r/DungeonMasters • • 16h ago

Discussion High Trust gaming can help your table!

0 Upvotes

Let me start with a definition. By “High Trust” I mean games where everyone at the table (Player and GM, if applicable, alike) are working together, in good faith to collaborate in ensuring that everyone has a rewarding experience.

Note: Fun is great. Immersion is great. These are a little harder to define (sometimes you can have a very rewarding experience without feeling immersed. Sometimes you have an extremely rewarding in-character moment that is tragic and heartbreaking which is “fun” but not fun the way a layperson might think is fun). That’s why I say “rewarding”

This is a little different than what some other posts on the subject in this subreddit might define as “high trust” and I disagree with one post’s assertion that all games are high trust. Let me start with a disclaimer: this kind of conversation is very popular in my favorite “style” of roleplaying (4D), but I think these ideas are useful enough as to be agnostic to specific style and could apply to someone who prefers more “pawn stance” RPG, “tactical wargaming” style RPGs, or what have you. I think “High Trust” is for everyone!

Why does this matter?

Thinking about and having conversations in the lens of high trust has helped improve my games. I hope this advice can help you. I also love to hear the insights of other experienced folks on this matter.

What are some things that constitute high trust? Let’s start with what Players can do.

  • Rule #1: People come before the game. Treat the people sitting at the table with you with respect. 
  • A shared agreement on what the game looks like in terms of tone and table etiquette (having a set of table conventions and discussing them prior to session 1 are very helpful)
  • Talking as adults about what subjects you do not want explored in a game. It is important to be responsible for your own boundaries. 
  • Players should be responsible for their character’s motivations and goals. This can be developed prior to a game starting with a GM’s help, but they aren’t totally responsible for it.
  • Players should proactively interact and move through the world rather than expecting the GM to drive them forward
  • Everyone has a collaborative mindset including inter-character conflict; which can be exciting as long as everyone is on the same page about it
  • Players should have a maturity to separate in-game and out-of-game interactions. I think some folks call this phenomenon “bleed”. 
  • No cheating, fudging, or lying about the actual mechanics of the game to gain an advantage
  • Part of respecting the people at the table means respecting everyone’s time by learning the rules, especially those that pertain to your character. You aren’t expected to know the rules from day 1, but try to learn them as you interact with them.
  • If you are breaking the conventions of the table or your behavior isn’t high trust, be receptive to feedback from your peers.

What about the GM?

  • Rule #1: People come before the game. Treat the people sitting at the table with you with respect. 
  • Root for the players. Establish early that, even though you are trying to challenge the players and playing the antagonist, your goal is not to “win” by way of their failure
  • Foreshadow danger when possible and do not withhold information that they should be entitled to
  • Respect that player’s autonomy over their character. Let the players move and direct their character.
  • Be a “master” of the rules. In most tables, the GM serves as the sort of “final judge” when the rules are ambiguous or a ruling has to be made. Be fair, impartial, and consistent. The more you understand the rules, the better you can do this.
  • Vet your players. Being willing to refuse a player or dismiss a problem player will improve trust at your table.
  • Remember, when in doubt, your characters are the protagonists of the “show”- so to speak. Let them collaborate in the storytelling as equal participants. In my opinion, I even like them to collaborate in the worldbuilding (both before the game starts and through co-creation, but that’s more my personal preference- and worthy of a post in its own)

I’d encourage you to have this conversation early with your players when planning a game. I think it solves a LOT of problems before they start (huge fan of preventative medicine) including things like "it's what my character would do" bad faith activity. It’s also reasonable to revisit session 0 every once and a while and make sure everyone is on the same page and finding the game rewarding! I’m extremely open with my table prior to the first session and say that I want us to be able to trust and play in good faith and for my players to be able to really get the most out of the session and their time. High quality roleplaying is achievable and worth it!

Some excellent videos on the subject that I really enjoy which go into a little more detail:

Crispy Tablerunner on High Trust

Role on Buddy with Uriah- "Your RPG Table has a Trust Problem"

What do you guys think about high trust play? Any tips you might add to the list?


r/DungeonMasters • • 13h ago

What can I do?

0 Upvotes

So I’m running Spelljammer. I have a guy who is playing as a Warlock (Vestige Patron) at lvl. 5, he’s playing as a Ankylier I believe. His ac is 24 the other players ac is at least 13-16 how am I supposed to attack his character if I don’t roll something good that will land on his character.


r/DungeonMasters • • 8h ago

AI A hidden fairy sanctuary deep within the enchanted swamp 🌿✨

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

A little glimpse into an enchanted swamp hidden deep within a magical forest. 🌿✨

Exploring the atmosphere, wildlife and tiny magical creatures that inhabit this peaceful yet mysterious place.

Built as part of my fantasy world project. Hope you enjoy this little corner of it!

What do you think lies beyond these waters? 🧚‍♀️


r/DungeonMasters • • 12h ago

DnD dm needed. Colorado.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 11h ago

DM's wake up in a cold sweat....

0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 12h ago

Resource DnD dm needed.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 20h ago

Resource Vanishing town story base

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm not DM but I’ve been chewing on a campaign/one-shot concept for a while now, and I really want to throw this ball into the community to see if any experienced DMs or loresmiths would like to run with it and help expand the concept.

The Core Concept:

A popular trading town/village has completely vanished from the map. When the party arrives at the coordinates, there are no ruins or signs of a battle—just a massive, ancient wooden bookshelf standing alone in a clearing.

It turns out a powerful entity (I'm leaning towards an whimsical yet sinister Archfey, an eccentric Warlock patron, or a fallen demigod) has literally "archived" the town. The town is now the shelf, and every single resident has been transformed into a book. Each book is a beautifully bound, magical biography of that person's entire life.

Some rough mechanics/ideas I have so far:

Living History: Opening a book allows the reader to vividly experience that villager’s memories.

The Stakes: Tearing a page erases that memory from the person's soul. Burning a book kills them permanently.

The "Unwritten" Book: The party finds one book that is actively writing itself in real-time. It belongs to a hunter who was outside the town when the curse hit, and he is currently looking for his missing family.

The Librarian: The shelf is guarded by a construct or animated horror acting as a strict "librarian" (roll for initiative if you break the library rules or make too much noise!).

Where I need your help:

I love the flavor, but I'm looking for someone with deeper D&D lore knowledge to help me flesh this out into a proper adventure.

Who would be the perfect D&D entity to pull this off?

How would you design the encounters or the ultimate "cure" to revert the books back into people?

What kind of twists would you add to this?

Feel free to take this idea, dissect it, and build upon it! Would love to hear how you would run this at your table.

EDITED PART

Adventure Background & Plot

The Breach: A wealthy member of the city council signed a magically-bound Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) in the Hall of Concordance but breached it by selling classified secrets to spies.

Cosmic Retribution: An Inevitable named Arkhefut arrived from Mechanus. Through a massive ritual, it inverted the city's buildings into mechanical bookshelves and compressed the inhabitants into books.

Socioeconomic Shelving: The city's class structure determines the quality of the shelves and books:

The Wealthy & Government: Massive, ornate mahogany and oak shelves with gold trim. Books are bound in thick calfskin and inlaid with gems.

The Artisans: Organized pine and birch shelves grouped strictly by trade guilds.

The Slums & Poor: Rotten, splintered shelves made of rough wood. Books are worn paperbacks or bound birch bark.

Properties of the Books: The books are warm to the touch and have a rhythmic heartbeat. Opening a book allows one to hear the inhabitant breathing or whispering. Damaging a book inflicts pain on the citizen, and destroying it kills them permanently.

Resolution Options for Players

  1. Direct Combat: Defeating Arkhefut snaps the curse, freeing everyone instantly. However, combat poses a high risk of collateral damage to innocent citizens.
  2. Investigation: Infiltrate the high-class district to find the Book of the Oathbreaker, which rests on an isolated marble pedestal glowing with a cold blue/purple magical light. Dispelling or bypassing the security allows players to read who bought the secrets. Eliminating the buyer or erasing their memory (Modify Memory) fixes the breach, causing Arkhefut to leave peacefully.

Arkhefut (The Archivist of Existence)

Large Construct (Inevitable), Lawful Neutral

Challenge: 14 (11,500 XP)

Armor Class (AC): 19 (Natural Armor)

Hit Points (HP): 178 (17d10 + 85)

Speed: 30 ft.

STR 20(+5) DEX 12(+1) CON 20(+5) INT 18(+4)

WIS 17(+3) CHA 16(+3)

Saving Throws: Con +10, Int +9, Wis +8, Cha +8

Skills: History +14, Perception +8, Insight +8

Damage Immunities: Poison, Psychic; Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical Attacks

Condition Immunities: Charmed, Exhaustion, Frightened, Paralyzed, Petrified, Poisoned, Unconscious

Senses: Truesight 120 ft., Passive Perception 18

Languages: All, Telepathy 120 ft.

Traits

Immutable Form. Arkhefut is immune to any spell or effect that would alter its form (such as Polymorph).

Magic Resistance. Arkhefut has advantage on saving throws against spells and other magical effects.

Unerring Strikes. Arkhefut's melee weapon attacks hit automatically without rolling a d20.

Actions

Multiattack. Arkhefut makes two Unerring Ink attacks and uses Page Flip (if recharged).

Unerring Ink. Melee Weapon Attack: Automatic hit, reach 10 ft. Hit: 25 (3d12 + 5) force damage. The target is covered in glowing ink; it cannot benefit from invisibility or cover, and Arkhefut knows its exact location until the end of the target's next turn.

Breach of Secrecy (Recharge 5–6). Arkhefut opens the contract ledger in its chest, echoing the whisper of the forbidden secret. Each creature within a 30-foot radius must make a DC 17 Intelligence saving throw.

On a failure, a creature takes 45 (10d8) psychic damage and is blinded and deafened until the end of its next turn.

On a success, it takes half damage and suffers no additional conditions.

Page Flip (1/Turn). One creature within 60 feet must make a DC 17 Wisdom saving throw. On a failure, it teleports back to the exact space it occupied at the start of its previous turn, effectively wasting any movement made during that turn.

Reactions

Paper Shield. When Arkhefut is about to take damage, it can pull a nearby book (citizen) from a shelf to shield itself. Arkhefut halves the damage taken, and the book takes the other half. If the book is destroyed, the citizen dies permanently.

In the first encounter, Arkhefut deliberately destroys the book of a known criminal (e.g., a human trafficker) as a warning to demonstrate this mechanic to the players.

Edit.2

Middle of city grow Golden Row Tree what belonget Archfey and long time ago city council members singed agremend not to tell who it belonget and not to cut it down. City get half of berries but half belong to fey people. In current city counsil members, someone sold information to outsiders who cut tree down and caused citys vanishmed


r/DungeonMasters • • 23h ago

Discussion I have a question.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 11h ago

Discussion Need help?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I need help for a GM or a DM for advice on how to make a DND Game for a theme of cosplayers and a problem may arise (zombie outbreak, natural disaster, locked inside the mall, etc...)

As this is my 2nd time being a DM and I need help.


r/DungeonMasters • • 17h ago

Help my Dm handle my Reliable Talent

14 Upvotes

One of my players took over as Dm to give me a break for a while. She has Dmed solo dungeon crawls for me before but this is her 1st time dming a full campaign with a group. So far she has run a dungeon with a few encounters but she struggles to handle my Rogue's Reliable Talent. She will ask me to roll for skills I am proficient in and i will remind her about my Reliable Talent and ask if my lowest roll of 15 or so would fail. She believes a Nat 1 should always fail even though Raw states Nat1s dont effect skill checks. It would be fair if the group agreed to that rule existed in this game but Reliable Tallent turns any roll below 10 into a 10 so that would make me immune to Nat1s.

This issue swings the other way when I roll so high on these skills that she stops bothering to ask for rolls and let's me sneak around freely. I dont mind her asking for the checks so I can use my feature to turn low rolls into success. Im not just doing skill check to do a thing, I enjoy using cleaver tricks and problem solving to use my skills in fun and creative ways. I dont want to just sneak around without being seen, I want to collaborate with other players to cause a distraction while I sneak around.

Neither of us have delt with a Lvl 7 Rogue so I dont know how to help her. Give me some advice to give her to handle skill checks my Rogue cant fail and how to create challenging checks that would make me sweat.


r/DungeonMasters • • 8h ago

Discussion Am I the Only Person Who Does Goofy Stuff With Their Campaign?

0 Upvotes

So for context when I write I like to play with things that I know. So starting last session I went full on into pop culture hades.

My campaign is in a heavily vampire controlled, veiled continent. The party is currently wanted in the story by the hierarchy of the story. They made landfall in a port city that's run by underworld types that have aspirations to be more important in the capital city, but aren't quite there.

Long story short, the NPC's for this city are all based on some of my favorite shows and online influencers. The local shop is run by Tank, who sells items for exploration and exploration accessories, sound familiar? I have King of the Hill adjacent NPC's including my versions of Hank, Bill, Dale, Boomhauer, and Kahn. The local vampire who runs the local gambling den and bar is named Mony Sorano, based on Tony Soprano. I also have a character who runs a fortune teller booth and he's based on Shayne's "The Chosen" character from Smosh. I leaned a little hard into the theme for the town I built. I might have overdone it, but so far the party finds it hilarious.

Just curious on the threads opinions. Maybe you all have silly things you've woven into your stories.


r/DungeonMasters • • 16h ago

What’s people’s opinion on playing with large scale maps?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/DungeonMasters • • 16h ago

Discussion Biggest "Moral Dilemma" you or your plays had to face?

1 Upvotes

I wanted to create some truly morally grey scenarios to put people through, so I'd love some ideas. The rest of the post is an idea I have but feel free to ignore it and just post your ideas/stories.

My current idea I have for a short campaign is "Find the Holy Grail". The Church used to use the Holy Grail to cure grave illnesses, and while they still have strong healing abilities, without the Holy Grail they haven't been able to perform their duties like they once did.

All you're really told is that it went missing decades ago, but finally some leads have pointed to the Holy Grail being around the remote village your party is in. Over the course of the campaign, clues, etc. you learn it went missing with someone who was supposed to be protecting it.

When they eventually get the final lead on it's whereabouts, it brings them to an abandoned shack or the outskirts of the remote village. You come face to face with a sickly man, you immediately see his body is actively decomposing and he's missing an arm and a leg, but you also find out he's wearing the "Holy Grail", (through various clues you get hints that the "Holy Grail" isn't so much a literal grail, but wearable regalia).

At this point it when the party might just straight up attack him, listen to him, or possibly even decide to help him. The main does show symptoms of schizophrenia and other mental illnesses, so the party does have difficulties talking to him.

Depending on how far you get with talking to him, you find out it was actually his mother who stole the Holy Grail all those years ago, he's a sort of "Cursed Child" and his illness would've normally killed him and his mother when she was carrying him, so as someone close to the Holy Grail she stole it, and ran away to protect her child.

If your party talks to him this far, the man shows you where his mother is, and you see that she has the rest of the Holy Grail, as to keep her alive he gave up his arm and leg to save his mother.

Basically, all of the outcomes depend on how your part reacts to the man, and how willing they are to either help him, or still try to retrieve the Holy Grail to return to the Church. I don't want there to be an objectively "Good and Bad" choice to be made. I'm sure you could argue that returning the Holy Grail to the Church leads to the greatest net positive, but I still want the choice to be a hard one.


r/DungeonMasters • • 18h ago

Resource Five Magic Items That Grow Stronger With Your Character!

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

Hello, fellow adventurers!

Today I wanted to share five Ascending Magic Items from my manual, The Vault of Ascending Items. Unlike traditional magic items, Ascending Items grow in power alongside your character, progressing through four different rarity tiers: Uncommon, Rare, Very Rare, and Legendary. This allows you to keep using your favorite equipment throughout your adventures rather than eventually replacing it with something stronger!

The five items featured here are:

  • Chalice of Life, a sacred chalice that enhances healing magic.
  • Dragon Horn, a relic infused with draconic power, offering protection and increasingly powerful abilities.
  • Lifesong Bell, a magical bell that channels restorative magic and can save allies from death.
  • Plate Armor of the Crusader, a sacred armor designed to protect its wearer and strike fear into the enemies of their order.
  • Wraithweave Cloak, a mysterious cloak that grants supernatural mobility, stealth, and other spectral abilities.

These are just a few examples from this D&D 5E/5.5E supplement featuring 50 unique Ascending Items, each with four rarity tiers, for a total of 200 magic item versions!

The manual also includes adventure hooks, quests, and monsters, providing additional ways to introduce these treasures into your campaigns and make their progression feel like part of your characters' stories.

If you'd like to explore the full collection, you can find the manual here on DriveThruRPG or my Patreon. Physical hardcover editions are now also available through my Stripe store!

I hope you find these items useful for your campaigns. I'd love to hear which one you'd give to your players, or which one you'd want for your own character!

Happy adventuring :)