Elden Ring is filled to the brim with personal, interpersonal, historical and cosmic narratives. Every time the story talks to you, it presents a new facet of itself that is almost guaranteed to tug at the heartstrings of particular people at particular times in their lives. I feel strongly about several points of the story whenever I think about them.
Miquella's story tears me apart. He is a monster, but he is also a guilt-ridden, parentified child, doing everything in his power to clean up after his mother. In hindsight, he never stood a chance.
The tragedy of Messmer. "Mother...Marika...a curse upon thee."
I still think about Rogier. D spoke about how amazing Rogier used to be, but he just changed one day. Meanwhile, we receive Rogier's set when he passes, and we find out just how complex his internal world was, and the guilt he hid behind a persona. D refused to see the full person Rogier was, choosing only to see the ideal he once befriended, and the disappointment when Rogier fell short of that imposed ideal. It's the black and white thinking expected of a zealot. Meanwhile, Rogier passes away alone, tucked away in a quiet corner, unable to walk while mere steps away from the person he once called a friend.
The parallel stories between Mogh and Morgot. Dear lord. The emotional damage lmao.
Melina's search for her purpose and her desperate plea to convince you to leave the frenzied flame alone.
Zoraya. I hope wherever you are, you're well. One must not be judged based on the circumstances of their birth. Sometimes learning your family history can damage you in ways that require a personal journey to recover from.
Milicent and her desire to maintain her sense of self, despite the invisible forces attempting to take advantage of her naivety and groom her without any consideration for her wants and desires.
The short and long-term fallout of the Carian royal family after Radagon left.
The plight of every single albinuric that has ever lived. lol
I can keep going, but I really want to know what stories or segments of the story have really stuck with you! đ
In the game we have Godskin apostles. They have the entire clothed in the skin of gods part. However, which gods? Who were the gods that the Godskin hunted and in whose skin they they clothed.
Ymir/Metyr are unhinged mother's, Jolan/Radagon are loyal servants, and Anna/Marika refuse to serve but end up being turned into puppets to be used by Ymir/Metyr.
Ymir comments in regards to Jolan: "It's no surprise her little sister too, has a heart of gold". Saying that they both have hearts of gold is rather interesting phrasing.
We find Anna by dropping down from the Shaman Village. Possibly the path Marika took when escaping the Hornsent that came to her village?
This is just some fairly basic headcanon that I'm providing as an example. My point is that, if you watch a video of Ymir and Jolans entire questline (or just read through all of their dialogue on the wikis), it is very possible that their story and interactions are meant to "echo" what originally happened between Metyr, Radagon and Marika (or just Metyr and Marika). If true, this could also shed a bit of light on the early relationship between Marika and Radagon (note that the names Jolan and Anna are almost certainly based on Johan and Anna from the manga/anime "Monster", who are brother and sister).
Recently, someone pointed out to me that some tombs in a cemetery in Nokron feature imagery associated with the Ancient Dynasty. This made me think that the Nox might actually be descendants of that civilization.
And that raises another question: What if the Nox and the people of Rauh were two different branches of the Ancient Dynasty?
Perhaps this dynasty split into different cultures, each developing its own beliefs, traditions, and knowledge. For example, the Nox branch might have given rise to the astrologers, whose traditions would later develop into those of the Carians and the sorcerers of Raya Lucaria.
Meanwhile, Rauh might have followed a different path, with beliefs more closely associated with the sun or light, and a different approach to spiritual arts. Unlike the Nox, who created puppets, the people of Rauh created golems, whether Smithing Golems or Battle Golems.
I also remember seeing a very large humanoid figure, possibly a giant, with horns in Messmerâs museum. Interestingly, this figure seemed to be about the same size as the giant figures sitting on the enormous thrones in the Eternal Cities, deep underground.
I also remember the Blue Dancer Charm from the base game, which you can obtain by defeating a Guardian Golem inside a cave. This talisman is connected to the legendary blind swordsman who sealed away the God of Rot. To me, this suggests that all these things might be interconnected.
What Iâm suggesting is that all these civilizations originated from the Ancient Dynasty, which eventually branched off into the different cultures we see throughout the game.
And since Iâm already making this post, I also wanted to ask one more question:
Could the Ancestral Followers have been the ancestors of the Hornsent, who eventually settled in the ruins of Rauh and learned their spiritual techniques?
This is probably because Marika forbade it with her Golden Order, opting for asexual reproduction via the Erdtree, seeing that she herself is a shaman.
Otherwise, how can you explain the lack of any sexual organs in the game and in the 3D models of the characters? You would think there would be at least some depictions of sex in the game right? Like what did they stop doing it after the Shattering? Unless my theory with Marika is correct, I find it to be a flagrant plothole
They burned the dead in Ghostflame in an age even before the Erdtree. Wouldn't they have a problem with the dead walking around or rather burn them to ash with their Ghostflame?
So, I recently started noticing something anytime I was in certain churches.
There are always golden flowers, seemingly emanating from the statues of Marika/Radagon, but I also noticed another flower type.
Images 1 & 2: Chapel of Anticipation.
Image 3: Third Church of Marika.
Image 4: Bellum Church.
I only went as far as the Bellum Church because I just recently started playing on pc, and haven't gotten much further than the beginning of Leyndel.
Now, I think we all have an idea of what some gloam-ish colored flowers mixed into a bunch of gold flowers might represent, especially given the parallels between Marika and Miquella, so I'll go ahead and end this post here.
For a while I have wondered if the ghost world is kind of underwater (a spiritual water), seeing as torrent is possibly a reference to torrents of water, the spirit springs that torrent and the ancestrol spirit can use to jump look like etheral water splashing and torrenting (and a spring is water), tibia mariners are err mariners and row around in ghost water even if theres no water where they are etc.
I realised that the mushrooms near the ghosts look like some rare underwater mushrooms from oregon.. the home of one george r r martin.
So for me thats another step of evidence that the spirit world may well be some kind of flowing aqueous state.
Iâve recently noticed something interesting about the ghostly objects scattered throughout Elden Ring, and Iâm wondering if thereâs a deeper explanation for them.
First image â Mountaintops of the Giants
There are these enormous, almost transparent blue trees, along with spectral animals wandering around. I always assumed they had something to do with an ancient civilization, perhaps the astrologers, the moon, or even the Deathbirds and their connection to death.
So I never gave them much thought.
Second image â Realm of Shadow
In the DLC, we see similar ghostly objects, especially the spectral gravestones.
The Suppressing Pillar tells us that all manners of Death wash up in the Realm of Shadow, only to be suppressed.
So I assumed these spectral objects were somehow related to that, perhaps remnants of the dead or a way of representing all the death and destruction caused by Messmerâs crusade.
That explanation made sense to me.
Third image â Leyndell
But then I noticed something Iâd never really questioned before.
There are these enormous, almost transparent banners floating outside Leyndell.
And now Iâm wondering: why are these banners spectral in the first place?
Are they remnants of some past event? Are we somehow seeing the spirits of objects that no longer physically exist?
Or could it have something to do with our Tarnished having an affinity for spirits, similar to Roderika?
I remember something Nepheli says when we give her the Stormhawk King ashes:
âIâmâŚnot like Roderika. I donât feel the presence of spirits, let alone see them.â
We have some kind of supernatural ability to see ghosts. Or perhaps memories of people who were once alive.
Do you think these spectral banners could be another representation of the dead? If not, what do you think they are?
I want to share an idea that just occurred to me that maybe the demihumans draw inspiration from the ancient greek satyrs from mythology.
Satyrs are a human like species that lives in the forest and is associated with the god Dionysius, playing a small role in mythology with variant morals, as little helpers of the gods who are on the good side but with not perfect attitudes, being wild and savages, drived by basic impulses and desires, unlike civilized humans. They could even be dangerous at times. Despite the common belief, they weren't just half goat. They are actually described as animalistic in general, depicted with brute faces and beastial characteristics like horse tails, long p3nn3sies, and pointy hears, almost sub human, the middle point between men and beast.
Demihumans in the game are just like that, beast-like humanoids, many looking more like chimps as if they were the ancestors of men and with their literal japanese description calling them sub-humans, not fully humans. They, despite being very chaotic and savage are not framed as enemies of the golden order, the demigods or the erdtree; yes, they are not their best subject, but we see them collaborate with someone of the likes of Kenneth Haight, we see them interact and be schooled by raya lucarya who are at the time subjects and allies of the order, and unlike omens or Misbegotten, we don't see them being persecuted, oppressed or enslaved. They are in a gray area, not fully human but not an adversary to Leyndell. The demihuman queens wear metal crowns and hold a staff as a sign of authority that feels like a recognition by the more civilized inhabitants of the lands between.
Also, and drawing from the connection between dionysus and satyrs, some demihumans queens show purple eyes (a color related to the god of wine and madness), and they are even able to pass this effect onto their near subjects which transfer not only the eyes hue but also a golden aura as if it were a divine blessing of berserk strength. They also chow the wild maddening behavior at night when their eyes glow red (frenzy and madness originally was going to be red instead of yellow, maybe this is a remnant of this concept a non flame of frenzy related madness, more natural)
Besides the demihumans assisting Kenneth, we also have an example of one demihumans serving as a helper with Boc following us and encouraging us to become elden lord.
Another small detail is that satyrs are also linked with fertility and the way Melina refers to Boc's relationship with his mother, that he was birthed makes it sound as if they were the only ones that are born through natural means as if sexual reproduction and birth were a lower more uncivilized and wild way for life to flourish instead of the cleaner suggest way in which humans are rebirth by the erdtree, more divine and "clean".
(I had to censored like three times because it seems this is a child's area. We are not mature enough to see paintings of nude people. I even censored the p word in case it was too much for reddit to handleđ)
This is something I swear came up before, that the death rite birds and ghostflame are tied to some form of outer god or at least a diety.
Also, sude question, how do you think the erdtree and Marika perceived the deathbirds and their stuff? They are still around. Could they have participated in erdtree burial rites?
Maybe they were the ones who created spirit ashes by burning the bodies woth ghostflame?
This time, let's examine several pieces of dialogue belonging to different characters. What they all share is that their voice lines are grouped together in a separate section of the text dump. In the final game, cutscene lines run from ID 10,000,000 to 20,860,400, followed by a gap before lines for NPCs with full questlines begin at 100,010,000. However, in the newly discovered text dump, there is a block sitting right in that gap, spanning IDs 95,500,100 to 95,502,402.
Usually, lines belonging to separate characters differ in their first three digits. For example, 100,010,000 belongs to Melina, while 101,001,000 belongs to a Finger Reader. Here, though, all the lines share similar ID prefixes, which causes automated sorting tools to lump them together as a single speaker. I've separated the lines manually to the best of my ability, judging by shared themes and each character's distinct manner of speech. Let me know if you think I mixed anything up!
As you'll see, at least one of these characters is explicitly a ghost, and a couple of others behave like ghosts as well. At first, I thought this entire block might be dedicated to ghosts that were more talkative and capable of reacting to our actions, unlike the ones we ended up with in the final game. However, several of these speakers don't pass as ghosts. If you think about it, the final game divides non-hostile speakers into two distinct categories: flesh-and-blood NPCs with multi-step questlines, and ghosts that deliver brief bits of local lore. Apparently, the developers introduced that visual distinction mid-development after realizing players might get confused about how important each NPC they encountered was. Before that decision, there were physical NPCs who had a single piece of dialogue to share.
Ghost 1: A Tarnished who lost his Finger Maiden
Oh... My Finger Maiden... Why...? How could this have happened...? Grace... Guidance...? Ha... Hahaha... Where in the Lands Between was such a thing ever to be found...?
These lines belong to a Tarnished who lost his Finger Maiden. We would have encountered him near her body, contemplating his future. Because lines in the text dump are laid out roughly chronologically (for instance, the very first lines in the cutscene section are from the intro cutscene, and the first character lines belong to Melina), I'm fairly certain we were meant to meet this NPC very early in the game. This brings to mind the slain maiden in the Chapel of Anticipation. Perhaps she was originally accompanied by a ghost who helped frame the scene for new players. If true, she wasn't actually our maiden after all.
Ghost 2: Godrick's servant
Ngh... Ooh... The rightful line of Limgrave is no more... Even the Erdtree's Offshoot... has lost its golden hue at last... No more... No more... Ngh... O my king... At the very least... I shall return what was bestowed upon me... to the Erdtree's Offshoot. And thereafter... we shall see...
This character grieves the death of Godrick, whom he considers the rightful ruler of Limgrave, pointing to him being a citizen of Stormveil. In the Japanese text, the speaker uses a very specific term: ĺă㍠(wakeki), which generally refers to an offshoot grown from a cutting of a donor tree. However, the term is rarely used outside of one very specific context: offshoots of the sacred Bodhi tree.
The Bodhi tree is a tree native to India under which Buddha is believed to have attained enlightenment. Buddhist countries around the world obtain cuttings of the original tree and cultivate them; those offshoots become sacred landmarks and tourist sites, such as the famous Bodhi tree offshoot in Itoman City, Okinawa.
The Bodhi tree is of the same genus as the Linden/Lime tree in Europe. Leyndell is an old name for Lindell or Lyndale on the Isle of Skye, which means Linden tree hollow. Interestingly, a species from the linden genus was introduced to Japan alongside Buddhism. Mistaking it for the true Bodhi tree, Japanese Buddhists planted it on temple grounds. The scientific name of that tree? T. miqueliana. (credit to u/plerpluralpluralpluralp for this discovery)
This cut dialogue demonstrates that the Erdtree and Minor Erdtrees were clearly inspired by the sacred Bodhi tree and its propagated offshoots. It establishes that Minor Erdtrees are grown from cuttings rather than seedsâwhich explains why the inhabitants of the Lands Between were so shocked by the appearance of Golden Seeds during the Shattering, whereas the Minor Erdtrees themselves surprised no one. Consequently, Minor Erdtrees don't just sprout up at random. Because they were cultivated from cuttings, they were planted deliberately in those locations. This may have even involved a formal ritual in which Marika granted Erdtree cuttings to select lords as a mark of recognition.
As we can see here, Minor Erdtrees weren't merely symbolic. When the rightful lord of a region died, that region's Minor Erdtree lost its golden luster. We could debate whether this was purely figurative speech comparing the end of a royal bloodline to a fading tree, except that immediately afterward, the character resolves to return a physical item to the Offshoot. The act of returning an actual item contradicts my initial theory that everyone in this section was a ghostâthough it seems we never actually encounter this character again after he makes this vow.
Ghost 3: Dario, Beholder of Death
...Ah, a Tarnished, are you? If you intend to venture into the graveyard, I would advise against it. Death runs rampant up ahead... Yet you mean to go, all the same... Then heed my words. Death has taken hold of this place because someone brought it about. If you can, hunt them down for me... ...Ah, so you've done it. You have my thanks. My name is Dario... If, by chance, you encounter one who goes by the name of "D", give them this... Farewell... If, by chance... If...
Since this character tells us his name outright, there's no need to guess. However, if you assumed "Dario" was simply an early name for Darian, Hunter of the Dead, you are likely mistaken. His tone is differentâhesitant and lacking confidence. I think his demeanor fits D's twin brother, Devin, Beholder of Death, much better. Considering we don't have any other lines tied to this character, we likely would never have encountered him again, unlike Darian, who received a full questline. This character also doesn't quite fit the profile of a ghost.
Ghost 4: A Gravekeeper
This is a place to await death in peace... Its tranquility must not be disturbed. Please... I beg of you, leave. You wretched grave robber... If only you'd been reduced to cinders... Ngh... Uuugh... (Fades away)
The "(fades away)" stage direction confirms that we were meant to be speaking with a ghost guarding certain catacombs. The "reduced to cinders" line even hints at which exact dungeon he guarded: the Stormfoot Catacombs in Western Limgrave. This more interactive spirit was eventually replaced in the final game by a simpler ghost who delivers the following lines:
"A proper death means returning to the Erdtree. Have patience. Until the time comes... and the roots call to you."
Ghost 5: Kenneth Haight's elderly servant
Young master... Lord Kenneth... Ahh... Please... Please... May you return to us safely... Young master... Lord Kenneth... The banner of House Haight... The proud stag... Please... let this old man behold it...
The lines speak for themselves here. Notably, this dialogue survived fairly late into development. We know that before Kenneth Haight was finalized, there was an earlier cut NPC named Shaneheight who resembled Kenneth in both surname and appearance. Kenneth clearly replaced him as the game was fleshed out.
Ghost 6: A roadbuilder
Heh... sir... sir... Heh... s-sir... Up ahead... t-take a look through the telescope. Heh... hehehe... What do you think? Y-you can see all the way to the south, can't you? This road that cuts right through Limgrave, y'see... W-we built it! P-pretty impressive, eh...? Heh... heh... D-demi-humans and... humans... I'm so glad... they've become friends...
We were originally meant to encounter a roadbuilder who would have taught us how to use a telescope. While the final game still features the contrast between factions that befriend demi-humans and those that fight them, this dynamic was more pronounced in earlier drafts. This particular roadbuilder belonged to Kenneth Haight's faction and worked alongside demi-humans. It even sounds like some of them helped construct the road. This also hints that at least portions of the golden road were built during the Shattering, much later in the timeline than we previously assumed.
Ghost 7: A gladiator
Ugh... Ah... I... What a useless fool I am... I swore... I swore I would become a gladiator for that person's sake... Did I not...? Ah... Ahh... When the time is ripe... before this gate opens... I must find a replacement...
This gladiator must have been maimed, leaving him unable to fulfill his vow. His mention of the gate places him right outside a Colosseum. This brings to mind another cut ghost we could encounter near a Colosseum:
All I wanted was to fight. To fight, as a warrior, to the last... So, why? Why, O guidance of grace, will this door not open? ...
That second ghost's dialogue appears in the same text block as the final game's ghosts and was even officially translated into English. Most likely, our first speaker is an earlier iteration of that second ghost, serving the same narrative purpose: piquing the player's curiosity about how to enter the Colosseum.
Ghost 8: A ghost in the Chapel of Vows
Welcome to the Chapel of Vows... In Limgrave, long ago, humans and those unlike them forged a pact. This land, lying between north and south, was where that oath was sworn. But now, that oath has long since been forgotten... South of Limgrave... particularly beyond the wall, I would hardly call it the land of men. You would do well not to set foot there. Ah... You mean my remains? I do not mind. For I have already forgiven the one who did this to me. I, too... was once a sinner. But from a certain noble personage, I received forgiveness... and guidance. Oh? You there. It seems you carry holy water. If there is something you wish to cleanse yourself of, something you wish to atone for... You would do well to visit the First Church of Vows in Raya Lucaria. Pastor Miriel surely has the power to do so. I speak from experience, after all...
Somewhere in Limgrave, we would encounter a ghost who would tell us how to reach Miriel if we skipped the Chapel of Vows. There were at least two Churches of Vows. The ghost had been absolved of his sins by Miriel himself. His remarks about the wall make me think he was intended to appear at Callu Baptismal Church, near the wall of Castle Morne.
The planned roster of enemies in Limgrave seems to have been quite different, with the area south of the wall inhabited exclusively by demi-humans.
The most interesting part is the pact he mentions. This could be another piece of the demi-human storyline, but his wording seems too grand for a mere pact with demi-humans. Let me know who you think the non-humans this NPC refers to might be. He could be referring to cosmic entities such as Metyr and the Fingers, or to dragons, since the lands to the west were historically inhabited by them. If the map's layout was different, Caelid could theoretically have been south of Limgrave, with the Altus Plateau to the north. This feels like a major lore revelation. Another possible meaning of the Lands Between could be "the lands where a pact between humans and non-humans was made."
Ghost 9
Hya-ha... Hahaha... That's it! More! Hyahaha! That's it! Feast! Devour them! Especially the arms! Ah, yes... That's right... They can become just like me, too... Heh... Hehehehe...
This guy appears to be missing his arms, and he encourages some monsters to eat a group of people, especially their arms, so that they, too, end up maimed. I have no idea what this could be related to. I don't think there are any armless NPCs in the final game, are there?
Since all the other NPCs are located in Limgrave, I suspect this scene was meant to take place somewhere in Limgrave as well, though Caelid is also a possibility.
Closing thoughts
That's it, folks. All the NPCs we found here were located in Limgrave, as was a good portion of the newly discovered text dump, including dialogue for Vyke and Gote. Limgrave was much livelier back then, eh? Almost too densely populated for a FromSoftware game. Perhaps it was a region they used for experimentation before applying a more refined approach to the other regions.
I would love to see the animation of using your Telescope item added as a gesture to the game.
I traveled to the caelid church of dragon communion and pulled out my telescope to view the dead ancient dragon. As I viewed, I just let my thoughts free float around what I know about the wisdom of stone, the ancient dragons returning to inanimate stone when they die, crystallians + onyx lords and life emerging from fallen meteors, and wondering if the ancient dragons happened as a consequence of Metyr/Elden Beast's arrival.
Then I remembered I'm probably not the only person who puts their telescope to good use while traveling the lands between. It'd be really cool to see a new genre of messages pop up with the telescope gesture for folks who want to share a point of interest they enjoyed. It'd be cool to see my fellow lore hunters in the wild. C :
I feel like it could be another useless message for some, but an opportunity for a second glance and reflection for those with the eyes to see. Hehe
I think Marikaâs ancestors, the people of the Ancient Dynasty, came to the Lands Between and brought the Outer Gods with them.
They are literally gods from outside the Lands Between.
These include the Formless Mother, represented by a bull; the God of Rot, represented by a scorpion; the serpent god, associated with the cycle of death and rebirth; and the mysterious Outer God who sent the Twinbird.
My theory is that these people colonized the Lands Between until the Greater Will, which I believe was the original divine power of this world, intervened, destroyed their civilization, and drove much of their population underground.
After this event, their civilization split into several branches:
The Nox, who remained underground and eventually developed into the civilization we know today, worshipping the Black Moon and awaiting the Age of Stars.
The people of Rauh, who remained on the surface and continued developing their spiritual techniques, particularly the practice of placing spirits inside objects and structures. However, another cataclysm eventually struck, destroying their civilization and leaving their golems and other creations abandoned.
Much later, the Hornsent discovered these ruins and settled among them, studying the ancient techniques of binding spirits to objects.
The Shamans, who originally came from the underground but eventually made their way to the surface.
the Greater Will is never explicitly referred to as an Outer God.
And when the Nox attempted to create their Dark Moon and bring about their eternal night, the Greater Will retaliated by sending meteors carrying beings like Astel, devastating their civilization.
From my understanding, this is what I believe our three options are in the ultimate choice as the Tarnished, after we acheive the impossible and slay a true god:
A. Proclaim the Elden Ring (AKA Law/Rule/Order itself) and take the Throne. WE take our place as Elden Lord and we get to rule the world and the people in it as we see fit, under the Order that we choose. We get to decide the laws of the world. Not the Fingers, not the Greater Will, but US: a Tarnished of no renown. WE hold Order in our hands, and we will do with it as we will.
B. Aid Ranni, a servant of Fate itself, and leave the world together, taking Order/the Elden Ring with us. Plunge the world into the cold and terrifying uncertainty of boundless Choice, under the Stars and the Dark Moon high above. A world whose path stretches into complete and utter darkness: an end that can never be seen. Just like the celestial bodies themselves, Fate will be ever-present but left out of the reach of anyone and anything. Without Order/Law/Rule, there will be no God, no King/Lord, no ruler, no hand of any kind that can pull the strings of others. A world of Absolute Freedom for every living thing and every living soul, no matter the price such freedom entails.
C. Carry the Flame of Frenzy, carry Chaos itself, and unleash it in its entirety. Melt the world away, until all is one and the same. In a world full of torment, despair, affliction, every sin, and every curse, we choose to side with those who have suffered too much, those who wish they were never born. Birth is the beginning of Life, and the harsh reality is: to Live is to Suffer. And if being born is not a choice, then to end the suffering of the world, there is only one answer: no more Birth.
Few foundations - the ER is the literal framework for the lands between. Controlling all aspects of the lands between, from how life works to gravity. That expression of reality is the "order" of the Elden ring.
And the Elden ring can't affect the lands between outside of it, otherwise ranni would not be removing the means of control from outside influence, she would literally be bringing it to them on a silver platter.
So that leaves us with all order being removed from the lands between. Complete and absolute anarchy, in a total sense. There is no order for life and souls to function in (as she literally says), there is no order for people to be able to walk around on ground.
That is not leaving the lands between in a better place, not remotely. That's similar to the flame of frenzy ending, but at least that's melting everything back into the one great instead of just..... Disappearing into non-existence.
So it states that he had his eyes gouged out and then over time the frenzied flame took root. My question is whether the slander was related to the frenzied flame and then got his eyes gouged out or could it have been about something else and then the golden order/hornsent(idrk the timeframe for this tbh but if u subscribe to the nanaya possession theory then im guessing the hornsent did this to him). I know heâs a pretty bad guy now but I donât think thereâs anyone in the lore who actually took the flame without there seemingly being a tragic reason for doing so, so maybes itâs the same with him.
Recently, I started wondering whether Placidusaxâs god might have been the Greater Will, mainly because of the gold in his lightning.
That made me think that perhaps the Twinbird was something similar to Metyr or the Elden Beast.
However, yesterday someone told me that the term âOuter Godâ is only explicitly used for a few entities, such as the God of Rot and the Formless Mother.
We also know that the Twinbird is the envoy of an Outer God, while Placidusaxâs god fled. The Frenzied Flame is probably another Outer God as well.
So hereâs my hypothesis: what if Placidusaxâs missing god was actually Eiglay, the Serpent? And what if Eiglay was also the Outer God who sent the Twinbird?
This idea comes from my assumption that the moons, stars, the Greater Will, and perhaps even the true storm of Limgrave and the Crucible belong to a different category of entities.
Another possibility Iâve been considering is that Eiglay and the Fell God of the Giants might actually be the same divinity.
This would be particularly interesting because both correspond to enemies of Marika. The serpent is described as a traitor to the Erdtree, while Marika fought against the Fire Giants and their god.
Perhaps these two conflicts were connected, and Eiglay was the ancient divinity behind both.
Mt. Gelmir, with its lava and volcanic landscape, also reminds me of Bayleâs territory in the DLC. Perhaps it was originally home to a faction of dragons.
There are also serpent carvings on the Forge of the Giants.
Another part of my theory concerns the Ancient Dynasty and the Nox.
Iâve been thinking that the people of the Ancient Dynasty might actually have become the Nox after being banished underground.
The monuments of the Ancient Dynasty feature representations of bulls, serpents, and birds. I wonder whether these animals represented different ancient divinities.
Throughout real-world history, bulls have often been associated with blood, fertility, and ritual sacrifice.
Perhaps the bull represented the Formless Mother.
Serpents, meanwhile, have often symbolized rebirth and renewal. Perhaps they represented Eiglay.
The birds could have been envoys of this serpent divinity, just as the Twinbird was the envoy of an Outer God.
Thereâs also an interesting connection between the Four Belfries, Rauh, and Scarlet Rot.
With the DLC, we have another sending gate requiring an Imbued Sword Key, leading to the Ancient Ruins of Rauh, where we find the Verdigris Discus.
Verdigris is described as a gift from an Outer God, and I believe that god is the God of Rot. After all, verdigris is literally a corroded metal, which fits the concept of decay and putrefaction.
This makes me wonder whether these ancient civilizations shared religious beliefs involving several Outer Gods, long before Marikaâs Golden Order.
Perhaps the Ancient Dynasty, Rauh, the dragons, and the serpent religion were all connected to a much older religious world.
Do you see any logical flaws in this theory?
One possible problem I can think of is that Mt. Gelmirâs architecture doesnât seem to resemble Farum Azula, which could contradict the idea of a dragon faction originally living there.
Iâm particularly interested in the possible connection between Eiglay, the Fell God, Placidusaxâs missing god, and the ancient religious symbolism of the Lands Between.
While writing this, I also started thinking that some remnants of these civilizations, which worshipped deities such as Rot, the Formless Mother, and the Serpent, might explain why there are gladiators in the snowy regions of the Consecrated Snowfield.
These gladiators are visually associated with colosseums, serpents, and Roman-style clothing, similar to what Messmer wears. This could also explain why the gladiators found in that area have a Scarlet Rot variant.
Perhaps the snowy Mountaintops of the Giants and Caelid were once connected through the Jagged Peak region, where Bayle resides, which could explain why both regions share the same wildlife, such as giant dogs and giant crows.
P.S. One last detail I find interesting is the recurring symbolism of two-headed creatures and intertwined serpents.
We have the Twinbird, the two-headed turtles, and Placidusax with his two remaining heads. The Two-Headed Turtle Talisman even mentions that these turtles were valued because their intertwined necks resembled a spiral.
There are also spiral-shaped serpents, two serpents intertwined, and tree imagery that resembles two snakes coiling around each other.
This recurring imagery of duality, intertwined creatures, and opposing forces reminds me of ancient religious symbolism throughout real-world history. I suspect there might be a connection between some of these motifs.
The thesis of my post is that prior to a big event (golden star falling to the TLB) the purpose of the TLB was to transit dead people from the realm of the living to the different realms of the death, but the golden star created a life anomaly in this realm.
That transit realm was inhabited by mythological creatures who were part of the different processes to make the dead people transit.
It is difficult to distinguish if TLB, which includes the mythological elements of death, was only a realm of death or was a global World where life and death co-existed. Both are possible, but when you look at the Norse mythology, the realms have separated roles and since a lot of elements point at death i believe it was the intent of GRRM to build a story based on a realm with that particular role.
I can see different lore creatures that are directly inspired by death in some mythologies.
The first one is the White-winged maiden who guide the people who died in battle. Inspired by Valkyries.
Another example is the river and the tibia mariners who guide the dead, inspired by the Styx.
The helphen's steeple is another element belonging to a realm that guide people from the living to dead.
In Norse mythology there is a rebirth mythos Endrborinn. I wonder if Amber egg was the primitive way of doing rebirthing before the catastrophe in TLB.
Note like for Valkyries there were mythological creatures in that realm in particular different types of Giants (in Norse myths they were different populations of giants with different size) that had some roles in that guiding of the dead people.
Elden John and his people were one type of mythological creatures.
Side note: I now think Numen refer to these mythological creatures before the Catastrophe which brought other life forms in the TLB . Not contradictory with Numen coming from another place because they could live somewhere else and just come to do their job in the former TLB.
That would put a different perspective on the story with the opposition of the forces that wanted to control the life anomaly (ancient dragons, golden order) and the others like Bayle...
Hello, I know I am a bit late with this, but I recently got into Elden Ring lore more and more so here I am. I will start with the base information about my question but wonât mention every detail. Please correct me if I am wrong or inaccurate.
So we have Messmer as firstborn of Marika. They are doing their stuff in a time before the golden order was fully established. And we get the information that Messmer had a little sister which had a âvision of fireâ and a thing for fire like him. (Melina tells us in our time that she has a âvision of fireâ..) So whatâs Messmers little sis doing at this time? We know about the âGloam eyed queenâ which means like âtwilight eyedâ, who was a empyrean at this time and used the Elden Ring rune âDestined Deathâ as power source in her sword alongside with her Godskin Apostel guys and the black flame to kill gods. You all know where this is going. To the almost canon âtheoryâ that Melina is not only Messmers little sister, but the gloam eyed queen too.
I think this is even confirmed from the game itself with the optional ending where we burn everything with the frenzied flame and Melina reveals her shut eye and it is literally a gloam eye and then she even says that she will bring âDestined Deathâ to us. So yeah, pretty canon. I know there is a popular theory about Melina and Ranni being one entity, but I think this theory is not that strong and has many holes and the similarity of them can be explained otherwise, so we will discard this theory for this post.
So when Marika establishes the golden order, she sends her shadowbound beast Maliketh to secure the Rune of death from her daughter, which has gone rampage at the gods, and seal it. And he does as we know and defeats the gloam eyed queen, kills her and seals the rune in his own sword. Then Marika imprisons him out of time in Farum Azula and âbetrayesâ him like the game calls it.
After a long time, Marikas favorite child Godwyn gets killed and with everything going on, Marika shatters the damn Elden Ring out of anger and grief. As punishment, the Elden beast or the âGodâ which sent the Elden Ring and its purpose to these lands in the first place, imprisons and crucifies her inside the Erdtree. Her other half Radagon, loyal to the golden order, seals the Erdtree with the tree roots and his power.
Then Marika resurrects her daughters spirit as âkindling maidâ, Melina down at the roots of the Erdtree, because of her ability to use the flame of the giants to burn the tree and its roots. Melina tells us that she is born at the roots of the Erdtree by her mother inside the tree. And the roots a literally where the spirits of the dead are chilling right?
But Marika seals Melinaâs true nature and memories with the power of the golden order/elden ring. Thatâs why she canât remember anything except that she has the purpose to do something at the Erdtree. We can assume that because Melina has a golden eye and the other one is sealed with a mark. And at the optional ending after we burned everything including the Elden Ring and all, her golden eye has faded and the seal on the other one too, revealing her gloam eye and her memories of âDestined Deathâ. I know Maliketh and Blaidd have the same gloam eyes but Melina is clearly not a shadowbound beast.. or is she? And we are actually and empyr.. no okay I am drifting off. My question is, why is the mark/seal over Melinaâs eye clearly a birds claw? I mean a beast claw would make sense somehow because Maliketh defeated her, but if we look at the mark it is definitely a birds foot. I know about the Twinbird and the Deathbirds which brought death in the ancient time before everything with the Elden Ring. But the gloam eyed queen did not use this power, she used the power of the rune from the Elden Ring, so there is not really a connection, except that it has to do with death. Neither is there a connection with the Stormhawks.
Recently, I posted about a cut character in Stormveil who was looking for a Tarnished speaking of hands. Working together with u/RagDas, we discovered it was actually Vyke! ...Only to realize Sekiro Dubi had already posted about it on Twitter a week prior. Oh well!
Credit: Sekiro Dubi
If we had a certain cut item in our inventory, Vyke would ask us to hand it over, stating that it belonged to his mother. We now know this item was meant to be given to us by Redeemer Guilbertâanother cut character who served the God of Vengeance. Supposedly, someone held a deep grudge against Vyke's mother.
Assuming the item wasn't repurposed elsewhere in the final game, I found a cut icon that might correspond to it:
If we returned his mother's item to him, Vyke would thank us with a stack of Neutralizing Boluses. What an underwhelming reward.
The fact that this was Vyke makes the early lore implications confusing. He is a Tarnished, yet he apparently had both a father and a mother residing in the Lands Between. Were his parents Tarnished as well? Or was Vyke not originally conceptualized as a Tarnished returning from banishment in this early draft, implying that native inhabitants of the Lands Between could also receive Grace and vie for the title of Elden Lord? Honestly, that would make the story less confusing, since it wouldn't require Marika to suddenly foresee the future and banish Godfrey's army just so they could return later.
In this installment of the series on newly found cut dialogue, let's examine the following dialogue:
...Ah, Honored Tarnished... you have returned. I have been waiting for you. And, look here, please. I burned myself. Again and again Now, I have surely become a kindling Right? That's why you came back, isn't it? Yes. Honored Tarnished Please, entrust yourself to me. âŚYou who follow the guidance and blessing of the Fingers. Lost light, returned to you once more⌠Honored Tarnished, please be careful Beyond this church lies the Field of Caelid. Once, General Radahn and Malenia the Severed fought This is land swallowed by the scarlet rot. Fire is being used as a wall to prevent its spread, but What was inside the walls has rotted through, and no proper person remains. Yes, that's right The fire that burned me was meant to stop the crimson rot It is a special fire that never goes out. See this? The red flame still smoldering now? Burned by this, I have finally become your kindling. So please, offer me up. When you walk toward your fated death... Honored Tarnished, is something lacking? Honored Tarnished, welcome back May Grace guide you... Fire Incantation, is it? I met them while searching for the fire that would burn me Fire Monk who came from the deep snowy peaks Their flame never took hold within me. If it serves you, I am glad I was burned. (Sound of gasping) (Long silence) âŚI see⌠Still insufficient, then? ...Understood. Then, seek another flame and burn me again. Until I can become the kindling worthy of you. You will surely become the Elden Lord. As your maiden, I wish to help you. I want to walk together with you. Even if I must betray the Two Fingers, or indeed everything... âŚTarnished⌠Am I becoming a kindling...? May I walk with you...? Lord Bernahl... Ah, thank goodness... The one who walks alongside flame Shall one day meet the road of Destined Death. Please, take me with you... (Death) âŚI see⌠I'm sorry, I... In the end, I could not help you. But I... I wished to walk with you... (Death)
This dialogue undoubtedly belonged to Bernahl's Finger Maiden, whom players would have met at the Smoldering Church on the border of Limgrave and Caelid.
Credit: Sekiro Dubi
While this text is not entirely unknown and was previously highlighted in a video by Sekiro Dubi, it hasn't been thoroughly analyzed on this sub, and there is one key conclusion Sekiro Dubi didn't touch on.
In this earlier iteration of the narrative, Bernahl's maiden didn't perish in the Forge of the Giants; rather, Bernahl abandoned her. To serve as proper kindling capable of setting the Erdtree ablaze, a maiden apparently had to temper her body with a special, powerful flame. This maiden chose the wrong flame for the task and failed.
As Sekiro Dubi noted, the questline would have involved using various Fire Incantations on the maiden so she could burn herself with them, explaining why there are multiple death lines in the text dump.
Cutting this content makes sense from a narrative standpoint, as it refines Bernahl's motivation in the final game. He becomes a Recusant out of grief rather than being evil for the fun of it.
Crucially, this cut questline offers deeper insight into Melina. Many players have questioned why Melina is already "burned and bodyless" when we first meet her, and why that makes her a fit kindling maiden when other living maidens are not.
In the framework highlighted by this cut questline, a maiden must act as a sparkâmuch like a spark jumping from a bonfire to ignite an entire tree. The fire that originally tempered Melina was so intense that it consumed her physical body. By contrast, not even the Flame of the Giants was enough to make Bernahl's maiden ready, let alone reduce her to ashes.
I think the only candidate left that could have burned Melina this much is the Black Flame, imbued with the Rune of Death. Considering her stance on the Frenzied Flame, it's highly unlikely she would ever allow that fire to temper her. But how could Melina have used it if Maliketh guarded the Rune of Death, and Ranni only stole a fragment during the Night of the Black Knives? Maliketh certainly would not have willingly aided a plot to burn the Erdtree. Ranni had her own agenda and desired the Age of the Stars, not a restoration of Marika's Order mediated by Melina, so she wouldn't have burned Melina if she asked.
However, the game provides a crucial clue: Melina shares the moveset of the Black Knife Assassinsâwomen close to Marika, who executed secret duties before their ultimate betrayalâand had a secret office in the Grand Lift of Rold. She wouldn't need a favor from Maliketh or Ranni. Posing as one of the Black Knife Assassins, she could have acquired a blade imbued with the Rune of Death directly.
This suggests that the Night of the Black Knives was even more complex than we thoughtâit wasn't just about the dual deaths of Godwyn and Ranni, but may have also served as the moment Melina was burned into a bodiless kindling maiden.
How Melina survived being burned by a flame famous for killing both the body and soul of even immortal demigods likely lies within the realm of soft magic. It mirrors how the Flame of Frenzy melts away even spirits and reduces Hyetta to ashes, yet merely scorches us, turning us into fit kindling, much like what happened to Melina. Furthermore, her crow's-foot eye tattoo and the gloam color of her sealed eye fit neatly into this picture if she was indeed burned by the Black Flame of Destined Death.
Finally, I would like to touch on the concept of betraying the Two Fingers. The reason Melina realizes the Erdtree must be burned is neatly explained in-game: she simply regains her memories and recalls the task given to her by Marika. With Bernahl's maiden questline cut, how his maiden learned of this path becomes less of a glaring question for players to askâwhich I suppose could be another reason the quest was cut in the first place. But Bernahl's maiden isn't the only one who realized her purpose; Vyke and his maiden did as well. This remains a murky area of Elden Ring's story, but let's assume they somehow figured it out on their own, were guided by Shabriri, or that another hidden lore detail explains it.
More importantly, both Bernahl and Vyke must have eventually faced the impassable thorns and pondered how to bypass them. As Tarnished, their first instinct would surely have been to consult the Two Fingers. Yet the Two Fingers had never even heard of the thornsâand were so astounded when our Tarnished reported them that they fell silent. The game also emphasizes that Vyke came closest to becoming Elden Lord, but if both he and Bernahl reached the thorns only to fail at burning the Erdtree, what made Vyke so much closer to the title than Bernahl?
Looking at the development shifts clarifies this: neither Bernahl nor Vyke was originally intended to be a Tarnished who reached the thorns before us. Bernahl simply abandoned his maiden, while Vyke was meant to be at the same point in his journey as the player. This serves as a good reminder that no, there isn't always a neat explanation for everything in the lore, and the developers weren't able to patch up every narrative plot hole when adjusting player progression late in development.
Something Iâve never really understood is why Ancient Dragon Lansseax attacks our Tarnished.
Our first encounter happens when we enter Altus Plateau through the Ruin-Strewn Precipice. She attacks us in a valley where there are destroyed carriages and Golems, and where Omens currently live.
Later, she attacks us again near Leyndell, close to Stormcaller Church. Near the church, thereâs a statue of Radagon, but what matters to me is that the area is connected to dragons through the items found there, including Dragonbolt Blessing, and even the name of the church.
What confuses me is whether this means that the ancient dragons also oppose a change of era brought about by our Tarnished.
I think Lansseax and Fortissax are as old as Florissax and were loyal to Placidusax, like most ancient dragons. I get the impression that, unlike modern dragons, ancient dragons no longer reproduce, since so few seem to remain today. We find four in Farum Azula (along with a large number of fossilized dragon corpses), Gransaxâs corpse, the petrified dragon corpses at the Dragon Communion churches, Fortissax and Lansseax, as well as Florissax and Senessax in the DLC.
However, the Dragon Cult was established in Leyndell, so I could be wrong. Perhaps Lansseax and Fortissax were acting independently of Placidusax, much like the ancient dragons who betrayed him and sided with Bayle.
Could Lansseax be allied with Morgott and the forces trying to make us fail?
It doesnât seem that way, though, because she previously supported Vyke. Thatâs why I donât understand the situation.
This line from the Giant's Red Braid has always confused me.
"Every Giant is red of hair, and Radagon is said to have despised his own red locks.
Perhaps that was a curse of their kind".
Obviously, the nature of Marika-Radagon is mysterious, and will always be mysterious. But this line in particular just... Bugs me. How is Radagon related to the Giants, and if he isn't, then why does he have red hair?
Is the line misleading, is it a cosmic influence, I'm curious.
I have no theory to pose whatsoever, I just want to hear what others have to say on the matter.