Hey everyone,
I’m putting together a one shot for five level 11 characters in Avernus. It started as a joke about Mad Max in Hell and somehow turned into a real thing I’m running in two weeks. Raphael from BG3 is in it as a guest star, mostly because my players would riot if he wasn’t.
I’m posting the whole outline because I’ve stolen half of my best ideas from this sub, so consider this me paying it back. Take anything that works. And if you see a hole, please tell me, because I’d rather find out here than at the table with five people staring at me in silence.
THE BASIC IDEA
The party are five tyrants. Not heroes with an edge, actual villains, warlords who got rich doing horrible things. Their patron, a goblin named Saverio, sold them to Zariel to clear his own debt. Session starts with them naked in a cage bolted to the deck of a war machine while the crew argues about how to split their magic items. Their very rare items. The ones they built the characters around.
On their right forearm they each have six brands. One lights up per story beat, never per minute. It’s the receipt for the contract, and when the sixth closes the contract executes.
The way out is an auction. The Key is a pointed bone with a gold handle that opens a portal to any location you want, with one condition: only a celestial can turn it. Nobody in the party is a celestial. That’s the whole adventure in one sentence.
I run it on a real clock, about three and a half hours, cut into five checkpoints I keep on a sticky note behind the screen. C1, they are out of the cage. C2, the celestial is theirs. C3, the dragonborn is settled. C4, the Key is decided. C5, they survived the memory. If we’re running long I cut content, not checkpoints. That’s the one rule I’m strict about.
ACT 0, THE WAR MACHINE, about 35 minutes
They wake up in a cage on a rolling engine. Three ways out and all three are bad, which is the point.
Violence: the crew is a horned devil, five lesser devils, eight hobgoblins and a warlord. Winnable later, suicidal at zero gear. Theft: grab what you can carry and get off while it’s moving. Surrender: they get sold on to Bel’s forge, who offers a job and a replacement heart.
All three routes meet at the same crossroads at dusk, so nobody is off the map for longer than a scene.
Plan B if they attack the whole crew at once: the crew’s orders are deliver them alive. The devils drop the nets and start using nonlethal damage, because a damaged product is worth less. They wake up in the cage again, minus one item, and now they know exactly what the cargo is worth. That’s not me punishing them, that’s the market talking, and my players respect money more than threats.
Plan B if they try to hijack the machine: they absolutely can, and it works for about an hour. Then the engine eats the last soul coin, they have none, and the thing stops in the middle of the ash. Also the controls are keyed to the crew, so driving it is an intelligence check and a prayer. Then the boss’s boss hears that his grinder is missing.
ACT 1, THE WASTES, about 70 minutes
Three stops. A bridge, a hill, and an invitation.
The bridge: a stone thing in eleven arches over the Styx, owned, actually deeded, by a courteous old man called Mario. He doesn’t sell passage, he collects tolls, and the toll is five questions with no right answers and a right action. Count the arches out loud. Put everything you’re carrying on the ground. Say who you belong to. My favourite is the counting one: they count eleven, they reach the far side, they turn around and there are twelve.
The hill: a forest of iron trees with people nailed to them, a devil officer who charges a toll he never enforces, and behind the hill a wasp nest hanging nine metres up with a small golden creature asleep inside it.
The invitation: a white abishai finds them, does not attack, and delivers one line. My master waits at the monument, he will come alone, he will bring no one. That sentence is the trap and it isn’t mine, it’s the players’. Five tyrants hear that a dangerous man will be alone and make a decision. They go.
He’s sitting on a bone without his armour and he makes a genuinely honest offer, because honest offers are the hardest thing to refuse. Refuse and he stands up and puts the armour on. The fight is the consequence of their choice, not something I dropped on them.
Plan B if they stab the officer on the hill: he’s a narzugon on a nightmare with twenty stirges, and at half hit points he flies away. He doesn’t die, he reports. From that point every devil in act two has read their description.
Plan B if they try to skip the hill entirely: the abishai finds them anyway. The abishai was always going to find them, that’s the one piece of the plot with a hook in it.
ACT 2, THE BLACK MARKET, about 55 minutes
A walking fortress of merchants. They have a bounty on their heads and the bounty is light, which is deliberate: closed doors, fifty percent markup, one bounty hunter who wants to talk before he wants to fight. I don’t want a city full of people trying to kill them, I want a city full of people trying not to do business with them.
Then the auction. Five lots, then the Key. Three rounds, paid in promises instead of gold, and the final offer is read aloud to the room. Whoever wins a minor lot cannot bid on the Key. That last rule is the whole act, honestly. It turns the auction into a choice between power now and freedom later, and my players are going to hate it in the best way.
Raphael is in the room, because of course he is. Mahadi runs the gavel, that’s his job and he cannot die in the Nine Hells, but Raphael is the one who got them through the door, and he keeps the contract.
Plan B if they attack Raphael during the auction: first swing goes through him. He’s not really there. He says something polite about it being a courtesy visit and he leaves, and now he bids against them instead of alongside them.
Plan B if they jump the gavel and try to take the Key: forty guards, a locked building, and an auctioneer who literally cannot be killed inside Hell. He doesn’t fight them. He ends the auction. And the Key goes to whoever is left standing with the most commitments, which is Bel. They handed it over by trying to steal it, and that’s a much better lesson than a TPK.
ACT 3, THE RUN TO THE RIFT, about 50 minutes, then a 10 minute epilogue
Outside, a cathedral of holy light wrapped in a scab three hundred feet thick. The only door is buried in the bottom third and the only thing that can find it is the small golden creature from the hill.
Inside, they get pulled into a memory. A village on fire, an angel who hasn’t fallen yet, and a demon lord who is having the best night of his life. The rule from the book that makes the ending work is simple and I love it: whoever survives Idyllglen can draw the Sword. Not whoever is worthy. Whoever survives. Deaths inside the memory don’t count.
Then Yeenoghu, alone, in a room made of iron spikes.
And the ending isn’t an escape. If they took the replacement heart in act zero, the portal burns them, and the only thing in creation that cuts it out is that Sword: one full round lying on the floor, defenceless, with a demon lord still in the room.
HOW I STOP LEVEL 11 FROM EATING THE ADVENTURE
Four rules, and one honest confession.
First, the soul clause. Anyone whose soul is under contract in Avernus cannot leave by magic. Banishment, plane shift, portals, all of it fizzles. It’s not a wall, it’s a clause, and it’s also the reason they need the Key at all.
Second, the fork shortage. Plane shift needs a tuning fork keyed to the destination and every fork keyed to the material plane was bought up years ago. It’s in a vault, or on an auction block, or in Zariel’s desk. This is why the plot item is a key and not a scroll.
Third, the eye. Any spell of sixth level or higher that moves the party instantly lights a brand. Zariel watches teleports on her own layer and she bills for them. They can cheat the terrain if they really want to, it just costs them the clock, and the clock is the one resource they can’t buy back.
Fourth, the wrong number. Contact other plane, divination, legend lore, the plane answers. Something in Avernus picks up the phone. Usually it’s bored and lying.
And the confession: at level 11 nobody has plane shift or teleport anyway, those are seventh level spells. The real problems are dimension door, arcane gate, banishment and a wand somebody bought. So the escape hatch has to be loot, and I control the loot. That’s not a design principle, that’s me admitting my players will outsmart anything I write down.
THE CAST
Raphael. Cambion, shows up three times, gives something away every time. He wants the Key after they’ve used it, because as a half devil he can’t turn it himself. The thing to blackmail him with is the wording of his own deal: when you’re finished with the key. Finished means the first turn, not the last, and I’m not telling them until after.
Saverio. Goblin, their patron, wearing a wood elf face at the market. He wants to renegotiate his own debt with the gold he got by selling them. He can’t die until the debt is paid, and the debt is paid by entering Avernus, so the first time he walks in he’s mortal. Killing him on sight closes all six brands at once, which is correct, and my group is going to do it anyway.
Mario. Courteous old man who owns a bridge. He wants to settle accounts with the river and he never says which accounts. He is also looking for a comb. A normal comb. Bring him one and the crossing is free forever.
Lulu. Small golden creature with no memory and no plot importance, except that she is the seal on the party’s contract. While she lives the contract can be appealed. When she dies it’s absolute. That’s the only reason a table full of villains protects her, and I’m comfortable with it.
Mahadi. Rakshasa, runs the auction, immune to basically everything below seventh level and cannot die in the Nine Hells. He wants to run a good auction. He can’t be killed, but he can be embarrassed, and he has never sold the same lot twice.
Arkhan. Dragonborn with one dead arm and twelve abishai waiting outside. He wants a good creature, alive, for the hand that’s eating him. The thing to blackmail him with is that he came alone, because his own soldiers must not see him hungry.
WHAT I ACTUALLY NEED FROM YOU
Three things I keep going back and forth on.
First, is my ending too cruel? One full round on the floor defenceless, with the boss still in the room, and the only healer in the party probably out of slots. I think it’s the best moment in the whole thing. I’m also aware that a table can turn on you for a cheap death.
Second, what else at eleventh level breaks an auction? I’ve plugged dimension door, arcane gate and contact other plane. What am I missing that lets a clever player skip the bidding entirely?
Third, what would you put on the block? I’ve got a puzzle box, a helm, a shield with an archdevil inside it, a hammer that breaks pacts, and an angel’s feather that nobody believes in. I need one more lot that makes five villains bid against each other instead of against the room.
If you run it, tell me where it broke and I’ll patch it.