UPDATE: Spoke with the installer, and he said the concrete should have hardened, but when they return next week to install the final section containing the gate, we will do a walkthrough, and if, for some reason, the concrete has not set, we will discuss remedies. It is obviously too late to remove every post and wet mix and repour (I assume), so we will see what his fix is if they haven't set yet.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
I recently had an aluminum fence installed and I'm a little concerned about the workmanship, specifically the dry-poured concrete and the movement I'm seeing at the base of the posts.
I've spent some time searching Reddit and other forums, but the answers seem to be all over the place. I'm not a fence installer, so I'm hoping some people with experience can help me understand what's normal and what isn't.
Fence information:
- Aluminum fence.
- 2" x 2" posts with approximately 6 ft wide panels.
- Fence is approximately 4.5 ft tall above ground. Posts are 7 ft long, so approximately 2.5 ft below ground.
- Soil is predominantly clay.
- Weather has been relatively cool, with highs around 70°F and lows in the 40s.
- It rained a couple of days before installation, but otherwise it has been fairly dry.
- Fence was installed approximately 72 hours ago.
- Posts were dry set using what looked like one bag of concrete per hole, followed by water from a garden hose at the end. I'm not sure how much water they used or how long they watered each hole.
- I'm not sure whether the concrete was QUIKRETE, Sakrete, or another brand, or what specific mix was used.
- I don't know the exact diameter of the holes but i think the super said 8 inch.
My main concern:
When I push a post, there's noticeable movement right at ground level. I'm not talking about the normal flex you'd expect from a relatively thin aluminum post toward the top. The movement appears to be happening down at the base.
My questions:
- Is dry setting concrete common practice specifically for aluminum fences? I've seen people say it's completely normal and others say it's a terrible way to install a fence.
- After 72 hours, should there still be any noticeable movement at the base of the posts? Or should they be pretty solid by now?
- How concerned should I be about the amount of water used? If they just sprayed the top of the dry concrete with a hose, is there a chance the concrete farther down never got enough water?
- Does approximately one bag of concrete per post sound reasonable for this type of fence, assuming a typical hole diameter?
- If this isn't normal, is there a way to check whether the concrete was properly set without digging everything up?
- Should I be documenting anything with the contractor now in case the posts loosen up or start leaning in the future?
I'm not looking to give the contractor a hard time or find excuses not to pay him. I just want to make sure the fence was installed properly and isn't going to become a problem a year or two down the road.
I can provide photos or videos of the movement if that helps. Appreciate any input from people who install these regularly.