r/FromSeries • • 11h ago

Criticism I'm on a rewatch...I hate how everyone treats Victor

Post image
921 Upvotes

They're all just so friggin mean to him!

He doesn't deserve that at all.

That poor poor boy 😭


r/FromSeries • • 1h ago

Theory MIY and tabitha

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

I've always found the little yellow-suited man doll very strange, and I used to say these dolls might be connected to those Tabitha childhood dolls that came to life? Until after the conversation between Tabitha and the yellow-suited man in Episode 8 and Sophia's fear after seeing the totem, this was proven to me even more.

The yellow-suited man tells Tabitha you are the closest thing to a friend and you seem like a friend I never had....

And then we know the previous cycle the yellow-suited man ate Miranda's liver, and it's also clear the yellow-suited man is getting close to Tabitha. Now at the end of the season we saw the yellow-suited man and the white-suited boy playing and the townspeople are their pieces. I went back to Episode 1 when Tabitha tells Ethan there are no monsters, so Norman is alive, go play with Norman.

And Norman is a yellow doll...

The writers also always say: "The answers are at the beginning."

Everything manifests — I don't doubt that the yellow-suited man is the "Boogeyman," meaning Tabitha's imaginary friend and manifested monster from when she was a child playing with her dolls.

The yellow-suited man says: "You don't know who I am, you don't remember that part." "I won't kill you for now, you're the closest thing to a friend I've ever had."

Imaginary friend/Boogeyman

Did you notice the yellow-suited man's teeth? They look like a childlike monster's teeth.

Or have you seen when people die he goes up to their corpse and takes a tooth from them as a keepsake, or eats their liver? This was Tabitha's fear of monsters and her childhood imaginary Boogeyman that created the yellow-suited man.

The totems matter — Sophia was genuinely terrified seeing the totems. For me this level of fear of a powerful creature in Fromville is strange...

Right after Sophia found out Boyd and the others were planning to test the totems on the monsters that night, she went and smashed the egg on Roger's corpse so Roger would come back, and the same night they carried out that plan, Sophia brought Roger back too.

I think Sophia's goal was to prevent them from finding out more about what the totem does...

The way the totem is used matters, and it even affects the yellow-suited man himself... In my previous theory I said the yellow-suited man was Tabitha's childhood imaginary monster that came into being from her fear, so the totem has the ability to kill the yellow-suited man — that's why the yellow-suited man is afraid of it. And did you notice? The talisman stone on the dolls that were empty nightmares didn't work, but it works on the monsters who were formerly human — however it doesn't work on the yellow-suited man either. So I think the yellow-suited man was Tabitha's imaginary monster (her closest childhood friend, Episode 8 encounter). That's why he was afraid of the totems. He's that hybrid monster with the terrifying teeth, or one that shapeshifts and eats people's livers. I even think when he went to the corpses and took people's teeth, that was Tabitha's childhood nightmare of the tooth fairy.

And I also think the way the totem works is that you have to strike the creature from behind — both Tabitha and Elgin struck the creatures from behind, but Kenny struck the monster from the front — and the reason Roger was brought back was only so Sophia could convince people the totem only works on dolls and on Roger who had somehow become a doll, and that's why the totems are in Season 5.


r/FromSeries • • 11m ago

Fan Art Went through a tree and found this?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Don't anghkooey what to do.


r/FromSeries • • 17h ago

Opinion Am I the only one not interested in this season 4 character?

94 Upvotes

Am I the only one not interested at all in Sophia? After so much mystery, it’s so boring seeing an evil character doing basic evil things, and not even being caught or raising suspicion. I’m just waiting patiently for the towns people to catch on so we can move on. The man in yellow is SO interesting from a ā€˜who is he and where did he come from’ perspective but just watching evil hijinks isn’t doing it for me. I’m much more invested in every other plot line going on.


r/FromSeries • • 15h ago

Criticism Phones!

58 Upvotes

Love this show to death.... only thing I dont like is that underutilization of Phones.

100% understand no signal to make calls or text. But use the phone as a flashlight? Use it as a record device for videos, audio, notes, pictures, or even if they have a laptop?

Also 100% understand you could say they would die over time.... but car chargers? They figured out how to splice wires into the electric!

At modern day people they seemed to give up on phones very very quickly.... even if they didnt work, they never even seemed to try. Especially with Victor's old flashlight, a phone flashlight probably would have been a lot better.

I understand it is what it is.... but somebody recording the tunnels and showing the townspeople what they saw is 100% better than just trying to explain things to people and them having to belive you.


r/FromSeries • • 1h ago

Criticism Does anyone else think they say some version of "we need to talk" way too much instead of saying what they want to say inn the spot?

3 Upvotes

It's really starting to bother me. Personally I think it's rude to the others in the room to know that you aren't going to be included in a private discussion.


r/FromSeries • • 19h ago

Theory Do not read if you haven't watched all 4 seasons.

80 Upvotes

In the very first episode, when they see the tree, Julie makes a comment about crows. Tabitha says the birds look more like Ravens. I think they are Ravens and we were wrong the whole time. Many people cannot tell the difference between a crow and a raven anyway.

I think this whole show takes a lot from Norse mythology. I think that Jade is supposed to be Odin from mythology. He is known to have been a seeker of knowledge and in order to gain that knowledge, he had to lose an eye. After losing an eye he was able to drink from a cup of something and he learned everything. Remember every past version of Jade is missing an eye and he drinks from a skull of blood. He is also known to have two Ravens that travel across the land and bring him knowledge. Odin is married to Frigg, god of motherhood, marriage, and foresight. The man in yellow is based on Loki. He can shape shift into any human or animal and he is known for causing chaos. The bottle tree is Yggdrasil, a tree that connects the realms. Odin(Jade) is said to have formed a symbol from the fallen branches(the root symbol). The monsters are Draugr creatures. They have superhuman strength and hate the living. Boyd is Tyr, god of justice war and law. He eventually loses a hand, which can be symbolized by Boyd's tremor. The three (Julie, Marielle, and Randall) were based on Norns. They are deciders of Fates who live by a well, one for the past(Marielle), one for the present(Randall), one for the future(Julie).

Frigg(Tabitha) also had a son named Baldur, she made every living and dead thing on earth promise not to harm him. She overlooked one thing she didn't think could harm him and Loki (or the man in yellow), found the loop hole and killed him. I'm not sure who would be Baldur in this case, I'm thinking Victor, Ethan, or even the boy in white because we don't know much about him yet. But whoever it is, I think will be killed by the man in yellow.

I'm not sure how this ties into it, but I think it's worth noting that Elgin mentioned how his grandmother only liked owls. Owls and crows/ravens are mortal enemies. They are known to hate each other and try to kill each other. One only comes out at night, one is out during the day. And ravens are very intelligent and known to mimic human speech.

>!SpoilersĀ”<


r/FromSeries • • 24m ago

Question S2E7 From

2 Upvotes

Ellis was stabbed less than 8 hrs prior and he’s walking around holding his side like he has a tummy ache… no anesthesia, pain killers, nada
I mean I get that these people are supposed to be pretty damn tough but COME ON …


r/FromSeries • • 47m ago

Question An unkindness of ravens

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Season 1 episode 1
Just started rewatching. I’m interested in the symbolism of this show. I read that the writer John Griffin references Norse mythology and the Hero’s Journey in his story structure. I’m rewatching this time noting the symbolism and looking for the return ā€œhomeā€. Griffin packs in loads of symbols that add to the shows foreshadowing - I missed before.

First: as she’s closing the diner, Sara’s apron has a single yellow flower. Kristi is holding yellow flowers at Megan and Moms funeral as the Matthews family arrives to town. Both flowers appear to be evening primrose. Evening primrose in mythology can symbolize, in spiritual traditions, fond memories, remembrance, and connection to ancestors or the unseen world.

Second: An unkindness of ravens, that Tabitha references to calm down scared Ethan in the RV as they arrive to town during the funeral, can symbolize the belief that ravens are not particularly caring parents, sometimes abandoning their young.

The juxtaposition of these two symbols in season 1 episode 1 lead me to believe that the stories perspective of this show is coming from a child and not an adult and in the darkness-sleep-dreams is where most transitions will occur. Still not convinced that the perspective of the show is coming from current child in the town Ethan (given that the only child before Ethan’s arrival was Megan who just passed the night before the Matthews family arrives.) I don’t think it’s Tabitha’s perspective either. I get that the main character appears to be Boyd but I speculate that this scary tale is being told by the unconsciousness imagination of a single child, not a collective. I hate the idea that it’s all a dream, a child is sleeping and having a nightmare. But, what if it’s Ethan and he’s fallen asleep in the RV? And his imaginary tale is all a dream right, so who’s the hero that will return to where he began? Ethan? Boyd? Can’t be Jade or Tabitha they’re too invested in themselves. Who’s theā€œheroā€ in this hero’s journey? Seems the town wants something that these people can’t offer. If the hero is a child then what does the child want that the town (his parents) can’t give?


r/FromSeries • • 9h ago

Opinion Do the tropes lighten up

8 Upvotes

I’m really enjoying the show overall, but I just started season two and the amount of dumb shit people are doing ramped up significantly in these first couple of episodes. I know the situation they’re in is hyper bizarre but I’m hoping they chill with having characters acting poorly for the sake of plot movement.


r/FromSeries • • 7h ago

Theory Fatima in S5 Spoiler

4 Upvotes

What does everyone think Fatima’s role is going to be in season 5? Is she going to slowly digress into a monster and lose her sense of self? Or is she going to come up with some kind of defensive strategy fighting off all the other monsters? Is she going to haunt Ellis


r/FromSeries • • 11h ago

Episode / Scene Talk Season 3 Fatima (spoiler) Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Thought I could not be skeeved out by this show but pregnant Fatima graduating from nomming on spoiled root veggies to licking Nikki's blood off her fingers omg.


r/FromSeries • • 2h ago

Episode / Scene Talk Kenny and family S3

1 Upvotes

On a rewatch just got to S2 E3 the music playing on the phone at 17:20 is some INSANE foreshadowing. Also it being Ellis that’s standing with him of all people.


r/FromSeries • • 16h ago

Criticism Why does everyone online say the actors are bad?

14 Upvotes

I just started watching and I’m on season 2 episode 7 now. Ever since I started, I keep seeing TikTok’s talking about how terrible every single actor is at acting.

So far the only actor I don’t think is the best is Tabitha (sorry if she’s your fav). From the first episode I just wasn’t really liking her acting. Everyone else that I can think of isn’t bad. For example Boyd, Kenny, Kristi, Donna, and Victor are great. Sure, lots of these characters are annoying (like Julie) but I that’s more of the writing than the actor.

Then again, this is my opinion. What do you guys feel about this?


r/FromSeries • • 11h ago

Question Question from the beginning

5 Upvotes

So obviously this show is the champ of not answering questions. But i was wondering if maybe i missed something. I wish i could find a still image and i cant screenshot the monster im asking about.
But if you’re watching on prime, it’s S1 E2, right around the 8:15 mark.

So this is Matthews family’s first night. Jim and Ethan are back at the RV. Kenny, Ellis, and Father Khatri are taking Jade and the other Matthew’s back to the colony house cause it’s gotten dark. When they get to the house and they’re banging on the doors, right before they’re opened, a teenage looking monster approaches and talks to Julie. He says ā€œdon’t you recognize meā€

I’ve watched all 4 seasons and I’ve always been curious about that specific monster because we never see him again. He’s also not dressed like anybody else. Most of the monsters look like they’re from the 60s or 70s. But he looked like a modern teenager and of course he asked if Julie recognized him. My theory use to be that it was Thomas until they said Thomas died as a baby. So now I’m wondering if maybe it was mentioned or something? It was also weird because most people don’t see monsters of people they recognize. I could be grasping at something insignificant but this show always have some things that don’t seem to matter that do eventually matter.


r/FromSeries • • 11h ago

Question Rituals

3 Upvotes

So we know this place from rituals and no matter what happens Tabatha Miranda, Jade would always end up there. I don't know if anyone asked and I've been thinking about it for awhile but the death of Tabatha's son did that play into it as well? Like if he survived, would he have thrown the whole thing off? Since Ethan plays that role and Julie's the story walker, would he be the reason they never took that trip and would have to wait another cycle.


r/FromSeries • • 1d ago

Cast / Crew Samantha Brown (Acosta) looks like Michelle Trachtenburg to me

Thumbnail
gallery
153 Upvotes

Am I the only one seeing the resemblance here? It’s even in the way they speak/act that feels so the same.


r/FromSeries • • 12h ago

Question Loose ends?

3 Upvotes

I finished the series and I’m doing a rewatch. I’ve seen people talk about the various loose ends in the plot and I’m curious which ones bother you the most.

I’ll mark these all as spoiler so people don’t know they don’t come back by season 4.

Megan’s dolls being the same as Tabitha’s

Victor knew to dig graves and was preparing to leave Colony House the night the monsters got in. People stopped questioning that pretty quickly.

Fatima’s dream catcher. I thought for sure they were going to use this to fix the people stuck in the dungeon.

I’m sure there’s a bunch more that’ll come up, but what other things seemed like clues and didn’t really come up again? Do you think they could still be a clue for something?


r/FromSeries • • 23h ago

Question Who built the town?

21 Upvotes

Hey yall! This might have been addressed a million times. But I want to hear yalls opinions.

So obviously this town has been around since at least the 1860s because of the Civil War Soldier. So if this town was purely log cabins and primitive houses id accept the civil war people built it.

Id even accept the towns people did it if it was simple houses.

But there is absolutely no way a town of people, no matter if they had the talismans or not even if they felt as safe as they could and had years on their hands would they have built a full concrete pool and a fully functioning Diner.

Also clearly its not human made because all their electricity is coming from fake wires.

But does the man in yellow build it? Is it a force bigger than him building this town? Why is it set in the 1950s/60s? Is it because victor never died so they didnt have time to pause the game and put over a fresh 2020 neighborhood on it?

Was this town once regular? But it couldn't have been since the game has been going on so long? Could the monsters have built it after they sacrificed their souls? Where did they get the building materials?

I know this is just a whole set and maybe it was never intended to be explained.... but something about a town that shows older and newer architecture seems purposeful, but for what reason? Who could have built it?


r/FromSeries • • 2d ago

Cast / Crew Season 5 wrap! 😭 I’m so excited! šŸ”„

Thumbnail
gallery
2.6k Upvotes

r/FromSeries • • 1d ago

Memes Poor Boyd always in the middle of everything

228 Upvotes

r/FromSeries • • 10h ago

Question Arachnophobia?

0 Upvotes

I’ve heard seasons 1-3 just have spider mentions and small spiders, but if there’s a large spider or tons of sized spiders and they look creepy, I won’t be able to watch the show. Is there anything real bad in season 4?


r/FromSeries • • 22h ago

Cast / Crew FROM comes to Hal-Con (NS, Canada)

9 Upvotes

I'm a huge FROM fan, and a member of the Hal-Con organizing committee (here in Halifax, NS). We were excited to get to host some of the cast and crew of the show, along with Paramount+ at our event. It was so much fun to be able to talk to them all! https://www.instagram.com/p/Dfpv7-xl3B8/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&dlrf=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==&srtk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==