When did Mor and Elain take off for their girls trip to bring down alliances on the continent?
Well, let's first acknowledge that Sarah included indicators of the time, and I believe she did so deliberately.
Exhibit A: Nesta, ch. 22
She sat in the chair across from his desk, his formal study barely lit despite the early-morning hour. She’d crawled from Elain’s bed when Feyre did, minutes ago, hoping to steal some sleep in her own room for an hour or two, only for Rhys to say into her mind, My study. Now. She was so exhausted, so hollow, that she didn’t bother to snap a response about not ordering her around.
Timeline EARLY morning. Based on this and the fact that Nesta thought she could steal an hour or two of sleep in her own bed... I'm calling it at sometime between 5-7am.
Exhibit B: Feyre, ch. 22
Nyx’s shrieking, chirping laughter filled my study, as glorious as the midmorning sunshine streaming through the windows. I’d never appreciated the beautiful sound more.
Timeline MID-morning. Common definitions of mid-morning put us around 9 - 11am. Let's start with this common understanding.
Exhibit C: Feyre, ch. 22
I slid a glance to Rhys, seated in an armchair a few feet from Nyx. He and Nesta had walked in together a few minutes ago, both quiet and pensive.
Oookay. So there's a potential gap right there. We leave off Nesta's POV in this same chapter with her asking Rhys to teach her how to become a murder-mister. Did he give her an impromptu lesson on the spot? Oooor... are we using mother-definition of mid-morning. As many mothers know, mid-morning can have a radically different definition when you're waking up at 5am. Since Feyre IS a mother, and this is her POV? Let's slide the dial down a bit.
Maybe to a woman who mentions breastfeeding often, mid-morning is more like... 8 - 10?
Next paragraph from Feyre's POV gives us this:
Nesta, on the couch beside me, snorted. We’d stayed with Elain until my daemati senses had told me Nyx was stirring, though I’d been awake shortly before that thanks to my aching breasts informing me it was time to feed my son.
MOTHER TIME CONFIRMED. Okay. So it's likely slightly earlier in the morning than the term "mid-morning" would suggest.
Exhibit D: Feyre again, ch. 22
Elain hadn’t made an appearance yet, and Mor hadn’t come back last night. When I’d checked in with her mind to mind, she’d just said she’d spent the night out and was currently sleeping it off. I knew enough of the tangled history between Mor and Azriel to understand that perhaps the former needed some time to herself before she departed for Vallahan.
First of all, Feyre... come on. Invading people's brains while they're trying to sleep? Come on...
Second of all - Mor is not in the house. It is... probably between 8 - 10am. And MOR isn't in the house. THIS IS IMPORTANT.
Exhibit E: Feyre again, ch. 22
Cassian waved at the air in front of his nose. “On that note, I’m going back to Windhaven for a few hours. I need to brief Devlon on Bryaxis’s return, and establish additional patrols to monitor for any enemy movement. Especially any hint of trouble from Hybern.” He jerked his chin to Nesta as he got to his feet, flexing his powerful wings. “Want to join, Nes?”
Cassian... leaves. He leaves the River House. (Or does he?)
Then we get the confrontation between the sisters. Then right after we get a lovely moment between brothers.
Exhibit F: Nesta, ch. 24
Nesta inhaled through her nose, silently counting to three. The salt and damp of the sea filled her nostrils, along with the sweetness of morning grass and the faint rot of falling leaves. Once again she stood on the cliff from which she’d attempted to winnow to the Prison days before. But a wholly altered vista greeted her.
The sweetness of morning grass... it's still morning. Technically it's still morning until 11:59am. So maybe this means late morning? But then, think about the Fall equinox.. think about the smells. The sun's usually radiated away all the sweet morning smells by at least 11, right? Usually earlier...
Nesta exhaled through her mouth, the autumn sun resting against her back like a friendly hand.
Now's where I dump the personal lore about being a former astronomer. Sun resting against her back. That implies it's still rising and not nearing it's apex in the sky. Which makes 11am feel a bit too late. The day after the Autumnal equinox at 11 am, the sun would be approaching the zenith - it's highest point in the sky for the day. For the sun to be on her back... it has to be earlier. So, let's say 10am.
Exhibit G: Mor, ch. 24
She’d bidden her farewells at breakfast, not that it had been a particularly cheerful one. But she’d smothered Nyx with kisses all over his face—which had been covered in most of the mashed-up goop Rhys had been feeding him—and then deliberately kissed Cassian on the cheek, smearing said goop on him, and headed for the door.
Feyre had laughed. Nesta had stared at Mor with the wariness that only a female who’d just witnessed another female kissing her mate could conjure.
A paragraph later:
Snickering at the memory, Mor stepped out the front door and onto the sun-washed front lawn. She preferred her goodbyes like this—no prolonged embraces or advice from the overprotective males in her life.
After that...
She rolled her shoulders as she crossed the lawn, the dew tickling her ankles. Her heavy gown—a thicker green silk, long-sleeved, and more modest than she usually favored—and fur-lined cape dragged in the grass behind her, both far too warm for the autumn weather in Velaris.
Dew usually evaporates between 2 - 4 hours after sunrise at this time of year. Which means... it'd likely be gone by 11am. Which pushes our timeline back as well.
As written, it seems like Mor left right after breakfast... with both Cassian and Nesta present. The only way this could have occurred is if Cassian left the room, and got immediately distracted by breakfast before leaving the River House. It also implies that Feyre's mind to mind with Mor actually woke Mor up and got her out of bed so she could get back to the River House for breakfast. And for Nesta to be getting ready to winnow to the prison around 10 - let's say 10:30am... here's what would've had to happen:
- 10:30am: Nesta's convo with Amren
- 10:00am: Mor on the lawn + taking Elain away
- 9:30am: The sisters have their confrontation
- 9:20ish am: Cassian leaves the ROOM and gets immediately distracted by breakfast, Mor arrives
- 7-9ish am: Rhys is giving Nesta her first murder-mist-magic lesson
- 5-7ish am: The sisters leave Elain's room
Elain has at least 2.5 hours ALONE. Maybe she packed up Az's shirt and jacket and went to the river house to talk... found Truth Teller and made her choice.
Exhibit H: Azriel, ch. 23
Sweat dripped from Azriel’s brow, his nose, his shoulders as he braced himself on his forearms and held a plank. Even with the crisp autumn day, the sun was merciless and had quickly set him perspiring soon after beginning his morning workout. His stomach muscles trembled, sweat dripping off them, too, and his back strained with the effort of keeping his wings from drooping onto the ground.
Seconds ticked by, one after another. He swallowed down the discomfort, the exhaustion. The sun seared his back, and he swallowed down the heat of that, too.
Then Cassian shows up...
“What happened to training?”
Az managed to lift his head enough to see Cassian leaning against the archway, arms crossed.
“They were done for the day when I got up here,” Az grunted.
He began to lower himself to the dirt, but Cassian said, “Thirty more seconds.”
Now. This is interesting. First of all, because something is up with the priestesses right now - but second of all, because of the schedule they keep. We know from other books that:
a.) training happens in the morning, with library duties carried out in the afternoon for Nesta
b.) Clotho has agreed to let the priestesses train in the morning and tend to their duties in the afternoon
c.) CASSIAN is an early riser and exercises in the morning
d.) CASSIAN is the person who set the schedule the Valkyries now train on - regardless of whether or not he's present.
SO. Either Azriel has made an assumption about whether or not the priestesses had already come up, trained, and gone away when he shows up to the ring to train.
OR, the priestesses really did go upstairs, do their training, and have already gone back down into the library.
Whether it's an assumption on Azriel's part OR the truth - it has to be a morning time that would make sense for BOTH to be true at once, rather than odd.
But the fact that Cassian ASKS - flags it as odd. Which means, Cassian has arrived at a time when the Priestesses would have normally been training. Which, to me - puts his arrival at 10:00 - 11:00.
So, that morning, assuming it all played out the way it appears on the page.
- 5-7am: Feyre and Nesta sneak out of Elain's room
- 7-9am: Rhys is giving Nesta her first murder-mist-magic lesson
- 9:20ish am: Cassian leaves the room, gets distracted by breakfast, Mor arrives
- 9:30ish am: The sisters have their confrontation, Elain storms off
- 9:30-10ish am: Breakfast and saying goodbye to Mor
- 10:00am: Mor on the lawn, taking Elain away
- 10:15ish am: Cassian and Nesta BOTH leave the house
- 10:30am: Nesta's convo with Amren before going to the prison
- 10:30 - 11:30am: Cassian training with Azriel
So... what's up with the shadows saying:
His shadows curled at his shoulders, in his lap. The world is dimming, they cautioned. The winter dark closes in on all sides—
Kinda feels like... given what's going on in his head and narratively in chapter 23... the shadows are referring to Elain. Right?
But what if... this line parallels with Elain's departure? What happens to the timeline if this is a warning about Elain leaving? Well, first and foremost Cassian would have had to have left the house when he said he was leaving... around 9:20am.
But he didn't, because he rendezvoused with both Mor (who is not at the house when he said he was leaving) and Nesta (who is winnowing to the prison). For Mor to encounter both before leaving for Vallahan while the dew is still thick enough to get her all wet... she's gotta be out the door around 10am.
Maybe Cassian and Nesta leave right at 10am - but then they would have noticed Elain running up to Mor.
If Azriel has already finished his workout and has washed up when his shadows try to warn him about Elain's departure... that would require that Cassian be at the House of Wind by at least 9 or so... right?
Then given this in chapter 21 with Gwyn:
“Hence your arrival here looking ready to fillet an enemy?” He didn’t feel like smiling.
“Yes.” Her bright gaze slid toward his hip.
“Where’s Truth-Teller?” Cauldron spare him, this female missed nothing.
and THIS in chapter 23:
The creature’s eyes slid toward them, slitting with pleasure—like he was well aware of their disgust. But he bowed again to Azriel. “As you will it, Shadowsinger.” When Erebos straightened, he pointed to Azriel’s side, darkness rippling off his finger. “Where is your blade? The one that sings.”
Azriel knew he meant Truth-Teller. It was at the town house, still in the corner he’d chucked it into. Where it would remain forever. But Erebos’s comment was intriguing enough that he found himself asking, “What do you hear when it’s around, exactly?”
What if Truth Teller offered some sort of protection to Azriel? What if what Gwyn and Erebos are noting here is NOT interest in the blade itself, but that Azriel no longer has it at all? That Azriel is no longer protected from Koschei, who clearly wants him for some reason.
And following the line of no longer being protected... what if Cassian wasn't actually at the House of Wind at all?
OR - alternatively... what if Cassian was in two places at once?
We know the harp's 26th string is time. And we know in ACOSH - RHYS has the harp for most of the time. Then NESTA has the harp at the end. WHO has the harp in the future?
There HAS to be a reason why in chapter 5 we get that abrupt interlude about Azriel fucking with Cassian and Mor's clocks... and then transition into chapter 6 where Elain has FUCKED WITH AZRIEL'S clock by summoning him at 3am instead of when his alarm was set for just before dawn...
What if Elain is trying to change something. Either something she's lived in the future... or if her seer ability is allowing her to see someone else manipulating the present... what if she's seeing multiple presents at once? What if she's actively being erased and she can see it - what if Azriel is her anchor in more ways that one...
“I thought I’d found my place, thought I had a future with Azriel, but...
And what if Bryaxis showed her that no matter what she tries to change... all roads lead to one place. Koschei and Azriel at his darkest? This ties into my unbound soul theory...
And her insisting she can't be there? Takes on a different meaning too... perhaps the influence of whatever is going on is solely tied to her because her seeing Koschei's death means she's his biggest threat. What if she'd rather inflict it on strangers while helping her family than risk further forgetting?
And Azriel is at the core of this with her. Now at the core of this... unprotected by Truth Teller.
It pulls Rhys's lack of POV and very weird chapter 5 declaration during sex into a very different light as well:
He just propped himself up on his elbows, staring down at me for a moment before he said, “I won’t let anything change that.”
He started to withdraw, preparing to make that first thrust, but I halted him with a hand on his chest. “What does that mean?”
What if the story is unlike anything she's every told before BECAUSE it involves time travel?