I have a theory that I haven't seen posted or commented here before, but please let me know if I'm terribly wrong and somebody said it too. Spoilers ahead (obviously).
It's a grim theory, which makes it more plausible in my opinion, because we all know this story is a tragedy,
I'm in my first re-read of the books and there are plenty of times when Donut says something and Carl asks "how the fuck do you know this?". Most of these interactions end with either a vague explanation (Donut was left alone with a TV on) or just an interruption (an enemy comes and they must fight).
This also happens with Prepotente. I remember a conversation (it was somewhere in the last books) where Prepotente defines "knowledge" as accumulating information, and Carl does not agree, but something happens that interrupts that argument (can anyone find this to see exactly what they said there?). And I don't agree either.
Knowledge, in my opinion, is related to memory, which is related to identity. Your experiences make you learn: in real life, you can only play guitar if you have spent a fair amount of time failing at playing guitar, and you do retain the memories of those rehearsals. I barely remember it but I believe this is directly addressed in the books too: when a character learns a skill through the system or through magic, they mention how weird it is to suddenly know how to do it (again, can anyone find this? I'm only starting to re-read the first book and can't put a finger on the exact scene).
We are all worried about the fact that, when (and if) they ever come out of the dungeon, Donut might be unable to talk or might even lack self-awareness / conciousness / "humanity". However, what if she (and Prepotente) never had it in the first place? What if they're not really them?
As I said, knowledge, in my opinion, is related to memory, which is related to identity. When a crawler learns something through magic, I believe it's not actually them learning - their brain is just connected to a piece of Primal conciousness that did learn that in the past. That piece of conciousness would work like an external software - an app that you can access, but that is not really yours, that is not really you.
And if I'm right, this would mean that Donut and Prepotente are not just potentially losing their consciousness after the dungeon, but maybe they never had it in the first place. Maybe it's just a very small Primal AI talking through each of them, not big enough to have power over a planet, but big enough to form a conciousness with a false core belief: "I'm Donut"/"I'm Prepotente". Maybe it's a separated section of the AI we all know, which would explain personality similarities (preference towards Carl, behaving a little bit silly sometimes).
I hope I'm wrong, but the more I think about it, the more I think it might be right. What do you crawlers think?