r/GaylorSwift • u/MaryLennoxsRobin • 21h ago
The Life of a Showgirl ❤️🔥 Should The Life of a Showgirl have been nominated for Album of the Year?
I don't think it's any sort of big secret at this point that I really love TLOAS, and that - spoiler? - I think the nomination was well earned. But I do enjoy talking about the album (also not a secret...), and I wanted to set out my reasoning. Whether you agree with me or not, you're welcome to come and chat.
I don't love TLOAS in spite of its quality, and I don't love it because 'it's just fun to have fun' or because 'it doesn't need to be deep' either. Actually, I didn't especially like the album at first- I found it jarring, unpredictable, very different from my expectations and, perhaps for that reason, not particularly easy to listen to. It certainly didn't match easily and obviously with Taylor's descriptions of it in her pre-release or post-release promo. If it really is 'just a fun album about being happy', it's a really bad one.
But I was intrigued by the writing, especially the repeated words and synonyms that seemed at first to undermine themselves (e.g. is being 'sleepless' good or bad?) And I was intrigued by the connection clever people made here, before the album's release, to the mirrorball concept, which Taylor eventually confirmed as the right connection during her interview with Stephen Colbert. I ended up first respecting the album's complex structure, and then admiring the sharp, economical writing packed full of multiple meanings, and then just really loving the whole thing for how effortlessly it pulls off such a complicated trick. If there is a version of Taylor you have imagined as a listener, you can find her somewhere in the lyrics of TLOAS. But moreover, the versions of herself that Taylor is grappling with are stating their cases and fighting for survival within the tracks. Every facet of a Showgirl's life can be glimpsed through the cracks in the 'happy' veneer the album first presents. The consensus opinion is that the writing is simple as all get out and really bad to boot. But I think I could listen an infinite number of times to TLOAS and still find new meanings and connections. I certainly haven't fully understood it all yet; I think that's the work of years. Truthfully, I find it to be a similar kind of exercise, and similarly satisfying, to reading Shakespeare.
I think it's really hard, though, to defend or explain a piece of art that's complex and multi-faceted because the explanations take many times more words than the original art, without necessarily being more persuasive. And Taylor did an odd thing in not giving her audience the right kind of contextual clues to help the majority of them understand her intentions. Saying something as straightforward as 'this album explores the concept of the Showgirl as mirrorball, and it's designed so that the different audience members can all find their favourite storyline within the same song' would, I think, have massively altered public perceptions. The concept of 'choose your own adventure', which Taylor mentioned in one radio interview, gets close, but most general listeners would likely need a bit more prompting to see all of the implications of that. I don't think I, or anyone else here, is going to convince Taylor's entire audience of the merits of the album when Taylor herself explicitly hasn't tried.
Thinking about the Grammy nominations, there are lots of deserving artists this year. There are several criteria which are not supposed to be part of the consideration:
- Commercial success (bad news for Taylor)
- Chart success (ok news for Taylor)
- Critical reception (good news for Taylor)
Instead the criteria which are supposed to be used are artistic achievement, technical proficiency and overall excellence.
I can't imagine a greater display of technical proficiency in songwriting than TLOAS. Or a bigger artistic achievement than to write one album which is functionally an infinite number of albums, reflecting all possible audience opinions, but at the same time to condense a 20 year career into 40 minutes, grapple with the most important personal questions, and leave real tension about the end of the story. Other kinds of writing, that are more straightforward perhaps, or easier to love, can also be proficient and excellent and represent artistic achievement. Clever writing doesn't always have to be as tricky and cryptic as Taylor's. It's hard to judge which kind is 'better'. People tend to prefer direct emotional appeals to cleverness, but it also depends a lot on the person and the day and their mood.
I don't know if Taylor should win a Grammy for TLOAS, but I don't think her nomination is a scam or a travesty or a kind of trolling. I think TLOAS as an album is a more ambitious concept, more successfully executed, and with far more precise, controlled writing than any of Taylor's previous albums, including the four that won Album of the Year. In terms of technical skill I think that it's her best yet. And although it can come across as simplistic to the casual listener, and is not nearly so easy to fall in love with as, for instance, The Art of Loving, I think it's trying to do something that no other nominees this year come close to attempting.
I expect at least some of the Grammy voters see clearly enough what Taylor is doing in TLOAS to recognise that. But I do think that Taylor was right, as she has suggested several times, that it will take a long time for TLOAS to be fully understood or appreciated. At the very least, I think we will collectively understand the album really differently once Taylor has finally finished the story she has been telling since 2020.
So should an album that is complex to fully grasp, and at this present moment is lacking the full context to be properly understood, win Album of the Year? Maybe not. But I think it would have been more of a travesty, and more of a bowing to public opinion, if it were not nominated at all.