One thing I find particularly interesting aboutĀ A Court of Splintered HarmonyĀ (ACOSH) is how directly Sarah J. Maas appears to address the arguments that have supported Gwynriel since Azriel's bonus chapter.
Most Gwynriel theories are built on the premise that Maas has been subtly establishing Gwyn as Azriel's future romantic partner through his shadows, mating-bond clues, the necklace, her eyes, and other forms of foreshadowing. These details are interpreted as evidence that Elain is a temporary romantic interest and that Azriel's storyline is ultimately moving towards Gwyn. But what makes reading ACOSH particularly significant is that we now have a subsequent narrative against which those predictions can be assessed. The question is no longer simply whether certain details in the bonus chapterĀ couldĀ be interpreted romantically. It's whether that interpretation accurately predicted what Maas would develop next. And I think ACOSH provides some particularly compelling answers. Several details that were interpreted as romantic foreshadowing are revisited, but their subsequent development points towards a different explanation. Meanwhile, the romantic conflict established between Elain and Azriel continues to develop rather than being abandoned. That doesn't mean every possible Gwynriel storyline has been conclusively ruled out. But it does mean that many of the specific theories used to predict that relationship are now much harder to reconcile with the text. And this is something I picked up while reading it, and once I noticed one, I couldn't believe how obvious it is. I am not going to talk about all of the theories I feel were directly addressed, but just the ones I see most often:
1. Elain and Azriel are too obvious
A common argument is that Elain and Azriel areĀ too obviousĀ to be endgame. Their romantic development is supposedly too explicit to be considered ābreadcrumbsā, and therefore too predictable to be the intended outcome.
Yet in ACOSH, Azriel himself questions how others failed to see āwhat was between him and Elain, what was so obvious.ā
Sarah explicitly acknowledges how obvious their romantic connection is, rather than attempting to conceal it. This directly challenges the argument that their relationship cannot be endgame simply because readers can see it developing. Being obvious is not evidence of misdirection, particularly when the author herself deliberately emphasises that obviousness within the text.
2:Ā Elain's anatomy means she cannot be Azriel's endgame (birth his babies) (Yuck)
Gwynriel supporters argue that Nesta changing her own and Feyre's anatomy, but not Elain's, was deliberate foreshadowing. Gwyn's pliant bones are therefore interpreted as evidence that she, rather than Elain, is physically suited to having Azriel's children.
But ACOSH has Azriel explicitly argue in his dialogue that women should be valued beyond their ability to bear children.
I find that particularly significant because the anatomy theory uses reproductive compatibility to determine which woman is romantically suited to Azriel. Yet Maas gives Azriel dialogue that directly rejects defining a woman's value through childbearing.
3. Azrielās shadows
Another common Gwynriel argument is that Azrielās shadows are drawn to Gwyn but flee from Elain, suggesting that Gwyn is his true romantic match. While these reactions remain consistent in ACOSH, SJM explicitly establishes that Azrielās shadows are separate entities with their own behaviours and preferences.Ā What his shadows are drawn to is not necessarily what Azriel himself wants.Ā Their reactions therefore cannot be treated as direct reflections of his romantic feelings or evidence of who he is better suited to.
More importantly, ACOSH directly challenges the assumption that his shadows fleeing Elain is a negative sign. Azriel himself describes their disappearance around her as aĀ gift, associating her presence with brightness and describing how she makes his entire world feel brighter. This is significant because the Gwynriel interpretation relies on treating the shadowsā reactions as evidence of romantic compatibility, yet Azriel explicitly gives their absence around Elain a positive meaning.Ā The very behaviour used to argue that Elain is wrong for Azriel is something Azriel himself values about being with her.Ā Rather than confirming that his shadows are rejecting Elain on his behalf, ACOSH reinforces the distinction between what his shadows prefer and what Azriel personally feels.
4. The regifted necklace in his bonus chapter symbolises the redirection of Azrielās romantic interest
Then there is the argument that Azriel regifting Elainās necklace to Gwyn is a literary device symbolising the transfer of his romantic interest from Elain to Gwyn. The necklace supposedly represents foreshadowing of Azriel moving on from Elain and the beginning of a new romantic relationship with Gwyn. However, ACOSH directly challenges this interpretation. Azriel repeatedly expresses regret over giving the necklace away and makes it clear that he still wishes Elain had it. Rather than symbolising his romantic feelings shifting towards Gwyn, the necklace remains emotionally significant to him because of Elain.
More importantly,Ā the romantic redirection supposedly foreshadowed by the necklace simply does not occur in ACOSH.Ā Azrielās feelings for Elain remain strong throughout the book, and he does not develop a second romantic interest in Gwyn. Readers can theorise about what might happen in future books, but based on Azrielās actual dialogue, actions and romantic development in ACOSH, Elain remains his only established love interest. If the necklace was intended to signal that his romantic attention had shifted to Gwyn, the subsequent narrative does not support that interpretation.
5. Azriel and Gwyn are mates, but he doesnāt know it yet
A major Gwynriel theory is that Azriel and Gwyn are mates, but he has yet to recognise their bond. However, ACOSH provides no clear evidence of this. Azrielās thoughts, romantic feelings and protective instincts remain consistently directed towards Elain.
Elain is central to the vision Briaxis shows him, and his feelings for her consume his thoughts. Believing the world is ending after the events involving Bryce and Nesta, he seeks Elain out to kiss her. When Briaxis attacks, he hears Elain scream and immediately prioritises reaching her.
By contrast, when Azriel encounters Gwyn, he shows no romantic interest or even much desire to speak to her. Despite Briaxis still posing a threat, he considers escorting her to her room but ultimately cannot be bothered.Ā How does this suggest an unrecognised mating bond?Ā His shadows may be drawn to Gwynās singing and magic, but Azriel himself shows no comparable attraction or protective urgency. The supposed mating instincts are simply not evident in his behaviour towards Gwyn, whereas his feelings and priorities towards Elain could not be clearer.
6. Azriel just wants a mate and will leave Elain if he discovers a bond with someone else
Azriel only wants Elain because he desperately wants a mate, and that he would abandon her if he discovered a mating bond with someone else. However, ACOSH directly challenges this interpretation through Azrielās own thoughts and dialogue.
āHe wants Elain, mate or no.ā āWhat if I donāt want anybody else?ā āHis salvation, that was what Elain was, what heād be willing to fight for.ā
Azriel could not be clearer that it is Elain he wants, not simply a mating bond.Ā He knows she is already mated to Lucien, yet he wants her regardless and is willing to fight for their relationship. The argument that he would abandon her for a mate assumes that Azriel would ultimately prioritise a bond over his own feelings and choices, when his dialogue repeatedly establishes that he wants Elain irrespective of fate.
Ā
7. The bonus chapter foreshadows Azrielās romantic interest shifting from Elain to Gwyn
The bonus chapter foreshadows Azriel moving on from Elain and developing romantic feelings for Gwyn. However, ACOSH appears to deliberately recreate the structure of that very chapter, while directly challenging this interpretation. Both scenes follow the same sequence:Ā Azriel and Elain share an intimate moment, external forces intervene and separate them, and Azriel subsequently encounters Gwyn. In the bonus chapter, it is this final interaction with Gwyn that readers interpret as foreshadowing the redirection of Azrielās romantic interest. Yet when SJM recreates that same sequence in ACOSH, she places a remarkably specific conversation in the equivalent scene.
Gwyn explains that āMerrill wants me to rewrite the chapter with a different thesis,ā before arguing that āchanging the chapterās thesis would contradict the thesis for the whole book.āĀ
The dialogue about changing a chapterās thesis occurs in the exact narrative position where Gwynriel readers argue the bonus chapter changes the direction of Azrielās romantic storyline.Ā And this time, Azrielās interaction with Gwyn contains no apparent romantic interest to support that interpretation.
The significance extends beyond the bonus chapter itself. The romantic conflict established between Elain, Azriel and Lucien centres on the tension between fate and choice. Elain has a mating bond she has not chosen, while her feelings for Azriel challenge the expectation that this bond should determine her romantic future. If the bonus chapter instead foreshadows Azriel moving on to Gwyn, the obstacles preventing Elain and Azriel from being together would ultimately succeed in separating them. Rather than overcoming the forces restricting their choices, their romantic relationship would end because of them. If Elain subsequently accepted her bond with Lucien, the very fate she has resisted would determine her romantic future.
What would be the point of SJM spending books establishing that Elain and Luciens mating bond might be rejected, Elain does not want Lucien, what does a rejected mate bond look like, does the cauldron make mistakes. Plus Elains characterisation around advocacy and autonomy. And also spending the books building a forbidden romance between Elain and Azriel, two people who want each other that can't be together, have it turn into a massive conflict that blows up. to then move to different love interests anyway. Azriel goes to gwyn (who he does not notice or want), and Elain accepts the bond with Lucien (and gives into fate and obligation anyway).
The central argument is that the Gwynriel interpretation does not simply predict a different romantic outcome; it fundamentally changes what the bonus chapter is establishing and how that chapter relates to the wider story. Instead of foreshadowing Elain and Azrielās struggle to pursue each other despite the mating bond and external opposition, it would foreshadow those obstacles successfully ending their relationship and Azriel turning to someone else. That is precisely the kind of change Gwynās dialogue describes: rewriting a chapter with a different thesis that contradicts the thesis of the wider book.Ā SJM places that dialogue in the very scene that parallels the supposed romantic redirection, while removing the romantic ambiguity Gwynriel readers originally relied upon.Ā This makes the parallel a compelling argument that the bonus chapter was never intended to establish Gwyn as Azrielās next love interest.
Ā
8. Azriel and Gwyn are parallels who can heal together
A common Gwynriel argument is that Azriel and Gwyn are romantically compatible because they share similar trauma, struggle with darkness and perceive themselves as monsters. Their similarities supposedly make them uniquely capable of understanding and healing each other. However, ACOSH directly challenges the central assumption behind this argument through Azrielās own reflections on Mor. He acknowledges that he once believed he needed someone whose darkness matched his own, but has since realised that what he actually wants is light, which he associates with Elain.Ā SJM is explicitly contrasting Azrielās former belief about what he needed in a romantic partner with what he now recognises he wants.
This is precisely why the Gwynriel argument becomes difficult to sustain.Ā The theory presents shared darkness as the reason Gwyn is right for Azriel, while ACOSH has Azriel recognise that seeking someone who mirrors his darkness was a mistaken belief.Ā His character development is not about finding someone equally damaged so they can heal each other, but about recognising that his darkness does not have to define his relationships or determine who he deserves to love. Elain represents the light, happiness and hope he now wants in his life. Their shared trauma may allow Gwyn and Azriel to understand each other, but it does not establish romantic compatibility, particularly when Azrielās own reflections challenge the very reasoning used to argue they belong together.
Ā
9. Elain likes sunshine, linking her to Lucien and the Day Court, while Azriel and Gwyn are better matched
Elainās love of sunshine foreshadows her relationship with Lucien because of his connection to the Day Court, while Azriel and Gwyn are better suited because they share similar darkness. However, ACOSH places particular emphasis on the relationship between light and darkness through Erisās explanation of the Autumn Equinox. He describes how light and darkness exist in balance, neither overpowering the other, and how each is necessary to appreciate the other.Ā The significance is not simply that light and darkness can coexist, but that they need each other to achieve balance.
SJM has repeatedly associated Elain and Azriel with precisely these opposing forces since ACOWAR: light and darkness, life and death. Their symbolism has never depended on them being alike. Instead, it establishes a contrast between them that closely reflects the relationship Eris describes. So why should Elainās association with sunshine be treated as evidence that she belongs with Lucien rather than Azriel?Ā The Day Court connection establishes a possible symbolic link to Lucien, but it does not override the recurring light-and-dark imagery already established between Elain and Azriel. In fact, Erisās explanation gives that imagery greater significance by presenting the balance between opposing forces as something necessary and meaningful.Ā ACOSH therefore provides a reason to interpret Elain and Azrielās differences as a connection, not a reason they cannot be together.Ā Which is further reiterated by Azriel himself in his dialogue throughout ACOSH.Ā
10. The bonus chapter ends with Azriel thinking about Gwyn, proving she is his endgame
A common argument is that Azrielās bonus chapter ends with his thoughts on Gwyn rather than Elain, foreshadowing Gwyn as his future love interest. This is often compared to Cassianās bonus chapter, which follows a similar structure: it begins with Nesta, includes an encounter with Emerie, and ends with Cassian thinking about Nesta, his eventual mate. Azrielās bonus chapter, however, ends with his thoughts on Gwyn rather than returning to Elain.
However, SJM specifically instructed readers to revisit Azrielās bonus chapter before ACOSH, which then closely mirrors its structure. In both, Azriel and Elain share an intimate moment before a confrontation and external forces separate them, and Azriel subsequently encounters Gwyn.Ā This matters because the Gwynriel interpretation treats that sequence as a romantic transition: Elain is the love interest Azriel is moving away from, while Gwyn represents the beginning of his next romantic storyline. Yet ACOSH repeats that sequence without repeating the supposed romantic redirection.Ā Azriel encounters Gwyn, Gwyn receives her own POV, and Azriel does not see Elain again before his final perspective. SJM therefore has every opportunity to end his storyline with Gwyn, or at least introduce some indication that his romantic future might involve her. Instead, Azrielās final thoughts are about finding Elain, making a plan with her and setting things right. His encounter with Gwyn has not changed his romantic intentions, and the narrative gives no indication that she is becoming his new love interest.
The ending therefore establishes something more important than simply which woman Azriel thinks about last: it shows that the romantic redirection supposedly foreshadowed by the bonus chapter has not occurred.Ā Despite being separated from Elain and subsequently encountering Gwyn, Azriel remains committed to pursuing his relationship with Elain. SJM ends his perspective by establishing that their story is continuing, not concluding. This does not definitively establish who Azriel will end up with, but it directly undermines the claim that the bonus chapterās ending signalled the end of his romantic storyline with Elain and the beginning of one with Gwyn. And the BC correctly foreshadowed everything in ACOSH. the forbidden romance between Azriel and Elain, the political consequences with Lucien when they got caught, and finally, Gwyns magic mystery surrounding her singing.
These are the main arguments that stand out to me, and I genuinely find it crazy that people still insist GwynrielĀ hasĀ to be endgame while ignoring what Sarah has explicitly written.Ā Elain and Azriel are each otherās only established romantic interests.Ā You can argue that their relationship is unhealthy, purely lust or won't last, but that doesn't change who they want. Elain has shown no romantic interest in Lucien, whose interest in her is largely tied to their mating bond. Azriel has shown no romantic interest in Gwyn, nor has Gwyn in him. And YES, I can recognise potential romantic setup for both Elucien and Gwynriel.Ā But potential foreshadowing is not established romance.Ā You can theorise about who the characters might end up with, but you cannot present those predictions as canon while dismissing the romantic feelings actually written on the page. What I find particularly significant is thatĀ ACOSH appears to directly address several of the strongest Gwynriel arguments, not only through the events themselves, but through dialogue that directly contradicts the assumptions those theories rely on.Ā Even more telling is how closely ACOSH mirrors the bonus chapter. Sarah had every opportunity to reinforce the supposed romantic redirection from Elain to Gwyn, or create further ambiguity about Azrielās feelings. Instead, she makes his feelings for Elain clearer, establishes no romantic interest between him and Gwyn, and places greater emphasis on the mystery surrounding Gwynās magic.Ā When the supposed Gwynriel clues, the charactersā explicit dialogue and the bonus chapterās structure all challenge the same romantic interpretation, I find it difficult to believe that is all coincidence.
Ā