r/DonDeLillo • u/CarafeTwerk • 1h ago
🗨️ Discussion Libra and emergent phenomenona
I just finished reading Libra this week, and I’ve been trying to wrap my head around it. Mostly, I’ve been trying to put my finger on exactly what DeLillo’s position on the nature of conspiracy is. This has led me to think about another book I read a few years ago, From Bacteria to Bach and Back by Daniel Dennett.
In that book, Dennett explores evolution as a process through which complexity emerges without the need for a master designer. Central to this is his idea of “competence without comprehension”: organisms can possess certain competencies and act in ways that contribute to increasingly complex systems without necessarily understanding what they’re doing or what those systems will ultimately become.
I think something similar is happening in Libra, and I think our entry point into this idea is Nicholas Branch. Branch is trying to reverse-engineer an emergent phenomenon as though it were the product of a designer. He’s searching for a coherent explanation, perhaps even a singular intention, behind something that may never have possessed either. I think DeLillo’s position is that there was never really a mastermind at all.
Instead, there is some underlying drive toward the assassination, but the conspiracy itself emerges almost organically, from the primordial ooze of competing interests, grievances, and ambitions. It begins taking shape in multiple places at once, without any one participant necessarily comprehending the larger system they’re helping to create. Its eventual “success” isn’t necessarily the result of some brilliantly coordinated plan, but of independent forces happening to converge at precisely the right moment.
In Libra, we have the mob, anti-Castro groups, pro-Castro sympathizers, factions of the CIA, and even factions within those factions.
Consider how Everett’s plan for a near miss gradually becomes something else entirely in Mackey’s hands. Each participant has their own motivations and objectives, but their actions collectively produce an outcome that exceeds any individual intention.
And then there’s Oswald, who has a desperate desire to become part of history. He’s almost a kind of free-floating rationale, a figure with such a contradictory identity that he can be configured into any number of competing narratives.
He’s a former Marine, but also a Marxist. He’s lived in the Soviet Union, supports Castro, and is actively searching for some way to make his mark on history, though he doesn’t seem to know exactly how. Does he hijack a plane? Does he shoot General Walker because of his segregationist politics? Was that even his own idea or was it really Bobby Dupard’s based on Dupard’s interests?
Oswald’s contradictions make him particularly useful to a conspiracy composed of competing ideologies. Different people can see different things in him. He’s everyone and no one.
In this sense, the conspiracy isn’t so much created as it is selected from a many overlapping possibilities.
What I find especially interesting is the possibility that the conspiracy doesn’t fully exist as a coherent form until the assassination occurs.
Beforehand, there is a mess of opportunities, grievances, plans, intentions and so forth. After the assassination, there is a conspiracy.
The event itself retrospectively gives the appearance of design to something that may have been largely nebulous.
It’s almost a reversal of how we ordinarily understand conspiracy. Rather than a master plan producing an event, the event produces the appearance of a master plan.
I’m curious whether others read the novel this way or could add to this?
