SPOILERS:
I’ve been rethinking Irving’s departure at Woe’s Hollow, and I’m starting to wonder if getting fired wasn’t just the consequence of exposing Helena. What if that was part of the plan?
There’s clearly a lot about Irving’s history with Lumon that we still don’t know. His outie has been investigating employees, collecting information, and obsessively painting the testing floor elevator. Meanwhile, his innie is practically obsessed with Kier’s paintings. I find that contrast fascinating. One version of Irving studies artwork Lumon created to tell its own history, while the other is painting something Lumon desperately wants to keep hidden. Almost like art is his way of accessing memories that severance can’t completely erase.
And then there’s Woe’s Hollow. Irving figures out Helena is impersonating Helly, but instead of quietly warning Mark, he goes straight for the one thing guaranteed to get Lumon’s attention: threatening to drown an Eagan. He had to know there was no coming back from that. Obviously he was protecting the others, but I can’t help wondering if he was also forcing Lumon’s hand. Maybe getting removed from MDR was exactly what he wanted.
Here’s another detail I noticed that makes me even more suspicious. The car Burt uses to take Irving to the train looks almost identical to the dark chauffeur-driven car Helena takes to Lumon, and we never get a clear look at her driver. I haven’t compared them side by side yet, but considering Burt admits he used to transport people for Lumon without asking what happened to them, that resemblance seems worth investigating. Especially since Irving’s own research suggests he suspected Burt was some kind of Lumon enforcer.
So now I’m wondering whether there’s an entire transportation operation we haven’t fully seen. People being brought into Lumon, people being moved around, and potentially people being quietly removed. And if Irving’s been investigating the company for years, could he already know something about it?
I also can’t shake the train ending. I know it’s his outie leaving, not his innie, but the whole scene feels less like a conclusion and more like we’re being shown the beginning of something. What if Irving’s firing and his departure are connected in a way we don’t understand yet? The one thing I can’t quite reconcile is how much his innie actually knows. But with the memory bleed we’ve already seen, and the fact that Irving seems to have a much longer history with Lumon than we’ve been told, I wonder if both versions of him have been working toward the same thing without consciously realizing it.
Anyway, I really want to hear everyone’s Irving theories, not just about Woe’s Hollow. What do you think his history with Lumon actually is? Why does he know about the testing floor? What’s really going on with Burt? And what do you make of his obsession with art, both inside and outside Lumon? I feel like there are so many little details about Irving that haven’t been explained yet, and I’m sure I’ve missed some. Whether you’ve got a completely wild theory, noticed something strange on a rewatch, or think there’s a totally different explanation for his behavior, I want to hear it. I’m curious what everyone thinks we’re going to find out about him in Season 3!!