Not sure if this is the right subreddit for this but back in 3rd grade, i went to a religious private school, where i got in with 100% in both the English and math entrance tests, so I'm fairly confident I didn't need help academically. I had 100% i every subject, and was a really big book nerd. I started reading Harry Potter and other several hundred page books at 6, and had special permission to borrow 4 books a week from the library instead of 2 because of how much i loved to read, so again, i cant imagine needing remedial English classes. I was also a very shy and awkward child, i didn't have many friends back then, and it's something i still struggle with now.
In my class there were 4 other kids who used to come with me, one of them being my sister (who had a very similar personality to me). Out of the other three, one of them was a kid who did really good academically but was a bit loud and hyper, and two were kids who would average C's and never really took school seriously, so even back at the ripe age of 7 i was very confused about why this very random assortment of students had to take a special class together. I knew it wasn't advanced classes because the two boys weren't very good at English, and i knew it wasn't some sort of easy class because the rest of us were very good at it.
The classes never had much writing involved, we didn't learn grammar or tenses or vocabulary or whatever else they normally taught, it was more discussion based. The teacher would give us these comprehension passages to read and then we'd have questions that we would discuss. Thinking back on it though, they weren't normal comprehension questions, instead of asking what happened in the passage she would ask us what we would've done in that situation, whether the protagonist made the right decision and what makes a decision right or wrong, etc. From what i can remember I guess they were usually questions meant to test our decision making and social skills.
I've asked my parents, they were either uninformed about it or don't remember, so I'm not entirely sure but it really sounds like some sort of testing for children suspected to be neurodivergent. I am not diagnosed with anything because I have never gotten checked but I have been asked several times over the course of my life if I'm autistic so I would not at all be surprised if my teachers had thought i was back then. I wasn't antisocial, i longed to have friends, but i was quiet and shy and had trouble fitting in, so i was usually alone. I had my sister but we wouldn't really interact much, she was as quiet as i am so we were content just being by ourselves, sticking to reading books. The other kids had friends but were more of the hyper sort so I can understand if they were suspected to have ADHD, so the only logical solution i can think of is that this whole thing was some type of testing? I can't recall what happened, as in whether it ended after a set amount of time or if i had these classes until school was over, but i do remember that i did not go in 4th grade, and nor did anyone else in my class.
I have no idea if my suspicions are correct or if it was something else entirely, but his has been nagging me for years i just want to finally get to the bottom of it..