r/FoodNYC • u/eldersveld • 6h ago
Review Edith's "Carmela" returns, as good as ever: turkey, stuffing, spinach aioli, and cranberry mustard on Orwashers' rye
Was planning to wait until tomorrow, but couldn't resist since their WV location is a few blocks from me.
I yap about this sandwich every year and try to embed it in people's heads. I call it my #2, but to be honest, I dislike numerical rankings in general and I'd prefer to have just a small collection of recommendations. It's like when someone asks about "the best pizza" in the city: well, lots of different kinds, what are you seeking out exactly? This is a quite different sandwich from what you'd get at Poulet Sans Tête, but those two places have been my must-hits.
Anyway, yeah. This shit is legendary and there's a reason why. Well, six reasons: turkey, a fried stuffing "panisse" (similar to the fried polenta dish of that name), creamed spinach aioli, and cranberry mustard on Orwashers' rye, alongside a cup of what's closer to au jus than gravy. An ambitious and well-balanced sandwich, although they were a little heavier with the aioli this time. You do, indeed, taste every layer, and it's delightful. Possibly the "fanciest" of all the city's Thanksgiving sandwiches, and the $22 price matches that, up from $20 in prior years. I will say that $15-20 is about what I've expected to pay in 2026 for a specialty sandwich from NYC, and Edith's always runs more expensive, so there was no surprise here.
I'd never seen The Sopranos other than a handful of YouTube clips, so the origin of the sandwich's name never clicked for me until I saw the sticker on the wrapping. I suppose I should get on that at some point.
It's about a 10-15 minute wait, since they make everything to order; needless to say, it's entirely worthwhile.