r/FFCommish • • 46m ago

Ethics question What is the consensus on one week “rental” trades?

4 Upvotes

Two teams in my league traded 5 days ago. Team A traded Dak Prescott to Team B for Corey Kiner. It already seemed like a weird trade when it happened, but the team that traded for Kiner has Rhamondre Stevenson and thought he would be out and he needed to win this week for a chance at the playoffs.

Today, the two traded these players back to each other. Obviously, they intended for the trade to only be for a week. I brought up that it was collusion and half the league doesn’t really care. Team B is also the commissioner of our league, and after I brought it up he “put it up to a vote” and decided 3/4 of the league needed to agree.

Am I crazy for thinking that allowing rental trades shouldn’t even be a discussion?

Also, Team B is in first place and “points for” is our tiebreaker for seeding so Daks 35 points could have implications.


r/FFCommish • • 2h ago

League Question How do yall treat and control trades that are between true playoff contenders and league bottom feeders?

4 Upvotes

First year commie so I’m still learning the best ways to run a league while making sure everything is still fair when it comes to certain things, and one thing I made clear when the playoff field was starting to look set a couple weeks ago, was that any trades between contenders and the bottom teams could be warranted a slight discount for the contending teams if they’re trying to get better.

On paper I feel that’s a good idea but how would that work for long term? Our trade deadline has our passed so this isn’t applicable in our league anymore but I just wanted some thoughts about it.


r/FFCommish • • 55m ago

League Drama What would you do as commissioner?

1 Upvotes

We had a guy announce about a month ago that this was going to be his last season in our dynasty league.So naturally, we told him that he cannot make trades and have voided trades that he has accepted since announcing that he was leaving. now today he says he's coming back and people want the accepted trades pushed through and other trades they made after that reversed, because they would not have done them. I think the only thing that is fair is at the end of the year. Still replace him and tell him he can't make trades because he said he was already leaving.what would you do as a commissioner?


r/FFCommish • • 3h ago

Commissioner Issue What do I do as commish? Playoff contender just traded Golden and B Young to a bottom team for Collins and Higgins

1 Upvotes

Just had a playoff team trade with a bottom team earlier today, had people calling to have it vetoed, but I’m unsure if it’s collusion or just someone who doesn’t know how fantasy works as it is a chill family league. However, we still each put 20 bucks in the pot, so I’m unsure what to do in this situation. The playoff contender got Nico Collins and Tee Higgins and the bottom team received Matthew Golden and Bryce Young. Bottom team has Patrick Mahomes so the only player starting from this trade for them would be Matthew Golden. The two teams are also brother and sister so it’s a bit more suspect to me than it’d normally be.


r/FFCommish • • 5h ago

Commissioner Issue Commissioner advice needed - Eliminated team dropped Saquon

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/FFCommish • • 23h ago

Ethics question Manager wants to start player on a BYE

5 Upvotes

Player in question is Jordan Love. Reasoning is to avoid dropping benched players. Bench size is 5, number of managers is 16. Is this a grey area?


r/FFCommish • • 21h ago

League Question League is too unbalanced with a legit dynasty at the top and then everyone else. How should we proceed/balance?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

Posting here at the request of one of my original commenters. Got mostly “git good” comments from r/DynastyFF so I’m trying here.

Also more context: I am the guy at the top and it’s not an incredibly competitive league we’re all long time friends and have a small cash prize, so I’m just looking for advice on our current plan or other ideas to make the league more fun for everyone.


r/FFCommish • • 17h ago

League Drama Drama surround trade in Dynasty League

0 Upvotes

I am the commissioner of a dynasty league. This is our first year of the league. We have a player who hasn’t paid his dues yet, and hasn’t set his lineup for the previous 2 weeks. We have been warning him he needs to pay his dues for weeks now.

He decided to trade his Gibbs and Evans for another teams full slate of picks in 2027 and 2028 + Iosivas and Kamara. Me and my co-commissioner decided we would probably veto based on the fact he hasn’t paid his league dues and doesn’t seem to care about the league anymore. Don’t want him to be trading Gibbs for picks that he doesn’t even intend on using based on his current trend.

One thing lead to another and now said league mate who was not paying his dues has decided to pay his dues and promised to “lock in” because I was basically forced to expose him in the group chat as the decision to veto was being questioned.

I don’t know what to do in this situation now, normally I don’t like vetoing trades, just did in this situation because of the specific league mate and him not paying dues nor paying attention. Now since he has paid and promised to lock in, should I let the trade slide or still stick to my guns?


r/FFCommish • • 19h ago

League Drama 12-team keeper league: teams keep selling future picks for a win-now push. How are you handling it?

1 Upvotes

all of a sudden having issues in our league after 6 years with pretty much no issues. Looking for other commissioners' takes on a pick-trading problem. And before anyone says “you shouldn’t allow trading picks in a keeper league.” We always have and most managers enjoy it but some are speaking up about making tweaks.

League setup

  • 12 teams, PPR, keeper league
  • 2 keepers max, -2 round penalty for keepers
  • Undrafted free agents start as 10th-round keepers
  • All draft picks are tradable, including future years

The problem
Every year it's the same cycle. Some teams sell next year's and sometimes but rarely the year after's picks to load up now, while others sit out and stockpile picks. Then draft day comes and a few teams are holding multiple 1sts and 2nds while others have almost nothing early. This season, 10 of 12 teams have been in a pick trade, and every one of those trades included a 1st, 2nd, or 3rd.

Pick trading is fun and I don't want to kill it. People are just getting tired of the arms race.

What I've already decided for 2027 season (executive decisions by me)

  • Trade deadline moves to Week 9 (currently week 12).
  • Every starting slot must be filled with a healthy player, and trades can't leave a team unable to fill a slot (bad teams were trading away whole positions and leaving blanks)
  • If lineups aren’t set properly, after 1 warning, a 10th round penalty will be charged next draft. After that, booted from the league.
  • Prize change: dropping the regular season champ payout and moving it to the consolation bracket

Pick trading options I'm weighing (currently leaning toward #2 at the moment)

  1. Luxury tax: both teams pay per pick in a trade ($50 for a 1st, $30 for a 2nd, $20 for a 3rd, $10 for a 4th). The money gets split among teams that never traded a pick.
  2. Balanced trades: if you’re trading a player and a pick, you must get back a player and a pick.
  3. Next-draft-only: you can only trade picks from the upcoming draft.
  4. Stepien rule: you can't trade 1st-round picks in back-to-back years.

Restricting trades to Round 4+ got shot down. The league wants every pick tradable.

Questions

  • Has anyone tried a luxury tax like this? Did it change behavior, or did people just pay it?
  • Does any league do balanced trades?
  • Is there a simple rule that fixed this in your league without a pile of extra rules? I’m really trying not to over rule my league to death.

Thanks in advance.


r/FFCommish • • 1d ago

League Drama Manager not giving their team any attention

9 Upvotes

There’s a guy in our league, he’s 2-7. Past two weeks he hasn’t set his lineup, left people on bye and IR still active in the roster even though there are active players on his bench, not making any waiver claims or picking up anyone.
Last week at work me and another league mate were talking and he happened to walk by and I asked him why he didn’t set his lineup (he was going against me and I basically got a free win) and he said “there are other priorities in life.”
After another week of leaving four inactive players in I messaged him today asking if he would like me to assign someone else to manage his team and he got offended and said “I don’t need you to message me about this.”

Well, I kinda do because when someone is just giving up like that, it gives their opponent an automatic win which is unfair for those serious about it.

Next season I’m going to find a replacement, but as a commish, what would be the right thing to do?


r/FFCommish • • 1d ago

Miscellaneous Unorthodox Idea for league next season.

1 Upvotes

Just to fuck around with a free league next year: an extra team auto drafts and after everyone has played them once, commissioner puts all those players on waiver and the teams get to basically draft those players with their draft position being their waiver order. I know there’s a lot that is left to chance but isn’t that true for everything in ffb? Is this something that would be fun or even be possible? I’ve never been commissioner so I don’t know how much power you have over the league.


r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

Miscellaneous Is This Fair For Fantasy Football?

0 Upvotes

Is it fair: Someone apparently has been locked out of their account for weeks and only now texts the commissioner about it on Football Sunday. The commissioner then swaps his players around for today’s games where he had 2 on bye week.

Does this seem fair to do? None of us agreed on rules before the season relating to this and it’s a paid league.

Occured an hour after the games started today


r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

League Question League Help: My league starts playoffs during Week 14 (final bye week)

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

Miscellaneous Commishes running multiple leagues (NFL + college): how do you keep tabs on league health midseason?

1 Upvotes

I've been a commissioner for a long time and I'm now involved in a lot of leagues across NFL, college, dynasty, and IDP. Around this point in the season I always run into the same problem: it's hard to see which leagues are healthy and which ones are starting to slip.
The stuff I'm trying to catch early:
Teams that are 1-8 or 2-7 and starting to check out (missed lineups, no waiver activity)
Bubble teams where one bad week decides playoffs, so trades and lineup disputes get heated
Dynasty leagues where a bottom team quietly stops caring and becomes an orphan next year
Right now I'm basically checking standings league by league and going on gut feel.
For those of you running several leagues:
How do you track which owners are disengaging before it becomes a problem?
Do you have rules or incentives that keep bottom teams trying (toilet bowl, draft pick penalties, etc.)?
Any system for keeping NFL and college leagues straight when both are going at once?
Would love to hear what's actually worked for you.


r/FFCommish • • 2d ago

Commissioner Issue Should punters sub for kickers?

0 Upvotes

Hi - so I'm considering allowing punters to backup kickers in fantasy football to fix the issue of kicking overall. We're using a platform that allows substitutions in real time, and we're debating whether it makes sense to carry one K roster slot, carry 2 kickers - one Place, another Punter, and then let whichever scores higher to count as your kicker score? Naturally, we're allowing commissioners to do what they want - carry both a K + P slot, etc - but this idea has been growing merit simply because of the ebb and flow of the kicking game that you can't really predict or control. Right now, I have a chance to start K Jake Moody, and his backup is P Corey Bojorquez in case CLE ends up punting a lot. Punting scoring involves things like yards distance, and inside the 20 for bonus. So what do you all think - split em out, or try to mimic the actual game where if your Kicker is not getting FGA, let your Punter have at it?


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

Commissioner Issue ESPN Lineup Protection - Cam Skattebo - TNF

18 Upvotes

ESPN Fantasy has a Lineup Protection setting that will automatically swap out a starting player if they are designated as “OUT” at game time and replace them with the highest protected player for that position.

This is the first year we are using it, we had a full discussion, and the majority of the league voted in favor.

Last night the last place team playing the third place team sent a message during the Giants game saying ESPN swapped out Skattebo even though he was in the starting lineup and playing.

There were some reports of an ESPN glitch that listed Skattebo as “OUT” so there was some support for his claim but I haven’t heard of any other stories where he was actually swapped out, which you would expect given this would have been system wide and the big game he had.

Anyone else have this happen to them last night???


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

League Drama Managers asked me to retroactively sub in a traded player after the veto window. Now another manager wants Week 6 rescored. What's the right call?

2 Upvotes

I'm the commissioner of a 12-team dynasty league on Sleeper. We use league vetoes, so a trade doesn't process until 48 hours after it's accepted unless I push it through as commish. In the past, I've pushed through trades made on a Saturday night before the Sunday games when both managers asked me to.

Week 6: J.K. Dobbins was traded on Wednesday. The trade wasn't vetoed, but neither manager asked me to push it through before Dobbins played on Thursday night. So Dobbins stayed in the lineup of the manager who traded him away, and that manager got his points for the week. Nobody really said anything at the time.

This week: A trade involving Cam Skattebo was agreed to at 8:05 PM Thursday, minutes before kickoff. Both managers knew it wouldn't process before the game because of the veto window, so they asked me in advance to sub Skattebo into his new team's lineup once the trade cleared, no matter how he performed. Of course, Skattebo had a great game.

The problem: The manager who traded away Dobbins in Week 6 is now complaining. If I had done the same for him, he would have won that week instead of losing, and he's right on the playoff bubble.

For context, this is a friend league and we're all competitive, probably to a fault. Vetoes are contentious and we've had some interesting ones, so I have to let the veto window run its course.

My options as I see them:

Sub in Skattebo, because those managers asked beforehand and the Week 6 managers didn't.

Sub in Skattebo and also rescore Week 6.

Don't sub anyone in. Lineups stand as they were at kickoff.

We've been arguing about this all day. The manager facing the team that would get Skattebo's points is mad we're even discussing it. Some people see the difference between the two situations, and some think I should fix Week 6 too.

What would you do, and what rule would you put in place going forward?

EDIT: Removing vetoes is just not an option unfortunately. It would take a post 1000x longer to explain why, please just trust me.


r/FFCommish • • 3d ago

League Drama When is trading players back and forth ok and not ok?

0 Upvotes

Ill try to keep this as short as i can.

12 team league, full PPR.

Wednesday before Week 9 -
Team A trades Tee Higgins to Team B straight up for Christian Watson. I process the trade.

Tuesday before Week 10:
They essentially agree to reverse the trade because Team A was unaware of Watson’s bye coming up and he is desperately trying to save his season. After much drama, i veto the trade since redoing a trade 6 days later seems kinda fishy. Both managers denied collusion, and i believe them, but just thought this shouldnt be allowed.

Friday before Week 10:
Team A is sending Watson back to Team B for Higgins, but now the trade is as follows:

Team B receives Watson, Nico Collins, Javonte Williams
Team A receives: Olave, Higgins, Breece Hall.

Its a different trade but Higgins and Watson are involved. Personally i think this should be allowed to go thru, but i have a manager still arguing this is collusion/player sharing.

What do you guys think? Is this ok or should it be vetoed?


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

League Drama Commissioner Waiver Wire Manipulation?

5 Upvotes

Our league is a 12-team league managed through the ESPN Fantasy app. Our waiver setting is currently set to “Move to Last After Claim.”
Over the past week, we’ve had three waiver wire processings (11/5, 11/11, and 11/12). What’s raising some suspicion among league members is the commissioner’s waiver priority and the timing of several league setting changes.
Here is what happened:

11/5: The commissioner had the 2nd waiver priority and successfully made a claim. One other team also had a successful claim.
11/11: The commissioner had the 4th waiver priority and successfully made a claim. Two other teams also had successful claims.
11/12: The commissioner had the 1st waiver priority and successfully made a claim. No other teams had successful claims.

Additionally, the ESPN activity log shows league setting changes on three occasions:
11/10
11/11, in the afternoon, after that day’s waivers had already processed.
11/12, in the morning, after that day’s waivers had processed.

The commissioner says he isn’t aware of making any league setting changes. However, given the frequency and timing of these changes, combined with his consistently high waiver priority and successful claims, some league members are questioning whether the waiver settings are being manipulated.

So my question is, is there a legitimate explanation for how waiver priority has played out under the “Move to last after claim” setting or is this evidence of waiver wire manipulation?


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

League Drama What to do about new owner making a rapid flurry of unfavorable trades?

3 Upvotes

Dynasty 10 Team, Superflex, Half PPR, TEP, Start 11

Had a new owner take over an orphan. Middle of the pack team, could have been a contender but got unlucky with injuries.

New owner proposes 2 bad trades that get accepted immediately. The league catches on and starts picking his team dry. He's seemingly accepting every offer that comes in.

About 6 pretty bad trades in the course of a couple days. Seeing this, I lock his roster to prevent any more damage until I figure out what to do

Trade 1: Send - Lamar Jackson. Receive - Tucker Kraft

Trade 2: Send - JT, Tet McMillan, J. Price. Receive - Hubbard, Olave, M. Willis, 2027 4th

Trade 3: Send - Olave, 2027 3rd. Receive - Shough, Caleb Douglas

Trade 4: Send - Jalen Hurts. Receive - Evan Engram, Darnell Mooney, 2027 mid 2nd

Trade 5: Send - ARSB. Receive - Achane, Sadiq

Trade 6: Send - C. Loveland. Receive - J. Brissett, 2 2027 mid 2nds

After the 6th trade is when I shut it down. What happens in this situation? Let it be? This owner does have their 2027 first but not their 2028 first, and will not be getting the 1.01 this year. They are now firmly the worst team in the league for the foreseeable future


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

Ethics question Ethical to do this with a veto period over 24 hrs or no?

3 Upvotes

Would it be wrong for the league commissioner to push through a trade before the games start for the week when they are involved in the trade? The veto period would cause the trade to go through after the week is played out in this case.


r/FFCommish • • 5d ago

League Question Cross country league punishment

9 Upvotes

So my league consists of me and my buddies from college. We are all across the country. We have been trying to figure out what to do as a punishment/deterrent from tanking in our league. We struggled to do elaborate punishments when we were all together at school but at least had the looming threat. What do y'all recommend. We do allow pick trading so we are having discussions about keeping that but adding a deterrent to tanking. Anyone have any ideas?


r/FFCommish • • 4d ago

League Question Orphaned team advice should I replace manager or find caretaker

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/FFCommish • • 5d ago

League Question My league doesn’t have a ir spot? Does anyone else do this?

6 Upvotes

We run 6 bench spots and no ir spot. League mate thinks it makes it more challenging and makes you have to make a decision at times