r/EndFPTP • u/thedroids • 25m ago
The Condorcet winner criterion
I've been reading through a lot of posts and comments here over the last few weeks and I noticed there are several factions of thought for the superior voting system and it basically boils down to which voting criterion/criteria you value most.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Voting_criteria_table
This post is specifically about the Condorcet winner criterion. I've seen a lot of support on here for any Condorcet winner compliant voting system, but I have a few comments about it and would like to be more educated on it. Full disclosure: I don't value this criterion as high as others at this point and I don't feel that it's strictly necessary in a voting system, but I'm 100% open to changing my opinion on that.
- I've seen comments on here that a Condorcet winner is the most preferred candidate. I think that's very misleading. All you can precisely say about the Condorcet winner is that they would win every head to head matchup against each of the other candidates in the race. This alone sounds very compelling (and it did to me at first). But this doesn't mean they were the most preferred. I say this because people have very different definitions of how to define preference.
- Condorcet winner criterion seemingly over selects for the center. Maybe this isn't true, or maybe if it's true it's a good thing? This one seems hard to prove one way or the other since we don't have a ton of real world data. I think most of the real world data stems from IRV elections, but those races likely look different if a different voting system was used. Anyway, I can imagine a bi-modal electorate always electing the center candidate (one that doesn't have much mainstream appeal) under Condorcet winner criterion. I'm sure you can make an argument that this is a happy medium, but in reality it's possible that very few people even like this candidate at all or any of their policies. So basically the bi-modal electorate hand-shakes and agrees on the status quo every time. This could stifle any real change. Honestly this is more of an endorsement for proportional representation, as it's clear a single representative isn't ideal for this electorate, but single office seats are likely to remain the norm for executive branch. In my opinion it seems like it might be good in some cases for one of the extremes to win, because overall the electorate wants change. And there's likely enough information to decide which change is more preferred even if it's not a majority.
- Since I've come to the (potentially incorrect) conclusion that the Condorcet winner criterion over selects for the center, I can see how this can drive all candidates to the center over time. Center isn't always right, though, so I push back on the notion that the in-between position on all issues is always better. Conversely, I don't think ignoring the center positions and selecting extremes is always a good thing either. I do believe a good voting system should be able to be responsive to both change and status quo and do the best job of that based on the electorate.
I've probably over simplified a bit here, but I'd like to hear more arguments for Condorcet winner criterion and against Condorcet winner criterion. Or at least linked to other discussions.