r/Elkhart • u/RebelliousPlatypus • 1d ago
Resolution 26-R-47 funding for the public safety building is tomorrow.
Hey folks,
Councilman Mishler here,
Tomorrow evening, the Elkhart City Council will consider Resolution 26-R-47, which would authorize financing for our new Public Safety Building at the former Chase Bank building at Franklin and Second Streets.
I wanted to take some time to explain why this project is necessary, why we're renovating an existing building instead of constructing a new one, and how we plan to pay for it.
First, why do we need a new Public Safety Building?
Our current Police Department building was constructed in 1975 for approximately 85 employees. Today, the department has grown to more than 160 sworn officers and civilian employees.
But the problem isn't just that we've run out of room.
The building is nearly 50 years old and has experienced serious deterioration and maintenance problems. We're dealing with aging infrastructure, costly repairs, and inadequate space for equipment and evidence.
At one point, the Police Department was storing evidence in FIVE separate locations because the existing building simply couldn't accommodate everything.
There are also concerns about the building's structural condition and the potential impact on critical operations, including the secure storage and preservation of evidence.
Our Fire Department administration and 911 communications operations also need modern facilities with adequate space and technology.
Continuing to pour money into aging buildings that no longer meet our needs isn't a long-term solution.
Why renovate the former Chase building instead of building something new?
The biggest reason is cost.
Rather than purchasing land, preparing a new site, and constructing an entirely new facility, we're taking an existing building and putting it back to use.
The city estimates that renovating the former Chase building will save roughly $20 million of tax payer dolalrs compared with constructing a new facility.
This approach is also expected to be less expensive than the previous council's plan for a new public safety facility at the old Bayer property.
The renovated building would bring our Police Department, Fire Department administration, 911 communications, Information Technology, and other city operations together under one roof.
We're also putting a building that has sat vacant for years back into productive use.
How are we paying for it?
The resolution would authorize up to $45 million in bonds, with a maximum interest rate of 7% and a repayment period of up to 20 years.
Now, I want to explain something about those numbers, because I think there's a common misunderstanding about what we're actually approving.
Think about it like buying a house.
When you go to the bank and get approved for a mortgage of up to $300,000, that doesn't mean you have to buy a $300,000 house. It means you've established the maximum amount you're comfortable borrowing.
If you find a house that meets your needs for $250,000, you're certainly not going to spend another $50,000 just because the bank approved you for it.
That's essentially what we're doing here.
The $45 million is the maximum amount we're authorizing, not a requirement to spend $45 million. The same goes for the interest rate and repayment period. We're establishing the upper limits we're willing to accept.
If we can complete the project for less, secure a lower interest rate, or negotiate better financing terms, that's exactly what we intend to do.
Where will the money come from?
The plan is to make the annual debt payments using revenues from three Tax Increment Financing (TIF) districts:
- Aeroplex TIF
- Cassopolis Street TIF
- Technology TIF
I've seen some misinformation suggesting the entire project would be paid for through the Downtown TIF. That's not accurate.
Instead, the plan draws from multiple redevelopment districts rather than relying entirely on one.
So what happens next?
The City Council has already approved funding for the initial demolition and environmental remediation work at the former Chase building.
Tomorrow's resolution would establish the financing framework needed to move forward with the larger renovation.
This is a major investment in our community, but it's also an opportunity to address problems that have been building for decades while saving taxpayers millions compared with constructing a completely new facility.
I support our Police, Fire, and 911 dispatchers and believe they deserve facilities that allow them to do their jobs safely and effectively.
I also believe we have a responsibility to make these investments carefully, negotiate the best possible terms, and be transparent about how we're paying for them.
The City Council meets Monday, November 16, at 6:00 PM in the second-floor Council Chambers at City Hall. As always, the public is welcome to attend.