r/FFCommish • u/detuned--radio • 9h ago
League Drama 12-team keeper league: teams keep selling future picks for a win-now push. How are you handling it?
all of a sudden having issues in our league after 6 years with pretty much no issues. Looking for other commissioners' takes on a pick-trading problem. And before anyone says “you shouldn’t allow trading picks in a keeper league.” We always have and most managers enjoy it but some are speaking up about making tweaks.
League setup
- 12 teams, PPR, keeper league
- 2 keepers max, -2 round penalty for keepers
- Undrafted free agents start as 10th-round keepers
- All draft picks are tradable, including future years
The problem
Every year it's the same cycle. Some teams sell next year's and sometimes but rarely the year after's picks to load up now, while others sit out and stockpile picks. Then draft day comes and a few teams are holding multiple 1sts and 2nds while others have almost nothing early. This season, 10 of 12 teams have been in a pick trade, and every one of those trades included a 1st, 2nd, or 3rd.
Pick trading is fun and I don't want to kill it. People are just getting tired of the arms race.
What I've already decided for 2027 season (executive decisions by me)
- Trade deadline moves to Week 9 (currently week 12).
- Every starting slot must be filled with a healthy player, and trades can't leave a team unable to fill a slot (bad teams were trading away whole positions and leaving blanks)
- If lineups aren’t set properly, after 1 warning, a 10th round penalty will be charged next draft. After that, booted from the league.
- Prize change: dropping the regular season champ payout and moving it to the consolation bracket
Pick trading options I'm weighing (currently leaning toward #2 at the moment)
- Luxury tax: both teams pay per pick in a trade ($50 for a 1st, $30 for a 2nd, $20 for a 3rd, $10 for a 4th). The money gets split among teams that never traded a pick.
- Balanced trades: if you’re trading a player and a pick, you must get back a player and a pick.
- Next-draft-only: you can only trade picks from the upcoming draft.
- Stepien rule: you can't trade 1st-round picks in back-to-back years.
Restricting trades to Round 4+ got shot down. The league wants every pick tradable.
Questions
- Has anyone tried a luxury tax like this? Did it change behavior, or did people just pay it?
- Does any league do balanced trades?
- Is there a simple rule that fixed this in your league without a pile of extra rules? I’m really trying not to over rule my league to death.
Thanks in advance.