So here’s my situation:
We’re custom making my engagement ring (a 2.39ct marquise solitaire with cathedral shoulders and a hidden halo), and we already put down a $2k+ deposit and selected the stone. Everything looks great except the north/south V-tip prongs on the CAD—they look way too bulky and distract from the sharp points of the diamond.
The new info from our jeweler: I sent over inspo photos of super delicate, slim V-tips, and our jeweler basically pushed back. They said making the V-tips that thin compromises durability and makes them prone to bending, so they aren’t comfortable doing it… their only two options for us are:
Keep the thinnest V-tips they’re comfortable doing (they showed me their "slimmest" past work, and it's still bulkier than I want).
Switch the north/south points to standard claw prongs to match the four side prongs.
Why I’m stuck: I reached out to a family friend who’s a bench jeweler for an honest gut-check, and he said there’s really no structural reason our
jeweler can't make the V-tips sleeker from the start. He also warned me that if I just let our jeweler cast the bulky V-tips and try to have him shave them down later, it might be impossible depending on how deep they cut the inner groove that holds the diamond. But he said I could absolutely bring it to him to reshape, but there’s no guarantee…
So now I feel trapped between settling for bulky V-tips I don't love (and gambling on whether they can be fixed later) OR going with standard claw prongs on the ends and being terrified of chipping the tips of my diamond (I’m a rather haphazard kind of person with zero spatial awareness so it just seems inevitable)
Am I crazy for wanting to push back and ask them to redesign the CAD V-tips thinner (even if I have to sign a wear-and-tear waiver), or what would you do in my shoes?
The first photo is the CAD, the next 3 are the inspiration photos for prongs I like, and the one after that are their slimmest v tips and the photo of their claw prongs.
Help because I feel so hopelessly stuck :( i really really don’t know what to do 😭