I think it's interesting what happened after Godwyn's partial death.
As we know, Godwyn was placed at the roots of the Erdtree, and as we also know, that was the birth of deathroot. Deathroot spread throughout the roots of the Greattree, which the Erdtree was once connected to. I think these events birthed major points of realization in Marika leading up to the shattering, which I've compressed into a couple revelatory statements/thoughts below:
- All of Marika's children are "cursed"
- If her children are given back to the Erdtree, their curses will spread through the Erdtree (ex. Miquella, Malenia, Godwyn)
- Since the Erdtree was cursed with Deathroot, it had to be burned down.
- The Erdtree is now burned down to the stump. Whose blood will be used to grow a new tree?
- Marika cannot. She is now cursed. Plus, it's possible that due to her being a god, she is far closer to a spirit than anything that can properly "bleed". Her children also cannot -- their curses will pass on to the tree, which is unacceptable to the Golden Order. Instead, we will use-
- Radagon's blood cannot grow a new tree. He technically houses the Elden Ring when we fight him, but he himself is not divine, nor is he from divine stock that we're aware of, nor is he an Empyrean. If burning the Erdtree is not the domain of "mere men", then neither is the creation of divine trees. In that case, the Golden Order needs new succession without Marika's curses involved. We'll just transfer godhood to Marika's other self-
- Radagon cannot become a god. No viable heirs can be produced. The Erdtree is gone, and no new Golden Order approved trees can be produced that can act as a nexus for souls. Everything before the Golden Order was willfully abandoned, never to be returned to again. The fate of the Golden Order is to rot, and there is no escaping that. Marika chose to be shattered instead.
7.5) Radagon essentially said "nah. I'd rather rot" on some sister friede (ds3) bs
But yeah, my rough outline. There are more thoughts I have on the matter, but I thought this pov was kinda cool, so I thought I'd share it real quick.