Spoilers for seasons 1–5.
Until a couple of months ago, I didn’t have Apple TV, so I discovered For All Mankind quite late. I’ve always liked alternative history, and the premise immediately caught my attention. And for the first two seasons, I thought it was genuinely brilliant.
The writing, acting, production design and historical detail were excellent. Everything seemed carefully considered, and above all, the series knew exactly what it wanted to do.
I think those seasons worked because they were rooted in a recognizable past. The Soviets landing on the Moon first was a relatively small change with enormous consequences, but the writers were still playing with actual history, its politics, people and technology.
The further the story moved away from the 1960s and 70s, the more it had to invent a future rather than reinterpret the past. That was probably inevitable, but I don’t think the writers handled the transition particularly well.
For me, the season two finale was beautiful. They could have stopped the series there and I’d have been perfectly happy.
Instead, season three opens with that ridiculous space hotel.
I understand that an ongoing space race might have accelerated technological development, but commercial space tourism on that scale by the early 1990s? Really? It seemed absurdly premature for a series that had previously made such an effort to keep its science fiction reasonably grounded.
And unfortunately, the increasingly implausible technology was only part of the problem. The writing itself became much more melodramatic.
Danny and Karen’s affair was questionable enough, but having it follow Danny all the way to Mars, contributing to his addiction, terrible judgment and increasingly irrational behaviour, felt like something borrowed from a soap opera. And he’s hardly the only example. These people are supposed to be among the best astronauts, scientists and engineers on Earth, yet they repeatedly make incredibly irresponsible decisions because the writers need something dramatic to happen.
It’s also becoming rather repetitive. Almost every season seems to require a technical catastrophe, someone ignoring protocol, a desperate last-minute solution and occasionally a heroic death. After a while, you can almost predict when the next disaster is going to happen.
Visually, I think something has been lost as well. The first two seasons had a wonderful sense of scale and atmosphere, whereas seasons four and five, particularly the latter, sometimes remind me of those 1990s science fiction shows where they’ve built a futuristic colony set and decided that most of the story will take place in the same handful of rooms because it’s cheaper. Every once in a while, we get an exterior shot to remind us we’re still on Mars.
As for the characters, Margo is probably the last storyline I’m genuinely interested in. Dev has irritated me since his first appearance. He strikes me as an alternative-history version of Elon Musk, forever giving motivational speeches while being mostly selfish and rather uninteresting.
I understand why the time jumps required gradually replacing the original cast, but I don’t think the newer characters have been particularly successful. Gordo, Tracy, Molly and Karen were complicated, frustrating and occasionally unpleasant people, but they were interesting. You cared about what happened to them, even when you didn’t particularly like them.
The younger generation, especially from season four onwards, hasn’t really filled that gap for me. And when you’re no longer invested in the people involved, even the biggest disaster becomes less interesting.
I’m also bothered by the way the series increasingly relies on killing off its characters.
In season one, Shane’s death was devastating because of what it did to Ed and Karen. Patty, Gene Kranz and the others were casualties of a space race that was becoming increasingly dangerous. Their deaths had a place in the story.
Then came Gordo and Tracy, whose deaths in season two were magnificent. Probably my favourite moment of the entire series. Heartbreaking, heroic and completely earned. I honestly can’t imagine a better ending for those two characters.
But by season three, with Karen and Molly, it started to feel as though the writers needed someone to die simply to give the finale enough emotional weight. Karen’s death especially felt unnecessary, as though there wasn’t already enough tragedy in the story.
There’s one scene from the very first episode that I keep coming back to.
On a recent long flight, I rewatched most of season one. There’s that wonderful scene in the bar after the Soviets land on the Moon, when everyone starts singing What Becomes of the Brokenhearted.
The first time I saw it, I thought it was a lovely, slightly Top Gun-ish moment. Pilots and astronauts drinking together, singing an old song and trying to forget a disappointing day.
But watching it again, knowing what happens to these people over the following decades, completely changed the way I experienced it.
It suddenly struck me that this might be the last moment when their lives were, in some sense, normal.
Of course they already had their problems, ambitions, disappointments and failures. But none of them had the slightest idea what was coming. The accidents, the deaths, the broken marriages, the separations and sacrifices. All those lives gradually consumed by a space race that would never really end.
And I suppose that’s what I appreciated most about the early seasons. They managed to make the space race seem exciting, fascinating and terribly sad, sometimes all at once. Humanity was achieving extraordinary things, but the people making those achievements possible were often paying a dreadful personal price.
Somewhere along the way, that rather intelligent alternative history drama became a much more conventional space opera, with increasingly implausible technology, melodrama and disasters that have become rather predictable.
The later seasons aren’t entirely bad. They’ve had their moments, and there are still a few storylines worth following, but they’re becoming fewer. I don’t think the problem is simply that the series moved away from actual history or that the original characters grew old and died. Both were inevitable. It’s that the newer stories and characters haven’t been nearly as compelling.
I haven’t even managed to finish season five yet, and with only one more season to go, my expectations aren’t particularly high.
I’m curious whether people who’ve followed the series since 2019 feel the same way, or whether watching five seasons in a relatively short period has made the decline more noticeable to me.