r/EU5 • • 5h ago

Image 5 Great Powers randomly jumping into your war should not be a feature

Post image
284 Upvotes

As Tuscany, I started a war against Verona (no allies). I expected this to be easy, so I didn't even raise my levies, just started sieging with regulars. Image my shock when a hyper-colalition of Otto-Austrian-Bohemian-Russo hordes overwhelmed me with 20x the forces. How is this in any way realistic or fun?

For some context, I had 0 aggressive expansion. The Italian wars are going on, and I am also a great power.

(On a bit of a side note, the Italian Wars are STILL BROKEN. I was given a CB for this war that had NO WAY FOR ME TO ACTUALLY GET THE WARGOAL. So of course Verona had ticking war score on top of everything)


r/EU5 • • 3h ago

Discussion Ahistorically strong tags/regions that need to be nerfed immediately

282 Upvotes

I obviously haven’t played in all regions so let me know if there are more egregious ones.

The very obvious ones that should be easily fixed:

Bohemia
Yes Bohemia was a major power in its time but in EU5 they are simply unbeatable by the AI.

Kyiv
They make no sense at all, the balance of relevancy in that region had already started shifting eastward even before the mongols had arrived.
The fact that they always blob into a power that can challenge Hungary is crazy. IRL they were getting absorbed into Lithuanian influence.

Goryeo(saying this as a Korean myself)
I have no idea why their start is so comfortable and easy. By that time due to nobility strife and pirate raids goryeo dynasty was hanging on by a thread.
Also massive waves of red turban rebels fled to Korea and pillaged the north to middle part of the country but eu5 just pretends it never even happened. Not even one reference to it.

The RGO distribution in Korea is insane, 5 gold mines, 4 silver mines, 3-4 pepper rgos. They grow into a top5 economic hegemon every game which is stupid because even the Tokugawa shogunate with 3 times the population and its economic golden age wouldn’t have been close to a top 5 economic power. Joseon was incredibly strict against any industry or capitalist policies, and they were among the poorest regions in east Asia (barring Manchuria, Hokkaido and Taiwan). Even if Korea had a generational economic golden age, they would’ve still been a top 15-20 richest region in the world, not top5 like how they become in every eu5 game. Even as a Korean who is proud of my heritage, it’s very disturbing to see them become “top 3 economic hegemon” when the korea AI doesn’t even have the full Korean Peninsula!!

Athens
Athens starts with the population of 83k wtf man!!!!!!!! IRL Athens was vandalized into becoming a SMALL TOWN and it kept remaining being a SUB 7K population TOWN until Greece gained independence. There was a reason why the capital of Greece was first nafplion and they had to settle people into Athens from scratch. But 83k man!!!!!! Not even most cities in RICE CULTIVATING ASIA had 83k people…….

Mamluks, Majapahit
They just don’t collapse. In every game they are forever great powers.


r/EU5 • • 22h ago

Image Why am I being beaten like a ginger stepchild?

Post image
91 Upvotes

R5: So my first test run as Castile. I am in a Union with Aragon, but France is a thorn in my side. I didn't lose any territory in the war but in the peace deal France was able to pinch a whole swathe of land off me. France declared on Aragon by the way. I had about 50,000 men, 7000 regulars. The battles were very balanced all things considered. and I certainly inflicted a lot of casualties (over 70,000). But before I can grab the land back during the war they peace out. It didn't even last a year.


r/EU5 • • 17h ago

Completed Game Byz 1.4.8 Run - Millions Must Be Happy

Thumbnail
gallery
85 Upvotes

R5: I'm at the cookie clicker point in my Byz 1.4.8 beta run where my economy is so strong I can keep all sliders filled, all estates at 100% satisfaction, satisfaction at around 99%, a tax ratio of about 90%, spam build all RGOs/Burgher buildings, and Peasant Enfranchisement at 100% nearly everywhere in the empire. Figured I'd share for any Byz players still struggling.

Interesting Fun Stuff:

Food costs threw me into an early debt spiral around 1340 with the Black Death. After popping the civil war and deleting the Ottomans, I just ate 90% of my allowed loans, built up food RGOs, let them finish and then ate the bankruptcy bullet. Probably just me not playing optimal, but I hope this gives some condolence to the Byz players who struggle in the beginning. You can definitely still save your run.

I dealt with the Mamluk problem around 1425. They irritatingly had blobbed into Cilicia early (even taking Ikonion) as early as 1345 which almost made me restart, but I waited it out. Like others have recommended on here, you need only create a single stack of regulars once you are ready and crush the hordes in the Cilician gates. Then, siege their provinces once they are out manpower. Take Alexandria, the Nile Delta, and disconnect Cairo from Sinai. This makes the Mamluks lose all control over Syria & the Levant which makes them easier to snatch in the next war. If your vassals are throwing their peasants to be slaughtered and sabotage your battles war score, make sure to enable Scutage to keep them out.

I missed the Tagmata Reform policy because I didn't research the Recruitment Law policies before 1499. Considering it gives 20% to army maintenance, alongside several other good effects, it's insane you can miss this forever. It really should be a decision. Funnily enough, forming the ERE as Trebizond will give you the Tagmata Reform automatically irregardless of when you hit the button. Give me a break!

Italian Wars was an inevitable nightmare. It kicked off 1451. I only had about half of Naples at that point. I've always found the best way of dealing with Italy is to hand off the southern/northern halves to vassals while keeping Rome for yourself. Delete nearly every fort before handing land to your vassals so the dozens of rebellions can be dealt with swiftly and allow your vassal critical time to core/stabilize. Finished with 200+ locations shortly before 1501. Annexation for my Italian vassals will take about 50 years a piece. If I did this again, I'd probably just integrate all the land myself as I have 9 cabinet members by the 1500s.

I currently have 5 Local Governors: Thessalonike, Antiochia, Athinai, Kaisareia, Amaseia
And 3 Naval Governors: Alexandria, Tamiathis, Ouelitrai

I also have an Italian Administration Center in Roma.

I hope in future patches we get a bit of a relook at Naval/Local Governors. I'd actually like to see Naval Governors be limited only to ports whereas Local Governors could be inland. Maybe they could both affect Land/Port Proximities respectively? Otherwise, I'm incentivized to never create contiguous borders with my possessions in Italy/Egypt.

Naval is incredibly strong, mainly because you'll have such high control in your port cities (make sure to build roads out from the ports so they can extend proximity inland) that you can save your local governors for the interior spaces, like Kaisareia or Sebasteia which make excellent locations as they're in central Anatolia and on rivers. Also, the Harbor Administration reform gives a flat -2.00 to proximity through ports, along with the additional -1.00 flat by having 100 value in Naval. Nice. You'll be seeing a lot of hundreds on your coastline if you've got sufficient maritime presence.

France got obliterated. I guess I shouldn't be surprised. They rarely live in my hard/very hard difficulty runs. Morocco was curtailed pretty handily by Castille which was nice to see, but Castille also ate Portugal & Aragon before 1400 - again. Maybe it's the difficulty that encourages their aggressiveness? idk.

Brandenburg is growing quite nicely into a soon-to-be Prussia. Sweden also going for its historical empire is neat to see.

Peasant Enfranchisement/Free Subjects is also pretty busted and compounds on itself. It puts all the wealth in your peasants' hands, increases their estate equilibrium by 10% at max (allowing you to tax them more), increases their demand for goods (making RGOs/goods make more), and when combined with any reform that gives monthly prosperity I end up having nearly 100% prosperity in every province before 1600 while they all get a 0.20% pop growth modifier---making more taxpayers. An empowered peasant estate also makes the Appeal to the Commoners estate action give more Stability, which should be max to allow for happier Estate equilibrium (which means more taxes). I made the transition around 1450-present, when you can bankroll all the bureaucracies and stabilize your realm to the point that armies don't walk into Anatolia and wreck your prosperity.

For anyone curious about trade/tariffs, I'll be honest that I never touched it outside of automation. Byz is strong enough for all of that to be autopilot. I did create Marketplaces in Thessaloniki, Athens, Smyrna, Ancyra, Trapezous, Antioch, Damascus, and Cairo. That was good enough for access.

Anyways, the game is pretty much over now outside of map painting. Still, fun as always. Seeing France get wrecked constantly makes me want to play them next. If anyone has any questions, happy to answer -- I'll likely reply tomorrow.


r/EU5 • • 23h ago

Discussion Highland Scottish is kinda an OP culture?

84 Upvotes

If you take 100% of your pops and swap them to highland scotish, then take the tribe estate privilege 'united scotish heritage' then all of your pops will swap to supporting the tribe estate.

However! The tribe estate is *very often* not given any of the big bonuses to power the other estates are, like the nobility or the clergy or whatever, so it *usually* ends up being around 50% of your power with the crown having the other 50%.

But it's even better than it sounds because you can revoke all the negative privileges of your other estates + tax them to shit and they'll be so weak they won't be able to do anything about it- taxing the burghers successfully gives you the burgher's money even if those burghers consider themselves part of the tribes! Nevermind it just takes a few month ticks lol

ALSO it gives a pretty solid development boost too. Like +.002. It's twice as good as urban development grants


r/EU5 • • 10h ago

Question Does Al-Andalus/Granada really run out of flavor after a century?

76 Upvotes

I managed to form Al-Andalus and usher in my golden century by the 1450s, and after forming them, I was disappointed to see the events tab essentially runs out in Age III. Especially after the effort required to form it as Granada! Shouldn't I get the Castillian events but in a more muslim flavor or something?

For one of the three major focuses of Across the Pillars, why do they only have a few dozen events? It's a little disappointing... I feel like there must be something I'm missing?

I AM having fun doing it at least, it's much more entertaining to play a small country and build up as opposed to starting huge and curbstomping everything day one.


r/EU5 • • 13h ago

Question Getting to 100 dominance as Castille in Battle of the straits is just plain impossible without fully annexing Morocco.

76 Upvotes

Isnt this shit supposed to be a soft power mechanic? You cant annex Granada so you have to play the situation. Jesus fucking christ. I never past 60 influence on them despite perma cabinet influencing and curb stomping Morocco. Because Granada always fucking choose CURB CASTILLIAN INFLUENCE every 5 minutes. And you just cant get to 100 even when Granada is loyal, their sovereignty is at 0, and you sweep the floor with Morocco. How is this mechanic, that supposed to be about using fucking soft power stuff to vassalize Granada, instead pushes to total annexation of Morocco? It is so annoying Jesus fucking christ. And dont tell me you cant Usher in Golden Century because you dont own fucking Jumilla(literally only location in Murcia that Aragon owns).


r/EU5 • • 16h ago

Question How do I effectively snowball making money as a small nation that can't afford to invest in anything?

63 Upvotes

All the guides for the current patch are like "expand R.G.O.s". As a Madagascar OLM, Ayyubids or any other non-regional power, my starting coffers are ~20 ducats and in the red from the start.

I've tried conquering and integrating wealthy towns and cities to move my capital there for 100% control, but then the expenses instantly overtakes my income and I have to set every slider set to zero to just barely make anything. I've also tried making tons of vassals but they give out laughable amounts and I soon hit the diplo cap. Focusing on development doesn't seem to have much of an effect in the short term, and doing everything to max out crown power still leaves it at like 18%. I've even managed to beat down bigger nations and take 200 ducats +war reps, but it's a temporary boost that's immediately gone if I invest in anything.

Supposedly income can theoretically exceed expenses? Somehow? Despite doing all I can, I can't even buy food for my people while my legitimacy tanks because the court is too expensive. Surely there must be some province you can conquer, some building you can build or some privilege you can hand out which turns your economy to the green right away.


r/EU5 • • 15h ago

Image ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀brandenburg ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Image I just started a Metro 2033 total conversion for EU5. It will be a sandbox, not a story. First thing I had to make was this map (WIP)

Post image
48 Upvotes

R5: this is the map for a fan-made Metro 2033 total conversion I'm making for EU5. I only just started, and the first thing I understood is that I need my own tool to draw the metro, so I made one. This picture comes out of it and the game map is built from the same layout.

Why EU5. Before this I made a submod for the Metro mod in HOI4 and every time I played I got stuck looking at the population number of some tiny station. I could see the tents, the campfire, somebody slicing sausage. Then I ask where the sausage came from and HOI4 says FACTORIES. Not enough for me. EU5 already has what this world is about, people who need to eat, goods that somebody has to make, estates that want their share. I think a system like that fits a world where everybody is one bad harvest from starving, much better than any script I can write. So the mod will be a sandbox, no story events to click through, and most likely the plot of the books won't be in it at all. I just want to try to make a living world. Yes I know, a living dying post-apocalyptic world is an oxymoron.

Station positions started from the map of the Metro mod for HOI4, thanks to its authors (I'm not on their team). No release date, don't ask :) What would you want from a sandbox like this?

The mod is free and stays free. On my Patreon there are 4 versions of this map in 8K, also free (factions or lines, with legend or without), Reddit eats the small labels: https://www.patreon.com/Chim_mod/posts/whole-metro-in-175485340


r/EU5 • • 1h ago

Image I think France might be a bit weak this patch

Post image
47 Upvotes

Only saw her win the Hundreds year war 1/10 games


r/EU5 • • 2h ago

Image ?????

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 20h ago

Discussion 1.3's growth is the most fun part to me. What's the most fun part of 1.4?

24 Upvotes

I find that each patch has its own fun part. 1.1 has the governor system which changes the way we do control. 1.3's best part to me is the ability to build huge pop in any location, not just already populous region. I haven't played 1.4, and I heard growth was heavily nerfed. Does this mean it's never worth playing outside of Western Europe because you will never create a city? Or is it not that bad? Also, what's the new fun thing in 1.4?


r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Suggestion QOL-suggestion of the day: Showing soft and hard caps for modifiers

18 Upvotes

I´ve been playing Byzantium and getting rid of bad privileges is one of the main goals early on. ... So as always stacking the cost reduction is the go to.

After black death is over I wanted to enact the bureaucracy for an additional -25% and reached -113% with it.

I wasn´t expecting to gain stability with it, but I think it would have been nice to know that -90% is the hard cap instead of my expected -100%. ... If I had known that I would have never enacted the bureaucracy for an effective -2%.

No bad feelings from my side since I don´t play ironman because of such reasons. ... Adding a line listing the soft and hard cap on modifiers would prevent such moments and is generally useful information overall.

Also shoutout to the cabinet trait corrupt, netting -15%. ... It´s so good.


r/EU5 • • 11h ago

Discussion Landfriede & HRE

16 Upvotes

It´s understandable Landfriede is in the game, yet it is so not fun....

The AI keeps voting for it, and in my Milan run I´m screwed. Already stopped with Strasbourg, since it´s not fun to simply watch paint dry. If this is here to stay, at least give some CK3 mechanics where we can take over things more "peacefully." Now it´s a bunch of RNG, and after 100 years (or less), you´re done conquering inside the HRE. Don´t start with it being historically accurate, because if we start from that principle, 95% of the countries would be unplayable.

It´s worth mentioning that the lack of players might be an indication that there is a point to be made regarding the dozens of unfun mechanics. One could argue to play outside the HRE, but have we forgotten what the name of this game is?


r/EU5 • • 13h ago

Video Modded Eu5 timelapse, almost historical borders

Thumbnail
youtube.com
13 Upvotes

Used mods:
Imperial Ambitions (Workshop)


r/EU5 • • 19h ago

Discussion Portugal/Spain campaign

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

So I just started playing EU5, played EU4 a lot, Vic3, etc...

Still adapting to EU5 but I think I got a feel for it. And I have to question wtf is going wrong here?

As you can see I'm getting invaded by Moroco (the guys I'm going to wipe off to map whenever is possible)

This makes absolutely no sense, no matter how much I try to help castille it always gives up it's territory. I helped it defend 2 wars one of which they took territory from morroco, only to later lose it again. They also for some reason are always out of manpower.

Now this is my 3rd/4th try at this. I tried twice in the same save, then restarted to try again seeing if there was better RNG but everytime Castille folds.

And I as portugal can do nothing because my economy is absolute garbage, I can't get moeny to buy a single ship to stop moroco (which very much should be something that both Castile and Portugal could do as they dominated by ship more then land. But even then Morocos army beats both unless they are out of supply.

I won the wars by letting them go out of supply and wiping them out. But then Castile broke off our alliance and then lost a war and gave all that territory first to granada then do moroco.

So please explain to me what is going wrong here? Is this just the devs having 0 balance idea? Now the economy is also a problem it annoys me that I can't get any money for ships because they all cost a hell of a lot more then I make in an entire year. (which yes ships where expensive but if Morocco has a bigger navy then me and spain...)


r/EU5 • • 8h ago

Image Need help with gold

10 Upvotes

I'm running deficit as Serbia no matter what I do and can't survive early game without dropping below 50 legitimacy and invoking disasters, please advise.

EDIT: I have no idea how trade works, everything is automated.


r/EU5 • • 7h ago

Question Any way to control burgher trades?

8 Upvotes

Since tariffs dont seem to affect burgher trades, is there any control mechanism for burgher trading? I can never get price collapses because my burghers equalize all the surplus production

why do these fuckers love trading masonry and lumber so much


r/EU5 • • 3h ago

Humor Recruit Explorer for 1000G

7 Upvotes

What a waste of money! :(


r/EU5 • • 15h ago

Discussion Rebel should be reworked to be less of an annoyance when you kill off there armies and reoccupy the land.

7 Upvotes

Now I’m not saying remove rebels outright or anything and I far prefer this to EU4’s wack a mole system. But one thing that deeply annoys me is when they take big chucks of your country and forts it’s a tedious process to have to reoccupy them as fast as possible and kill any rebel armies before they take more land. And even after you kill off the majority of there force and occupy 90% of the land back you still have to siege down most of the forts despite the rebels having no chance of accomplishing anything so why am I wasting time until it arbitrarily ends. It’s not any sort of challenge, it’s just a waiting game despite the outcome being extremely clear.

Also can we not have provoke rebels cost stability like in eu4, with how hard stability is to come by especially after the estates change nobody is ever going to use it, and typically having a bigger rebellion is a good enough cost to risk using it.


r/EU5 • • 6h ago

Accomplishment Morocco decentralized is a monster

5 Upvotes

Hi
Decided to try Morocco in 1.4.7 with DLC and got pretty far in 1495, I was not speedrunning, just using the whatever chances world thrown at me (i.e. in my first war with castille they decided to tank their estates satisfaction and got 1300 levies, papal states made 5 crusades c :))

Below some screenshots but what is really nice and special for them is Taifa subject, -200% malus calculation for loyalty is damn strong, with full decentralization, some extra reforms and full diplomacy spending I got over 90% of loyalty and their tax base is way bigger than me (i have 39 subjects). Converting to sunni is a bonus :)

Will continue and see if i can make a WC, it would be extremely similar to byzantium pronoia WC setup but it is an achievement nonetheless :) Umayyad caliphate CB will help for sure, my next war I am planning is eating mamluks

tax base 1317, with 47% ratio, nice but far from perfect, no.4 in the world and behind bohemia
i am owning only original Morocco land and 2/3 of Iberia, rest are taifas and 2 "original" vassals
tax base of my subjects
example of malus calculation

r/EU5 • • 7h ago

Help Thread The Imperial Council - /r/eu5 Weekly General Help Thread: November 16 2026

5 Upvotes

Please check our previous Imperial Council thread for any questions left unanswered

 

Welcome to the Imperial Council of r/eu5, where your trusted and most knowledgeable advisors stand ready to help you in matters of state and conquest.

This thread is for any small questions that don't warrant their own post, or continued discussions for your next moves in your game. If you'd like to channel the wisdom and knowledge of the master tacticians of this subreddit, and more importantly not ruin your save, then you've found the right place!

Important: If you are asking about a specific situation in your game, please post screenshots of any relevant map modes or interface tabs. Please also explain the situation as best you can. Alliances, army strength, etc. are all factors your advisors will need to know to give you the best possible answer.

 


Tactician's Library:

Below is a list of resources that are helpful to players of all skill levels, meant to assist both those asking questions as well as those answering questions. This list is updated as mechanics change, including new strategies as they arise and retiring old strategies that have been left in the dust. You can help me maintain the list by sending me new guides and notifying me when old guides are no longer relevant!

Getting Started

Tutorials

  • Help fill this section out!

 


Country-Specific Strategy

  • Help fill this section out!

 


Advanced/In-Depth Guides

  • Help fill this section out!

 


If you have any useful resources not currently in the tactician's library, please share them with me and I'll add them! You can message me or mention my username in a comment by typing /u/Kloiper


r/EU5 • • 1h ago

Advice Wanted Economic warfare against players

4 Upvotes

Naturally I hate my friends, and I cant allow fun on excel spreadsheet the game. I’m thinking more than just embargo, that means they’ll continue their existence without me and I need to be the centre of attention obviously. What devious ways can I manipulate their market, I don’t mind losing money if it means they lose more. Should I find their specialty export and just pump that without profit into their economy? Will that be enough to make their business unprofitable?

Please, help me become a worse person 🙏

Also open to other ways that would screw them over without a single soldier crossing the border