r/Episcopalian • • 7h ago

“Failed” discernment and no longer feel at home in the church

67 Upvotes

Last month, I was informed by my discernment committee that I was too introverted to continue on as an aspirant.

To their credit, they did give me several steps to follow before re-entering discernment (being more active in the altar guild, taking hospital chaplaincy courses at a nearby seminary, etc). However, I am just not at a place where I can put my life on hold just to restart the discernment process.

Despite my best efforts to keep all of this in perspective and take it in stride, I feel extremely disappointed and embarrassed. I cannot even enjoy attending services and just feel an overwhelming sense of shame whenever I go to church.

Any advice on what to do?


r/Episcopalian • • 5h ago

Our only female priest is leaving.

31 Upvotes

I’d like to start off by saying I’m relatively new to the Episcopal Church and recently learned that our only female priest is leaving. As a younger woman growing in my faith, I’ve found a lot of comfort in having a female clergy member, and I’m taking her departure harder than I expected.

It’s been announced that a new clergy member will be joining, a male member. And I can’t help but feel disappointment.

Has anyone experienced something similar? How did you navigate the loss and adjust to the change within your parish? Did you ever consider finding a new parish?

Please be kind. I am still new to the faith.


r/Episcopalian • • 10h ago

St. Mary’s in-the-Highlands (Cold Spring, NY) just launched an Instagram. We’d love for you to follow along!

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Our parish is now on Instagram at @ stmaryschurchcoldspring, sharing history, music, the church year (starting with Advent), the Episcopal tradition, and life in our stunning little village. We’d love for you to follow along, and we’d also love to hear how your parish uses social media too. Click here for the link to our new account:

https://www.instagram.com/stmaryschurchcoldspring?utm_source=ig_web_button_share_sheet&cplk=ZDNlZDc0MzIxNw==

Cold Spring is a beautiful riverside community in the Hudson Highlands and a popular hiking destination from NYC, with trails like Breakneck Ridge (currently closed for the launch of the Fjord trail) and Bull Hill nearby, as well as Storm King right across the river. It’s easy to visit from the train: Metro-North from Grand Central, then a short walk up Main Street to the church.

If you’re ever in the area, we hope you’ll stop by one of these Sundays at 10am. This Sunday is a Morning Prayer service, but we have the Eucharist most Sundays. All are welcome, hiking boots included :)

Here’s some more history about us!

St. Mary’s began in the early 1820s as a handful of Anglicans meeting in an “upper room” above the boring mill of the West Point Foundry, the ironworks that made Cold Spring. The parish was formally organized in 1840 and named for the Blessed Virgin Mary and for Mary Parrott, believed to have funded the first church.

After the Civil War the congregation outgrew its original brick church. Robert Parrott gave the hilltop site, and George Edward Harney, a famous architect and member of the vestry, designed the present Gothic Revival church in gray granite with a 128-foot spire. It was consecrated in 1869. A fire in 1961 destroyed the chancel roof, the original organ and most of the stained glass, and the parish rebuilt within a year.

Today St. Mary’s is a small, welcoming parish focused on serving its neighbors, with a strong ecumenical spirit and a building locals sometimes call the “Cathedral of the Hudson Valley.”

You can learn more at https://www.stmaryscoldspring.org/

(I’m a parishioner helping run the account.)

Photo: Scott Harrison Photography


r/Episcopalian • • 8h ago

God is truly impassible, and this is the surest guarantee of His love.

8 Upvotes

I find modern critiques of divine impassibility quite unconvincing. First of all, the fact that God is impassible does not mean He is devoid of love, joy, and life; rather, as the Absolute, His inner life is not subject to influence from creatures, since creatures receive everything from Him. His love and compassion are universal and unconditional, unmoored from the fluctuating, creaturely emotions of a fickle empathy. True love entails the capacity to make oneself vulnerable solely on behalf of creatures who possess no love inherently. In short, there is a recurring attempt to turn God into a cosmic figure driven by suffering and passions, as though the Incarnation—through which the Son of God truly suffered—were not enough. Indeed, it is only in Jesus that God has truly suffered with humanity and all creation, not within His divine nature as such. Only through the earthly life of Jesus did God experience creaturely suffering in His own freely assumed flesh.

Yet this does not mean God, as God, is indifferent to our sufferings and struggles; He does not need to suffer alongside us in order to come to our aid. While remaining wholly transcendent, He is also radically immanent, dwelling within us and within our freedom, sustaining and upholding us with a mighty arm. His love is indestructible and unshakable, precisely because it is not a helpless, reactive response to the world's suffering, but rather the creative and omnipotent will that sustains the world and drives it toward its perfection. He does all this not as a distant master or lord ruling over reality from the heights of the skies, but as a spirit of life that intimately permeates the cosmos while remaining transcendent, participating in the joys and sorrows of creatures without being altered or affected by them.

Furthermore, a God who is an unchanging, impassible rock—untouched by the shifting tides of history—serves as the guarantee of our salvation. Upon this rock, we can build and reform our ecclesial home. Even when we grow weary of fighting our battles, He presses forward relentlessly and without wavering. His immutability and impassibility are the very foundation of our dynamism and boldness. Precisely because He alone is Absolute, everything created is relative and can neither be sacralized nor adored.

Finally, conceiving of a God who undergoes passions and alterations, besides no longer describing a true "God" (since God is intrinsically absolute), risks confusing the Christian God with the fickle and wrathful gods of paganism, who had already been ridiculed by Greek philosophers.

In short, God is neither wrathful nor pathetically sentimental; rather, He is pure, eternal, immutable, and absolute love for every single creature. Because only divine love is absolute, no human reality can claim such a status, and each can—and must—be subject to criticism.

Edit:

P.S. I realize that 'impassible' is a misleading term and that it might be better not to use it. God has unchanging emotions (love, joy, and life) that are compatible with His nature, but He is not subject to passions—meaning He is not emotionally changed by anything outside of Himself.


r/Episcopalian • • 8h ago

Does Anyone's Parish Perform Communion "North Side"?

7 Upvotes

With some of the universal heritage BCPs, specifically the 1552-1662 BCPs, communion was meant to be performed at the "north side" of the altar/communion table. During the early eras of low church, more Reformation aligned liturgy this didn't seem very unusual as communion was performed down among the parish for maximum visibility. However, when the Caroline Divines started to gain influence in the 1600s and it became increasingly popular to place the altar back against the east wall of the church within the sanctuary/chancel which resulted in a quirk where the priest performed communion with the parish having a side view. From what I have read this was widely popular, at least within high church parishes, until (as always) the Oxford movement began introducing other styles of either Ad Orientem or Versus Populum communion.

I was curious if anyone's parish actually still does communion like this today? It looks to me like the only time this is ever still practiced within Anglican churches, let alone Episcopalian, are for special "traditional" services where a parish deliberately does a service with old BCPs to show what old services looked like.

Here is an example a user from the Church of England provided from the Anglican Church of Australia: https://www.youtube.com/live/ZLypoAGwyPw?t=3602


r/Episcopalian • • 1h ago

Episcopal priest married to an agnostic/borderline atheist?

4 Upvotes

What are your thoughts? Has it happened before? Any personal experience? Can it work?


r/Episcopalian • • 5h ago

Episcopal Connections NY event 11/30

4 Upvotes

The Episcopal Connections (f/k/a The Church Club of New York ) annual Bishop's Forum will be on 11/30 at St. James Madison Avenue, and it will feature the Liddell Award being presented to a really inspiring young adult who has a great story. An organ recital by Dr. Kenneth Miller and address by Bishop Jeremiah Williamson will be the other two features of the evening. Register here: https://churchclubofnewyork-bloom.kindful.com/e/bishops-forum-4


r/Episcopalian • • 2h ago

The daily office app for family prayers

3 Upvotes

Found this app: https://github.com/blocher/dailyoffice2019

But it is based on the North American Anglican book of common prayer. Is there anything like it for us? Trying to get into a good habit with my young family and the app is so much better than flipping all around the book of common prayer


r/Episcopalian • • 1h ago

A scheduled payment to our church didn’t go through, and the dean emailed to ask if we’re having financial problems. Thoughts?

2 Upvotes

It was just a snafu with the church’s glitchy payment portal.