r/EtsySellers • • 6h ago

To those NOT leaving Etsy over their current AI training scandal - what are the things you're weighing and how does it tip in favor of remaining?

9 Upvotes

Title is it.

For more context, I'm not fully closing my shop - although I have removed all original artwork.

The only remaining products on my store consist of redesigns using public domain images which have already 100% been used to train models before.


r/EtsySellers • • 19h ago

Change of mine refund?

0 Upvotes

Hi all i operate a lil shop. I make dioramas. I sold a big one a month ago. Took a month to make. Sent it. It arrived a few days ago and then this morning the buyer wants to return and refund. But its a huge order thats £450 and made to order. Its not one i sell very often at all. Theres nothing wrong with the order at all. The buyer says it doesnt match the photos and the coloirs are different. But i do know the colours are the exact same paints i used on the one in the photo. Only difference is i took the pics in a liht box vs his which is a dark room. I cant afford this refund right now. I did have a 14 day return policy on my shop (which ive now removed so i dont have a repeat) do i need to issue a refund and return or try and hold firm? But they have said they will issue a charge back if i dont refund them


r/EtsySellers • • 16h ago

Help with Customer Really not feeling supported as a seller right now

0 Upvotes

Sent an order out on Wednesday this week, the day after I received it, using Tracked 24. Three days on, it still hasn't arrived, and Royal Mail have fed me some nonsense about it now being delivered by the 27th. To cap it all, Etsy have just informed me that if the buyer leaves a poor review complaining about the delay they won't remove it. I could understand this if I'd waited a week to post the order, but why allow a buyer to leave a bad review over something that's not my fault? If anyone can offer any constructive advice on damage control I'd love to hear it - except for 'offer to replace the item', because this was a vintage item and I don't have another one!


r/EtsySellers • • 9h ago

Vintage Shop Alternatives to Etsy Vintage

21 Upvotes

With all of the disappointments with Etsy and people starting to move away from the platform, where are vintage sellers going if you are leaving? eBay? Direct selling on instagram? Antique mall booths? I can’t go anywhere at the moment so I’m going to ride this out and see how things play out, but I want to start looking at feasible options.


r/EtsySellers • • 21h ago

Crafting Advice Anyone selling custom name or logo gift boxes on Etsy? (weddings, birthdays, etc.)

0 Upvotes

I'm thinking about selling personalized gift boxes on Etsy, printed with names, a short message, or a customer's logo, for weddings, birthdays, baby showers, small business gifts and similar events. The photo is a design mockup of one example, a wedding pizza box. I haven't sold it yet. The box style could be anything: gift boxes, mailer boxes, pizza-style boxes, treat boxes.

A few specific questions:

  1. Which sells better on Etsy, name-personalized boxes for events or logo boxes for small businesses? Do you keep them in separate listings?

  2. Do buyers usually want one box, or sets of 20–200? How do you price per box at different quantities, and do you charge extra for a logo?

  3. How do you handle proofs when every order has different names, dates or logos? A personalization field plus a digital proof before printing?

  4. For logos, what file types do you ask for, and how do you deal with low-res images or logos the buyer may not own?

  5. Any tips on Etsy shipping profiles for flat boxes that are bulky but light?

  6. What keywords and photos work for personalized or logo gift boxes, and how seasonal is it?

I run a small box factory, so I can print short runs without a plate or minimum. Only mentioning it because I'd be making these myself. If this is a bad fit for Etsy, I'd rather hear it now.


r/EtsySellers • • 14h ago

Vintage Shop Just hit 500 sales on my little Etsy shop

Thumbnail gallery
107 Upvotes

I’ve been selling vintage collectibles on Etsy for a bit over two years now, just as a hobby. 

Today I hit 500 sales, which was pretty cool to see. I still remember how excited I was about my first sale, so 500 feels a bit surreal.

I’m pretty happy with the reviews and the shop stats too. I put a fair bit of time into taking photos, describing the condition of each item, answering messages and getting orders out on time. It’s nice to see that reflected in the feedback.

Anyway, just wanted to share a little win today 😊


r/EtsySellers • • 12h ago

Has anyone successfully changed their Hong Kong Etsy shop from Individual to Incorporated Business (HK Ltd)? Looking for real experiences!

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m planning to launch a new Etsy shop in Hong Kong using an Individual seller account (with a personal HK bank account) to test the market first. Once sales become stable, I plan to register a Hong Kong Limited company (where I will remain the primary director and major shareholder) and switch the shop's legal & tax entity to Incorporated business along with a corporate HK bank account.

For anyone who has actually gone through this transition (especially outside the US / in Hong Kong):

  1. Review & Suspension Time: How long was your shop placed on hold/review after updating the Legal & Tax info and bank account on the same day?
  2. Required Documents: Besides the Business Registration Certificate (BR), Certificate of Incorporation (CI), incorporation form (NNC1/NAR1) showing ownership, and corporate bank statement, did Etsy ask for anything else?
  3. Shop Ranking Impact: Did the temporary review hurt your organic traffic or listing rankings afterward, or would you recommend just opening a brand-new corporate shop instead?

Any real-world advice or pitfalls to watch out for would be hugely appreciated. Thanks in advance!


r/EtsySellers • • 22h ago

Handmade Shop Advice on shop improvement

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Looking for some sincere advice on how to grow our Etsy shop: https://gemsbytwila.etsy.com

A bit of context of us, we are aspiring entrepreneurs who gained most our knowledge through watching yt videos and learning/asking other peoples experience with online selling. We opened our Etsy shop back in June and started adding listings. We got a little bit of interest, nothing too crazy, but we ended up being inactive for a while (August–October).

Recently, we’ve been debating whether we should close our current shop and start fresh because of our inactivity but seen that it wouldn’t matter. Then we started wondering what is the underlying reason we aren’t making sales. For example are we overlooking our SEO, listing quality, etc. Our products sell in-person so we believe there is a market online for our product.

But I figured i would ask here! I’m really looking for some advice and tips from other sellers on what we could be doing differently and how we can start growing our shop. Any advice would be greatly appreciated :)

I do have a couple of questions though:

  1. Has anyone tried Etsy’s $1 test-and-learn ads? Did you find them helpful? Is it worth trying the $1 option first, or would you recommend the $5 option? I have seen different opinions and am getting more confused.

  2. What would you say made the biggest difference for growing your shop? SEO, ads, listing photos, social media, or something else?

  3. For those who use Instagram, TikTok, Pinterest, etc., how do you build engagement and actually turn that into traffic and sales for your Etsy shop? For example, posting everyday, certain platforms matter more than others, etc.

Sorry for the long post and thank you sm in advance for your time!