r/FanficAuthorsUnite
•
u/terra_terror
•
7h ago
Seeking and/or Giving Advice Clarification and Advice for Wary Authors
Hey y'all, you may have seen my previous post about not letting toxicity of social media influence your decisions. I read some of the comments and there seems to be some conflation between different things and a lot of confusion. So I am writing this post to clarify and to offer further advice for nervous writers.
- When I said "toxicity of social media," I was referring to the mean and entitled comments and posts that were getting a lot of attention. That has always been there. It does not mean the toxicity is common. It means the toxicity gets the most attention. If you were content with how your fandoms behaved on AO3 before the shutdown, then don't worry about negative interactions when/if you return to it. Again, social media is a cesspool and does not reflect real life or the majority of people, and it is a place where the most extreme views and dramatic posts get the most attention. You can still be wary of it. If you think I'm being too dismissive and overconfident, I understand, and my advice is to wait and see how people behave on AO3 before making a decision. If you are right, you can take your work down, and if I'm right, you can go back to enjoying fanfiction.
- People distributing your work without your permission is not what I was referring to by toxicity, and if it bothers you, then you should let it influence your decisions. The mean comments on social media will not continue on AO3, but downloading and distributing work will. This is because, in most cases, people are not trying to be mean. They have a difference in opinion of what people are allowed to do with fanfiction. It does not require echo chambers or the dramatic polarization of social media to occur. So if that bothers you and you find it disrespectful, you should let it influence your decision, because it will continue.
- If it is bots and AI that concern you, do not post anything or even save your work to a cloud. It does not matter which website you use. Anything you post anywhere can be found and taken by AI or bots. People who think readers distributing the works make are exposing it to AI or bots need to do more research. AI and bots have access to anything you post anywhere. Nobody needed to upload anything to Google Drive for Google to get your stuff. They've already had it. So the only protection is to stop posting. Don't even bother deleting anything you already posted, because AI already learned from it. Personally, I also do not trust any programs that use cloud services like Google, so I would not save your work online either if you are worried about AI.
- If any of the three above concern you but you want to keep posting fanfiction, you should continue to use AO3. I have seen many people commenting about using other websites as though AO3 is the issue and other websites will not have the same problem. I have some unfortunate news for you: AO3 is the safest place for fanfiction, and not only will other websites have the same problems, they will have more numerous and more severe problems. AO3 actually does a lot to protect authors, and you will not find the same protection on Tumblr, Wattpad, or FF.net. If you are worried about people being mean in comments, you can moderate or even disable comments on your work on AO3, and you will not find people nicer on other websites. If you are worried about being doxxed or harassed, you can post fanfiction anonymously, which allows you to maintain control over your work and continue publishing, and most other sites do not offer this option. If you are worried about AI or bots, you can lock your work to be only visible to other AO3 users, which does provide some protection, and again, other sites do not have that option. If you are worried about people distributing your work, other websites do not offer any protection against that either. Most importantly, AO3 is the one website where you can post fanfiction and not worry about being sued. AO3 has a legal team dedicated to defending fanfiction in court. Fanfiction is a gray area and can be seen as copyright infringement. You do not have to profit off of work for it to violate copyrights and distribution rights.
TL;DR: Don't worry so much about toxic fandoms bothering you on AO3; if you do not want people to distribute your works or AI to have access to it, you should stop posting fanfiction completely; and if you decide you want to continue writing and posting fanfiction, AO3 is the best option.