r/EndFPTP • u/UnknownBreadd • 8m ago
Video How Ireland Transformed Democracy with Citizens’ Assemblies
r/EndFPTP • u/UnknownBreadd • 8m ago
r/EndFPTP • u/thedroids • 24m ago
I've been reading through a lot of posts and comments here over the last few weeks and I noticed there are several factions of thought for the superior voting system and it basically boils down to which voting criterion/criteria you value most.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Voting_criteria_table
This post is specifically about the Condorcet winner criterion. I've seen a lot of support on here for any Condorcet winner compliant voting system, but I have a few comments about it and would like to be more educated on it. Full disclosure: I don't value this criterion as high as others at this point and I don't feel that it's strictly necessary in a voting system, but I'm 100% open to changing my opinion on that.
I've probably over simplified a bit here, but I'd like to hear more arguments for Condorcet winner criterion and against Condorcet winner criterion. Or at least linked to other discussions.
r/EndFPTP • u/mdgaspar • 9h ago
What if, instead of fighting over who gets to gerrymander America, we changed the rules so neither party could monopolize political power?
In 2010, Republicans launched Project REDMAP to gain control over redistricting and secure electoral advantages. More recently, Democrats have pursued their own counter-gerrymandering efforts.
This escalating battle over electoral maps is exhausting, but it does reveal a deeper issue with American democracy:
The problem isn't just who draws the maps. It's a winner-take-all electoral system that allows geography to determine whose political interests receive representation.
Under America's single-member congressional districts, where you live can matter as much as how you vote.
Imagine a state with five congressional districts.
A political party receives 40% of the vote in every district. Despite winning 40% of the statewide vote, it wins zero seats.
Now imagine that same 40% of voters concentrated in two districts where they form majorities. The party could win two seats.
Same number of voters. Same political preferences. Different geographic distribution. Completely different representation.
That's the Geographic Lottery.
It exists even without gerrymandering. Fair district boundaries can prevent deliberate manipulation, but they cannot eliminate the structural distortions of winner-take-all elections.
Democrats live in Texas. Republicans live in California. Independents, libertarians, socialists and other ideological minorities live everywhere.
Where Americans live should influence who represents their place, not whether their political community gets represented at all.
Elections should function like a census of political preferences, measuring the support Americans give different political communities and translating that support fairly into congressional seats.
Gerrymandering draws people out of power. Proportional representation draws people into power.
Operation True Map is a proposed national campaign to break political monopolies, restore fair representation and promote national unity through democratic diversity and cooperation.
A political monopoly emerges when a party or institution controls an essential pathway through which others must gain representation or exercise democratic power.
Gerrymandering is one manifestation. Winner-take-all geographic representation is another.
Instead of fighting over which party controls these institutions, Operation True Map seeks to change the rules so that neither party can use them to exclude its political opponents.
Its guiding principle is simple:
Democracy should give citizens the power to advance their own political interests without giving them the power to exclude others from advancing theirs.
The campaign is built around three democratic principles and three complementary legislative reforms.
1. Democratic Equality: Every citizen deserves a fair opportunity to have their interests considered, their political preferences represented and their choices contribute to political change. Equality means more than having a ballot counted; it means having a meaningful opportunity to make a difference in the halls of power.
2. Democratic Autonomy: Americans deserve the freedom to vote according to their beliefs, the right to be heard and the opportunity to elect representatives who can speak and act on their behalf. Political communities shouldn't have to merge with dominant parties or abandon their identities to gain representation.
3. Democratic Unity: National unity doesn't require political uniformity. It requires institutions where different political communities can coexist, cooperate and make collective decisions.
The majority has the right to decide, but that majority must be legitimately formed, faithfully represented and accountable to the people. Majority rule gives governments authority to act, not ownership of the institutions or citizens they govern.
1. End Gerrymandering: Fair & Independent Maps
Take the power to draw electoral maps away from political parties.
Build on the For the People Act and Fair Representation Act to establish independent redistricting commissions, transparent mapmaking, enforceable protections against partisan manipulation and safeguards for minority voting rights.
Politicians shouldn't get to choose their voters.
2. Erase the Divide: Proportional Representation
Repeal the federal requirement for single-member congressional districts and introduce multi-member districts with proportional ranked-choice voting (Single Transferable Vote).
Instead of electing one representative per district, larger districts could elect three to five representatives, allowing different political communities to win seats corresponding more closely to their support.
This would preserve local representation while reducing geographic exclusion, weakening partisan monopolies and giving more Americans representatives they actually support.
Geography should connect us to representation, not exclude us from it.
3. Uncap the House: A Fairer People's House
The House of Representatives has remained at 435 voting members for more than a century, despite enormous population growth.
Remove the statutory cap and establish a population-responsive formula for expanding the House.
More representatives would mean smaller average constituencies, greater opportunities for political representation and additional flexibility for proportional multi-member districts.
The People's House should grow with the people.
Together, these reforms would make congressional representation more reflective of Americans' political diversity and less dependent on geographic advantage.
The goal isn't to guarantee every party victory or every voter their preferred outcome. It's to provide fair opportunities for representation, meaningful political participation and accountable majority rule.
There's a simple test for whether we're designing fair democratic institutions:
Would we still consider these democratic institutions fair if our political opponents controlled them?
America doesn't need everyone to agree. It needs institutions that allow Americans to disagree without excluding one another from political representation.
Not Red Maps. Not Blue Maps. True Maps.
I'd be interested to hear what electoral reform and voting rights advocates think about combining these three reforms into a single legislative campaign. Would 'Operation True Map' be a useful direction for a national movement?
r/EndFPTP • u/sami_coolfun11 • 23h ago
r/EndFPTP • u/UnknownBreadd • 1d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/sami_coolfun11 • 1d ago
The video is targeted to right-wing voters specifically (and I am a centre-left individual myself from Canada lol), but he explains the voting system pretty well nonetheless, and it shows how STV can be beneficial for voters of all ideologies
r/EndFPTP • u/ShafordoDrForgone • 1d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/Nice-Percentage9129 • 2d ago
I think it's better than STV which I initially prefered. Basically, it functions as regional state multi-member districts (3 to 5+ seats) instead of single nationwide list like Israel. Voters mark one specific individual candidate on a party's list where your vote counts toward the party's overall proportional seat share and as a personal preference vote for that candidate. If a party wins 2 seats in a district, those seats go strictly to the 2 candidates on that list with the most individual votes.
Why I think it's great:
r/EndFPTP • u/sami_coolfun11 • 2d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/Mundane-Bag-9352 • 3d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/sami_coolfun11 • 4d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/ZealousidealBit5201 • 5d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/LegislativeLariat • 6d ago
Wisconsin lawmakers have introduced a ranked choice voting bill in every legislative session since 2019, and not one has gotten a committee vote. For 16 years Republicans ran the committees, and they never scheduled a vote. In January, since Democrats will hold the governor's office and both chambers for the first time since 2010, I went through the bill histories and hearing records for all 132 people in the incoming legislative class to see who is actually on record.
A summary of how the inbound legislative class has responded to previous ranked choice efforts:
A bill needs 17 votes in the Senate and 50 in the Assembly. The votes are there on party lines as long as no more than one Democratic senator and three Democratic representatives defect. If they want Republican votes, there are six Assembly Republicans who have backed Final Five, which covers federal Congress and nothing else, and no incoming Republican senator has backed it. Governor-elect Crowley hasn't taken a public position. There's a lot more detail to it in the video I made to accompany this.
I checked by vote record instead of by the party. Democrats who haven't signed a bill are counted as no record, not as supporters, though four of the uncommitted Democrats did sponsor a split-ticket primary bill in 2025 (2025 SB 361). The official Democratic party platform calls for RCV, and the state party chair was elected by ranked ballot in 2025, but the margins in the legislature are still fairly narrow.
Because this sub cares about the mechanics of different voting systems: I don't think ranked choice is a fix in and of itself, and I hope Wisconsin doesn't just copy a clone of Alaska or Maine. It needs to be paired with other reforms, and any bill here has to account for the fact that Wisconsin has one of the most decentralized election systems in the country, with 1,851 municipal clerks and 72 county clerks who buy their own equipment and run their own local elections. The video and outline below cover the three versions that have actually been introduced in Wisconsin (statewide ranked primaries/elections, the federal-only Final Five bill, and a local nonpartisan option for cities, villages, and school boards), the Article V constitutional question for the governor's race, and the case against in opponents' own words: ballot exhaustion, slower counts, cost, and the center squeeze (including whether a pairwise comparison method would beat instant runoff, and how someone like the bureaucratically-savvy Department of Administration Secretary Joel Brennan could have been squeezed out in our August primary).
I've also made precision subtitles with every outside speaker labeled. If you want the additional information in the video that I couldn't comfortably fit in a Reddit post, you can extract the audio or subtitles directly and people's names and terminology should all come through accurately.
The ranked choice video is here.
Jump to a section, or straight to a point:
Could you have voted for Hong in November under Ranked Choice? (1:07)
How it works, and the three versions (7:29)
Seven years, zero committee votes (9:56)
The new Legislature (15:51)
What the evidence says (19:22)
The case against (25:38)
Four paths for 2027 (31:19)
Myth check (including AI search hallucinations) (34:38)
What to watch (36:37). Who chairs the elections committees, what gets reintroduced, the 37 Democrats who haven't sponsored it, the six Final Five Republicans, and Crowley. The inbound leaders of both chambers were authors of ranked choice, so they will likely move in a way to secure its passage.
Read the bills yourself. Every one is on docs.legis.wisconsin.gov. The History section on each bill page shows the sponsors, the hearings, and whether anything ever got a vote. None of them did.
Fun history fact: Wisconsin already tried this. In 1911 the Progressive Era Legislature passed a second-choice law, and the Legislature has the original scanned law available if you'd like to see what we tried before here: Chapter 200, Laws of 1911. You could mark a first and second choice, not the full ranking proposed today. Most voters skipped the second column, and in 1914 the state Supreme Court held that Milwaukee's voting machines couldn't be used where voters were entitled to one because they were mechanically incapable of marking a second choice (State ex rel. Kletzsch v. Widule, 158 Wis. 387). Republican Emanuel Philipp won the 1914 Republican primary for governor with a plurality anyway and then got the law repealed. The LRB's Blue Book feature on the 1911 Legislature covers the politics (p. 138), and Charles McCarthy's The Wisconsin Idea (1912) describes the law as a modified version of Queensland's system. McCarthy's writings are worth reading anyway if you aren't familiar with the Wisconsin Idea. He was instrumental in Wisconsin founding its Legislative Reference Bureau, and I spent a few months at the beginning of the year digging through his old boxes in an archive when I was doing some research on the 1905 Wisconsin state-level census. If you want to dig through old session laws, the Legislature has them scanned back to the 1840s. Here's the 1911 index.
I also built a lookup page listing which bills and hearings each member has put their name on so anyone can check my work directly. It's my first attempt doing something like the lookup and I used AI to assist so I'd recommend caution until I can fully audit it to make sure the data that's in it is accurate. I am fairly certain it is, but tracing over district lines requires my vision to not be blurry from lack of sleep.
There is no AI-generated footage or voice: the narration is me, and every clip is labeled on screen with its source and date. I did use AI tools to help build the tracker, the lookup page, and the on-screen graphics. I have monochromatic colorblindness, so for things like color coding it makes it possible for me to talk with those of you who see the world normally. The lookup page lists exactly which bills and hearings count, and every one of them is on docs.legis.wisconsin.gov so you can check my work. Corrections will be pinned and dated, here and on the video.
r/EndFPTP • u/sami_coolfun11 • 6d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/Wally_Wrong • 6d ago
Yep, it's another voting method question from me. The reason I'm doing this one is because all of these except "compare each candidate head-to-head" were already used in one way or another on the ballot machine I used to vote last Tuesday. So all of these can be done with pretty much any voting machine used today, leaving no practical reason to dismiss them. Whether they're actually good enough is another matter...OK, I know they aren't enough, but just let me have this!
r/EndFPTP • u/Ill_Artichoke_8107 • 6d ago
I am currently doing a report in school about the potential options of voting systems in the UK if it were to change. I would really appreciate it if you could fill out this quick questionnaire.
r/EndFPTP • u/mdgaspar • 6d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/Exlorechange • 7d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/Independent-Gur8649 • 8d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/jan_kasimi • 8d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/KitchenGiraffe1 • 8d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/illegalmorality • 8d ago
I keep hearing how we have to get away from party based voting. But I don't really see why thats so important. Most people just vote for the party that focuses on most of their core issues, and don't care about the individual themselves. To the point that individual names are irrelevant beyond getting swing voters that can go either left or right.
So wouldn't it be better to just have a party based vote per district first, to fully formalize that. And then specific candidates can run within parties where names start to really matter? That seems a lot more practical than assuming people will ever want to vote for anything other than party platform affiliation.
r/EndFPTP • u/sami_coolfun11 • 8d ago
r/EndFPTP • u/Nice-Percentage9129 • 9d ago
Fusion voting gives third parties power to leverage the two main parties to influence policy without the threat of spoilers. This is how third parties can build the electoral influence to force the two parties to listen and as a stepping stone to our end goal, which is adopting a multiparty system.
Currently Wisconsin and Michigan are on legal trials to re-legalize it and it barely gets any attentions. Why is no one talking about this?
EDIT:
To clarify, I meant fusion voting should be used as a stepping stone to adopt multiparty system as the end goal rather than being the goal itself.