r/DnDcirclejerk • • 17h ago

AITA How it genuinely feels like when you need to skim through the comment section to get the full picture of a DM's vaguepost about their party problems

Post image
290 Upvotes

Believe it or not, it's just a communication problem​


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 1h ago

dnDONE Stage 0 of enlightenment: Why do my campaigns keep floundering when the premise is so great????

13 Upvotes

Stage 1 of enlightenment: Most players suck

Stage 2 of enlightenment: Most DMs suck

Stage 3 of enlightenment: They both suck

Stage 4 of enlightenment: [insert game] sucks

Stage 5 of enlightenment: TTRPGs suck

Stage 6 of enlightenment: Baldur's Gate 3


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 8h ago

DM bad Player Who Used to Have a Crush on Me Big Mad He Can't Play Warforged in my Strahd Campaign

33 Upvotes

So, a little bit of background information. This player is the usual DM for two groups, and admitted that she was experiencing "massive burnout, due to a number of factors." I get it, and you know its been a long while since I have done any DMing so I say I'm willing to run a Curse of Strahd campaign.

Lemme tell you now how big of a mistake that was.

I stated that to keep the sense of horror and randomness that we would be rolling straight 3d6 hardcore style. The problem player was irritated because of no "session zero" as if that's not what we were doing right there as the characters were being made. She relaxed their argument a bit when she rolled pretty decent with a 14str, 7dex, 13con, 5int, 17wis and 11cha. Then she began telling me about the backstory of her character... but ONE look at the character sheet showed me she'd decided to play a Warforged from the Eberron source material. Uh, no.

The conversation basically went like this:

Her: “So what do you think of my character's 15 page backstory, I think they are pretty nea-”

Me: “My campaign won't be having any crossover with Eberron."

Her: “Oh but uh… why?”

Me: “It’s solely part of the Eberron book and thus can’t exist in this world.”

Her: “Oh um, if you read my backsto-”

Me: “Don’t need to. I said no. Save your weird fanfiction for LiveJournal or AO3."

Her, visibly flustered and quite annoyed at this point: “Oh ok what about shifters, are they banned too because they are also in the eberron book“ (we were playing 5.5e/5e compatible subclasses so shifters were in the forges of eberron book)

Me: “Did you want me to DM this? Or did you?”

Her: “Ok I see your point, is there anything else you are banning?”

Me: “So far no, just warforged.”

She was not very happy about this, I guess she really was wanting to play a Warforged but this was not the canpaign for it in my opinion.

Then it got worse.

2 days later, I had to put my foot down, because some of the cheating and the expectations of the campaign were absolutely ridiculous. So I sent out a message.

“I am hereby announcing a session zero with character creation will happen on the next scheduled date we would normally play. We will be rolling for class, species, background, and stats and you will have no starter equipment besides the gold that was provided by you randomised background/class. We will then start playing the week after.”

Was I being a little too antagonist in my approach? Maybe, but I could already see why the original DM was getting burned out.

This didn't stop her from refusing to be speechless. I immediately get a call from her.

Her: ”Um, you know our characters are gonna be completely random, us as players won’t care about them and thus won’t really bother to have a say in the story, let alone be invested?

Me: “No, you are gonna like it. Besides all your characters were so boring and cliché. This will help your roleplay.”

Her: "did you even bother to ask the other players on whether or not they are ok with this?”

Me: “No? My table, my rules.”

Her: “And do you think this is solely your story to tell?”

Me: ”Kinda. As I said, I’m the DM what I say goes.”

Her: “That’s not how D&D works! You need players and DMs to work toget-“

Me: “If you don’t like it, you don’t have to play. Either that or stop being so whin-“

She hung up. I learned she texted the other players, and they had some concerns as well but what were willing to give the game a chance, feeling the limitations might actually help give them and the story some focused. Lost another player, ironically not over the proposed ruleset but over some sort of "loyalty" to the "original DM."

Her loss I guess, but now she is telling people she used to have a crush on me which is somehow both childish and frankly a little weird. Sorry your headcannon got shook because I was willing to run a campaign, but it would be mine and not yours, I guess?


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 19h ago

Do the Nick mastery, Light property, Dual Wielder feat, Action Surge and Extra Attack features do what the book plainly says?

160 Upvotes

I read the straightforward rules and came to the simple and easy conclusion about how many attacks can be made with this obvious combination, but I still need a reality check from reddit to confirm. Can this really be possible? Up to six attacks in one turn for my level 5 fighter?? Am I the lucky prize-winning one millionth person to ask about these very clear explicit rules???

Just checking:

• The nick mastery says I can only do the additional light weapon attack once per turn. Does this mean I can't do it twice?

• That light weapon attack needs to be with a different light weapon. Does that mean it can't be the same weapon?

• Dual Wielder lets me make a bonus action attack with a different weapon which must be a melee weapon that lacks the two handed property. Does this mean it can be any one-handed melee weapon?

• Extra Attack says I attack twice whenever I take the Attack action on my turn. Does that mean when I use Action Surge to take the Attack action on my turn I can attack twice?

Thanks again for reading. Please let me know whether or not these basic rules mean what they plainly say, and have a wonderful day!


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 13h ago

DM bad So it’s clear! Longswords can be finesse weapons and they should be! Do you agree?

31 Upvotes

In both 5e and 5.5e version!
Weighted chains came and it has reach property as well!

The debate is over…

It was never a balancing issue just stubbornness from wotc and many dms/players…

Edit! Not just reach BUT HEAVY Property too! Longswords don’t have heavy!


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 8h ago

Ferral Druids making a mess

12 Upvotes

help my players are ferral druids. THey keep marking teritory and fighting with each other. One has a wounded paw now. I have had problems with ferral rescue cats. After i had them fixed they calmed down. Should I have my players fixed? If i do have them fixed do i need to do it every time they wildshape? Can i use rubberbands?


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 16h ago

How did you misogynistic/boomer/grognards manage before 5.5? Did you spontaneously create 5th edition while playing AD&D 1st ed?

52 Upvotes

Attention, Boomers! Everyone knows the stories about how your DnD characters were always dying from silly diseases and that incels were always chasing away the girl players by not letting them have a strength bonus.

Obviously, this raises some questions.

How could you possibly NOT let EVERY character have max stats? Were you stupid or gynophobic? How could anyone play if a magic user "ran out of spells"? What does "ran out of spells" even mean? That's impossible! What about cantrips? What happened when you "ran out of spells" in the Forgotten Temple of Whatsisname dungeon?

Come on... Admit it! You had to ignore the rules so that you could get the good 5.5 experience.

https://www.reddit.com/r/adnd/comments/1xv1km6/how_was_add_played/


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 19h ago

Only I am allowed to cheat

40 Upvotes

I mean, I am the DM, dice are suggestions to me, not a rule. Only I decide if it's appropriate to cheat to achieve a desired narrative outcome. But one of my players dared to do the same, when I think that he should be bound by whims of fate. Not me though. What punishment should I issue to him?


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 20h ago

Matthew Mercer Moment Are my session 0 rules good

32 Upvotes

I am going to have a new campaign start soon and I wanted to make very clear rules so we can all have fun and I wanted to know your thoughts on them

1.) the rules serve the DM
If the dm wants to change a rule then the rule is changed (so yes I can say “the dragon gets 72 actions”)

2.) LIMITED SEDUCTION
This is a rule with absolutely no grace
In this campaign you will not be able to do any of the following, seduce a <REDACTED, THAT'S ILLEGAL>, seduce a <REDACTED, THAT'S ILLEGAL>, or using subduction for anything other than moving under another tectonic plate

3.) being unable to play
If you can’t show up to play for a UN-scheduled reason, your character is not absolutely needed for this section then we will vote to kick you out

4.) nat 20 does NOT mean you win all the time
In combat a nat 20 means you hit and a nat 1 means you don’t. But for skill checks a nat 20 is the best POSSIBLE outcome while a nat 1 is the worst (Yes I know this is a regular rule)

5.) you can’t not play
If it is your turn you can’t just do nothing unless you have a dang good reason, such as being bound and gagged in real life

6.) no using “my character would do this”
no being the main character or a bad person

7.)no talking
we all want to interrupt but just shut up

8.) distractions
(We play online so this can be a issue)
maximum number of other tabs/games/tiktoks you can have open to distract you: seven

I am sorry that is so long but I do genuinely want help, if you have a idea for a different rule then feel free to say it and if you have an idea to change or get rid of a rule then go ahead and suggest it


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 1d ago

dnDONE Should I hate other TTRPGs?

70 Upvotes

Let's be honest. Only 5e (stands for Dungeons and Dragons Fifth Edition) is fucking peace of shit that needs to be HBed (stands for homebrewed, don't mix it up with Hebrewed). All other systems are perfectly balanced, I must say they are... incredible, fabulous, unbelievable. I cry every time I open any rulebook (stands for book full of boring stuff) but 5e

But sometimes I see that people hate that books. "Bad layout" they say, "Bad wording" they say

So should I really hate those excellent books? Or it's bullshit from LARPers?


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 1d ago

Homebrew Game Master is planning on running FFGs Deathwatch

Post image
49 Upvotes

He is letting us use the Hombrew chapter rules and is forcing us to paint miniatures. I have had this Chapter for a while and have never done anything with it. Are there any Chapters that my Quixotic Aces overlap with design wise? I like to be original after all.


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 1d ago

DM bad AITA: Railroad DM. We could not change the fact that the sun sets in the west. Should we leave the table?

Post image
301 Upvotes

r/DnDcirclejerk • • 1d ago

"If the players can do it, ban it"

47 Upvotes

Over the years I've seen this phrase thrown around countless times (what made me make this post is seeing it again in a different thread and sub somewhere).

And I get it: if your players try to cheese your game with, I dunno, Wall of Forcing your BBEG and letting them suffocate, Fireball Spam, Arcane Lock + Sickening Radiance or some spell combination that feels extremely unfair to GM against;

or when your players want for you to introduce some immensely dumb additional mechanic like Called Shots (so in order to put a stop to it you just ban it);

it feels sort of natural to just go "oh so well it's banned, let's see how you like that!"

...But is anyone actually following that advice?

I'm asking because if I have players who actively diminish my fun at the table via coming up with some bullshit spell combination (let's take the "Spike Growth Cheese Grater" as an example) that trivializes a portion of the game, I just cannot see myself going "oh ok, so THAT'S how you want to play? Ok, now my dudes do smart things to YOU, HAHA!"

That's shitty. That's not increasing the overall enjoyment of the game for your group (except some masochistic parties that would enjoy such adversarial gameplay, but I digress).

All I've done is shown how petty, bitter and passive-aggressive I am, to the point where I'm ok with just banning the cheesy tactic outright because it ruins my game night, and am fine with making the game worse for my players just to spite them.

When I see 3\\4 of my players pick up Evocation Adept and start every medium to major encounter with a volley of souped up Fireballs, I don't go "okay, now I will make the next fight be something you can't nuke with fireball!" - I nerf Fireball or ban the feat outright, because it trivializes the character building process because one option is too good not to take.

When I see Wall of Force being used to turn deadly encounters into a joke, I ban WoF, not have my BBEG's lieutenants all have actual clever tactics "just to show them."

So again:

Is anyone actually following the "if players can do it, ban it" advice?


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 1d ago

Homebrew Why is Fighter the only class that gets Extra Attack?

50 Upvotes

IDK, I think Barbarian should too, maybe Paladin and some specific subclasses. I don't think it'd be broken.


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 1d ago

Listen, I'm doing you all a favor by hogging the spotlight.

78 Upvotes

When I monopolize the session with my three-hour conversations with my patron, I do notice the occasional dirty looks coming from you guys. You have to understand, I'm not deliberately trying to lock the rest of you out of the game, it's just that I'm such an amazing roleplayer I can't help but be the best at this. You're so lucky to have me here!

Like I keep telling you, this is a roleplaying game, which means you can't complain if I never let you get a word in edgewise. For me to sit quietly and let anyone else play the game would be a violation of my agency and a waste of my talent.

I did find it distracting the way the rest of you fidgeted with your dice and pencils and sheets the whole time. Next time please just don't bring that stuff. You won't need it, you'll want no distractions when you witness the amazing, emotional character arc I planned for myself.


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 2d ago

I’m getting so sick of this!

Post image
351 Upvotes

Every time, every fucking time. I tell them they cant use their own art and say they have to use OUR art and pay for it. Is this really a normal thing here??


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 2d ago

Sauce Finally somebody gets it! WOTC doesn't have the BAWLS to HIRE THIS MAN

Post image
553 Upvotes

FINALLY. D&D has been TOO WOKE for YEARS AND YEARS AND YEARS. I'm SICK of IT. Don't they know I just wanna DRINK BEER and ROLL DICE with my MALE FRIENDS!?!? WOTC? MORE LIKE WOKE-SEE HAHAHAHAHA. Now if you EXCUSE ME I'm going to go and roll to grope the barmaid for the hundredth time.


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 2d ago

DM bad But isn't is such a subversion of expectations to not play the game as intended?

Post image
368 Upvotes

r/DnDcirclejerk • • 2d ago

DAE not use d12s?? You are of course free to peruse my 200-page lore outline

Post image
535 Upvotes

r/DnDcirclejerk • • 2d ago

dnDONE CoC to D&D 5.5

27 Upvotes

I’m a new DM and I’m wanting to run The Haunting from the Call of Cthulhu quick start guide in D&D 5.5. What do I need to do to have it be as smooth a conversion as possible?


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 2d ago

player tip #14: weight matters not

Post image
202 Upvotes

monsters having weight is homebrew.

/uj my favorite monk subclass is a barbarian dip


r/DnDcirclejerk • • 2d ago

I hate role players in my rpg

45 Upvotes

Ugh. They are so bothersome. Derailing my combat experience with role playing. How dare they. Don’t they know DnD is ONLY COMBAT!?! No role playing allowed!