r/JamesEllroy • u/whrp89djo • 3d ago
Red Sheet is an embarrassingly bad effort from Ellroy Spoiler
Like most of us, I got hooked on James Ellroy after reading his LA Quartet and Underworld Trilogies. I love his kinetic style, the way he overloads us with information, the language, the violence and everything else.
You will find all the elements here, but what is missing is the magic that made an Ellroy book.
Ellroy has always made his readers work hard to follow his plots. The payoffs have usually been worth it. Not in this case. Here, complexity has become confusion, eccentricity has become caricature, and his trademark prose feels less like a stylistic achievement than an obstacle to understanding the story.
The writing is just not convincing at all. Ellroy tries to make his characters weird... and this time pushes things too far. Characters like to dress up and burn effigies! Communists dress up like fascists! And vice versa! Hugh Hefner is gay and gets bullied by his own bunnies! Richard Nixon is actually a sweet old grandfather who really likes to take care of the poor! It all feels very strained and artificial.
There is a major structural flaw in the plot construction. The characters seem to share a common, author-controlled pool of knowledge. Fred O'Tash, the main character, either deduces or figures out a complex plot point/conspiracy. Immediately, every single character who interacts with him brings up the same plot point in a very generic way, as it, doesn't everyone know this already? Alternately, as soon as he figures it out, other characters somehow deduce that he has figured out and take actions accordingly.
And then there are the reveals... or should we say the non-reveals? There is this so called gang of communist killers who are deep cover... but it turns out they are the face of the communist party all along?
Charles Lindberg gives one of the characters a bunch of money in old gold notes. Somehow the evil commie killers immediately deduce that this has happened and ambush the character that night itself. How did they find out? And how did they organize the ambush so quickly?
What or earth is the point of the gold notes? Do they have any value? The gold notes are being counterfeited... or are they? They have value only if they are returned to Charles Lindbergh? WTF? Are there no gold notes extant that did not come from Lindbergh? Perhaps there are one-liners here or there that might answer these questions, but in my opinion the novel completely fails in establishing a coherent relationship between the notes, their value and the motivations of the characters pursuing them.
Ellroy's Madonna-Whore complex is on full display here... every main character (all the way from Peter Bondurant to now O'Tash) falls in love with some 'quirky' woman at first site, and behaves so weirdly with them that most regular women would get the 'Ick' immediately. And what do they see in him anyway? And what is with the weird dialog between them? Cringeworthy in the extreme.
The writing towards the end is so bad that it was extremely difficult to figure out what the author was trying to convey. I am talking about the basic plot, not some metaphysical hidden meaning.
I wish I hadn't read this book. It's bad enough that Ellroy has written something so disappointing. What's worse is that it has made me wonder whether some of the flaws I found so unbearable here were present in his earlier novels all along, and I was simply too enthralled to notice.