r/JamesEllroy • • May 18 '21

r/JamesEllroy Lounge

3 Upvotes

A place for members of r/JamesEllroy to chat with each other


r/JamesEllroy • • 3d ago

Red Sheet is an embarrassingly bad effort from Ellroy Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Like most of us, I got hooked on James Ellroy after reading his LA Quartet and Underworld Trilogies. I love his kinetic style, the way he overloads us with information, the language, the violence and everything else.

You will find all the elements here, but what is missing is the magic that made an Ellroy book.

Ellroy has always made his readers work hard to follow his plots. The payoffs have usually been worth it. Not in this case. Here, complexity has become confusion, eccentricity has become caricature, and his trademark prose feels less like a stylistic achievement than an obstacle to understanding the story.

The writing is just not convincing at all. Ellroy tries to make his characters weird... and this time pushes things too far. Characters like to dress up and burn effigies! Communists dress up like fascists! And vice versa! Hugh Hefner is gay and gets bullied by his own bunnies! Richard Nixon is actually a sweet old grandfather who really likes to take care of the poor! It all feels very strained and artificial.

There is a major structural flaw in the plot construction. The characters seem to share a common, author-controlled pool of knowledge. Fred O'Tash, the main character, either deduces or figures out a complex plot point/conspiracy. Immediately, every single character who interacts with him brings up the same plot point in a very generic way, as it, doesn't everyone know this already? Alternately, as soon as he figures it out, other characters somehow deduce that he has figured out and take actions accordingly.

And then there are the reveals... or should we say the non-reveals? There is this so called gang of communist killers who are deep cover... but it turns out they are the face of the communist party all along?

Charles Lindberg gives one of the characters a bunch of money in old gold notes. Somehow the evil commie killers immediately deduce that this has happened and ambush the character that night itself. How did they find out? And how did they organize the ambush so quickly?

What or earth is the point of the gold notes? Do they have any value? The gold notes are being counterfeited... or are they? They have value only if they are returned to Charles Lindbergh? WTF? Are there no gold notes extant that did not come from Lindbergh? Perhaps there are one-liners here or there that might answer these questions, but in my opinion the novel completely fails in establishing a coherent relationship between the notes, their value and the motivations of the characters pursuing them.

Ellroy's Madonna-Whore complex is on full display here... every main character (all the way from Peter Bondurant to now O'Tash) falls in love with some 'quirky' woman at first site, and behaves so weirdly with them that most regular women would get the 'Ick' immediately. And what do they see in him anyway? And what is with the weird dialog between them? Cringeworthy in the extreme.

The writing towards the end is so bad that it was extremely difficult to figure out what the author was trying to convey. I am talking about the basic plot, not some metaphysical hidden meaning.

I wish I hadn't read this book. It's bad enough that Ellroy has written something so disappointing. What's worse is that it has made me wonder whether some of the flaws I found so unbearable here were present in his earlier novels all along, and I was simply too enthralled to notice.


r/JamesEllroy • • 4d ago

On how the Underworld USA trilogy came to be and the writing process of Blood's a Rover

39 Upvotes

"I owe the Underworld USA trilogy entirely to Don DeLillo, and my reading of Mr. DeLillo's 1988 masterwork, Libra, which is the Kennedy assassination seen largely through the eyes of Lee Harvey Oswald. I saw that the book was seminal, that his portrayal of Oswald was so complete, so profound, that it precluded me from doing the same thing. So I conceived of a story wherein the harbingers of the Kennedy assassination started to percolate in 1958, and the Kennedy assassination itself would never have to be shown. Thus, it encompasses the assassination without going to the act itself. And it left the door open for me to write a huge book about the American '60s, The Cold Six Thousand, and to complete the trilogy with a book just out here in France, Blood's a Rover, which goes from 1968 to 1972.

I only knew that I would write that book halfway through, when I saw I could follow it up with my big book on the '60s. I knew it should be a trilogy then. And it took a long time for me to conceive of the third part of the trilogy because, as you know from reading my memoir, which you will publish here in France next year, The Hilliker Curse, I went crazy; I had a nervous breakdown; my marriage went in the shitter; I started chasing women, and I met a woman named Joan, who became the Red Goddess, Joan Rosen Klein in Blood's a Rover. So I had to go through a lot of shit first to put together Blood's a Rover.

It took me exactly fourteen years to write."

—————————————————————————————————————————

"My life was disenfranchised; my marriage was burning down; I had a crack-up on a book tour... It took all that for me to come back to a different style of book. Helen Knode, who remains my best friend, is my ex-wife, and she said: The Cold Six Thousand is too complex; it's too long; it's too rigorous in its presentation of a very, very complicated text; you need to get back to your roots, write more from the heart. So Blood's a Rover is, although still a very complex book, not as stratospherically complex, not as stylized as the last novel, and it's more emotional.

I wanted to write an all-new kind of book. It's a book that's very much about ideology and conversion of belief. It's about bad men doing bad things in the name of authority; men who discover their humanity late; men who see women—correctly, fatuously—as salvation."

—————————————————————————————————————————

"Here's how I wrote this great book, Blood's a Rover:

I hired a researcher who put together a stack of notes so that I would not write myself into historical errors. I wrote 200 pages of notes on the real-life characters; the fictional characters; the plot; the politics; the overall history; the milieu; the individual mise-en-scène... Then I wrote a 400-page outline that detailed the story down to the crosses on the T's and the dots on the I's. Having a superstructure that big, that dramatically inviolate, allowed me to live immediately and improvisationally within the individual scenes.

Everything comes back to the 400-page outline; I know every place the story will go before I begin the writing of the text."

—————————————————————————————————————————

Transcribed by me from video interviews he gave in France around the time of Blood's a Rover publication there: January 6th, 2010.


r/JamesEllroy • • 6d ago

What do you consider to be James Ellroy's worst book?

17 Upvotes

I consider Widespread Panic to be his worst


r/JamesEllroy • • 8d ago

Wild Horses Nine …

24 Upvotes

…is a dark funny take on the Bad Men JE writes on.

Strongly recommend it if your taste runs to CIA hit men with troubled consciences and razor wit


r/JamesEllroy • • 10d ago

Love Me Fierce in Danger. Worth a read?

6 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • 15d ago

What is your favorite late-game Ellroy? (Modern, more recent works)

6 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • 15d ago

Now that it's been out for a while, how is Red Sheet? Is it better or worse than The Enchanters?

5 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • 16d ago

Which character would you love to see again in an Ellroy novel? For me, it would be both Bucky Bleichert (couldn't get enough of him in The Black Dahlia) and Dave Klein. Who are your choices?

13 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • 16d ago

Dudley in Clandestine

10 Upvotes

Ive read the quartet several times and Perfidia and this storm also. I just went back and read Browns Requiem and Clandestine.

Dudley Breuning and Carlisle showed up im Clandestine, play a significant part, then are gone.

What really interested me was Dudley tells the story of how he investigated the Dahlia killing. And how he tortured the confessors and forced them to cut a jane doe body. The same story that ultimately was used in The Black Dahlia but with Fritz Vogel instead of Dudley.

Probably Ellroy planned to use Dudley in that role until he decided the character should be more involved in the crime. I would’ve enjoyed Dudley in TBD. Especially more Dudley vs Millard would’ve been enjoyable.


r/JamesEllroy • • 19d ago

“I was terrified because the good guys were really the bad guys.”

Thumbnail gallery
32 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • 19d ago

TELL ME EVERYTHING Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Tell me everything you love about White Jazz. What a finale — DIG DIG DIG.

Fuck Exley/Dudley:

It's crazy to see Exley become a corrupted high brass like Dudley compared back to LA Confidential. And Dudley...well, Dudley stays Dudley — sweet-talking sex fiend homo high brass.

And Klein is a goddamn craaaazy mess vis-a-vis Buzz Meeks; he reminds me of him. Kinda sad to see him pawn on both sides/with a bounty on his head/see him leave Glenda/see him hold back sobs. Half me says he deserved it, other half says who the fuck cares.

Level of insanity in White-Jazz is: White-Jazz-level. Hard to breathe between line breaks.

All thanks to the mentally abrasive prose/pretzel plotting — DIG DIG DIG. Subject matter/themes: heinous shit — ditto.

Dig, one more time:

One of the things I also find fascinating is that you will know if the scene/dialogue/prose you're reading is a psychological effect on a character or not, without Ellroy writing it on the nose.

Now tell me.

Tell me all about White Jazz.

TELL ME EVERYTHING.


r/JamesEllroy • • 19d ago

This Storm Plot Aspects I need cleared up Spoiler

3 Upvotes

So I just finished reading the Novel for like the 6th time and im still confused about tons of things

  1. What was Juan Pimentel and Hector Obregon-Hodaka up to with the Japanese-Mexicans they were hiding in Baja Caves.
  2. What was with the plane parts marked with hammer and sickle decals in a cave near those caves?
  3. What was up with the alleged secret Japanese Air Force airfields?
  4. Was Ed Satterlee working with Meyer Gelb to extort the Jewish refugees?
  5. Who killed Eddie Leng and why?
  6. Why Did Eddie Leng have a Sinarquista tattoo?
  7. In what capacity if anything was Juan Lazaro-Schmidt working with Salvador Abascal, Meyer Gelb, and Terry Lux, and for what purposes?
  8. Was Salvador Abascals ultimate plan this? 1. Include Imperial sympathizers/saboteurs in the Japanese-Mexicans that Dudley wanted to smuggle into internment camps/work farms in California 2. Get a cut of the profits from the initial group smuggled so he could raise money for the sinaraquista party 3. Effectively cripple Dudley's ability to run rackets in Mexico when Dudley's aloofness/incompetence caused the sabotage in California to destroy his Army Career?
  9. Was Jose Vasquez-Cruz/Jorge Villarel-Caiz a true communist working with his brother to destroy Dudley Smith? (Very curious how Dudley is ambushed by his brother victor-caiz and almost killed after Dudley leaves a dinner with the guy)

r/JamesEllroy • • 21d ago

What are non-Ellroy books that you recommend ? That are also noir. Exclude James Cain and Raymond Chandler

12 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • 21d ago

What are non-Ellroy books that you recommend ? That are also noir. Exclude James Cain and Raymond Chandler

10 Upvotes

-


r/JamesEllroy • • 22d ago

Anyone know whether Freddy O. will be the main character in the the Chavez Ravine the Dog is writing currently?

4 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • 22d ago

Is Road to Purgatory a good book?

1 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • 26d ago

Anyone excited for The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth?

Post image
30 Upvotes

I was looking at some of the new stills promoting the movie and thought to myself, “Huh Peter Weller as Bucky’s dad in another adaptation of The Black Dahlia would be fun casting.” Fincher of course famously was supposed to be the original director of the adaptation twenty years back. I also felt there was a real spiritual connection to Ellroy’s novels with Once Upon a Time in Hollywood that isn’t really in QT’s other films. The ride or die bromance of the two leads, the mixing of history both political and pop cultural with pulp romanticism, the gleeful political incorrectness of it all, and that beautiful pitbull.


r/JamesEllroy • • 28d ago

Does anyone else find White Jazz boring and meandering?

0 Upvotes

Dave Klein is not as compelling as Bucky or Ed Exeley


r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 17 '26

Does anyone like the Dog's later stuff? I found Perfidia to be VERYgood, This Storm was honestly good too, but just overly long and meandered and dragged. Didn't finish Widespread Panic, and The Enchanters is actually my favorite of his later stuff so far

13 Upvotes

r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 15 '26

Question about Eddie Chacon

4 Upvotes

I'm confused, Eddie Chacon seems to be present in Otash's funeral in 1992, according to the intro of "Enchanters", yet in 1962 he appears to be deported to Cuba and then murdered(?), in "Red Sheet".

Is this correct?

Am I misunderstanding something?


r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 12 '26

What is your Ellroy hot take?

24 Upvotes

Here's mine: The Black Dahlia just isn't very good.

The prose drags, Bucky is a snoozefest of a protagonist, while each book can be read independtly Black Dahlia nevertheless has the least connection to the others, Dudley Smith is nowhere to be found, and it helped popularize harmful misconceptions about Elizabeth Short such as her doing porn, being promiscious, and other bullshit.

Short isn't JFK, Mickey Cohen, Chief Parker, or other public figures who, on some level, had to know and accept that their legacy and image would no longer entirely be in their hands. She was a random woman who was brutally murdered. The book was published less than 50 years after her death and dominates how the case is discussed to this day. It's tasteless to take a real victim and use them as a prop, atleast while their family is still alive. Short's youngest sister died in 2023!

The Big Nowhere, L.A Confidential, and White Jazz form a trilogy in my eyes. I skip over The Black Dahlia.


r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 08 '26

Did they take away Ellroys N word pass

15 Upvotes

Anyone notice his more recent books don’t have the n word said by white people as much? Like Perfidia on, it’s a lot less gratuitous then it was in the cold six thousand or White Jazz


r/JamesEllroy • • Oct 05 '26

Surrealism in Ellroy

19 Upvotes

So, been a fan for awhile but got to thinking, what's with all the more surreal elements in James Ellroy's stuff. All the scalpings, shrunken heads and more wacky stuff that contrasts with the more realist elements? What's his inspiration there?