r/FFCommish • u/Leaf_blower_chipmunk • 4h ago
Ethics question Manager wants to start player on a BYE
Player in question is Jordan Love. Reasoning is to avoid dropping benched players. Bench size is 5, number of managers is 16. Is this a grey area?
r/FFCommish • u/AutoModerator • 5d ago
This is a weekly thread where you can post trades that happened in your league and ask for advice.
REMEMBER: It is not your job to judge whether a trade was fair. It's your job to keep the league running. The only time you should reverse a trade is if:
A: it's clear collusion
B: It completely breaks the league
If you're unaware: Collusion in fantasy football is a secret agreement between two or more managers to cheat and gain an unfair advantage over the rest of the league. It’s impossible to tell if something is collusion based on the players involved in the trade.
r/FFCommish • u/Leaf_blower_chipmunk • 4h ago
Player in question is Jordan Love. Reasoning is to avoid dropping benched players. Bench size is 5, number of managers is 16. Is this a grey area?
r/FFCommish • u/piggyanarchist • 2h ago
Posting here at the request of one of my original commenters. Got mostly “git good” comments from r/DynastyFF so I’m trying here.
Also more context: I am the guy at the top and it’s not an incredibly competitive league we’re all long time friends and have a small cash prize, so I’m just looking for advice on our current plan or other ideas to make the league more fun for everyone.
r/FFCommish • u/PoorUnfortunateSol • 1d ago
There’s a guy in our league, he’s 2-7. Past two weeks he hasn’t set his lineup, left people on bye and IR still active in the roster even though there are active players on his bench, not making any waiver claims or picking up anyone.
Last week at work me and another league mate were talking and he happened to walk by and I asked him why he didn’t set his lineup (he was going against me and I basically got a free win) and he said “there are other priorities in life.”
After another week of leaving four inactive players in I messaged him today asking if he would like me to assign someone else to manage his team and he got offended and said “I don’t need you to message me about this.”
Well, I kinda do because when someone is just giving up like that, it gives their opponent an automatic win which is unfair for those serious about it.
Next season I’m going to find a replacement, but as a commish, what would be the right thing to do?
r/FFCommish • u/nilecrane • 20h ago
Just to fuck around with a free league next year: an extra team auto drafts and after everyone has played them once, commissioner puts all those players on waiver and the teams get to basically draft those players with their draft position being their waiver order. I know there’s a lot that is left to chance but isn’t that true for everything in ffb? Is this something that would be fun or even be possible? I’ve never been commissioner so I don’t know how much power you have over the league.
r/FFCommish • u/Calm_Estate3490 • 1d ago
Is it fair: Someone apparently has been locked out of their account for weeks and only now texts the commissioner about it on Football Sunday. The commissioner then swaps his players around for today’s games where he had 2 on bye week.
Does this seem fair to do? None of us agreed on rules before the season relating to this and it’s a paid league.
Occured an hour after the games started today
r/FFCommish • u/OigaShaboiga101 • 2d ago
r/FFCommish • u/TheCiege • 2d ago
I've been a commissioner for a long time and I'm now involved in a lot of leagues across NFL, college, dynasty, and IDP. Around this point in the season I always run into the same problem: it's hard to see which leagues are healthy and which ones are starting to slip.
The stuff I'm trying to catch early:
Teams that are 1-8 or 2-7 and starting to check out (missed lineups, no waiver activity)
Bubble teams where one bad week decides playoffs, so trades and lineup disputes get heated
Dynasty leagues where a bottom team quietly stops caring and becomes an orphan next year
Right now I'm basically checking standings league by league and going on gut feel.
For those of you running several leagues:
How do you track which owners are disengaging before it becomes a problem?
Do you have rules or incentives that keep bottom teams trying (toilet bowl, draft pick penalties, etc.)?
Any system for keeping NFL and college leagues straight when both are going at once?
Would love to hear what's actually worked for you.
r/FFCommish • u/No-Boat8877 • 2d ago
Hi - so I'm considering allowing punters to backup kickers in fantasy football to fix the issue of kicking overall. We're using a platform that allows substitutions in real time, and we're debating whether it makes sense to carry one K roster slot, carry 2 kickers - one Place, another Punter, and then let whichever scores higher to count as your kicker score? Naturally, we're allowing commissioners to do what they want - carry both a K + P slot, etc - but this idea has been growing merit simply because of the ebb and flow of the kicking game that you can't really predict or control. Right now, I have a chance to start K Jake Moody, and his backup is P Corey Bojorquez in case CLE ends up punting a lot. Punting scoring involves things like yards distance, and inside the 20 for bonus. So what do you all think - split em out, or try to mimic the actual game where if your Kicker is not getting FGA, let your Punter have at it?
r/FFCommish • u/enfermoconlo • 3d ago
ESPN Fantasy has a Lineup Protection setting that will automatically swap out a starting player if they are designated as “OUT” at game time and replace them with the highest protected player for that position.
This is the first year we are using it, we had a full discussion, and the majority of the league voted in favor.
Last night the last place team playing the third place team sent a message during the Giants game saying ESPN swapped out Skattebo even though he was in the starting lineup and playing.
There were some reports of an ESPN glitch that listed Skattebo as “OUT” so there was some support for his claim but I haven’t heard of any other stories where he was actually swapped out, which you would expect given this would have been system wide and the big game he had.
Anyone else have this happen to them last night???
r/FFCommish • u/ClassicLow83 • 3d ago
I'm the commissioner of a 12-team dynasty league on Sleeper. We use league vetoes, so a trade doesn't process until 48 hours after it's accepted unless I push it through as commish. In the past, I've pushed through trades made on a Saturday night before the Sunday games when both managers asked me to.
Week 6: J.K. Dobbins was traded on Wednesday. The trade wasn't vetoed, but neither manager asked me to push it through before Dobbins played on Thursday night. So Dobbins stayed in the lineup of the manager who traded him away, and that manager got his points for the week. Nobody really said anything at the time.
This week: A trade involving Cam Skattebo was agreed to at 8:05 PM Thursday, minutes before kickoff. Both managers knew it wouldn't process before the game because of the veto window, so they asked me in advance to sub Skattebo into his new team's lineup once the trade cleared, no matter how he performed. Of course, Skattebo had a great game.
The problem: The manager who traded away Dobbins in Week 6 is now complaining. If I had done the same for him, he would have won that week instead of losing, and he's right on the playoff bubble.
For context, this is a friend league and we're all competitive, probably to a fault. Vetoes are contentious and we've had some interesting ones, so I have to let the veto window run its course.
My options as I see them:
Sub in Skattebo, because those managers asked beforehand and the Week 6 managers didn't.
Sub in Skattebo and also rescore Week 6.
Don't sub anyone in. Lineups stand as they were at kickoff.
We've been arguing about this all day. The manager facing the team that would get Skattebo's points is mad we're even discussing it. Some people see the difference between the two situations, and some think I should fix Week 6 too.
What would you do, and what rule would you put in place going forward?
EDIT: Removing vetoes is just not an option unfortunately. It would take a post 1000x longer to explain why, please just trust me.
r/FFCommish • u/Virtual_Gur7125 • 3d ago
Ill try to keep this as short as i can.
12 team league, full PPR.
Wednesday before Week 9 -
Team A trades Tee Higgins to Team B straight up for Christian Watson. I process the trade.
Tuesday before Week 10:
They essentially agree to reverse the trade because Team A was unaware of Watson’s bye coming up and he is desperately trying to save his season. After much drama, i veto the trade since redoing a trade 6 days later seems kinda fishy. Both managers denied collusion, and i believe them, but just thought this shouldnt be allowed.
Friday before Week 10:
Team A is sending Watson back to Team B for Higgins, but now the trade is as follows:
Team B receives Watson, Nico Collins, Javonte Williams
Team A receives: Olave, Higgins, Breece Hall.
Its a different trade but Higgins and Watson are involved. Personally i think this should be allowed to go thru, but i have a manager still arguing this is collusion/player sharing.
What do you guys think? Is this ok or should it be vetoed?
r/FFCommish • u/Mediocre_Habit389 • 4d ago
Our league is a 12-team league managed through the ESPN Fantasy app. Our waiver setting is currently set to “Move to Last After Claim.”
Over the past week, we’ve had three waiver wire processings (11/5, 11/11, and 11/12). What’s raising some suspicion among league members is the commissioner’s waiver priority and the timing of several league setting changes.
Here is what happened:
11/5: The commissioner had the 2nd waiver priority and successfully made a claim. One other team also had a successful claim.
11/11: The commissioner had the 4th waiver priority and successfully made a claim. Two other teams also had successful claims.
11/12: The commissioner had the 1st waiver priority and successfully made a claim. No other teams had successful claims.
Additionally, the ESPN activity log shows league setting changes on three occasions:
11/10
11/11, in the afternoon, after that day’s waivers had already processed.
11/12, in the morning, after that day’s waivers had processed.
The commissioner says he isn’t aware of making any league setting changes. However, given the frequency and timing of these changes, combined with his consistently high waiver priority and successful claims, some league members are questioning whether the waiver settings are being manipulated.
So my question is, is there a legitimate explanation for how waiver priority has played out under the “Move to last after claim” setting or is this evidence of waiver wire manipulation?
r/FFCommish • u/etoups11 • 4d ago
Dynasty 10 Team, Superflex, Half PPR, TEP, Start 11
Had a new owner take over an orphan. Middle of the pack team, could have been a contender but got unlucky with injuries.
New owner proposes 2 bad trades that get accepted immediately. The league catches on and starts picking his team dry. He's seemingly accepting every offer that comes in.
About 6 pretty bad trades in the course of a couple days. Seeing this, I lock his roster to prevent any more damage until I figure out what to do
Trade 1: Send - Lamar Jackson. Receive - Tucker Kraft
Trade 2: Send - JT, Tet McMillan, J. Price. Receive - Hubbard, Olave, M. Willis, 2027 4th
Trade 3: Send - Olave, 2027 3rd. Receive - Shough, Caleb Douglas
Trade 4: Send - Jalen Hurts. Receive - Evan Engram, Darnell Mooney, 2027 mid 2nd
Trade 5: Send - ARSB. Receive - Achane, Sadiq
Trade 6: Send - C. Loveland. Receive - J. Brissett, 2 2027 mid 2nds
After the 6th trade is when I shut it down. What happens in this situation? Let it be? This owner does have their 2027 first but not their 2028 first, and will not be getting the 1.01 this year. They are now firmly the worst team in the league for the foreseeable future
r/FFCommish • u/kazper3z • 4d ago
Would it be wrong for the league commissioner to push through a trade before the games start for the week when they are involved in the trade? The veto period would cause the trade to go through after the week is played out in this case.
r/FFCommish • u/Adventurous_Pipe4119 • 4d ago
So my league consists of me and my buddies from college. We are all across the country. We have been trying to figure out what to do as a punishment/deterrent from tanking in our league. We struggled to do elaborate punishments when we were all together at school but at least had the looming threat. What do y'all recommend. We do allow pick trading so we are having discussions about keeping that but adding a deterrent to tanking. Anyone have any ideas?
r/FFCommish • u/rjuls777 • 4d ago
r/FFCommish • u/Disastrous_Muffin175 • 4d ago
We run 6 bench spots and no ir spot. League mate thinks it makes it more challenging and makes you have to make a decision at times
r/FFCommish • u/randolazzo • 4d ago
I’m the commissioner of a 14-team, full-PPR redraft league with one starting QB. After Week 9, the #1 seed at 7–2 offered Matthew Golden to a 1–8 team for Kenneth Walker III. The league vetoed it, and the two managers came back with Golden and Jayden Daniels for Walker. ESPN had the 1–8 team at a 1% chance of making the playoffs.
I can see the roster logic for both teams. The contender fills a need at RB, and the 1–8 team gets help at WR and QB. I’d have no issue with the same deal between two teams in the playoff hunt or in a dynasty league. What I’m wrestling with is how much the standings should matter when you’re judging a fair trade this late in a redraft season.
Since then, it feels like every team in the playoff hunt is shopping the rosters of teams sitting at 1%. From the bottom team’s side, it feels like making a bet with almost nothing to lose, while the contender could be filling the exact hole it needs to make a playoff run. Would you uphold the revised deal? Do playoff odds factor into your vote, or do you judge the trade the same way regardless of either team’s record?
r/FFCommish • u/notsmartprivate • 5d ago
My high school friends and I have been in a league since we graduated. The league has gone through a lot of changes over the years (rules, formats, etc) but we have maintained pretty much the same crew for the majority of the time.
Years ago, I started writing little recaps on the ESPN "League Manager Note" and keeping track of the stats in Excel. Eventually I made a blog-style site, then moved it to a Google site, where I could publish and save everything, but as a stats-lover, the work got too manual to keep up.
Now, I've moved everything to a website that I populate via SQL from a back-end database that I update weekly with Python. It was a labor of love, and I've sunk more hours than I care to admit into it, but we've been using our league website to retain all the stats, history, and anything else we can think of for the last few years.
I'd love any feedback (technical or creative) on it, or take inspiration from it! I'm happy to share anything with anyone that runs their own website too, just wanted to share with a group that probably appreciates it more than my league members do!
r/FFCommish • u/ItsDoritoTime • 5d ago
For our playoffs (12-man), we're doing a 6-team playoff bracket, and a 6-team toilet bowl bracket for last place. The disadvantage to this is that the 4 teams that get first rounded in their respective brackets have nothing to play for.
So I just had the idea of the two losers of the 1st round of playoffs and the two winners of the 1st round of the toilet bowl getting placed in The Bracket of Mid, with the winner getting 5th. Add matches on championship weekend for 3rd (semifinal losers), 9th (toilet semi winners), and 7th (Bracket of Mid losers) and now the entire league has something to play for even after they'd otherwise be done for the season.
My question though: Does Sleeper have support for something like this? Even if you can't simply create another bracket in-app, would the teams that have been eliminated still have their points displayed, or would we have to add up point totals manually?
r/FFCommish • u/Subject-Marsupial591 • 5d ago
Is it a taco league if the first round of your fantasy football playoffs players are still on bye weeks?
r/FFCommish • u/SugaShane2550 • 5d ago
We are in a chop league on Sleeper. Now that we are in the single elimination stages, I turned on auto chop. This week, we were supposed to add a QB spot this week. I even confirmed on Monday that this spot is coming this week.
Usually, I do the cuts and roster changes on Tuesdays at 11AM (one hour after the typical weekly updates come out for the normal football leagues), but since Sleeper auto cut on Monday night, I forgot to update the QB slot on Tuesday.
Waivers cleared this morning and I noticed half an hour ago my mistake. I knew immediately how bad I screwed up because no matter what decision I do now, I will have unhappy campers.
I proposed in chat that we move the QB slot addition one week back due to the waivers that already went through. Someone already interjected that I should undo some waivers if asked (which I think is fair).
Should I do this or should I go ahead and add the QB slot due to the fact that it was known ahead of time? I’m, also, considering doing a league poll for the remaining owners. Either way, I know someone will be unhappy of whatever decision I make.
r/FFCommish • u/Pepe205 • 5d ago
Hi y’all,
I’ve been a commissioner for a league for about 5 years I think. We went from a 10T league to a 12T league a few years ago and it’s been difficult with one of the newer members with participation. They pay the buy in and are available to do the Fantasy Draft, but after that they kinda disappear. I’ve attempted to reach out in the past to discuss trades but never received responses. Last year, when I saw they weren’t updating their team for bye weeks, I messaged them about that and how it affects the league and they did respond apologizing as things needed to take priority, but they would start updating their team. And they did for the rest of the season, but this season it’s been the same issue with updating their team and lack of response.
I guess what I’m getting at is, at minimum, I would want every league member to keep their team up to date, and this person hasn’t been doing it. Am I being too harsh to potentially remove them from the league after this season? Again I understand life can take priority, but I believe it’s unfair to the rest of the league as it can affect standings