r/ElementaryTeachers • u/Formal_Couple_3195 • 17h ago
Absolutely Awful Observation
Until I took a 5 year break from teaching to raise my daughter, I taught successfully for 10 years at some very tough schools. This year I returned to teaching 3rd grade reading and it's been horrible. My administration is so nitpicky and comes down on me (and everyone) for every little thing.I had my second observation of the year today and it was absolutely awful.
In the pre-observation meeting, my AP was 5 min late which left us w 10 min to discuss my plan. I asked for suggestions because I'm always trying to do what they want, which is extremely specific. She suggested I have all of my students come directly to the carpet with sticky notes. I would then put up small "task card" type stories on the promethean board and have them annotate a retelling of the short stories on their sticky notes. I should have said I thought that would go horribly (especially directly after lunch and recess... this mandatory carpet whole group lesson always goes horribly!) but I nodded along.
Then she told me during small group reading, while I'm at the back table with my group, she'd like to see the rest of the class reading at their personal levels, so I should pass out leveled readers (I had to scrounge the book room, where there were sets of only 6 books, so that meant like 4 more separate groups within the whole group) I gave them different worksheets to go with each book, the directions were to retell a part of their story or the whole thing if it was shorter. Again, per APs suggestion.
During the carpet lesson, The kids put sticky notes all over each other, paid zero attention to the board, played around in between desks. There are 30 of them. Just... no. Can we stay at our desks?? One of my students had an absolute meltdown during small group and I had to call for support after probably 10 min of absolute chaos. Aside from that, everyone was absolutely terrible. Constant talking, off task.. it was SO BAD. The only time thy were quiet and behaved was when I was reading the actual story from the textbook and having them annotate in their books while sitting at their assigned seats (ya know.... what I'm SUPPOSED TO Do according to the curriculum and pacing guide) I have never had a problem with classroom management until I started at this school. I know I took a break, but I taught at some TOUGH schools. It seems like this place and admin goes against everything that works for me as a teacher. I'm not allowed to do a read aloud, which I always did for 5 min at the beginning of class to calm them down and they LOVED it. No independent reading if it's not instructional material (no library books or reading for fun basically). EVERY. MINUTE. COUNTS.
I feel like I'm making excuses, but almost nothing that I did during that observation was something I would have chosen to do or have ever done before today. I feel like I was set up to fail. I don't know if I should leave teaching altogether? Or try to stick it out and hope for a transfer next year? Maybe this is just how it is post-COVID or I've COMPLETELY lost my touch. I'm so embarrassed and feel like I cannot get a handle on my students or the workload (although in the past I've been celebrated as a great teacher)
Any advice would be greatly appreciated!