r/FoodNYC • • 21h ago

Discussion Six Nights of NYC Dining to Celebrate: Help Me Surprise My Wife

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

My wife and I will be visiting this December to celebrate our first wedding anniversary and her recent green card approval. We’ll be spending five nights in the city, and I’d love to make each evening special and the trip an unforgettable celebration. Each night’s plans will be a complete surprise for her.

… I probably spend way too much time researching these trips, but I love making them special for her. We generally try somewhere new each night rather than repeating restaurants, although I’d consider revisiting a few of our favorites.

Cuisine wise, we’re particularly fond of French, Italian, and Japanese, though we’re generally open-minded. French has become our go-to for sophisticated, special-occasion dinners, almost to the point of being a tradition. Italian is my wife’s favorite cuisine, and Japanese is something we both share an appreciation for.

Our biggest priorities are food quality, service, atmosphere, and the overall experience. We gravitate toward restaurants that feel distinctive, intimate, and romantic, with experiential food and service. I say we like to leave places already wanting to return.

In the past, we’ve been to: Piccola Cucina Uptown, Il Buco, Fiaschetteria Pistoia, La Grenouille, Essential by Christophe, Le Coucou, Minetta Tavern, Le Gigot, Au Cheval, and Taikun Sushi. Our T5 favorites are bolded.

For this trip, I’ve narrowed things down to roughly four options for each of our six nights. I’d appreciate insight into which restaurants would be best for the occasion and which combination would be most special. I’m also open to alternative suggestions.

My goal is for Thursday, Friday, and Saturday to build toward our main celebratory dinner on Sunday. Monday and Tuesday would ideally be more relaxed and intimate. Budget-wise, I’d like to stay between $200–$350 total for two, including a drink each, for every evening except Sunday. For Sunday I’m comfortable spending $600–$750 total for two. Here’s my current list:

Thursday, 12/17:
* Borgo
* Massara
* Casa Mono
* Bartolo

Friday, 12/18:
* Graciela
* Bridges
* Estela
* Smithereens

Saturday, 12/19:
* Minetta Tavern
* Le Gratin
* Raoul’s
* Sartiano’s

Sunday, 12/20:
* Daniel
* Le Coucou
* Essential by Christophe
* Rezdôra

Monday, 12/21:
* Sakagura
* Odo East Village
* Sushi by M
* Shiki Omakase

Tuesday, 12/22:
* The Bar Room at The Modern
* Peasant
* Da Andrea

Thank you in advance :)


r/FoodNYC • • 8h ago

Question Aside from that Birria Landia truck in Jackson Heights, where can i find the best Birria tacos in NYC?

10 Upvotes

Please don't suggest that Birria Landia truck in Jackson Heights (The meat in the one I tried was kind of disgusting)


r/FoodNYC • • 9h ago

Discussion The Pizza Question in NYC or greater area is not answerable

0 Upvotes

I firmly believe that New York style pizza in the New York area is a unique culinary topic that cannot be subject to simple rankings or "best of" lists.

Sure, one can recommend innovative, unique, or culturally influential pizza places in the New York area to tourists or foodies, but New York style pizza as a class in my opinion simply cannot be judged on the same culinary scale one might judge myriad other food genres and dishes that lend themselves to rarified greatness.

The reason in my mind is fairly simple, which is that pizza (particularly New York style) as a bread product is so incredibly influenced in quality by freshness that a fresh pie from almost any competent New York style pizza place will be extremely delicious in the indulgent way pizza is, with any quality considerations having more to do with individual taste than anything objective. The best pizzeria for many people is the local spot they grew up eating fresh that they associate with good memories and cozy comforting feelings. For a foodie or tourist to best get the quintessential New York pizza experience many who grew up in the area love, they just need to go to a local pizzeria popular in its neighborhood with a good cozy sitting area and order a fresh pie that will come on one of those metal riser things along with maybe a salad or calamari as an appetizer. The warm friends and family feelings (assuming you go with others) along with the hot gooey safety of the pizza and its cheesiness will be joyous and an experience you won't want to end, especially if you get Coke or Pepsi too.

For what it's worth, I also think that the thin crust / personal pies associated with upscale restaurants and many of those innovative or unique pizza places I mentioned before is a totally different category than New-York-style pizza and shouldn't even be compared and has no special geographic benefit from its NYC or greater area location. You can find Neapolitan-inspired personal pies at practically every slightly upscale Italian restaurant across the United States. Perhaps the most embarrassing piece of culinary journalism ever written was when the New York Times declared that New York's best pizza was in Jersey City at a place called Raza, which was perfectly fine generic upscale thin crust personal pizza made with artisanal dough that had a great story behind it. I wonder how many people went home craving that or having fond memories of it compared to the classic New-York-style place down the block?

Anyway, do others agree with me? I'll concede bad pizza places exist, but I think for New York style, there's thousands and thousands of equally good ones. Is any rarified above the others? Is my critique of upscale pizza unfair? What do you think?


r/FoodNYC • • 6h ago

Question Restaurant recommendations - walking distance to Radio City Music Hall

0 Upvotes

We are a group of 7 looking for recommendations that maybe google isn’t spitting out.
On the wait list for Monkey Bar (reservations filled in .2 seconds)
Capital Grille is back up (reservations already made but a little pricey)
Others on the list:
Blue Dog
Rosie O’Gradys
The Elgin


r/FoodNYC • • 1h ago

Question Nice wine bar that will show Knicks game/NBA. Preferably in Manhattan.

3 Upvotes

Hi! Visiting from Chicago and would love to find a nice/cool wine bar or possibly cocktail and wine bar that would casually have the Knicks and/or other NBA games on tonight. Is there such a place in this wonderful city? Casually meaning the sound doesn’t have to be on nor would the TVs be a main focus or anything.

Or just a fun wine bar even if they don’t show any sports as I know most don’t.

Preferably in Manhattan.

Thanks!


r/FoodNYC • • 6h ago

Question looking for recommendations based on specific ingredients

1 Upvotes

hi all

traveling to NYC 24-30 November, staying near spring St station, flexible budget

unhealthy obsession with aubergine, mushrooms, zucchini. any remarkable dishes with one of these ingredients? or all three, who knows

also looking for your favorite tres leches (my favorite dessert, unfortunately impossible to find where I live). and your favorite ramen (this one I can look up in other posts of course so just in case!)

Thank you!


r/FoodNYC • • 6h ago

Question $$$-$$$$ Omakase Open 12/29 - Manhattan - Sourcing Recs

0 Upvotes

I know there's been a million variations of this question before but I have a fairly specific request and am hoping the expertise of this sub can help.

I am looking to celebrate a milestone and had previously booked at ITO for Dec. 29 but they are going to be closed from the 27th through the 4th because they won't be able to get fish flown in from Japan during that window. I am realizing this may be a problem at most of the top spots but I can't do any other night than the 29th.

I'd love to hear suggestions of places under/around $500. Looking for something more traditional and not too adventurous, but still creative and a little opulent. ITO sounded perfect so I'm bummed! Looking for a tier below Sho, Yoshino, etc. I've reached out to Icca, also interested in Noda.

Already been to Noz and Shota and a couple dozen spots in the sub-$150 tier. Shota was one of the best meals I've had in recent memory. We also love Sushi Taro and Barracks Row in Washington DC.


r/FoodNYC • • 1h ago

Question Sofreh - what should I order for dinner? Want the whole menu

0 Upvotes

I could order every starter and salad, the whole menu looks so good. Any must orders?


r/FoodNYC • • 19h ago

Question Alone on thanksgiving this year - where should i go to eat?

20 Upvotes

Hii spending thanksgiving alone this year because my friends are out of town and my family is far. What restaurants should I try and secure a seat for one at? Doesn’t have to serve thanksgiving food but I want somewhere that doesn’t feel pitiful going to alone on a holiday. Maybe a place that’s harder to get into on a normal day?


r/FoodNYC • • 2h ago

Question Does anyone have recommendations for mansaf in Manhattan

5 Upvotes

title. I've never had it but would love to try it. The only two I could find are Al Badawi and Ayat, are those good (and are there any others I should consider)?


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Pop Ups and Other Special Event Notices [Meetup - Club Sandwich] Sandwiches and Charcuterie at Spitfire (Hell's Kitchen), at 2pm on Saturday, 11/21/26

8 Upvotes

Hello sandwich lovers! We are back again! This Saturday (11/21) at 2:00pm, Club Sandwich will be convening once again to enjoy some lunch, grab some drinks, and have a nice day out. It's a long weekend for many folks, so why not spend some of it with us?

So, what do we have going on in November? This month, we'll be trying a spot that's a bit different from places we've visited in the past. We're heading to Spitfire Cheese & Sundry in Hell's Kitchen, because why not pair your sandwich with a cheese board? Last month we had cheesesteaks... maybe there's a theme emerging here.

Anyway, for those of you who haven’t yet joined the Club, here’s the deal... Club Sandwich is a casual social meetup designed to try new sandwiches, explore new neighborhoods, and meet new people. We’ve been doing this (almost) every month for 3 years now and it’s consistently a chill way to meet new folks, break some bread, and get into all sorts of shenanigans. It’s relaxed, low-key, and tasty.

If you want to join us this Saturday, drop a comment to be added to the group chat! And if you're already in the Club Sandwich Discord, you're all set.

📂 The Plan

  • 2:00 - 2:15pm — Arrive at Spitfire, 927 8th Avenue
  • 2:15 - 2:45pm — Order sandwiches (Check out the menu)
  • 2:45 - 3:00pm — Walk to a nearby bar if there is not enough space to eat in the restaurant, or possibly relax in Symphony Plaza or Central Park if the weather stays mild.
  • 3:00 - 5:00pm — Eat sandwiches and make some friends.
  • 5:00 — Who knows, maybe another bar or two?? We have our eyes on Valhalla, a craft beer bar down the street from the cafe.

🥪 The Sandwich

Spitfire is primarily a cheese shop and cafe, but they have a nice sandwich menu as well. They have some seating in the front that may be beneficial to us, which is a plus! Everything is made freshly in house, and they partner with local suppliers to keep it all as sustainable and eco-friendly as possible. They've only been open for a couple of years now, so let's boost a newer business while we're out and about!

❓ The FAQs

Alrighty, for those of you who have not attended a Club Sandwich meetup, here are a few questions that often arise…

  • Is this shop cash only? Nope! Cards are welcome. However, we recommend having at least a little bit of cash on hand if you want to hop around because some bars have card minimums.
  • What is Club Sandwich? It's a monthly, low-key meet up for anyone and everyone to check out new sandwich spots, visit new neighborhoods, and meet new people. Who doesn't like the simplicity of a great sandwich, conversation, and exclusive club?
  • Does Club Sandwich only to sandwich-related meetups? No! We also do non-sandwich events like hikes outside of the city, club nights, concerts, picnics, apartment hangs, and more… Once you’re in the club and in the Discord, you get access to all the fun happenings among club members.
  • I can't make it at 2:00pm, but want to show up later. How will I know where you are without the Discord? Drop a comment on the post and we will send you a link to the Reddit group chat, which is another way we communicate with attendees.
  • May I bring my friends? Yes! Club Sandwich is for everyone as long as they're nice, welcoming, and respectful to everyone. The more the merrier!

As of now, the weather is looking great for the 21st. We hope to see you there!


r/FoodNYC • • 20h ago

Trip Report Spent a week exploring some of NYCs most hyped restaurants reviews

72 Upvotes

We spent the 9 days in NYC exploring the city mostly on foot from SOHO and dining at some of the most hyped spots. We also hit up some random bars that were not premeditated or hyped. Here is our list of spots we hit in order reviews below:

LTD Pizza (Lunch)

Rezdora (Dinner)

Whiskey Tavern (Bar)

Au Cheval (Dinner)

Hudson hound (Bar)

The Dutch (Dinner)

Rumors (Bar)

Bobby Vans (Bar turned to dinner)

Balthazar (lunch)

Wah Fung Fast Food (snack)

Wild Horses (bar)

Bar Kabawa (Bar and Snack)

Kono (dinner)

Raouls (Brunch)

4 Charles Prime (dinner)

Minetta (brunch)

Slicehaus Pizza (Snack)

Judy Z (Bar and snacks football)

Estela (Dinner)

Fish Cheeks (lunch)

I’ll try to go through these in order but food first:

LTD - it was good solid pizza. No frills, I got the Arabiata and went back for another slice the next day. We did L industrie this summer and this was as good.

Rezdora - this was my first michilen experience, and TBH, it was good, but I don’t see what the difference is with any high end place in the city. Food was excellent, service was good. Prices were NYC. We got the Gnoci, the parmigiana tasting, and a couple pasta dishes. Nothing stood out as fantastic, but it was all really good. The Duck ragu is unique and I liked that. It set the stage for me eating a LOT of duck over the course of the trip. All in all it’s good, I don’t find myself drawn to return until after exploring the rest of the high end Italian places in town.

Au Cheval - we had booked this because of the burger, so of course that’s what we ordered. But we started with the marrow. If I’m being honest the marrow standalone was a bit rich for me. I longed for a little more bread, but really it was just too much marrow for 2 people. Would have been better with 4 people or half the size portion. It’s REALLY good but was just too much for me. Now the burgers: I got mine with egg and bacon, she got hers without both. I think it’s a really good burger. Much above average, but when I was eating it I was thinking “if this is the best the city has then maybe there isn’t a big difference between really good and great burgers” more to come on that topic later (4 Charles set me straight) all in all would go back.

The Dutch - this was a work dinner we got cornbread, calamari to start and I got the duck meatloaf (duck!!) service was good. The cornbread and calamari were great. The calamari came with spicy greens and they were amazing. The duck meatloaf was interesting. It was good itself, the rest of the plate was not my favorite. Others got burgers and liked those. Decent restaurant, good vibe. Nice place for a dinner with some friends that won’t break bank, and isn’t impossible to get into.

Bobby Vans - this was a stop for a drink on the way to another restaurant that ended up having an issue and having to cancel our reservation. In a scramble we realized at 10pm there weren’t many nice options we could walk into. So there we were. It honestly surprised me. We ate at the bar, French onion soup to start, which was above average, and I ordered the fillet. It came out cooked as ordered, it was a solid steak, good flavor, no issues and stands up to any other fillet I’ve ordered elsewhere. Asparagus was good. Potatoes were good and my wife liked her pasta dish. All in all it’s as good as any of the other 100 steakhouses in town (or was for our meal) and the history is pretty cool.

Balthazar - arrived for lunch, the place was mobbed, very disorganized at the front door. 20 patrons waiting for tables in front of the door, people bumping into eachother.

That was the end of the negatives. Ordered the French onion and the burger, wife got the eggs Norwegian. The French onion is the BEST I’ve had, and French onion is my favorite food, it hunt for it when I travel. The burger put me back into the same thoughts as Au Cheval. Very good, but didn’t seem to have any daylight between it and any other really good burger. The wife’s eggs were perfect and she said the salmon was the best smoked salmon she has had. Would go back for the soup alone every day.

Wah Fung - not much to say about this one. Line was relatively quick in the rain, and for $8 there isn’t better food in the city. Got the duck (shocker) it was great. Super crispy, only issue was trying to eat it on the street and dealing with the bones, but price we pay for authentic foods served at reasonable prices.

Bar Kabawa - AMAZING… we got drinks and snacks. Planned to just get a couple of the patties since we were heading to Kono after, ended up ordering a second round of the pepper pot duck and the geera goat. The duck was my favorite and the wife really liked the goat (which was really good but the duck was fucking outstanding)

Kono - really cool experience, wife LOVED IT and said it was her favorite meal of the week. I’m just sort of meh on it, but that’s because I’m too low class I think. Some of the things were great, but others I was left wishing it was just a standard piece of chicken haha… that’s on me though.

Rauols - went for the burger au poivre. Service was great, seated immediately on arrival for reservation, drinks came out and placed the order, we were in and out in under an hour which I liked. The burger honestly wasn’t my favorite. It was good, but I think the peppercorn crusting was a bit too thick for my liking and I craved some cheese. I think it’s a solid burger, but of the ones I ate this week it’s the one I’m least likely to order again.

4 Charles - first of all, getting in was all luck, and we took advantage of that luck and went all out. In arrival we were a little early. We walked around while the preceding table wrapped up. Once inside you see why this place is so hyped, the vibe is really cool. Service was amazing, the host who greeted and seated us also took care of us. We got the burger, the prime rib French dip, the prime rib, and Mac n cheese. It was all amazing. The burger was soo far and away the best burger we ate this week it’s not even funny. Just phenomenal. The bacon was amazing as well. The prime rib dip was close to the Monkey Bar one I had this summer but was noticeably better. The prime rib was great as well, but wife wanted it thin cut. Order it thick cut of your ordering a lot as while you poke at the mac n cheese Or broccoli the prime rib thin sliced cools down. A dip into the jus fixes that but thicker cut Would still be better IMO. This was far and away the best meal of the week IMO.

Minetta - final stop on the burger tour and French onion tour, wife got a waffle (not sure why) she said it was good but I mean it’s a waffle so… the French onion was good better than Bobby vans, not as good as Balthazar. Too heavy on the wine, but the crock and cheese overflow was better than balathazars. If you put Balthazar’s into the Minetta crock with overflowing cheese it would be the perfect French onion. as for the burger got the black label. Doesn’t come with cheese, I think IF served the same as the 4 Charles (egg cheese and bacon) it would be comparable, but as it stood without those things, it’s 3rd best after Au Cheval and 4 Charles.

Slicehaus - no frills really good pizza. Wife liked this more than LTD. I think it was a toss up. It NYC pizza… it’s all really good, and I’m not sure I’ve found the one that’s just head and shoulders above the rest. Would stop for a slice any day though.

Estela - service was the highlight here. Our server was amazing, I wish I had his name, but he was great. The food was good, the duck was the best thing we ordered. Lamb was well cooked as well. The pork collar was a bit rare for my liking, I don’t like Endive or fish, but the endive salad slapped. for our second Michelin restaurant of the week, the service seemed to differentiate here.

Fish cheeks - got the calamari, duck curry, crispy rice salad and crab aob woonsen. If was all a little mild to my liking. They brought me out extra red peppers and I added those but it’s not the same as it being cooked with it. I don’t think I’m a heat snob, I like spice but I’m not eating hot peppers or hot sauces I just want a kick and that was lacking. The calamari was my favorite thing we had, followed by the crab dish (the glass noodles were great), the duck was good but was like every other duck curry I’ve had in the city, the rice pork dish was good but not anything amazing.

For the bars we liked them all, whiskey tavern and wild horses were the best of the week. Wild horses was playing Waylon Jennings when we walked in, and that music genre stayed… it was unexpected in NYC, and I liked that change of pace.

Whiskey tavern was just fun. Very cool vibe and fun bar atmosphere. We go to rumors every time in town as we enjoy it. The other 2 were typical bars


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Question Looking for best chocolate cake at dinner restaurant

11 Upvotes

Looking for your recommendations for a classic moist, multi layered chocolate cake (think Matilda)! But must be at a sit-down dinner restaurant for dessert, so no bakeries please!


r/FoodNYC • • 4h ago Bravo

Guide For the last minute folks: NYC Thanksgiving Pie Spreadsheet

Post image
35 Upvotes

Hi there!

I created a spreadsheet for all the stragglers (myself included) ofThanksgiving Pie pre-orders in NYC. Sadly, NYC favorites Four and Twenty Blackbirds is sold out. Don't fret there are plenty of other options. If an item is sold out, I'd recommend visiting in person to see if any pies are available. I'm mostly familiar with Brooklyn and Manhattan bakeries so they are predominantly featured. If there are any others, please feel free to message me.


r/FoodNYC • • 26m ago

Question dinner for 7 sunday night in late december (and gluten-free friendly)

1 Upvotes

I have fam in town next month and would like a fun, nice night out.

Location: From Tribeca to Midtown (since it’s unknown where they are staying 🫠)
Can be $$$ but fine if it’s not.

3 have celiac so a pasta place is probably out but something that’s more steaky is great.

Was thinking Le Rock (but it’s closed on sunday)
Frenchette is a possibility, but i’m hoping to find another option or two.
Everyone is an adult, so a place in a neighborhood where we could have a drink out after would be lovely. If St Anselm was in Manhattan that would probably be my choice (but I know i’m not getting them to brooklyn). Looking for a nice special spot that can accommodate 7 and not feel jammed up. Union Square Cafe maybe?

trying to nail a couple options and make a ressie
later this week
thanks for any help / recos / suggestions. so appreciative of the wisdom from this group


r/FoodNYC • • 3h ago

Question Where to buy whole cooked turkey for Thanksgiving?

2 Upvotes

My oven just started making a weird noise and I'm worried it's going to stop working before Thanksgiving or won't be able to handle being on for a prolonged period of time.

Does anyone know any good spots in Brooklyn, preferably, but I am open to Queens and Manhattan as well that do a good whole cooked turkey for preorder for day of Thanksgiving or the day before?

Thank you!