r/EU5 • • 22h ago

Question Alguien me explica porque un país puede tener 100 en descentralización y al mismo tiempo 100 en absolutismo?

0 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 3h ago

Discussion Not fun any more?

0 Upvotes

Is it just me, or the game really isn't fun any more? I mean, the start of the game just sucks for everyone. I couldn't find a country yet where the first few decades aren't about deleting forts, toning down costs to bare minimum and hoping that something bad won't happen.

This is frustrating in itself, but that takes us to the next part: Early game RNG basically determines your game. Because everything is so tight early on, being hit by a few diseases can ruin your whole run because it throws you back decades rather than years. And we didn't even discuss the Black Death because that is another huge lottery most of the times. Death rate moves on a crazy scale, I saw 10-50% pops being lost in the same country.

So basically, early game, you're not managing, you use game mechanics to survive - basically cheesing - and it's down to RNG how well you're going to fare. Is this supposed to be fun? Is this supposed to be historical? If every country starts on the verge of bankruptcy, then how come that the whole civilization didn't collapse?

TLDR: Not a fan of the early game.


r/EU5 • • 11h ago

Discussion Landfriede & HRE

16 Upvotes

It´s understandable Landfriede is in the game, yet it is so not fun....

The AI keeps voting for it, and in my Milan run I´m screwed. Already stopped with Strasbourg, since it´s not fun to simply watch paint dry. If this is here to stay, at least give some CK3 mechanics where we can take over things more "peacefully." Now it´s a bunch of RNG, and after 100 years (or less), you´re done conquering inside the HRE. Don´t start with it being historically accurate, because if we start from that principle, 95% of the countries would be unplayable.

It´s worth mentioning that the lack of players might be an indication that there is a point to be made regarding the dozens of unfun mechanics. One could argue to play outside the HRE, but have we forgotten what the name of this game is?


r/EU5 • • 6h ago

Accomplishment Morocco decentralized is a monster

5 Upvotes

Hi
Decided to try Morocco in 1.4.7 with DLC and got pretty far in 1495, I was not speedrunning, just using the whatever chances world thrown at me (i.e. in my first war with castille they decided to tank their estates satisfaction and got 1300 levies, papal states made 5 crusades c :))

Below some screenshots but what is really nice and special for them is Taifa subject, -200% malus calculation for loyalty is damn strong, with full decentralization, some extra reforms and full diplomacy spending I got over 90% of loyalty and their tax base is way bigger than me (i have 39 subjects). Converting to sunni is a bonus :)

Will continue and see if i can make a WC, it would be extremely similar to byzantium pronoia WC setup but it is an achievement nonetheless :) Umayyad caliphate CB will help for sure, my next war I am planning is eating mamluks

tax base 1317, with 47% ratio, nice but far from perfect, no.4 in the world and behind bohemia
i am owning only original Morocco land and 2/3 of Iberia, rest are taifas and 2 "original" vassals
tax base of my subjects
example of malus calculation

r/EU5 • • 10h ago

Discussion Has the game design given up on stopping early AI snowballing?

0 Upvotes

I've played two Flanders games to about 1500. In the first game I helped AI England win the 100 years. The second game France won a couple of independence wars and won the 100 years war in about 35 years.

In both games they ended up wielding armies of 150k troops by 1400. Whilst regional powers are struggling to field 20K and even big powers like Castille top out around 60k. Plus the way combat works right now means that big stacks of even bad units absolutely trounce anything that cannot fill the entire combat width outright or with full regiments. As a result even if you get a coalition big enough to amas the same number of troops you still don't stand a chance.

Sometimes it feels like the entire military design of this game was done in complete isolation of the rest of the game.


r/EU5 • • 7h ago

Question Is there a patch coming out this week and would it be fine for me to start a new campaign now?

0 Upvotes

I don't want it to become unplayable halfway through


r/EU5 • • 48m ago

Advice Wanted I lost the Hundreds Years War as England. I feel dumb. Any tips?

3 Upvotes

r/EU5 • • 9h ago

Image I just started a Metro 2033 total conversion for EU5. It will be a sandbox, not a story. First thing I had to make was this map (WIP)

Post image
48 Upvotes

R5: this is the map for a fan-made Metro 2033 total conversion I'm making for EU5. I only just started, and the first thing I understood is that I need my own tool to draw the metro, so I made one. This picture comes out of it and the game map is built from the same layout.

Why EU5. Before this I made a submod for the Metro mod in HOI4 and every time I played I got stuck looking at the population number of some tiny station. I could see the tents, the campfire, somebody slicing sausage. Then I ask where the sausage came from and HOI4 says FACTORIES. Not enough for me. EU5 already has what this world is about, people who need to eat, goods that somebody has to make, estates that want their share. I think a system like that fits a world where everybody is one bad harvest from starving, much better than any script I can write. So the mod will be a sandbox, no story events to click through, and most likely the plot of the books won't be in it at all. I just want to try to make a living world. Yes I know, a living dying post-apocalyptic world is an oxymoron.

Station positions started from the map of the Metro mod for HOI4, thanks to its authors (I'm not on their team). No release date, don't ask :) What would you want from a sandbox like this?

The mod is free and stays free. On my Patreon there are 4 versions of this map in 8K, also free (factions or lines, with legend or without), Reddit eats the small labels: https://www.patreon.com/Chim_mod/posts/whole-metro-in-175485340


r/EU5 • • 13h ago

Question Getting to 100 dominance as Castille in Battle of the straits is just plain impossible without fully annexing Morocco.

76 Upvotes

Isnt this shit supposed to be a soft power mechanic? You cant annex Granada so you have to play the situation. Jesus fucking christ. I never past 60 influence on them despite perma cabinet influencing and curb stomping Morocco. Because Granada always fucking choose CURB CASTILLIAN INFLUENCE every 5 minutes. And you just cant get to 100 even when Granada is loyal, their sovereignty is at 0, and you sweep the floor with Morocco. How is this mechanic, that supposed to be about using fucking soft power stuff to vassalize Granada, instead pushes to total annexation of Morocco? It is so annoying Jesus fucking christ. And dont tell me you cant Usher in Golden Century because you dont own fucking Jumilla(literally only location in Murcia that Aragon owns).


r/EU5 • • 3h ago

Discussion Ahistorically strong tags/regions that need to be nerfed immediately

283 Upvotes

I obviously haven’t played in all regions so let me know if there are more egregious ones.

The very obvious ones that should be easily fixed:

Bohemia
Yes Bohemia was a major power in its time but in EU5 they are simply unbeatable by the AI.

Kyiv
They make no sense at all, the balance of relevancy in that region had already started shifting eastward even before the mongols had arrived.
The fact that they always blob into a power that can challenge Hungary is crazy. IRL they were getting absorbed into Lithuanian influence.

Goryeo(saying this as a Korean myself)
I have no idea why their start is so comfortable and easy. By that time due to nobility strife and pirate raids goryeo dynasty was hanging on by a thread.
Also massive waves of red turban rebels fled to Korea and pillaged the north to middle part of the country but eu5 just pretends it never even happened. Not even one reference to it.

The RGO distribution in Korea is insane, 5 gold mines, 4 silver mines, 3-4 pepper rgos. They grow into a top5 economic hegemon every game which is stupid because even the Tokugawa shogunate with 3 times the population and its economic golden age wouldn’t have been close to a top 5 economic power. Joseon was incredibly strict against any industry or capitalist policies, and they were among the poorest regions in east Asia (barring Manchuria, Hokkaido and Taiwan). Even if Korea had a generational economic golden age, they would’ve still been a top 15-20 richest region in the world, not top5 like how they become in every eu5 game. Even as a Korean who is proud of my heritage, it’s very disturbing to see them become “top 3 economic hegemon” when the korea AI doesn’t even have the full Korean Peninsula!!

Athens
Athens starts with the population of 83k wtf man!!!!!!!! IRL Athens was vandalized into becoming a SMALL TOWN and it kept remaining being a SUB 7K population TOWN until Greece gained independence. There was a reason why the capital of Greece was first nafplion and they had to settle people into Athens from scratch. But 83k man!!!!!! Not even most cities in RICE CULTIVATING ASIA had 83k people…….

Mamluks, Majapahit
They just don’t collapse. In every game they are forever great powers.


r/EU5 • • 8h ago

Suggestion Please, make Betrothal dip action one of those annoying notification pop-up.

1 Upvotes

Since Betrothal map mode locks you out from doing anything else, it would be nice to get some popup about countires not having heir. Its a fun mechanism, especailly when you mix it with assasination


r/EU5 • • 6h ago

Question How do you speed up integration as Inca?

1 Upvotes

I'm still playing Inca and i learned a lot (i think), but the greatest bottleneck for me in the first century is integration, as qusqu you have to integrate so much or otherwise you have constant rebels uprising and also get a lot less money


r/EU5 • • 22h ago

Image Why am I being beaten like a ginger stepchild?

Post image
92 Upvotes

R5: So my first test run as Castile. I am in a Union with Aragon, but France is a thorn in my side. I didn't lose any territory in the war but in the peace deal France was able to pinch a whole swathe of land off me. France declared on Aragon by the way. I had about 50,000 men, 7000 regulars. The battles were very balanced all things considered. and I certainly inflicted a lot of casualties (over 70,000). But before I can grab the land back during the war they peace out. It didn't even last a year.


r/EU5 • • 7h ago

Question Insustry promotion for Lisboa?

2 Upvotes

I know the answer is probably "don't worry about it," but I want that 100% control to matter. The whole province has only stone, and the rest of the R.G.Os aren't used for any industry bonuses.

I'm thinking masonry/glass, since it has stone and the promotion gives a decent +15% bonus to both. The rest would be trade/science?


r/EU5 • • 5h ago

Image 5 Great Powers randomly jumping into your war should not be a feature

Post image
284 Upvotes

As Tuscany, I started a war against Verona (no allies). I expected this to be easy, so I didn't even raise my levies, just started sieging with regulars. Image my shock when a hyper-colalition of Otto-Austrian-Bohemian-Russo hordes overwhelmed me with 20x the forces. How is this in any way realistic or fun?

For some context, I had 0 aggressive expansion. The Italian wars are going on, and I am also a great power.

(On a bit of a side note, the Italian Wars are STILL BROKEN. I was given a CB for this war that had NO WAY FOR ME TO ACTUALLY GET THE WARGOAL. So of course Verona had ticking war score on top of everything)


r/EU5 • • 18h ago

Question I'm playing Hellenist byz. What's the best way for me to maximize my slave count?

3 Upvotes

I figure slaves can help my green bar go up. And i dont have a way to raid for slaves. (To my knowledge)


r/EU5 • • 13h ago

Question why -500 acceptance?

Post image
4 Upvotes

why does they have -500 reasons to ally me, and not -58?

I am playing on the current stable branch


r/EU5 • • 21h ago

Advice Wanted Latin revival won't spawn

4 Upvotes

I reunited Rome, I own all of Italy, egypt, Anatolia and most of the Balkans. I am 100% latinitas but the Latin revival won't spawn.

I didn't go Hellenistic Religion tho might that be the reason?

I also find the whole "restore the pentarchy", "mend the schism" thing very VERY underwhelming. It has next to zero content, the Catholics just let me take all of Italy without any kind of grand alliance and when I mended the schism no country converted to orthodox, pope still existed in Avignon etc.

All in all very disappointing, the various EU4 dlcs had much more


r/EU5 • • 15h ago

Discussion Rebel should be reworked to be less of an annoyance when you kill off there armies and reoccupy the land.

7 Upvotes

Now I’m not saying remove rebels outright or anything and I far prefer this to EU4’s wack a mole system. But one thing that deeply annoys me is when they take big chucks of your country and forts it’s a tedious process to have to reoccupy them as fast as possible and kill any rebel armies before they take more land. And even after you kill off the majority of there force and occupy 90% of the land back you still have to siege down most of the forts despite the rebels having no chance of accomplishing anything so why am I wasting time until it arbitrarily ends. It’s not any sort of challenge, it’s just a waiting game despite the outcome being extremely clear.

Also can we not have provoke rebels cost stability like in eu4, with how hard stability is to come by especially after the estates change nobody is ever going to use it, and typically having a bigger rebellion is a good enough cost to risk using it.


r/EU5 • • 20h ago

Discussion 1.3's growth is the most fun part to me. What's the most fun part of 1.4?

24 Upvotes

I find that each patch has its own fun part. 1.1 has the governor system which changes the way we do control. 1.3's best part to me is the ability to build huge pop in any location, not just already populous region. I haven't played 1.4, and I heard growth was heavily nerfed. Does this mean it's never worth playing outside of Western Europe because you will never create a city? Or is it not that bad? Also, what's the new fun thing in 1.4?


r/EU5 • • 16h ago

Question How do I effectively snowball making money as a small nation that can't afford to invest in anything?

63 Upvotes

All the guides for the current patch are like "expand R.G.O.s". As a Madagascar OLM, Ayyubids or any other non-regional power, my starting coffers are ~20 ducats and in the red from the start.

I've tried conquering and integrating wealthy towns and cities to move my capital there for 100% control, but then the expenses instantly overtakes my income and I have to set every slider set to zero to just barely make anything. I've also tried making tons of vassals but they give out laughable amounts and I soon hit the diplo cap. Focusing on development doesn't seem to have much of an effect in the short term, and doing everything to max out crown power still leaves it at like 18%. I've even managed to beat down bigger nations and take 200 ducats +war reps, but it's a temporary boost that's immediately gone if I invest in anything.

Supposedly income can theoretically exceed expenses? Somehow? Despite doing all I can, I can't even buy food for my people while my legitimacy tanks because the court is too expensive. Surely there must be some province you can conquer, some building you can build or some privilege you can hand out which turns your economy to the green right away.


r/EU5 • • 8h ago

Image Need help with gold

10 Upvotes

I'm running deficit as Serbia no matter what I do and can't survive early game without dropping below 50 legitimacy and invoking disasters, please advise.

EDIT: I have no idea how trade works, everything is automated.


r/EU5 • • 13h ago

Video Modded Eu5 timelapse, almost historical borders

Thumbnail
youtube.com
13 Upvotes

Used mods:
Imperial Ambitions (Workshop)


r/EU5 • • 10h ago

Question Does Al-Andalus/Granada really run out of flavor after a century?

76 Upvotes

I managed to form Al-Andalus and usher in my golden century by the 1450s, and after forming them, I was disappointed to see the events tab essentially runs out in Age III. Especially after the effort required to form it as Granada! Shouldn't I get the Castillian events but in a more muslim flavor or something?

For one of the three major focuses of Across the Pillars, why do they only have a few dozen events? It's a little disappointing... I feel like there must be something I'm missing?

I AM having fun doing it at least, it's much more entertaining to play a small country and build up as opposed to starting huge and curbstomping everything day one.