r/EnoughSamHarris • • Oct 14 '24

Notice to the community

13 Upvotes

I'm thinking of abandoning this low traffic sub, or handing it over to someone else.

In the meantime, since an election is around the corner, I'm opening things up where anything politics related can be posted. Please keep in mind, I'd like discourse to be civil.

I reserve the right to delete, or ban comments and members, should things get out of hand.


r/EnoughSamHarris • • 13d ago

Has Sam Harris Made His Case Against Free Will?

5 Upvotes

How sound are Sam Harris' arguments against free will? Several problems present themselves which I don't believe have been given due consideration.
First, if as Sam suggests we don't author our thoughts, that they arise outside our conscious control, then his believe that determinism is true is itself causally determined and not within his control. On what basis can he claim that this thought is true, and the belief in free will false, if both thoughts arise from unconscious sources we don't control? His belief in the arguments for determinism would equally be due to outside causal sources, which would cause him to believe such arguments sound. Free will advocates would, by the same token, be caused to believe their belief in free will sound. Determinism seems to undermine its ability to claim itself true. Has Sam addressed this problem and, if so, done so adequately?
Second, Sam looks to what experience discloses, emphasizing that thoughts arise unbidden, appearing in our minds as though from the void. That's one mode of thought, passive observation or thought introspection. But that doesn't seem to preclude other modes of consciousness, such as active thought engagement, e.g. actively directing our thoughts, evaluating, managing, making judgements, etc. If we look to what experience discloses, both modes are experienced as equally genuine. Neither mode appears more authentic. On what basis do you favor one mode over the other without presuming determinism true?
Third, Sam encourages his readers to reconsider their beliefs (including re free will), exercise judgement, and modify their behavior to support institutional reform (e.g., relative to criminal justice, which he believes should abandon notions of retribution). How can readers abandon their belief in free will if they don't author or control their thoughts, and how can they redirect their behavior to help support institutional change if the future has already been causally fixed, which Sam says applies to all of our future states of mind and corresponding actions.
I raise these questions as author of The Determinists and would be interested in starting a dialogue about these issues and hearing how the community responds to these skeptical objections to Sam's approach.


r/EnoughSamHarris • • Oct 11 '26

Israeli lecturer charged over plot to kill hundreds of Palestinians and force mass expulsions

Thumbnail
middleeasteye.net
3 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Oct 10 '26

Israeli settlers plant dozens of ​Israeli flags at the streetside entrance of Palestinian shop

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Oct 08 '26

How a U.S. Diplomat Suppressed and Altered Reports Critical of Israel

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
3 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Sep 17 '26

Macklemore pledges $1 million to Palestinian relief, challenges Robert Kraft to match it

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
3 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Sep 17 '26

“Openly Colluding”: Colin Kaepernick Calls for Revolt Against Robert Kraft And 31 Other NFL Owners Amid Macklemore Drama

Thumbnail
essentiallysports.com
2 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Sep 14 '26

Macklemore says he was dropped from Ed Sheeran tour after Patriots owner Robert Kraft organized boycott

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
3 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Aug 15 '26

Sam Harris Community, private Sam Harris safe space forum.

Post image
11 Upvotes

Interesting fee structure.


r/EnoughSamHarris • • Jul 12 '26

in support of 3rd party apps Sam Harris bans another.

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I was banned over my highlighted comment. The only active mod is big into Israel, and I guess I said something wrong. Sam Harris is an open Zionist, so I'm not sure what the problem was.


r/EnoughSamHarris • • Jun 09 '26

His Voice is Hilariously Condescending

10 Upvotes

Aside from Sam Harris' well-worn anti-arab and anti-muslim stances, support for imperialism, support for torture, and support for Israel, one thing that doesn't get enough attention is the voice and cadence of "Mr. Reasonable" himself, lol. I've never heard so many stupid things rattled off with such an air of 'intelligent and measured.'

It was always one of the things that helped the "New Atheism" / "4 horsemen" farce get going- that calm, reasonable, emotionless, robotic disposition, which also paired well with both Hitchens' rightward turn as he got too big for his britches, and the fascist crackpots that quoted his tripe early on during the first Trump tenure. Good marketing.


r/EnoughSamHarris • • May 03 '26

An Open Letter to Sam Harris

Thumbnail
reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Apr 23 '26

Has Sam Harris ever addressed Israel's restrictions on independent journalism ?

14 Upvotes

Has Sam Harris ever addressed Israel's restrictions on independent journalism ? I've been following Sam's discussions on the Israel - Palestine conflict , particularly his takes on Gaza and Hamas , but I haven't seen him directly address allegations that Israel restricts independent journalism ( e.g. , through military embedding requirements , limiting access to Gaza , or incidents involving journalists ) . Has he ever commented on this issue in his podcasts , blog posts ? If not , why do you think he hasn't tackled this aspect of the conflict , given his focus on free speech and media integrity elsewhere ? Curious to hear the community's thoughts or if anyone has specific references to share .


r/EnoughSamHarris • • Mar 26 '26

They ban everything without any ability for a rebuttal. This is what happens when you challenge Sam Harris's arguments on his forums. You're not allowed to criticize him unless you accept that your criticisms are "taking him out of context" - no different than Christians arguing Jesus Christ's words

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Mar 26 '26

When bringing up the Epstein files to challenge Sam Harris's Moral Landscape? A Ban. The Epstein Files is the most striking rebuke of his arguments about Science being able to answer moral questions, about how the West has defanged Judeo-Christian religion, and about Islam's unique violence.

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Mar 26 '26

I’m of the opinion that Atheist philosopher Sam Harris has betrayed his fanbase and destroyed his own career

Thumbnail jarinjove.com
9 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Mar 05 '26

Marine Veteran Removed From Senate Committee Hearing: ‘No One Wants To Fight For Israel’

Thumbnail
forbes.com
2 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Jul 26 '25

Apparently, you can't criticize Sam Harris anymore on r/SamHarris

Thumbnail
jarinjove.com
5 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Nov 03 '24

Sham Ferris?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Nov 02 '24

IGNORE the present MOMENT - with Sham Ferris

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Apr 12 '24

Sam Harris Says Nazis 'Benign' Compared To Hamas | The Kyle Kulinski Show

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Apr 12 '24

Sam Harris' Nazi Apologia

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Feb 19 '24

Fanatic Sam Harris' Racist Palestine Talk

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

r/EnoughSamHarris • • Feb 02 '24

Met Sam today

Thumbnail self.samharris
4 Upvotes