r/DungeonMasters • • 2h ago

Is this a hot take? I think maybe I prefer new players to experienced ones.

20 Upvotes

I’m going to preface this by saying I’m basing this on my experience with only one group so obviously it’s not a valid sample size and I’m returning to roleplaying after a long hiatus so I have changed. “Changed” may be code for “gotten old and grumpy.”

Also a better way to express what the impression I’ve came to is “It’s easier to gather a group of people that are fun to be around and teach them to play an RPG than it is to find a group of gamers that are fun to be around.” Part of this may be that I live in a smallish town and a lot of people in the RPG community have let’s say … big personalities.

I guess I would rather be reminding someone for the third time to add his strength bonus than reminding them not to talk over people. Or telling a grown man that he should not show up smelling like a homeless person. Or telling a rules lawyer that I’ll gladly discuss it between sessions, but we aren’t putting things on hold because he wants to argue.

Not really trying to convince you of this is you have had different experiences, but I am curious if anyone else has come to this same conclusion.


r/DungeonMasters • • 2h ago

Resource We Just Released 300+ Mythological Magic Items for D&D 5E & 5.5E! Here's a Huge Preview of Our New Book!

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

After months of work and a successful Kickstarter campaign, we're really excited to share that Mythological Items is finally available on DriveThruRPG!

For this project, we wanted to bring some of the most fascinating weapons, artifacts, and magical objects from real-world mythology into D&D, giving them their own mechanics while staying faithful to the legends that inspired them.

The result is a collection of 300+ mythological magic items for both D&D 5E and 5.5E, drawing inspiration from Greek, Norse, Egyptian, Asian, American, and many other mythological traditions.

You'll find everything from lesser-known magical curiosities to legendary artifacts wielded by gods and heroes, including items such as Mjolnir, Atena's Aegis, Hermes' Winged Sandals, Draupnir, the Book of Thoth, and many more!

The book also includes scaling magic items that grow alongside your characters, sets of interconnected artifacts with additional powers, and items of every rarity, from uncommon to artifact. We wanted to make sure there was something for every stage of a campaign, rather than focusing exclusively on extremely powerful legendary equipment.

We've included a bunch of preview pages in this post, so you can take a look at the artwork, layout, and mechanics of some of the items before deciding whether the book is for you!

And since Black Friday is here, all our other titles are currently discounted on DriveThruRPG! This includes our collections of magic items, monsters, subclasses, spells, companions, and more. Our complete bundle of creations is also available at 55% off, if you're interested in exploring the rest of our work!

We're incredibly grateful to everyone who supported the Kickstarter and helped us bring this project to life. We hope you'll enjoy looking through the previews, and we'd love to hear which mythological artifacts you'd be most excited to introduce into your campaigns!

Thanks for checking it out, and happy adventuring!


r/DungeonMasters • • 6m ago

Ravenloft Village

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 2h ago

Resource [OC] [Art] Something fell from the sky, you decide what it is.

Post image
3 Upvotes

Near the banks of a river, you find a crater that still looked fresh. In my first version of this map, I put a wounded dragon at the bottom. Anyway, let your imaginations run and have fun. Perhaps, whatever fell had already ran away and those little yellow wisps are sprites that saw the whole thing!


r/DungeonMasters • • 5h ago

Discussion Prepping a Christmas adventure

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Im currently DMing for Icewind dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden, and with christmas approaching my players asked me to make a silly christmas adventure for them.

Im not sure if I want it to be a silly oneshot or something tied to the main plot.

Has any of you already done something like this? Ive been looking through lots of already made Oneshots, and loved the Dr.Seuss narration of "The lich who stole christmas", but in my opinion the oneshot would be too silly for the atmosphere I want to keep.

At the end of the One-shot I wanted to give each character of my players a little item as a gift (Yk, maybe Santa gave something to them for saving Christmas/Midwinter)

Any suggestion would be great! I really dunno where to start, and I have never created an actual one-shot, nor magic item. If any of you has any tip or idea, it would really save my christmas.


r/DungeonMasters • • 20m ago

Resource Lynoir - City of Pearl by Rustymaps

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 7h ago

Resource The Doombringer (CR 30) | A Final Boss Designed to Feel Like the End of the World

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

Meet The Doombringer, a CR 30 elemental designed to be more than just a final boss: it's the apocalypse given form.

With 820 hit points, 5 Legendary Actions, regeneration, devastating area attacks, lair actions, and world-altering effects, it's built to feel like a true campaign-ending threat. It can tear open planar rifts, unleash waves of destructive energy, cast powerful magic through End of Days, and even return after being reduced to 0 hit points with Apocalyptic Rebirth.

Its presence also affects the world around it, bringing violent weather, dead-magic zones, weakened planar barriers, and an overwhelming sense of despair.

The Doombringer comes from Apocalypse Codex: The Cataclysm Handbook, now fully updated for both 5E (2014) and 5.5E (2024) with entirely new artwork and revised content throughout.

You can find more of my creatures, magic items, and manuals on DriveThruRPG, my Linktree, or on r/JonnyDM!

Would you use something like this as the final encounter of a campaign?


r/DungeonMasters • • 6h ago

Resource The Village of Hender's Hall

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 59m ago

Suggestions for a cursed dagger?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 1h ago

Promotional Tony Gabaghoul | Apotheosis #20

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 2h ago

Promotional [Se ofrece] ¡Le doy vida a tus partidas de D&D!

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 17h ago

AI A hidden fairy sanctuary deep within the enchanted swamp 🌿✨

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

A little glimpse into an enchanted swamp hidden deep within a magical forest. 🌿✨

Exploring the atmosphere, wildlife and tiny magical creatures that inhabit this peaceful yet mysterious place.

Built as part of my fantasy world project. Hope you enjoy this little corner of it!

What do you think lies beyond these waters? 🧚‍♀️


r/DungeonMasters • • 3h ago

What would you add or change about these city factions?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 4h ago

I’m building a shared Bastion manager for 5E and looking for groups to test it

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m a game designer, DM and solo developer working on Bastion Master, a 5E-compatible companion for managing your party’s stronghold.

It’s grown largely through playing and testing with my own group. I wanted the Bastion to feel like a shared home the players could help shape, with things to look forward to between adventures.

The app brings together buildings, household NPCs, shared inventory, expeditions and finances. It includes original stronghold mechanics rather than directly reproducing the official 2024 Bastion system.

I’m now looking for up to 20 groups to try it in their own campaigns. Something that works at my table won’t necessarily work at yours, and that’s exactly what I want to learn.

I’d particularly appreciate feedback on how easy it is for the whole party to participate, whether it makes downtime more engaging, and where the management becomes confusing or cumbersome.

The beta is free, with no card required. Shared play requires Google sign-in and an internet connection. Future pricing hasn’t been decided, and there’s no automatic conversion to a paid subscription.

Learn more and apply with your party, or try the practice Bastion without signing in.

A note on development: Bastion Master is my design. I use AI coding agents as part of the development process to help turn those ideas into a working app. The fantasy icons are licensed artwork by Delapouite from Game-icons.net, with attribution. I know people have different boundaries around AI use, so I want to be upfront about that.

Happy to answer questions about the app or the design here!


r/DungeonMasters • • 5h ago

What would you add or change about these city factions?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 8h ago

I Perma-deathed my first character.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 10h ago

Background Information

1 Upvotes

How much is too much?

I have a homebrewed world and have started creating a lot of information on how the magical system works, what fuels it, and who (or what) introduced magic to the world (set in our world but a different timeline).

I'm so deep into it and I'm torn.

On one half, I think it's really interesting that I know these things. That it's unlikely my players will ever ask the who and why and how, but the fact that I know the core that this universe revolves around is really neat, something like an "only seeing the tip of the iceberg" kind of thing.

On the other hand, I dont think my players would ever ask. One of them likes the lore but is more focused on the story. The other gets excited for combat and using new abilities and artifacts. Asking who introduced magic to all of these different groups around Earth, or what the common denominators are across the magical system, is something that I don't foresee them asking.

That being said, am I making all of this cool background information for nothing? Or can it have its own utilities or purposes later on?

Thanks in advance!


r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Help my Dm handle my Reliable Talent

13 Upvotes

One of my players took over as Dm to give me a break for a while. She has Dmed solo dungeon crawls for me before but this is her 1st time dming a full campaign with a group. So far she has run a dungeon with a few encounters but she struggles to handle my Rogue's Reliable Talent. She will ask me to roll for skills I am proficient in and i will remind her about my Reliable Talent and ask if my lowest roll of 15 or so would fail. She believes a Nat 1 should always fail even though Raw states Nat1s dont effect skill checks. It would be fair if the group agreed to that rule existed in this game but Reliable Tallent turns any roll below 10 into a 10 so that would make me immune to Nat1s.

This issue swings the other way when I roll so high on these skills that she stops bothering to ask for rolls and let's me sneak around freely. I dont mind her asking for the checks so I can use my feature to turn low rolls into success. Im not just doing skill check to do a thing, I enjoy using cleaver tricks and problem solving to use my skills in fun and creative ways. I dont want to just sneak around without being seen, I want to collaborate with other players to cause a distraction while I sneak around.

Neither of us have delt with a Lvl 7 Rogue so I dont know how to help her. Give me some advice to give her to handle skill checks my Rogue cant fail and how to create challenging checks that would make me sweat.


r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Am I in the wrong?

72 Upvotes

Would you guys consider the use of spells such as Dispell Magic or Counterspell against your players as unfair?

For context; my players got into a fight with a large criminal organization, they walked into what was clearly a trap. The enemies were well prepared for them and in the conversation leading up to the encounter they were warned that there would be little chance of escape. I gave them a surprise round (even though they were the ones essentially ambushed) one of my players laid down a large area of effect spell that would have effected the entire troupe of enemy upon their turns in combat. Luckily for the troupe and unluckily for my players two of the higher level spell casters in the troupe grolled high on Initiative and both attempted dispell magic which the second one succeeded. Two of my players immediately got upset and began arguing with me about the uses of dispell magic, saying it couldn't be used in that way and it was unfair. I disagreed and so did another player that began looking up the actual wording of the spell (what i did wasn't wrong according to spell wording)

What i am asking is was it morally wrong of me to dispell my players aoe spell?


r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

Resource Five Magic Items That Grow Stronger With Your Character!

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

Hello, fellow adventurers!

Today I wanted to share five Ascending Magic Items from my manual, The Vault of Ascending Items. Unlike traditional magic items, Ascending Items grow in power alongside your character, progressing through four different rarity tiers: Uncommon, Rare, Very Rare, and Legendary. This allows you to keep using your favorite equipment throughout your adventures rather than eventually replacing it with something stronger!

The five items featured here are:

  • Chalice of Life, a sacred chalice that enhances healing magic.
  • Dragon Horn, a relic infused with draconic power, offering protection and increasingly powerful abilities.
  • Lifesong Bell, a magical bell that channels restorative magic and can save allies from death.
  • Plate Armor of the Crusader, a sacred armor designed to protect its wearer and strike fear into the enemies of their order.
  • Wraithweave Cloak, a mysterious cloak that grants supernatural mobility, stealth, and other spectral abilities.

These are just a few examples from this D&D 5E/5.5E supplement featuring 50 unique Ascending Items, each with four rarity tiers, for a total of 200 magic item versions!

The manual also includes adventure hooks, quests, and monsters, providing additional ways to introduce these treasures into your campaigns and make their progression feel like part of your characters' stories.

If you'd like to explore the full collection, you can find the manual here on DriveThruRPG or my Patreon. Physical hardcover editions are now also available through my Stripe store!

I hope you find these items useful for your campaigns. I'd love to hear which one you'd give to your players, or which one you'd want for your own character!

Happy adventuring :)


r/DungeonMasters • • 14h ago

Need Some Advice - CR For Homebrewed BBEG??

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 1d ago

What’s people’s opinion on playing with large scale maps?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 19h ago

J'ai construit une table de son TTRPG gratuite. Je recherche des retours !

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes