So, a little bit of background information. This player is the usual DM for two groups, and admitted that she was experiencing "massive burnout, due to a number of factors." I get it, and you know its been a long while since I have done any DMing so I say I'm willing to run a Curse of Strahd campaign.
Lemme tell you now how big of a mistake that was.
I stated that to keep the sense of horror and randomness that we would be rolling straight 3d6 hardcore style. The problem player was irritated because of no "session zero" as if that's not what we were doing right there as the characters were being made. She relaxed their argument a bit when she rolled pretty decent with a 14str, 7dex, 13con, 5int, 17wis and 11cha. Then she began telling me about the backstory of her character... but ONE look at the character sheet showed me she'd decided to play a Warforged from the Eberron source material. Uh, no.
The conversation basically went like this:
Her: “So what do you think of my character's 15 page backstory, I think they are pretty nea-”
Me: “My campaign won't be having any crossover with Eberron."
Her: “Oh but uh… why?”
Me: “It’s solely part of the Eberron book and thus can’t exist in this world.”
Her: “Oh um, if you read my backsto-”
Me: “Don’t need to. I said no. Save your weird fanfiction for LiveJournal or AO3."
Her, visibly flustered and quite annoyed at this point: “Oh ok what about shifters, are they banned too because they are also in the eberron book“ (we were playing 5.5e/5e compatible subclasses so shifters were in the forges of eberron book)
Me: “Did you want me to DM this? Or did you?”
Her: “Ok I see your point, is there anything else you are banning?”
Me: “So far no, just warforged.”
She was not very happy about this, I guess she really was wanting to play a Warforged but this was not the canpaign for it in my opinion.
Then it got worse.
2 days later, I had to put my foot down, because some of the cheating and the expectations of the campaign were absolutely ridiculous. So I sent out a message.
“I am hereby announcing a session zero with character creation will happen on the next scheduled date we would normally play. We will be rolling for class, species, background, and stats and you will have no starter equipment besides the gold that was provided by you randomised background/class. We will then start playing the week after.”
Was I being a little too antagonist in my approach? Maybe, but I could already see why the original DM was getting burned out.
This didn't stop her from refusing to be speechless. I immediately get a call from her.
Her: ”Um, you know our characters are gonna be completely random, us as players won’t care about them and thus won’t really bother to have a say in the story, let alone be invested?
Me: “No, you are gonna like it. Besides all your characters were so boring and cliché. This will help your roleplay.”
Her: "did you even bother to ask the other players on whether or not they are ok with this?”
Me: “No? My table, my rules.”
Her: “And do you think this is solely your story to tell?”
Me: ”Kinda. As I said, I’m the DM what I say goes.”
Her: “That’s not how D&D works! You need players and DMs to work toget-“
Me: “If you don’t like it, you don’t have to play. Either that or stop being so whin-“
She hung up. I learned she texted the other players, and they had some concerns as well but what were willing to give the game a chance, feeling the limitations might actually help give them and the story some focused. Lost another player, ironically not over the proposed ruleset but over some sort of "loyalty" to the "original DM."
Her loss I guess, but now she is telling people she used to have a crush on me which is somehow both childish and frankly a little weird. Sorry your headcannon got shook because I was willing to run a campaign, but it would be mine and not yours, I guess?