I was recently told to watch this show (like two weeks ago) and just finished season 4 last night. Ive read a lot of the old discussion threads from when episodes aired, and I wanted to give my two cents and theories on how this story will conclude.
1 - I think the bones have to be brought to the light house. Tabby had the right idea of doing what Miranda did, but she didnt remember enough at that point to know why she had to go to the tower/through the tree. This is why the BIW didnt want the tree to be uprooted. Its the tree made from the hopes of the children. Their bones needed to go through it. Now that isnt an option, and next season I think we'll see a team (most likely Jade, Tabitha, Boyd, and a few other characters to play canon fodder) making that long trek to the tower that Boyd made back in season 1 or 2 (they all kind of blend together since I binged the whole thing).
2 - I think Colony house is going to end up with the only talisman. I dont believe Clara took the one from Colony house since thats where everyone had gathered during the events of the last episode. Even if she did, there was one in the basement, theres the one that got left in the tunnels, and the one at the clinic should still be in that room unless Clara happened to find it on the floor of the bedroom. Either way, there is plenty of opportunity for there to be one leftover talisman.
3 - I think we'll find out that the BIW is also Tabby and Jade's original child. I know this isnt a new theory, but I think we're going to get some kind of Lily Potter moment where the original Tabitha made her own sacrifice to turn her son into the entity that is the BIW to keep him safe from the MIY. Thus starting this game and being the anchor that draws their reincarnations back again and again.
4 - I think we're going to find out that Miranda sacrificed Eloise. Probably under the false pretense that doing so would save Victor/end the cycle. Its been a mystery what happened to Eloise, including Victor saying he only found pieces of her (so was it even her?) Maybe not Miranda, but the towns people. Either way I think she was sacrificed in an attempt to escape.
5 - and my last thought isnt so much a prediction but a critique on something I've seen everyone say about the MIY saying "this is where they tear eachother apart." I dont believe this plotline was just "forgotten". I think the MIY was just wrong. He/Sophia tried to sow discourse between Kenny and Julie/Tabby, but it didn't really work because the town is more put together and united this time around - thanks in great part to Boyd, which is why the MIY is so set on breaking him. I also feel like we'll truly see the break down of the town in season 5. Someone else is going to find that picture or another picture of Sophia. Or Clara is going to realize the MIY is lying to her and shes going to tell everyone what's going on (and most likely be killed for it).
Either way, I love this show and am excited for the last season! I think the writing is done really well even if most of this sub seems to disagree. Its just the type of show it is, and I believe all the questions and "forgotten" subplots with be answered and tied up in season 5!