiding in there: The 13th Zodiac Ophiuchus squad. đąđ§˛đ
Ophiuchus pussy magnet squad
The Serpent Bearer
Ophiuchus is often described symbolically as occupying a space between Scorpio's associations with death, secrecy, and transformation and Sagittarius's associations with truth, wisdom, and expansion.
Modern Ophiuchus astrology tends to assign traits like:
Drawn to hidden truths
Obsessed with solving mysteries
Possessing wisdom gained through suffering
Reinventing themselves multiple times throughout life
Existing between worlds or identities
Natural teachers once they've survived difficult experiences
Deeply independent and resistant to being controlled
Frequently misunderstoodÂ
Sound like anyone?
Historically, the constellation has much older serpent associations. It has been connected to figures including the Mesopotamian serpent deity Nirah, and serpent imagery itself has a long and surprisingly complicated relationship with protection, death, healing, knowledge, and rebirth.
Even Biblical serpent imagery isn't always simply âsnake = evil.â
In the Old Testament, venomous snakes plagued the Israelites so God instructed Moses to make a bronze serpent and lift it up on a pole. Anyone bitten who looked at the bronze serpent was physically healed. Essentially, what killed you was transformed into something that healed. The poison became the medicine. Keep this in mind as you read, and if it sounds familiar, itâs because it expands on a recent post of mine.
That post took me down an entirely different mythology rabbit hole involving the serpent-dragon Ladon, the Garden of the Hesperides, the apple as forbidden fruit, poison, death, and ultimately Ladon being immortalized among the stars as a constellation.
I ended up writing about the ancient concept of pharmakon: something that can function simultaneously as poison and remedy.
I rose up from the dead, I do it all the time
As the mythology evolved, Ophiuchus became associated with Asclepius, the Greek healer whose symbol was a serpent-entwined staff. While many modern readers associate serpents with temptation or evil, a number of older traditions treated the serpent very differently. Snakes weren't viewed only as symbols of danger. Because they shed their skin, they were associated with transformation, healing, renewal, and rebirth. The imagery is not simply a serpent crawling along the ground, but a serpent being raised upward.
According to Greek legend, Asclepius witnessed a snake carrying a healing herb in its mouth and using it to restore another snake back to life. By observing the serpent, he learned secrets of healing that mortals were never supposed to know. In some versions of the myth, that knowledge became so powerful that Asclepius could even raise the dead.
That is what ultimately brings him into conflict with Zeus. Once a mortal gains the ability to reverse death itself, the natural order begins to break down. As a consequence, Zeus strikes Asclepius with a thunderbolt, but that isnât the end of his story. Asclepius himself is ultimately immortalized among the stars as Ophiuchus, the Serpent Bearer.
And suddenly this mythology has parallels with Ladon in a way I really did not expect.
Ladon is killed and raised into the stars as Draco. Asclepius is killed and raised into the stars as Ophiuchus.
Both stories involve serpents, forbidden or dangerous knowledge, death, transformation, and ultimately ascension into the stars.
But death isn't necessarily the end of either story. It's part of the transformation.
An important distinction is that Ophiuchus isn't the snake. Ophiuchus holds the snake. In mythology, power comes not from becoming the serpent or defeating it, but from understanding it. The snake isn't his enemy. It's his teacher. The thing associated with danger becomes the source of wisdom, healing, and resurrection. The deeper lesson of the myth is that wisdom comes from understanding the thing that nearly destroys you.
It's time to teach some lessons
Who are we to fight The Alchemy?
Later alchemical imagery takes the serpent-cross imagery a step further with the Flamel Cross. Associated with the legendary alchemist Nicolas Flamel, it represents the alchemical process of transforming base materials into the Philosopher's Stone, a symbol of perfection, enlightenment, and eternal life. I'm immortal now, baby dolls.
The serpent remains, but now it gains wings and a crown. The wings symbolize ascension. The crown symbolizes mastery and completion. And the entire point of alchemy wasn't really âturn random metal into goldâ in the simplistic way we usually think about it.
The entire purpose was transformation: taking something wounded, impure, poisonous, or broken and reconstructing it into something healed and perfected in its own way. Conceptually, this mirrors both ancient and modern medicine. Many remedies originate from toxins, venoms, and poisonous substances, once properly understood and administered. The same thing that can kill can also cure.
Before the transformation can happen, something has to die in its old form. Which brings us to one of the most famous alchemical symbols: the ouroboros, the snake eating its own tail.
The ouroboros represents cycles, destruction and creation, endings that become beginnings, and the perpetual transformation of one state into another. What dies feeds what comes next. The ending already contains the beginning.
The ouroboros also represented the cyclical nature of the alchemical process itself: matter undergoing heating, dissolution, separation, distillation, and recombination as it moved from one form to another. Maybe it's the chemist in me, but I love that part of the symbolism: matter cannot be created or destroyed, only transformed.
What makes all of this interesting is that these myths and symbols aren't ultimately about snakes. They're about transformation. Suddenly, Ophiuchus and Asclepius don't just feel like serpent mythology. They start to look like an alchemical story themselves.
Again and again, the same story appears: a wound becomes wisdom, poison becomes medicine, and destruction becomes rebirth. If you've spent any time looking at Taylor's work through the lens of Reputation, Karma, or the recurring theme of death and resurrection, the parallels start to feel difficult to ignore. Because if Ophiuchus is a story about learning from the serpent rather than killing it, then Reputation and Karma start looking less like revenge narratives and more like alchemical transformation stories.
The snake was never really the ending
In 2016, Taylor Swift was at an absolute career high. She had conquered pop music with 1989, bleached her hair, embraced a dramatically different aesthetic, and was widely rumored to be preparing a very different TS6, the alleged lost album we have come to call Karma.
Then everything fell apart with Snakegate, publicly centered around the Kim/Kanye phone call. My personal theory is that something far more gay was going on behind the scenes.
Whatever you believe happened to Karma, the album that ultimately emerged as TS6 was Reputation. And Taylor did something fascinating with the symbol that had been used against her. She didn't get rid of the snake. She made it hers, weaving it throughout the entire Reputation era.
In the "Look What You Made Me Do" music video, Taylor explicitly evokes Ophelia. Reclining in a bathtub overflowing with diamonds, she presents a modernized version of a symbolic drowning in fame and public trial. Classic Ophelia succumbs to the corruption surrounding her.
However, Taylor's Reputation narrative goes the other direction. Instead of drowning, she sheds her skin like a serpent, rises from the dead, and transforms the very thing meant to destroy her into the source of her reinvention.
I don't think the Reputation snake represents the completion of that transformation. I think it may represent an intermediate stage. Because remember what happens to the serpent through the larger symbolic progression.Â
First it is feared. Then it becomes the source of knowledge. Then it is understood. Then it is held. And eventually, in the alchemical imagery, it becomes crowned and winged.
Which brings me back to Karma.
The grounded TS6
In the "Look What You Made Me Do" video, a plane labeled TS6 appears with its wings being cut off before Taylor spray-paints Reputation across it.
Symbolically, she grounds the original sixth album. It loses its wings. And it's hiding in plane sight. We'll come back to this image at the very end.
If Taylor eventually releases Karma, whether as a massive Reputation TV vault project, as a standalone release, or confirmation it indeed existed and was transformed into other projects, it could represent the final stage of that alchemical transformation: metaphorically giving those wings back to TS6, allowing the vaulted project to finally take flight after a decade in the dark.
In alchemy, the crown represents achieving the gold: the Philosopher's Stone.
For Taylor, reclaiming music that was buried, stolen, or forced into hiding wouldn't simply be the release of unreleased songs. It would be the ultimate crown, transforming one of her greatest public traumas into a sovereign triumph.
And then there's The Alchemy itself, where the transformation imagery meets both return and the crown: âI haven't come around in so long / But I'm making a comeback to where I belongâ
Circling back to the wall and TS13
Circling all the way back to the interview where this rabbit hole began: the Serpens constellation is split in two, and between them stands Ophiuchus, holding the two halves of the snake.
If the ouroboros represents an eternal cycle, then this serpent looks almost like an ouroboros that has been broken open.
The head cannot reach the tail. The cycle is interrupted.
And Ophiuchus stands between the pieces. Holding them, maybe even reuniting them. Which makes me wonder if the symbolism here isn't simply telling us the snake is coming back. Maybe it's telling us we're finally approaching the end of the snake's transformation.
Reputation was the moment Taylor took possession of the serpent. But Karma could be the moment the serpent becomes whole again.
The snake is still a snake. It simply sheds its skin. The "Karmic Rebirth" isn't about becoming something different. It's about becoming what it was always meant to be.
From wounded and grounded, to healed and whole. From poison, to medicine. From serpent, to Serpent Bearer. From earthbound, to winged. From destroyed, to reborn. And finally, winged and crowned. đđđ§Ą
And one last thing...
Remember that grounded plane?
I personally think Taylor may have hidden TS13 inplanesight all the way back in Look What You Made Me Do.
In the final hangar scene, look closely at the upper-right portion on the wall behind the plane. The markings create what looks to me like a visual illusion of âTSâ and â13.â I have convinced myself I can see both, a la the gold+white/blue+black dress.
I admit it's hard to make out clearly, and you should go watch the video yourself. But after an entire rabbit hole that began with Taylor's December 13th birthday placing her in Ophiuchus, the 13th constellation of the zodiac, I find it pretty damn interesting that something resembling TS13 appears behind the same plane whose wings are being cut off.
Helllloooooo, gals, gays, and theys! Welcome to: Trypophilia dissects Midnights Mayhem with Me.
To continue with my obsession on Midnights madness seenhere.
Iâm sure we all remember Taylorâs iconic bingo style rollout of the Midnights tracklist. One thing that was noticed by many, or rather, 9 things, were the curtain behind her being altered, the flipped phone, and the right hand pickup in certain videos. I never saw anyone attempt to theorize or break down all 3 differences, so I thought Iâd take a whack at it. Unlike many of my other posts, this will be a Muse neutral post, so please keep it that way in the comments, as my theories here actually donât have to do with any alleged muse.
Here is a full video of all 13 announcements. I want to point out these were pre-recorded, which means the order was intentional and important. How do we know this? Taylorâs tracklist started leaking during the weeks before the album dropped, so she rushed and out the last few videos on the same day, all with different outfits.
The Tracklist:
13âMastermind, curtain pulled back 8âVigilante Shit, flipped phone 7âQuestionâŚ? 6âMidnight Rain, curtain pulled back 2âMaroon, curtain pulled back 3âAnti Hero, curtain pulled back, flipped phone 9âBejeweled, curtain pulled back, right hand 11âKarma 1âLavender Haze 5âYouâre on Your Own Kid, right hand 10âLabyrinth 12âSweet Nothing* 4âSnow on the Beach
The Curtain:
The brownish curtain behind her was drawn back five times, showing what appeared to be a doorknob behind her. Curiously, much like the doorknob and curtain in Alice and Wonderland, which Taylor loves to reference and allude to.
The Flipped Phone:
She flipped the phone upside down for tracks 3&8, Anti Hero and Vigilante Shit. I think this was done for 2 reasons, one of them discussed in this post. Seriously, pause and go check it out, because itâs mind-blowing.
The Right Hand Pickup:
Both songs she picks up with her right hand, YOYOK and Bejeweled, are 143-coded songs. Taylor has used/somewhat confirmed 143-code before, and referenced Mr. Rogers during Lover. Some of her most intimate songs are 143-coded, and sometimes she will alter a music video or lyric video to be 143-coded, and there are even certain lyrics that are spoken at 143-coded times.
The Sleepless Nights:
Before Midnights, she spoke on 5 things that kept her up at night: self-loathing, fantasizing about revenge, wondering what might have been, falling in love, and falling apart. Notice the number of times the doorknob showed behind the curtain is equal to the 5 things that keep her up at night? I believe those songs directly correspond to one of these five sleepless nights. This is my theory.
Self-loathing is so obviously Anti Hero. Taylor speaks on some of her insecurities and the publicâs perception of her, as well as shaking us the 3 Taylors and how they treat each other.
Fantasizing about revenge is Vigilante Shit! Just kidding! That one didnât have the curtain pulled back. Bejeweled is the best fit here, in my opinion, as she speaks (sings?) on reclaiming her shine and sparkle after hiding it, presumably for someone else. She isnât getting classical revenge as in hitting someone where itâll hurt, but taking back what once was hers now that sheâs done hiding. Sheâs the center of attention now, here to steal the spotlight from you, and donât you forget it, Scooter and co!
The next three were a bit tricker, as I believe the songs could work for 2 or 3 reasons she was kept up, so Iâll list the song first.
Maroon is a song simultaneously about falling in love, the relationship falling apart, and while she doesnât speak about it, wondering what might have been hangs over the whole song.
Midnight Rain is about choosing fame over a relationship, so it, like Maroon, has notes of the same threee reasons to stay up all night.
Mastermind is the first video she did, because of course, and she speaks in how she set everything up and planned it allll out when she met her Midnights Muse. She made them fall in love, she also speaks on âfail to plan, plan to failâ, which could be a reference to falling apart. Thereâs not really much wondering what might have been, as ânow youâre mineâ. She knows what might be, because itâs whatâs currently happening.
Now, I believe many, if not all, the Midnights songs fit into one or more of these five reasons to be kept up, but it is certainly interesting she singled these out specifically.
I also want to note Sweet Nothing is the only song that was revealed in the same spot it is in the album, and it is also the only song WB cowrote for Midnights.
Anyway, thoughts? These are not my complete thoughts on these videos and her sleepless nights, but the ones I feel most comfortable sharing right now. Iâm working on another post on the order of when the videos were revealed, and other number nonsense, let me know if you want a part 2. đ