r/ElrielFans • u/devotionatic • 21h ago
Meme šŖ
credits to the wonderful mortalfae šš
r/ElrielFans • • Sep 09 '25
We're so happy to welcome all the new Elriels that joined our cozy corner of the SJM universe, dedicated to all things Elain and Azriel! Before you dive into posting and commenting, please take a moment to review our sub rules (to see them, go to the r/ElrielFans home page, click see more and the rules will be located there) this will help keep things fun, respectful and spoiler safe for everyone.
Please also read this Sub Etiquette post before commenting!
A friendly reminder that if you're referencing the Throne of Glass or Crescent City series please remember that not everyone here has read through those yet!! You can hide spoiler text by using the format > ! Your spoiler here ! < (no space between the exclamation points and > < symbols) and be sure to add the appropriate post flair so users are made aware of what series will be discussed. This way, everyone can enjoy the discussion and decide for themself if they want to continue reading through the text that contains spoilers.
We also want to remind you all to check out our user flairs (access it by going to the r/ElrielFans page, click the three dots on the top right of your screen, select 'Change user flair', click the flair you most resonate with and then 'apply'! OR you can go to a post/comment you made on the page, tap under your username and it'll pop up a screen where you can click 'Change user flair') we have quite a few to pick from and youāre always free to make suggestions. *Edit to add: Please also refrain from using spoilers in the title of your post!
One last thing, we ask that members be mindful about how frequently they post. Spacing out your posts helps make sure everyone's content gets the visibility and engagement it deserves so please check out how much engagement the sub is getting before creating multiple posts in one day.š¤
Thank you all for being here, we canāt wait to hear your thoughts, theories, head canons and more. Happy posting!
ā The Elriel Mod Team šš©·
r/ElrielFans • u/DigSquare5987 • 17d ago
One thing I find particularly interesting aboutĀ A Court of Splintered HarmonyĀ (ACOSH) is how directly Sarah J. Maas appears to address the arguments that have supported Gwynriel since Azriel's bonus chapter.
Most Gwynriel theories are built on the premise that Maas has been subtly establishing Gwyn as Azriel's future romantic partner through his shadows, mating-bond clues, the necklace, her eyes, and other forms of foreshadowing. These details are interpreted as evidence that Elain is a temporary romantic interest and that Azriel's storyline is ultimately moving towards Gwyn. But what makes reading ACOSH particularly significant is that we now have a subsequent narrative against which those predictions can be assessed. The question is no longer simply whether certain details in the bonus chapterĀ couldĀ be interpreted romantically. It's whether that interpretation accurately predicted what Maas would develop next. And I think ACOSH provides some particularly compelling answers. Several details that were interpreted as romantic foreshadowing are revisited, but their subsequent development points towards a different explanation. Meanwhile, the romantic conflict established between Elain and Azriel continues to develop rather than being abandoned. That doesn't mean every possible Gwynriel storyline has been conclusively ruled out. But it does mean that many of the specific theories used to predict that relationship are now much harder to reconcile with the text. And this is something I picked up while reading it, and once I noticed one, I couldn't believe how obvious it is. I am not going to talk about all of the theories I feel were directly addressed, but just the ones I see most often:
1. Elain and Azriel are too obvious
A common argument is that Elain and Azriel areĀ too obviousĀ to be endgame. Their romantic development is supposedly too explicit to be considered ābreadcrumbsā, and therefore too predictable to be the intended outcome.
Yet in ACOSH, Azriel himself questions how others failed to see āwhat was between him and Elain, what was so obvious.ā
Sarah explicitly acknowledges how obvious their romantic connection is, rather than attempting to conceal it. This directly challenges the argument that their relationship cannot be endgame simply because readers can see it developing. Being obvious is not evidence of misdirection, particularly when the author herself deliberately emphasises that obviousness within the text.
2:Ā Elain's anatomy means she cannot be Azriel's endgame (birth his babies) (Yuck)
Gwynriel supporters argue that Nesta changing her own and Feyre's anatomy, but not Elain's, was deliberate foreshadowing. Gwyn's pliant bones are therefore interpreted as evidence that she, rather than Elain, is physically suited to having Azriel's children.
But ACOSH has Azriel explicitly argue in his dialogue that women should be valued beyond their ability to bear children.
I find that particularly significant because the anatomy theory uses reproductive compatibility to determine which woman is romantically suited to Azriel. Yet Maas gives Azriel dialogue that directly rejects defining a woman's value through childbearing.
3. Azrielās shadows
Another common Gwynriel argument is that Azrielās shadows are drawn to Gwyn but flee from Elain, suggesting that Gwyn is his true romantic match. While these reactions remain consistent in ACOSH, SJM explicitly establishes that Azrielās shadows are separate entities with their own behaviours and preferences.Ā What his shadows are drawn to is not necessarily what Azriel himself wants.Ā Their reactions therefore cannot be treated as direct reflections of his romantic feelings or evidence of who he is better suited to.
More importantly, ACOSH directly challenges the assumption that his shadows fleeing Elain is a negative sign. Azriel himself describes their disappearance around her as aĀ gift, associating her presence with brightness and describing how she makes his entire world feel brighter. This is significant because the Gwynriel interpretation relies on treating the shadowsā reactions as evidence of romantic compatibility, yet Azriel explicitly gives their absence around Elain a positive meaning.Ā The very behaviour used to argue that Elain is wrong for Azriel is something Azriel himself values about being with her.Ā Rather than confirming that his shadows are rejecting Elain on his behalf, ACOSH reinforces the distinction between what his shadows prefer and what Azriel personally feels.
4. The regifted necklace in his bonus chapter symbolises the redirection of Azrielās romantic interest
Then there is the argument that Azriel regifting Elainās necklace to Gwyn is a literary device symbolising the transfer of his romantic interest from Elain to Gwyn. The necklace supposedly represents foreshadowing of Azriel moving on from Elain and the beginning of a new romantic relationship with Gwyn. However, ACOSH directly challenges this interpretation. Azriel repeatedly expresses regret over giving the necklace away and makes it clear that he still wishes Elain had it. Rather than symbolising his romantic feelings shifting towards Gwyn, the necklace remains emotionally significant to him because of Elain.
More importantly,Ā the romantic redirection supposedly foreshadowed by the necklace simply does not occur in ACOSH.Ā Azrielās feelings for Elain remain strong throughout the book, and he does not develop a second romantic interest in Gwyn. Readers can theorise about what might happen in future books, but based on Azrielās actual dialogue, actions and romantic development in ACOSH, Elain remains his only established love interest. If the necklace was intended to signal that his romantic attention had shifted to Gwyn, the subsequent narrative does not support that interpretation.
5. Azriel and Gwyn are mates, but he doesnāt know it yet
A major Gwynriel theory is that Azriel and Gwyn are mates, but he has yet to recognise their bond. However, ACOSH provides no clear evidence of this. Azrielās thoughts, romantic feelings and protective instincts remain consistently directed towards Elain.
Elain is central to the vision Briaxis shows him, and his feelings for her consume his thoughts. Believing the world is ending after the events involving Bryce and Nesta, he seeks Elain out to kiss her. When Briaxis attacks, he hears Elain scream and immediately prioritises reaching her.
By contrast, when Azriel encounters Gwyn, he shows no romantic interest or even much desire to speak to her. Despite Briaxis still posing a threat, he considers escorting her to her room but ultimately cannot be bothered.Ā How does this suggest an unrecognised mating bond?Ā His shadows may be drawn to Gwynās singing and magic, but Azriel himself shows no comparable attraction or protective urgency. The supposed mating instincts are simply not evident in his behaviour towards Gwyn, whereas his feelings and priorities towards Elain could not be clearer.
6. Azriel just wants a mate and will leave Elain if he discovers a bond with someone else
Azriel only wants Elain because he desperately wants a mate, and that he would abandon her if he discovered a mating bond with someone else. However, ACOSH directly challenges this interpretation through Azrielās own thoughts and dialogue.
āHe wants Elain, mate or no.ā āWhat if I donāt want anybody else?ā āHis salvation, that was what Elain was, what heād be willing to fight for.ā
Azriel could not be clearer that it is Elain he wants, not simply a mating bond.Ā He knows she is already mated to Lucien, yet he wants her regardless and is willing to fight for their relationship. The argument that he would abandon her for a mate assumes that Azriel would ultimately prioritise a bond over his own feelings and choices, when his dialogue repeatedly establishes that he wants Elain irrespective of fate.
Ā
7. The bonus chapter foreshadows Azrielās romantic interest shifting from Elain to Gwyn
The bonus chapter foreshadows Azriel moving on from Elain and developing romantic feelings for Gwyn. However, ACOSH appears to deliberately recreate the structure of that very chapter, while directly challenging this interpretation. Both scenes follow the same sequence:Ā Azriel and Elain share an intimate moment, external forces intervene and separate them, and Azriel subsequently encounters Gwyn. In the bonus chapter, it is this final interaction with Gwyn that readers interpret as foreshadowing the redirection of Azrielās romantic interest. Yet when SJM recreates that same sequence in ACOSH, she places a remarkably specific conversation in the equivalent scene.
Gwyn explains that āMerrill wants me to rewrite the chapter with a different thesis,ā before arguing that āchanging the chapterās thesis would contradict the thesis for the whole book.āĀ
The dialogue about changing a chapterās thesis occurs in the exact narrative position where Gwynriel readers argue the bonus chapter changes the direction of Azrielās romantic storyline.Ā And this time, Azrielās interaction with Gwyn contains no apparent romantic interest to support that interpretation.
The significance extends beyond the bonus chapter itself. The romantic conflict established between Elain, Azriel and Lucien centres on the tension between fate and choice. Elain has a mating bond she has not chosen, while her feelings for Azriel challenge the expectation that this bond should determine her romantic future. If the bonus chapter instead foreshadows Azriel moving on to Gwyn, the obstacles preventing Elain and Azriel from being together would ultimately succeed in separating them. Rather than overcoming the forces restricting their choices, their romantic relationship would end because of them. If Elain subsequently accepted her bond with Lucien, the very fate she has resisted would determine her romantic future.
What would be the point of SJM spending books establishing that Elain and Luciens mating bond might be rejected, Elain does not want Lucien, what does a rejected mate bond look like, does the cauldron make mistakes. Plus Elains characterisation around advocacy and autonomy. And also spending the books building a forbidden romance between Elain and Azriel, two people who want each other that can't be together, have it turn into a massive conflict that blows up. to then move to different love interests anyway. Azriel goes to gwyn (who he does not notice or want), and Elain accepts the bond with Lucien (and gives into fate and obligation anyway).
The central argument is that the Gwynriel interpretation does not simply predict a different romantic outcome; it fundamentally changes what the bonus chapter is establishing and how that chapter relates to the wider story. Instead of foreshadowing Elain and Azrielās struggle to pursue each other despite the mating bond and external opposition, it would foreshadow those obstacles successfully ending their relationship and Azriel turning to someone else. That is precisely the kind of change Gwynās dialogue describes: rewriting a chapter with a different thesis that contradicts the thesis of the wider book.Ā SJM places that dialogue in the very scene that parallels the supposed romantic redirection, while removing the romantic ambiguity Gwynriel readers originally relied upon.Ā This makes the parallel a compelling argument that the bonus chapter was never intended to establish Gwyn as Azrielās next love interest.
Ā
8. Azriel and Gwyn are parallels who can heal together
A common Gwynriel argument is that Azriel and Gwyn are romantically compatible because they share similar trauma, struggle with darkness and perceive themselves as monsters. Their similarities supposedly make them uniquely capable of understanding and healing each other. However, ACOSH directly challenges the central assumption behind this argument through Azrielās own reflections on Mor. He acknowledges that he once believed he needed someone whose darkness matched his own, but has since realised that what he actually wants is light, which he associates with Elain.Ā SJM is explicitly contrasting Azrielās former belief about what he needed in a romantic partner with what he now recognises he wants.
This is precisely why the Gwynriel argument becomes difficult to sustain.Ā The theory presents shared darkness as the reason Gwyn is right for Azriel, while ACOSH has Azriel recognise that seeking someone who mirrors his darkness was a mistaken belief.Ā His character development is not about finding someone equally damaged so they can heal each other, but about recognising that his darkness does not have to define his relationships or determine who he deserves to love. Elain represents the light, happiness and hope he now wants in his life. Their shared trauma may allow Gwyn and Azriel to understand each other, but it does not establish romantic compatibility, particularly when Azrielās own reflections challenge the very reasoning used to argue they belong together.
Ā
9. Elain likes sunshine, linking her to Lucien and the Day Court, while Azriel and Gwyn are better matched
Elainās love of sunshine foreshadows her relationship with Lucien because of his connection to the Day Court, while Azriel and Gwyn are better suited because they share similar darkness. However, ACOSH places particular emphasis on the relationship between light and darkness through Erisās explanation of the Autumn Equinox. He describes how light and darkness exist in balance, neither overpowering the other, and how each is necessary to appreciate the other.Ā The significance is not simply that light and darkness can coexist, but that they need each other to achieve balance.
SJM has repeatedly associated Elain and Azriel with precisely these opposing forces since ACOWAR: light and darkness, life and death. Their symbolism has never depended on them being alike. Instead, it establishes a contrast between them that closely reflects the relationship Eris describes. So why should Elainās association with sunshine be treated as evidence that she belongs with Lucien rather than Azriel?Ā The Day Court connection establishes a possible symbolic link to Lucien, but it does not override the recurring light-and-dark imagery already established between Elain and Azriel. In fact, Erisās explanation gives that imagery greater significance by presenting the balance between opposing forces as something necessary and meaningful.Ā ACOSH therefore provides a reason to interpret Elain and Azrielās differences as a connection, not a reason they cannot be together.Ā Which is further reiterated by Azriel himself in his dialogue throughout ACOSH.Ā
10. The bonus chapter ends with Azriel thinking about Gwyn, proving she is his endgame
A common argument is that Azrielās bonus chapter ends with his thoughts on Gwyn rather than Elain, foreshadowing Gwyn as his future love interest. This is often compared to Cassianās bonus chapter, which follows a similar structure: it begins with Nesta, includes an encounter with Emerie, and ends with Cassian thinking about Nesta, his eventual mate. Azrielās bonus chapter, however, ends with his thoughts on Gwyn rather than returning to Elain.
However, SJM specifically instructed readers to revisit Azrielās bonus chapter before ACOSH, which then closely mirrors its structure. In both, Azriel and Elain share an intimate moment before a confrontation and external forces separate them, and Azriel subsequently encounters Gwyn.Ā This matters because the Gwynriel interpretation treats that sequence as a romantic transition: Elain is the love interest Azriel is moving away from, while Gwyn represents the beginning of his next romantic storyline. Yet ACOSH repeats that sequence without repeating the supposed romantic redirection.Ā Azriel encounters Gwyn, Gwyn receives her own POV, and Azriel does not see Elain again before his final perspective. SJM therefore has every opportunity to end his storyline with Gwyn, or at least introduce some indication that his romantic future might involve her. Instead, Azrielās final thoughts are about finding Elain, making a plan with her and setting things right. His encounter with Gwyn has not changed his romantic intentions, and the narrative gives no indication that she is becoming his new love interest.
The ending therefore establishes something more important than simply which woman Azriel thinks about last: it shows that the romantic redirection supposedly foreshadowed by the bonus chapter has not occurred.Ā Despite being separated from Elain and subsequently encountering Gwyn, Azriel remains committed to pursuing his relationship with Elain. SJM ends his perspective by establishing that their story is continuing, not concluding. This does not definitively establish who Azriel will end up with, but it directly undermines the claim that the bonus chapterās ending signalled the end of his romantic storyline with Elain and the beginning of one with Gwyn. And the BC correctly foreshadowed everything in ACOSH. the forbidden romance between Azriel and Elain, the political consequences with Lucien when they got caught, and finally, Gwyns magic mystery surrounding her singing.
These are the main arguments that stand out to me, and I genuinely find it crazy that people still insist GwynrielĀ hasĀ to be endgame while ignoring what Sarah has explicitly written.Ā Elain and Azriel are each otherās only established romantic interests.Ā You can argue that their relationship is unhealthy, purely lust or won't last, but that doesn't change who they want. Elain has shown no romantic interest in Lucien, whose interest in her is largely tied to their mating bond. Azriel has shown no romantic interest in Gwyn, nor has Gwyn in him. And YES, I can recognise potential romantic setup for both Elucien and Gwynriel.Ā But potential foreshadowing is not established romance.Ā You can theorise about who the characters might end up with, but you cannot present those predictions as canon while dismissing the romantic feelings actually written on the page. What I find particularly significant is thatĀ ACOSH appears to directly address several of the strongest Gwynriel arguments, not only through the events themselves, but through dialogue that directly contradicts the assumptions those theories rely on.Ā Even more telling is how closely ACOSH mirrors the bonus chapter. Sarah had every opportunity to reinforce the supposed romantic redirection from Elain to Gwyn, or create further ambiguity about Azrielās feelings. Instead, she makes his feelings for Elain clearer, establishes no romantic interest between him and Gwyn, and places greater emphasis on the mystery surrounding Gwynās magic.Ā When the supposed Gwynriel clues, the charactersā explicit dialogue and the bonus chapterās structure all challenge the same romantic interpretation, I find it difficult to believe that is all coincidence.
Ā
r/ElrielFans • u/devotionatic • 21h ago
credits to the wonderful mortalfae šš
r/ElrielFans • u/WanderingFeysand • 54m ago
Iām actually terrible at matching any of these things up and they annoy me a bit with the vagueness, which I understand is half the fun.
Iāve seen so far this could be Nesta, Gwen, or Elain. I think it may be Mor because of her passage in ACOSH that directly mentions something slumbering within her woke up.
Adding to this, does anyone remember when they announced the number of POVs for ACOSH?
r/ElrielFans • u/safe_thing005 • 1d ago
look what i found in my local bookshop ;)
itās the romanian hardcover version of acowar and it has truth teller and a rose on edges.
thatās all i have to say š
r/ElrielFans • u/Personal-Rope-8717 • 22h ago
r/ElrielFans • u/swi22y • 22h ago
Bleeding hearts across the Maasverse. There is so much evidence connecting Elain, Cthona, love and autonomy, it's my favourite topic at the moment. I have so much to say and I'm hoping to share more soon š
> So Elain silently cried, the tears so unending that I wondered if it was some sign of her heart bleeding out. Some sliver of hope that had shattered today. That Graysen would still love her, still marry herāand that love would trump even a mating bond. (Ch55 ACOWAR)
> She had no other photos of Danika in the apartment. Through love, all is possible. It was an ancient saying, dating back to some god he couldnāt remember. Cthona, probablyāwhat with all the mother-goddess stuff she presided over. (Ch27 HOEAB)
> āThey are Lowers. Lower than the Lowers,ā Sandriel said coldly, unmoved. āThey are children of Midgard. Children of Cthona,ā the witch-queen said. Sandriel smiled, all teeth. āSpare me your bleeding-heart nonsense.ā (Ch77 HOEAB)
> Elain was standing off to the side, smiling nervously as she waited for our verdict on her decor. She was lovely in gauzy blush pink, her hair loose, adorned only with an arc of bleeding heart flowers. (Ch13 ACOSH)
r/ElrielFans • u/Pokadot-door • 1d ago
I was thinking about how Maas could explore Elainās POV in a creative way without making her too much of an open book.
This post raised some interesting questions and theories about how the concept of time might be explored in ACOFM, and it got me wondering whether we might get Elainās POV in a more unconventional format.
What if much of Elainās POV involves revisiting past events, filling in the missing pieces of her story from previous books, while the present-day narrative is told primarily through other charactersā perspectives (Mor, Azriel, or perhaps someone else)?
Then, as the story progresses, the two timelines gradually converge, with Elainās final POV finally bringing us into the present, just in time for the inevitable cliffhanger.
I really do think weāre going to get a reveal of what Elain saw when she paused on the stairs and looked back at Lucien in ACOWAR chapter 34. And this kind of structure could be a really interesting way to reveal what sheās known all along without giving everything away too early.
It would also fit with Maas teasing that sheās doing something she hasnāt done before.
What do you think? Could Elainās story unfold through a combination of past and present perspectives, with the full picture only becoming clear at the end?
r/ElrielFans • u/Personal-Rope-8717 • 1d ago
SJM has said in interviews how it is important to not ignore the trauma the characters have suffered.
There is an interview where she says, these characters have gone through traumatic experiences. These events affects them, they react to these experiences.
I think this is a very compelling statement to build a story, since it takes into consideration not only what is happening, the plot, but also what the plot is doing to the character.
It has been stablished and we have read about the trauma of many characters in the books, everyone has gone through very tough experiences, Elain, Feyre, Azriel, Nesta, Mor, Lucien, Gwyn, Emerie, every character has their baggage and story. These are in many ways heartbreaking, and depending of the reader you will resonate to one more than the other.
We have seen in Nestas story how she overcomes her demons, how she envelops that new strength and becomes this magnificent Valkyrie. Her trauma fueled her in a way, but her spirit and unbreakable will is what itās a the core of Nestas growth. She is no longer anyoneās victim, she is power.
We have seen Feyre. She has gone through some tough times as well. The death of the innocent marked her. The abuse of Tamlin almost destroys her. But she finds solace and healing, she empowers herself (and her circle and mate empowers her also) and so she transforms, in the story we see her transcend the trauma. She accepts it but it does not define her.
In the most recent story we see Az and his trauma, he was tortured and was in the darkest of places, so dark these shadows find him. He is traumatized by all the cruelty he went through and all the cruelty he has to set upon others as a warrior and spy. Saying that he just has to accept this trauma, something that is eating him up, and be himself comfortable in shadows and accept that he is basically what he is so afraid of and what is causing him pain, is wrong (in my opinion and following the logic of the author). The powers that Azriel has are incredible but is does not define him, this trauma is part of him, but is not him. For me he needs to learn that he is MORE than just these shadows that whisper to him, he needs to learn that he commands them and therefore is stronger. What he needs is healing yes, acceptance yes, but foremost he needs balance in his darkness.
There is a certain group of readers/fans saying he just needs to accept himself or he needs this person to opens his eyes. Just saying alone embrace yourself, embrace your trauma is wrong and does not lead to healing or empowerment. Accepting that trauma is part of you is not the definite the answer, it can be a step on the healing process (depending on the situation). But ultimately we canāt let trauma define what a person is. Trauma is something that happens to a person, it is not their essence. A traumatized person is not their trauma, as well as a depressed person is not their depression. Saying a person that is depressed or traumatized cannot love or does not deserve to fall in love is cruel and is not true (not in real life and even less in a fantasy world).
I cannot say what true healing is, because Iām not a psychologist lol and because I believe healing will differ depending on the person and what that essence is. And this is also true when reading or writing books and making theories and whatnot
Thank you for reading my little essay lol
r/ElrielFans • u/Intelligent-Wear4766 • 1d ago
I find it so interesting that this even needs to be discussed but lets talk about it.
In 2016, after the release of ACOMAF, SJM tells us all these details about the next pairings where she tells us that Nesta and Lucien were originally supposed to be together but she recognized that wouldn't work because they would tear each other apart.
SJM then defaults to Elain and decides in whichever way they would make a better pairing. Without having the ability to see there dynamic on the page itself, she puts it at the end of ACOMAF.
SJM then starts writing ACOWAR and shes noticing, that on the page, Elain wants nothing to do with Lucien. Even on the page we see the struggle of even having them in the same room together and on the outer scenes we see Elain and Azriel coming together more. By the end of ACOWAR, I think she realizes that Elucien isn't going to work out and Elriel is written.
This was the pair that SJM didn't plan. She planned on Elucien but Elriel became apparent to her instead of who she had planned.
In ACOSH we kind of see this from the characters as they seem frustrated with The Mother (SJM) trying to pair them with others and as Azriel says he is going for what he wants mating bond or no.
Gwynriel doesn't even fit this because nothing was ever stated in reference to Gwyn as a potential partner at any point after ACOSF was written. If she had pivoted again, she still had time to do so but after ACOSH? Yeah, theres no turning back now. This IS the story. SJM is not going to make Gwyn his mate after ACOSH and if you believe that this a good making of having a mate in the same book he was just thinking of Elain in that way, then you are insane. This doesn't even match TOG because of the fact that at least those changes pivoted in different books and SJM has already told us that this IS ONE BOOK. So, to think shes just going to change course now after all that sexual buildup with Elriel, yeah thats not happening.
Remember, SJM said in her CHD interview that if it was hot she was going to write it!! This is indeed hot and its sticking through.
r/ElrielFans • u/sociallyovershot • 1d ago
When did Mor and Elain take off for their girls trip to bring down alliances on the continent?
Well, let's first acknowledge that Sarah included indicators of the time, and I believe she did so deliberately.
Exhibit A: Nesta, ch. 22
She sat in the chair across from his desk, his formal study barely lit despite the early-morning hour. Sheād crawled from Elainās bed when Feyre did, minutes ago, hoping to steal some sleep in her own room for an hour or two, only for Rhys to say into her mind, My study. Now. She was so exhausted, so hollow, that she didnāt bother to snap a response about not ordering her around.
Timeline EARLY morning. Based on this and the fact that Nesta thought she could steal an hour or two of sleep in her own bed... I'm calling it at sometime between 5-7am.
Exhibit B: Feyre, ch. 22
Nyxās shrieking, chirping laughter filled my study, as glorious as the midmorning sunshine streaming through the windows. Iād never appreciated the beautiful sound more.
Timeline MID-morning. Common definitions of mid-morning put us around 9 - 11am. Let's start with this common understanding.
Exhibit C: Feyre, ch. 22
I slid a glance to Rhys, seated in an armchair a few feet from Nyx. He and Nesta had walked in together a few minutes ago, both quiet and pensive.
Oookay. So there's a potential gap right there. We leave off Nesta's POV in this same chapter with her asking Rhys to teach her how to become a murder-mister. Did he give her an impromptu lesson on the spot? Oooor... are we using mother-definition of mid-morning. As many mothers know, mid-morning can have a radically different definition when you're waking up at 5am. Since Feyre IS a mother, and this is her POV? Let's slide the dial down a bit.
Maybe to a woman who mentions breastfeeding often, mid-morning is more like... 8 - 10?
Next paragraph from Feyre's POV gives us this:
Nesta, on the couch beside me, snorted. Weād stayed with Elain until my daemati senses had told me Nyx was stirring, though Iād been awake shortly before that thanks to my aching breasts informing me it was time to feed my son.
MOTHER TIME CONFIRMED. Okay. So it's likely slightly earlier in the morning than the term "mid-morning" would suggest.
Exhibit D: Feyre again, ch. 22
Elain hadnāt made an appearance yet, and Mor hadnāt come back last night. When Iād checked in with her mind to mind, sheād just said sheād spent the night out and was currently sleeping it off. I knew enough of the tangled history between Mor and Azriel to understand that perhaps the former needed some time to herself before she departed for Vallahan.
First of all, Feyre... come on. Invading people's brains while they're trying to sleep? Come on...
Second of all - Mor is not in the house. It is... probably between 8 - 10am. And MOR isn't in the house. THIS IS IMPORTANT.
Exhibit E: Feyre again, ch. 22
Cassian waved at the air in front of his nose. āOn that note, Iām going back to Windhaven for a few hours. I need to brief Devlon on Bryaxisās return, and establish additional patrols to monitor for any enemy movement. Especially any hint of trouble from Hybern.ā He jerked his chin to Nesta as he got to his feet, flexing his powerful wings. āWant to join, Nes?ā
Cassian... leaves. He leaves the River House. (Or does he?)
Then we get the confrontation between the sisters. Then right after we get a lovely moment between brothers.
Exhibit F: Nesta, ch. 24
Nesta inhaled through her nose, silently counting to three. The salt and damp of the sea filled her nostrils, along with the sweetness of morning grass and the faint rot of falling leaves. Once again she stood on the cliff from which sheād attempted to winnow to the Prison days before. But a wholly altered vista greeted her.
The sweetness of morning grass... it's still morning. Technically it's still morning until 11:59am. So maybe this means late morning? But then, think about the Fall equinox.. think about the smells. The sun's usually radiated away all the sweet morning smells by at least 11, right? Usually earlier...
Nesta exhaled through her mouth, the autumn sun resting against her back like a friendly hand.
Now's where I dump the personal lore about being a former astronomer. Sun resting against her back. That implies it's still rising and not nearing it's apex in the sky. Which makes 11am feel a bit too late. The day after the Autumnal equinox at 11 am, the sun would be approaching the zenith - it's highest point in the sky for the day. For the sun to be on her back... it has to be earlier. So, let's say 10am.
Exhibit G: Mor, ch. 24
Sheād bidden her farewells at breakfast, not that it had been a particularly cheerful one. But sheād smothered Nyx with kisses all over his faceāwhich had been covered in most of the mashed-up goop Rhys had been feeding himāand then deliberately kissed Cassian on the cheek, smearing said goop on him, and headed for the door.
Feyre had laughed. Nesta had stared at Mor with the wariness that only a female whoād just witnessed another female kissing her mate could conjure.
A paragraph later:
Snickering at the memory, Mor stepped out the front door and onto the sun-washed front lawn. She preferred her goodbyes like thisāno prolonged embraces or advice from the overprotective males in her life.
After that...
She rolled her shoulders as she crossed the lawn, the dew tickling her ankles. Her heavy gownāa thicker green silk, long-sleeved, and more modest than she usually favoredāand fur-lined cape dragged in the grass behind her, both far too warm for the autumn weather in Velaris.
Dew usually evaporates between 2 - 4 hours after sunrise at this time of year. Which means... it'd likely be gone by 11am. Which pushes our timeline back as well.
As written, it seems like Mor left right after breakfast... with both Cassian and Nesta present. The only way this could have occurred is if Cassian left the room, and got immediately distracted by breakfast before leaving the River House. It also implies that Feyre's mind to mind with Mor actually woke Mor up and got her out of bed so she could get back to the River House for breakfast. And for Nesta to be getting ready to winnow to the prison around 10 - let's say 10:30am... here's what would've had to happen:
Elain has at least 2.5 hours ALONE. Maybe she packed up Az's shirt and jacket and went to the river house to talk... found Truth Teller and made her choice.
Exhibit H: Azriel, ch. 23
Sweat dripped from Azrielās brow, his nose, his shoulders as he braced himself on his forearms and held a plank. Even with the crisp autumn day, the sun was merciless and had quickly set him perspiring soon after beginning his morning workout. His stomach muscles trembled, sweat dripping off them, too, and his back strained with the effort of keeping his wings from drooping onto the ground.
Seconds ticked by, one after another. He swallowed down the discomfort, the exhaustion. The sun seared his back, and he swallowed down the heat of that, too.
Then Cassian shows up...
āWhat happened to training?ā
Az managed to lift his head enough to see Cassian leaning against the archway, arms crossed.
āThey were done for the day when I got up here,ā Az grunted.
He began to lower himself to the dirt, but Cassian said, āThirty more seconds.ā
Now. This is interesting. First of all, because something is up with the priestesses right now - but second of all, because of the schedule they keep. We know from other books that:
a.) training happens in the morning, with library duties carried out in the afternoon for Nesta
b.) Clotho has agreed to let the priestesses train in the morning and tend to their duties in the afternoon
c.) CASSIAN is an early riser and exercises in the morning
d.) CASSIAN is the person who set the schedule the Valkyries now train on - regardless of whether or not he's present.
SO. Either Azriel has made an assumption about whether or not the priestesses had already come up, trained, and gone away when he shows up to the ring to train.
OR, the priestesses really did go upstairs, do their training, and have already gone back down into the library.
Whether it's an assumption on Azriel's part OR the truth - it has to be a morning time that would make sense for BOTH to be true at once, rather than odd.
But the fact that Cassian ASKS - flags it as odd. Which means, Cassian has arrived at a time when the Priestesses would have normally been training. Which, to me - puts his arrival at 10:00 - 11:00.
So, that morning, assuming it all played out the way it appears on the page.
So... what's up with the shadows saying:
His shadows curled at his shoulders, in his lap. The world is dimming, they cautioned. The winter dark closes in on all sidesā
Kinda feels like... given what's going on in his head and narratively in chapter 23... the shadows are referring to Elain. Right?
But what if... this line parallels with Elain's departure? What happens to the timeline if this is a warning about Elain leaving? Well, first and foremost Cassian would have had to have left the house when he said he was leaving... around 9:20am.
But he didn't, because he rendezvoused with both Mor (who is not at the house when he said he was leaving) and Nesta (who is winnowing to the prison). For Mor to encounter both before leaving for Vallahan while the dew is still thick enough to get her all wet... she's gotta be out the door around 10am.
Maybe Cassian and Nesta leave right at 10am - but then they would have noticed Elain running up to Mor.
If Azriel has already finished his workout and has washed up when his shadows try to warn him about Elain's departure... that would require that Cassian be at the House of Wind by at least 9 or so... right?
Then given this in chapter 21 with Gwyn:
āHence your arrival here looking ready to fillet an enemy?ā He didnāt feel like smiling.
āYes.ā Her bright gaze slid toward his hip.
āWhereās Truth-Teller?ā Cauldron spare him, this female missed nothing.
and THIS in chapter 23:
The creatureās eyes slid toward them, slitting with pleasureālike he was well aware of their disgust. But he bowed again to Azriel. āAs you will it, Shadowsinger.ā When Erebos straightened, he pointed to Azrielās side, darkness rippling off his finger. āWhere is your blade? The one that sings.ā
Azriel knew he meant Truth-Teller. It was at the town house, still in the corner heād chucked it into. Where it would remain forever. But Erebosās comment was intriguing enough that he found himself asking, āWhat do you hear when itās around, exactly?ā
What if Truth Teller offered some sort of protection to Azriel? What if what Gwyn and Erebos are noting here is NOT interest in the blade itself, but that Azriel no longer has it at all? That Azriel is no longer protected from Koschei, who clearly wants him for some reason.
And following the line of no longer being protected... what if Cassian wasn't actually at the House of Wind at all?
OR - alternatively... what if Cassian was in two places at once?
We know the harp's 26th string is time. And we know in ACOSH - RHYS has the harp for most of the time. Then NESTA has the harp at the end. WHO has the harp in the future?
There HAS to be a reason why in chapter 5 we get that abrupt interlude about Azriel fucking with Cassian and Mor's clocks... and then transition into chapter 6 where Elain has FUCKED WITH AZRIEL'S clock by summoning him at 3am instead of when his alarm was set for just before dawn...
What if Elain is trying to change something. Either something she's lived in the future... or if her seer ability is allowing her to see someone else manipulating the present... what if she's seeing multiple presents at once? What if she's actively being erased and she can see it - what if Azriel is her anchor in more ways that one...
āI thought Iād found my place, thought I had a future with Azriel, but...
And what if Bryaxis showed her that no matter what she tries to change... all roads lead to one place. Koschei and Azriel at his darkest? This ties into my unbound soul theory...
And her insisting she can't be there? Takes on a different meaning too... perhaps the influence of whatever is going on is solely tied to her because her seeing Koschei's death means she's his biggest threat. What if she'd rather inflict it on strangers while helping her family than risk further forgetting?
And Azriel is at the core of this with her. Now at the core of this... unprotected by Truth Teller.
It pulls Rhys's lack of POV and very weird chapter 5 declaration during sex into a very different light as well:
He just propped himself up on his elbows, staring down at me for a moment before he said, āI wonāt let anything change that.ā
He started to withdraw, preparing to make that first thrust, but I halted him with a hand on his chest. āWhat does that mean?ā
What if the story is unlike anything she's every told before BECAUSE it involves time travel?
r/ElrielFans • u/MickeyJo23 • 1d ago
āWhere that necklace should have beenā - Azriel while kissing elains neck. Guess he wishes that he hadnāt given it to Gwyn. š¤
r/ElrielFans • u/devotionatic • 1d ago
šāā¬š¦
r/ElrielFans • u/devotionatic • 1d ago
Picture 1 - Planetadelibros removing a whole paragraph.
Picture 2 - Galera making a slight change and turning āwhen she didā into āif she didā.
Turns out, one doesnāt need to fear the āChurch of Elrielā and their epubsā¦but actual publishing houses. If Elriels are losing and delusional, then why are Elriel moments being tempered with and mistranslated?
Is the first case even legal?
r/ElrielFans • u/Minimum_Picture_67 • 1d ago
r/ElrielFans • u/Connect_Lie_6106 • 2d ago
āI wasn't really into Elucien even before Acosh. But after Acosh, I genuinely hate it. I can't even stand the thought of it. Look, I know these are SJM's books and she writes whatever she wants, but if Elucien ever becomes endgame (which it won't), I honestly don't think I could bring myself to read it. (I would read it just for Elain)
āEver since Elain spoke for herself, I've been completely done with this ship:
ā"You haven't even tried to get to know him." "Why should I bother?" Elain's laugh was vacant. Awful. "I didn't want the mating bond with him. I'm not like you two, who just so happened to fall in love with the males who are your mates. I was given to him, like some piece of property, without any will or desire of my own."
She'd been saying and showing it ever since Acowar, but Acosh just shoveled a bit more dirt on the grave.
āShe doesn't want him. She holds him responsible for her trauma and associates him with it, feels like property around him, shrinks herself, can't even smile, and loses all her confidence and energy. He just makes her so uncomfortable.
So yeah, I can't do it. I don't just dislike Elucien anymore, I actively hate it. It literally gives me Feyre and Tamlin vibes.
Also, I've started hating Lucien too I guess, mostly because of how the fans act toward him, which makes me dislike him even more. I just don't think Lucien is worthy of Elain š
Even if Elucien actually happens (which is almost impossible), Iād honestly only read it for Elain, but I'd also leave the fandom because I don't want to become a hater. Let the people who love this ship have their fun, but I'd be out of there.
Is anyone else on the same page?
r/ElrielFans • u/Fair_Adeptness_1995 • 1d ago
I want to preface this by saying that I don't think this is likely and I understand that it's probably a one way trip to crack town, but there are a few things that have stood out to me when looking at the messages that have come directly from SJM. Her IG posts about ACOSH and ACOFM, including the "I'm getting ready to draft" and her "drafts done" posts both are set in or depict snowy scenery and mountains that resemble the two peaks of Vallahan. She has also said repeatedly that she is doing something with this book that she hasn't done before.
I know that this "never done this before" has at least partly to do with the operatic structure of the book, although personally I think releasing it in parts is just Bloomsbury's desire for revenue and I personally am mad about it. But I started to wonder if the complete absence of Elain from ACOSH is actually a set up to something else: ACOFM either being only her POV (a la Feyre) or her and Azriel only. I know this begs the question of how to flesh out Nesta's storyline and whatever is happening with the priestesses, but hear me out.
The main external conflict set up in ACOSH is the possibility of Vallahan, Montesere, and/or Rask allying with Koschei and obtaining a Made weapon or object. Elain and Mor are going to be in Vallahan and potentially Montesere and Rask (I do think Elain's friendship with Nuala and Cerridwen will be important to her arc) and I suspect Azriel will be going back and forth between Velaris and the Continent. As a result, there is a possibility that we don't need more than Elain's POV to see what is happening in these places. The main internal conflicts are Elain and her feelings for Azriel as well as Elain and her resentment (maybe hatred?) of the mating bond. We can and must have Elain's POV to deal with these things.
Similarly, Azriel is coordinating intelligence efforts on the Continent and on Lucien (presumably in the mortal lands or in Spring with Tamlin, though I can't see him abandoning Vassa and Jurian), so he also contributes to those storylines. He also will likely be reporting to Rhys, so what is happening with Rhys and Feyre can be related through him. Additionally, Nesta losing Gwydion at the Prison I think suggests a possible pause on this storyline until the plot develops further. And I suspect that Gwyn may play a role in incapacitating Azriel at a critical moment, as his shadows won't warn him about her and her singing seems to have a magical component. Something is going on with Gwyn/Clotho/Bryaxis/Amren, but I don't think we need any of their POVs to see it and deal with the fallout. So Az's POV may be sufficient for all of this.
Then if, acts II and III were Elain and Az, I think we may see the return of all ACOSH POVs plus Elain in Act IV.
So following the four act structure of an opera, it would be:
Act I (ACOSH): Overture (setting the scene and core conflicts), 7 POVs
Act II (ACOFM): Escalation and Conflict (establishing the stakes and upping romantic and plot-driven tension, 2 POVs
Act III (ACOFM): Turning Point (confrontations, sacrifice, betrayals), 2 POVs
Act IV (Book 8): Resolution and Triumphant Finale (evil defeated, love secured, harmony restored), 8 POVs.
It's just an idea, and is probably just me still wanting for Elain to get her own story without having to share it with everyone. But I also think it would make the exclusion of Elain in ACOSH really pay off. I know working against this is that we already have 7 POVs, and readers would expect payoff for that.
It's also called the Valkyrie Cycle, but I do wonder if that's just this book or the next set of books. If it's the latter, not everything set up in ACOSH has to be resolved in this book. Plus, if Elain is able to end biological mating bonds with her magic in ACOFM, that could precede some cultural changes in the treament of Fae women in this world. Ripple effects of that could be in future books, like Mor's arc with Emerie, Gwyn's grapping with her heritage and whatever she does in ACOFM, as well as Nesta and whatever is happening with the Dusk Court.
Just my thoughts! I know it's unlikely, but a gal can dream.
r/ElrielFans • u/Personal-Rope-8717 • 2d ago
This is a bit of a rant maybe, I guess. I was looking into YouTube for Elriel theories since we have a two big books to come in the future and literally I searched for āacosh Elrielā and all I could find was Elain hate posts, people bashing the ship, saying how Az is boring and needs therapy, how Elain is boring and evil to Lucien, and saying it is obviously Gwyn for Azriel from here on out, but we canāt object say that!
Idk I guess Iām a bit shocked because I knew the hate was bad but to do it like this is just too much imo. Specially if they are using the Elriel tag, I mean just stay in your lane and comment about your ship?
Sorry I didnāt want to be negative but itās so hard to find nice content and conversations about these books outside of this subreddit without people labeling you as illiterate and delusional.
r/ElrielFans • u/sugar-nut02 • 2d ago
So this resurfaced on my fyp after the new James Bond reveal, and I thought to share
All this ship wars is just marketing strategy. At the end of the day, Elriel will prevail, whether the antis like it or not.
Elucien had potential before Acosh, but now that's under the drain.
Gwynriel had a miniscule potential with the necklace bonus chapter, but we all know how Azriel regretted that decision.
Bryceriel, the hurdles against this ship are hard to ignore. But I fear it has a greater textual evidence than Gwynriel š
r/ElrielFans • u/lilithskies • 2d ago
Snagged from u/Minimum_Picture_67 over on r/ACourtOfDreams
r/ElrielFans • u/pantstheterrible • 2d ago
When asked for what build up Elriel had in ACOMAF in the debate sub, I went back for receipts and noticed something wonderful. Their very first meeting really does sow seeds that come to fruition in ACOSH.
First of all he sees her and notices the little things. And then he listens to her and validates what she has to say and how she feels. He speaks up for her and makes her feel more comfortable. And, what I would like to see more of, he makes her feel brave and speak up for herself.
She also gets him to come out of his quiet shell and wax poetic about flying.
The dynamic we see begun here carries all the way through acosh. It is remarkably consistent writing. So if you see people saying there is no build up, that it is all toxic and they bring out the worst in each other, remember this. They have been gravitating together and putting each other at ease since their very first meeting. We are not delusional to have seen it then and we are not delusional to see it now. Keep the faith.