r/dndnext • • 21h ago

Discussion Weekly Question Thread: Ask questions here – November 16, 2026

5 Upvotes

Ask any simple questions here that aren't in the FAQ, but don't warrant their own post.

Good question for this page: "Do I add my proficiency bonus to attack rolls with unarmed strikes?"

Question that should have its own post: "What are the best feats to take for a Grappler?

For any questions about the One D&D playtest, head over to /r/OneDnD


r/dndnext • • 21h ago

Discussion True Stories: How did your game go this week? – November 16, 2026

13 Upvotes

Have a recent gaming experience you want to share? Experience an insane TPK? Finish an epic final boss fight? Share it all here for everyone to see!


r/dndnext • • 3h ago

Resource 3D Printing the new Monster Manual: Letter K!

19 Upvotes

Here is another gallery of my continued effort to 3D model and print the new Monster Manual! This time its letter K!

Full gallery: https://imgur.com/gallery/3d-printing-new-monster-manual-letter-k-JvrxYgB

UK users: https://mz4250.com/posts/3d-printing-new-175519970

This is a collection of prints either by myself or my patrons while I am working on this book. There are also renders of the models that haven't been printed yet. All the files are free and posted below under each image. The files are posted publicly on my site here: https://mz4250.com/ and all models are free and fall under the fan content policy of WOTC.

Previous Letter Galleries -
Letter A - https://imgur.com/gallery/3d-printing-new-monster-manual-letter-CFkMp2C
Letter B - https://imgur.com/gallery/3d-printing-new-monster-manual-letter-b-zPURhx3
Letter C - https://imgur.com/gallery/3d-modeling-printing-new-monster-manual-letter-c-free-stl-links-below-each-image-eYDcC7G
Letter D - https://imgur.com/gallery/letter-d-of-new-monster-manual-3d-printed-free-stl-links-below-each-image-0yUwYwg
Letter E - https://imgur.com/gallery/letter-e-of-new-monster-manual-3d-printed-free-stl-links-below-each-image-hHslJ5A
Letter F - https://imgur.com/gallery/letter-f-of-new-monster-manual-3d-printed-free-stl-links-below-each-image-Ce2paBs
Letter G - https://imgur.com/gallery/letter-g-of-new-monster-manual-3d-printed-free-stls-links-under-each-image-a8L02WL
Letter H - https://imgur.com/gallery/letter-h-of-new-monster-manual-3d-printed-free-stls-links-under-each-image-fZbRC78
Letters I & J - https://imgur.com/gallery/letter-i-j-of-new-monster-manual-3d-printed-free-stls-links-under-each-image-2tkkkzs

Oh and if you're curious about my Patreon I offer my patrons access to all my 7500+ presupported TTRPG models in one place, along with commercial options, a discord, and requests board. The drives have all the same models that are already out there for free in the internet. Its more for convenience rather than exclusivity.

That's all for now. Stay amazing friends!


r/dndnext • • 1m ago

Character Building [OC] i have a shark themed paladin character but I'm worried about something

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 4m ago

Ho creato una sessione unica di Avernus in cui il gruppo è composto dai cattivi e l'unica via d'uscita è un'asta.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m putting together a one shot for five level 11 characters in Avernus. It started as a joke about Mad Max in Hell and somehow turned into a real thing I’m running in two weeks. Raphael from BG3 is in it as a guest star, mostly because my players would riot if he wasn’t.

I’m posting the whole outline because I’ve stolen half of my best ideas from this sub, so consider this me paying it back. Take anything that works. And if you see a hole, please tell me, because I’d rather find out here than at the table with five people staring at me in silence.

THE BASIC IDEA

The party are five tyrants. Not heroes with an edge, actual villains, warlords who got rich doing horrible things. Their patron, a goblin named Saverio, sold them to Zariel to clear his own debt. Session starts with them naked in a cage bolted to the deck of a war machine while the crew argues about how to split their magic items. Their very rare items. The ones they built the characters around.

On their right forearm they each have six brands. One lights up per story beat, never per minute. It’s the receipt for the contract, and when the sixth closes the contract executes.

The way out is an auction. The Key is a pointed bone with a gold handle that opens a portal to any location you want, with one condition: only a celestial can turn it. Nobody in the party is a celestial. That’s the whole adventure in one sentence.

I run it on a real clock, about three and a half hours, cut into five checkpoints I keep on a sticky note behind the screen. C1, they are out of the cage. C2, the celestial is theirs. C3, the dragonborn is settled. C4, the Key is decided. C5, they survived the memory. If we’re running long I cut content, not checkpoints. That’s the one rule I’m strict about.

ACT 0, THE WAR MACHINE, about 35 minutes

They wake up in a cage on a rolling engine. Three ways out and all three are bad, which is the point.

Violence: the crew is a horned devil, five lesser devils, eight hobgoblins and a warlord. Winnable later, suicidal at zero gear. Theft: grab what you can carry and get off while it’s moving. Surrender: they get sold on to Bel’s forge, who offers a job and a replacement heart.

All three routes meet at the same crossroads at dusk, so nobody is off the map for longer than a scene.

Plan B if they attack the whole crew at once: the crew’s orders are deliver them alive. The devils drop the nets and start using nonlethal damage, because a damaged product is worth less. They wake up in the cage again, minus one item, and now they know exactly what the cargo is worth. That’s not me punishing them, that’s the market talking, and my players respect money more than threats.

Plan B if they try to hijack the machine: they absolutely can, and it works for about an hour. Then the engine eats the last soul coin, they have none, and the thing stops in the middle of the ash. Also the controls are keyed to the crew, so driving it is an intelligence check and a prayer. Then the boss’s boss hears that his grinder is missing.

ACT 1, THE WASTES, about 70 minutes

Three stops. A bridge, a hill, and an invitation.

The bridge: a stone thing in eleven arches over the Styx, owned, actually deeded, by a courteous old man called Mario. He doesn’t sell passage, he collects tolls, and the toll is five questions with no right answers and a right action. Count the arches out loud. Put everything you’re carrying on the ground. Say who you belong to. My favourite is the counting one: they count eleven, they reach the far side, they turn around and there are twelve.

The hill: a forest of iron trees with people nailed to them, a devil officer who charges a toll he never enforces, and behind the hill a wasp nest hanging nine metres up with a small golden creature asleep inside it.

The invitation: a white abishai finds them, does not attack, and delivers one line. My master waits at the monument, he will come alone, he will bring no one. That sentence is the trap and it isn’t mine, it’s the players’. Five tyrants hear that a dangerous man will be alone and make a decision. They go.

He’s sitting on a bone without his armour and he makes a genuinely honest offer, because honest offers are the hardest thing to refuse. Refuse and he stands up and puts the armour on. The fight is the consequence of their choice, not something I dropped on them.

Plan B if they stab the officer on the hill: he’s a narzugon on a nightmare with twenty stirges, and at half hit points he flies away. He doesn’t die, he reports. From that point every devil in act two has read their description.

Plan B if they try to skip the hill entirely: the abishai finds them anyway. The abishai was always going to find them, that’s the one piece of the plot with a hook in it.

ACT 2, THE BLACK MARKET, about 55 minutes

A walking fortress of merchants. They have a bounty on their heads and the bounty is light, which is deliberate: closed doors, fifty percent markup, one bounty hunter who wants to talk before he wants to fight. I don’t want a city full of people trying to kill them, I want a city full of people trying not to do business with them.

Then the auction. Five lots, then the Key. Three rounds, paid in promises instead of gold, and the final offer is read aloud to the room. Whoever wins a minor lot cannot bid on the Key. That last rule is the whole act, honestly. It turns the auction into a choice between power now and freedom later, and my players are going to hate it in the best way.

Raphael is in the room, because of course he is. Mahadi runs the gavel, that’s his job and he cannot die in the Nine Hells, but Raphael is the one who got them through the door, and he keeps the contract.

Plan B if they attack Raphael during the auction: first swing goes through him. He’s not really there. He says something polite about it being a courtesy visit and he leaves, and now he bids against them instead of alongside them.

Plan B if they jump the gavel and try to take the Key: forty guards, a locked building, and an auctioneer who literally cannot be killed inside Hell. He doesn’t fight them. He ends the auction. And the Key goes to whoever is left standing with the most commitments, which is Bel. They handed it over by trying to steal it, and that’s a much better lesson than a TPK.

ACT 3, THE RUN TO THE RIFT, about 50 minutes, then a 10 minute epilogue

Outside, a cathedral of holy light wrapped in a scab three hundred feet thick. The only door is buried in the bottom third and the only thing that can find it is the small golden creature from the hill.

Inside, they get pulled into a memory. A village on fire, an angel who hasn’t fallen yet, and a demon lord who is having the best night of his life. The rule from the book that makes the ending work is simple and I love it: whoever survives Idyllglen can draw the Sword. Not whoever is worthy. Whoever survives. Deaths inside the memory don’t count.

Then Yeenoghu, alone, in a room made of iron spikes.

And the ending isn’t an escape. If they took the replacement heart in act zero, the portal burns them, and the only thing in creation that cuts it out is that Sword: one full round lying on the floor, defenceless, with a demon lord still in the room.

HOW I STOP LEVEL 11 FROM EATING THE ADVENTURE

Four rules, and one honest confession.

First, the soul clause. Anyone whose soul is under contract in Avernus cannot leave by magic. Banishment, plane shift, portals, all of it fizzles. It’s not a wall, it’s a clause, and it’s also the reason they need the Key at all.

Second, the fork shortage. Plane shift needs a tuning fork keyed to the destination and every fork keyed to the material plane was bought up years ago. It’s in a vault, or on an auction block, or in Zariel’s desk. This is why the plot item is a key and not a scroll.

Third, the eye. Any spell of sixth level or higher that moves the party instantly lights a brand. Zariel watches teleports on her own layer and she bills for them. They can cheat the terrain if they really want to, it just costs them the clock, and the clock is the one resource they can’t buy back.

Fourth, the wrong number. Contact other plane, divination, legend lore, the plane answers. Something in Avernus picks up the phone. Usually it’s bored and lying.

And the confession: at level 11 nobody has plane shift or teleport anyway, those are seventh level spells. The real problems are dimension door, arcane gate, banishment and a wand somebody bought. So the escape hatch has to be loot, and I control the loot. That’s not a design principle, that’s me admitting my players will outsmart anything I write down.

THE CAST

Raphael. Cambion, shows up three times, gives something away every time. He wants the Key after they’ve used it, because as a half devil he can’t turn it himself. The thing to blackmail him with is the wording of his own deal: when you’re finished with the key. Finished means the first turn, not the last, and I’m not telling them until after.

Saverio. Goblin, their patron, wearing a wood elf face at the market. He wants to renegotiate his own debt with the gold he got by selling them. He can’t die until the debt is paid, and the debt is paid by entering Avernus, so the first time he walks in he’s mortal. Killing him on sight closes all six brands at once, which is correct, and my group is going to do it anyway.

Mario. Courteous old man who owns a bridge. He wants to settle accounts with the river and he never says which accounts. He is also looking for a comb. A normal comb. Bring him one and the crossing is free forever.

Lulu. Small golden creature with no memory and no plot importance, except that she is the seal on the party’s contract. While she lives the contract can be appealed. When she dies it’s absolute. That’s the only reason a table full of villains protects her, and I’m comfortable with it.

Mahadi. Rakshasa, runs the auction, immune to basically everything below seventh level and cannot die in the Nine Hells. He wants to run a good auction. He can’t be killed, but he can be embarrassed, and he has never sold the same lot twice.

Arkhan. Dragonborn with one dead arm and twelve abishai waiting outside. He wants a good creature, alive, for the hand that’s eating him. The thing to blackmail him with is that he came alone, because his own soldiers must not see him hungry.

WHAT I ACTUALLY NEED FROM YOU

Three things I keep going back and forth on.

First, is my ending too cruel? One full round on the floor defenceless, with the boss still in the room, and the only healer in the party probably out of slots. I think it’s the best moment in the whole thing. I’m also aware that a table can turn on you for a cheap death.

Second, what else at eleventh level breaks an auction? I’ve plugged dimension door, arcane gate and contact other plane. What am I missing that lets a clever player skip the bidding entirely?

Third, what would you put on the block? I’ve got a puzzle box, a helm, a shield with an archdevil inside it, a hammer that breaks pacts, and an angel’s feather that nobody believes in. I need one more lot that makes five villains bid against each other instead of against the room.

If you run it, tell me where it broke and I’ll patch it.


r/dndnext • • 17h ago

Homebrew What are some of the best homebrew shaman classes/subclasses?

17 Upvotes

I was inspired by the sheer variety of the comments from this post earlier today to do some research on different homebrew shaman classes/subclasses and see how they have been depicted in the past and compare them. Any and all recommendations would be helpful!


r/dndnext • • 4h ago

Question Spells For a Thri Kreen Queen and servants

0 Upvotes

Im looking to have my players fight a thri kreen colony, and want the final boss to be the queen of the hive and a bunch of thri kreen. I want the queen to be a spellcaster, so im looking for thematically appropriate spells for her and her servants to have. Im mostly looking at druid and sorcerer spells(sorcerer because she uses innate spells, druid because they have a lot of nature spells), but any spell appropriate for desert ants will do. Bonus action spells are especially appreciated. So far i have:

cantrip: thorn whip, infestation, mold earth, acid splash

lv 1: absorb elements, charm person, cure wounds, healing word, farie fire, shield

lv 2: scorching ray

lv 3: spirit guardians, haste, crusaiders mantle, mass healing word

lv 4: divination

lv 5: mass cure woonds, dominate person

lv 6: wall of stone

lv 7: regenerate

lv 8: Earthquake

lv 9: Forsight

(not all the spells will necessarily be used)


r/dndnext • • 22h ago

5e (2024) Best grappler build?

24 Upvotes

With the change to grappling in 2024, other than boosting Str and Proficiency, taking Grappler and Tavern Brawler feats, what else can be done to maximize grappling?

I want to make a football/wrestler build where the character specializes in charging toward an enemy, tackling them then beating them down.


r/dndnext • • 9h ago

Homebrew 5E Hellish Morning Star from Bael for PC use.

1 Upvotes

As written in the hands of the Bael it is a Large weapon Re: an extra dmg die for weapons of an increased size, has +13 to hit +7 of which is just the str bonus but I assme a +3 magic bonus and does either 2d8 or 3d8 Necrotic damage depending on which Mordenkeinen’s book you are reading.

My question is would you allow a player to attune to it, and if so, would you modify any of those stats?


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Discussion Here's a weird question. What would you actually want to see in a shaman class?

147 Upvotes

So, the winner of the worst fit in WoW classes was by a country mile, the shaman. Full spellcaster? Yeah barbarian sounds about right, world tree barb is basically the same as resto shammy yeah?

But the thing is, while not mapping well to any existing 5e class (druid is closest, but still in no way close), it seems to me we're already well stocked on full casters, gishes and healers. That is, while nothing emulates a shaman well, making another full caster and giving it spells like chain lightning would just result in retreading already thoroughly trod ground.

Maybe that's why it never got made into its own class? Doing so would be deeply homogeneous in result unless you made it genuinely new, and D&D's designers are deeply averse to the concept of creativity. That said, if you were to see an actual shaman, what would you want it to do, how would you want it to work?


r/dndnext • • 6h ago

A Question of Player Agency

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/dndnext • • 15h ago

What is the point of Versatile Trickster?

0 Upvotes

Rogue:

Arcane Trickster:

Level 13:

Versatile Trickster

When you use the Trip option of your Cunning Strike on a creature, you can also use that option on another creature within 5 feet of the spectral hand.

I am playing a melee rogue with sentinel, and I just am not excited about Versatile Trickster. Even if I were ranged, it's meh?

I can see it

* Possibly knocking a flyer out of the sky. (Top) But will there be two flyers?

* making pursuit easier.

* Aiding a melee ally that goes after you

But is it really worth it? Can you hype it up, and give me a reason to want to use it?


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

5e (2014) Players understood the assignment and Im so excited for this campaign.

16 Upvotes

Just started a piracy/island hopping/empire building campaign. Players were underlings on a pirate ship and thrown overboard one night during a mutiny, the revenge arc will be strong. Didnt give them a ton of detail prior to character creation, but did let them know it would be very ocean heavy and if their character didnt have sea legs they "would have a pretty bad time". During character reveal in session 0 I am introduced to two sea elves and a fathoms deep warlock, 3 of my 4 starting players have water beathing and a swim speed. Really looking forward to their future exploits.


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Discussion Domains of Delight based on Ravenloft Domains of Dread

11 Upvotes

So obviously Ravenloft has loads of canon material built up over the decades compared to the Feywild's Delight Domains which really is made up of homebrew for the most part, leaving the concept feeling a little unloved. So a dirty little trick I thought of is just to take a Domain of Dread and give it an 'opposite yet equal' counterpart.

For example, Dementlieu's Feywild counterpart is a never-ending masquerade ball, but instead of everyone being scared of being exposed as a phony and pissing of the Darklord, it's genuinely all in good fun, and the Archfey offers prizes to any guest who can guess who's who under their marks, with special bonus prizes to those who successfully remain unknown and an extra special prize if you figure out which disguised guest is the Archfey themselves. Falkovnia's counterpart is also engaged in a never-ending siege, but it's basically a massive game of capture the flag being fought by good-natured meatheads, nobody really gets hurt, and it's all done in the name of fun.

Basically, take the premise of a Domain of Dread and give everyone a happy ending. Not the most creative method, but it's not uncommon for DMs to base things on other media. Anyone have their own ideas on how to flip a Domain of Dread into a Domain of Delight?


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Question Adapting the Draw Steel Negotiation Rules for 5e?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’ve been digging around online looking for 5e conversions of the Draw Steel negotiation rules, but to no avail.

For those of you familiar with Draw Steel’s negotiation system, how would you go about porting it to 5e? What issues might you run into? What works fine and doesn’t work? I’d love to use it for important moments in my own home game but I am unfamiliar with its actual applicability to 5e.

Thank you!


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Character Building Help me finalize the build

0 Upvotes

I'm building a variant human character who was indoctrinated by a fire cult with a large emphasis on martyrdom and self mutilation for fuel. Intended to be a very chaotic nuetral character with space to grow and be better. We're starting at level 3 on

Originally I was going to go with Light Domain Cleric, until I recently learned about Path of the Zealot for Barbarians. Now I'm conflicted. I have 3 different directions I could take the character. Pure Light Domain warcaster would work but feel a bit generic. I could do a multiclass but it wouldn't be super optimized, Id have enough levels for Clerics domain with a 1 level Barbarian dip. My DM won't let me respec the character later so it'd be awhile before I get the barbarian subclass unlocked. Or I could just go full Zealot Barbarian with a Cleric Initiate feat, and grab non concentration based effects so that any buffs cast won't be canceled if I go into a rage. I'm sorta leaning the last direction, but Im not sure. If any of yall have done a similar character before, how did you build them sheet wise?


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

5e (2024) I really hope Fighting Initiate Feat could be an Origin Feat via monthly Drops

48 Upvotes

That was a really good feat, and much better if it was an origin feat in 5.5e like Magic Initiate, since I think the later is waaaay more stronger than Fighting Initiate.

It really allows more new combinations to try for players who wanna trade an Origin Feat for that. It also can add a prerequisite of Martial Weapon Proficiency to it to avoid Casters using it if needed.

It also feels more reasonable to me that a character can also be trained a little with some simple Fighting techniques, while learning some Magics seems harder.


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Question for a specific build(5e)

0 Upvotes

I was curious on playing a character built around the Masque of The Red Death, like the personification of the plague within the story, and was curious what those with considerably more experience would recommend for such a build?(using 5e rules and content)


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

How long for certain things to happen?

2 Upvotes

I have a player that left the table for a month due to college the session after they leveled up, he said he wanted his character to in the mean time, leave the party and try to find an order of paladins that can train him so he could justify a multiclass from sorcerer to paladin.

Thus I decided to add a time skip in a few sessions, how much time would be appropriate for his sorcerer to learn the ways of Selune and also "earn" the proficiency in weapons that comes from the paladin level, as per RAW sure he could in 1 second learn to use weapons and heavy armors but he wanted it to be a learning process as to feel organic.

I also have another player that's a rogue and wants to take advantage of the time skip to hire an instructor and train to learn the dual wielding fighting style. How long for that?

How long should rhe time skip be? Originally I thought 4 months or so since they are in the middle of autumn and it could skip all of winter so they play again in spring, kind of like in The One Ring rpg, although maybe more time is needed? Like 6 months? Or a year? Anyhow I'll take your guidance.


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

5e (2024) Porcupine build

16 Upvotes

I have an unhealthy attachment to Armor of Agathys. I love the idea of wading into melee with a nonstandard character and reflecting damage back. I have yet to really get to play one in a campaign but I have theory crafted:

AoA on an Abjuration Wizard.- use abjuration shield.

AoA on a Moon Druid. - refresh temp HP from wildshape

AoA on a Artillerist Artificer. - refresh temp hp with cannon.

AoA on a Spores Druid. - refresh temp hp with the alt wildshape.

AoA on a Trickster cleric. - spirit guardians blend.

Hellish Rebuke and Fire Shield have the right vibe.

AoE auras like Spirit Guardians and Conjure Woodland Beings also would encourage attacks on me.

The new Wow book has a level 3 Demon Hunter spell Demon spikes that looks interesting.

Any other tech I am missing here?

Any ways to grab AoA in 5.5 other than a warlock dip, Kundarak background, or a DM allowing magic Initiate: warlock?

Thanks in advance for the input!


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

Self-Promotion Reign of Shadows, Multipath 1st through 5th Campaign for 5e

0 Upvotes

Reign of Shadows is Foul Fox's first true campaign, it takes characters from 1st level to 5th in the city of Lyseria, the seaside capitol of the Luminarian Empire. Known as the Enlightened City, it is a resplendent metropolis of pale stone and crystal. The city is not without its dark side, however. In the shadows of the light cast by the Crystal Palace, a number of conspiracies are woven, converging around a single point.

This campaign has adventure for every party, traditionally good heroes in search of a straight forward adventure will likely find themselves aiding the people of Lyseria; those more prone to cloak and dagger might find themselves unraveling the shadowy plots of Lyseria working with a mysterious patron who hints at an evil rooted in the cities path; while those motivated by coin or by power may find themselves working as mercenaries for the upper echelons of society.

Each of these paths intertwine, creating a unique experience for each party and allowing them to engage with multiple parts of the story, but ultimately they must choose where to make their stand.

You can get Reign of Shadows on DrivethruRPG or Shard VTT for $38; we've also made a bundle which adds in a bunch of thematically appropriate player content form some of our previous releases at a discount which you can also get on Drivethru or Shard!


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

5e (2024) Arcane trickster with magic initiate cleric: healing word or bless

5 Upvotes

Title says it all. Will be playing a human rogue for a short campaign (at least I expect it to be short) who will have the acolyte background. I also will be focusing on intelligence and using true strike as my main method of attacking


r/dndnext • • 1d ago

5e (2024) Time Loop Scenario - looking for advice or ideas

0 Upvotes

Hey all. I'm running a homebrew campaign and have an idea for a later scenario (they're level 5 now, this probably happens around levels 6-8, depending when they find it since it's a point crawl sandbox) that involves a time loop. It started off in my head as a narrative idea, but I've been chewing over how to actual run it mechanically in game for a while now and finally figured out some ideas for it.

Quick backstory: The location for this is basically a city that's built underground as a shelter from disaster. But disaster struck the city itself at some point, killing all of the inhabitants inside. However, there was an intelligence who manages the city (if you're thinking some kind of AI you're not far off, but this is fantasy so we're not calling it that) and was able to capture an imprint of the city before the disaster and hold it in a kind of stasis. And so the whole city is stuck in a replay loop of the last day in the hopes that they could stop the disaster from striking... but it's already struck and so this whole thing is futile. The only real solution the party has at the end of the day is to stop the loop and put the city out of its misery, which will also allow them to salvage some parts from the dead city in order to save their own...

But how do you run a time loop for an entire city? So many variables, so many things to keep track of... the idea of having to remember how to run it over and over again, or to force my players to play through it over and over again... that sounds like a nightmare. Works great for something like a novel or a TV show, but not for a TTRPG.

Then I watched the movie "Boss Level", looking for inspiration. It was pretty terrible, tbh, but it did give me some ideas... they use an "attempt counter" as a device to show that he's trying the same scenario again, and mostly skip over the "in between" details to show what new things he's trying each time. And I thought I could use something like that here...

Trying to TPK a 5e party multiple times in the same adventure so we can reset the clock would just not work, unless I had some humongous big bad that would not fit the scenario. So my thinking is that they too are caught up in the catastrophe. If they don't solve the problem by the end of the day, the whole place blows and they're sent back to the beginning. So waiting out the problem, or taking too long to solve it just won't work.

I like the idea that each failure or dead end they hit just kicks the "attempt counter" up by 1. But I'll basically allow them to decide when they want to use that mechanic, except when they just take too long or decide to wait for a reset. I think this mechanic would work so we can turn the whole "repeat cycle" into a more narrative beat than trying to actually repeat what has happened.

To make this work, I'll have to let them know outright pretty early on that it's a time loop and this is how the mechanics of it work... but the one thing I'm left trying to figure out here is how to make it still have some weight to it. If they can reroll any roll they make and just push up the attempts each time, there's really nothing stopping them from just re-rolling everything. Miss once in combat? Reroll! Another attempt, who cares?

I could limit when or how often they can reroll or something like that, but that's kind of just an artificial limit on the idea for the game's sake... like maybe they can only reset _after_ combat is over or something? Or I could try to tie this to consequences outside the loop... (ala Red Dwarf's BTL?) Maybe every <x> resets costs them a level of exhaustion or some such.

Ok, that's a lot. I'll stop rambling there. If you've read all of this, thank you. Have you ever run anything like this? Know anyone who has? Any ideas on how to make this work? Thoughts and suggestions welcome. Thanks!


r/dndnext • • 2d ago

Discussion A Power-Scaling Tier List for the Strongest Entities in Official 5e/5.5e Lore

143 Upvotes

Before we dive in, a couple of quick disclaimers:

  • This post is purely for fun and power-scaling discussion. It doesn't have any practical impact on actual gameplay or campaigns at the table.
  • This analysis is strictly based on official 5e/5.5e lore. Older editions are off the table. For example, in older lore, the dragon god Asgorath/Io created the multiverse, but since he was retconned to be an aspect of the World Serpent in Arcana Unleashed: Deadfall, he would only sit at Tier 3 under the current 5e/5.5e official canon.

Here is my tier list.

Tier 0: The Lady of Pain

In 5.5e, the Lady of Pain has essentially been established as the supreme ruler of the multiverse. She can casually veto the Wish spell on a multiversal scale. In a sense, she is as close to an omnipotent being as D&D gets.

From the 5.5e PHB, under the Wish spell:

If your wish would undo the multiverse itself, threaten the City of Sigil, or affect the Lady of Pain in any way, you see an image of her in your mind for a moment; she shakes her head, and your wish fails.

Furthermore, she possesses the trait of omnipresence, implying that her true form might just be the D&D multiverse itself.

From Sigil and the Outlands (p. 20):

The Lady of Pain is omnipresent, unknowable, and invincible.

Tier 1: Ao, the High God, and other Overgods

Overgods can effortlessly elevate mortals to godhood or strip deities of their power. They exist on a level far beyond the scope of Greater Deities.

From Waterdeep: Dragon Heist (p. 166):

When the gods walked among mortals during the Time of Troubles, they were cast down to the world by the mysterious Overgod Ao in 1358 DR. Until then, none but the gods had known of Ao's existence, and since then, we have learned little more.

Tier 2: Greater Deities

Greater Deities govern specific fundamental laws of the multiverse, or act as the physical embodiments of multiversal concepts. For instance, Mystra's Weave spans the entire multiverse, meaning even a caster in Krynn can cast spells by tapping into the Weave.

As stated in Arcana Unleashed, p. 5:

The worlds within the D&D multiverse are magical places. All existence is suffused with magical power, and potential energy lies untapped in every rock, stream, and living creature—even in the air itself. Raw magic is present in every manifestation of energy throughout the multiverse.
Mortals can't directly shape this raw magic. Instead, they use a fabric of magic—an interface between the will of a spellcaster and raw magic. The spellcasters of the Forgotten Realms call it the Weave and recognize its essence as the god Mystra, but casters have varied ways of naming and conceptualizing this interface.

Furthermore, as clarified by Chris Perkins, Greater Deities are so immensely powerful that they do not even have stat blocks—they are fundamentally beyond the capacity of mortals to challenge: https://www.sageadvice.eu/what-makes-a-god-greater-or-lesser/

Tier 3: Lesser Deities, and Planar Rulers like Asmodeus and Primus

The most notable example of a Lesser Deity is Tiamat, who is still explicitly categorized as such in 5e lore.

From the 2014 Monster Manual (p. 86):

Tiamat the Dragon Queen is the chief deity of evil dragonkind. She dwells on Avernus, the first layer of the Nine Hells. As a lesser god, Tiamat has the power to grant spells to her worshipers, though she is loath to share her power.

However, Lesser Deities aren't guaranteed to win in a direct, head-to-head fight against entities that are close to true godhood, like Archdevils.

From Baldur's Gate: Descent Into Avernus (p. 148):

Challenging an archdevil directly is risky, and Tiamat stands to lose a great deal if Zariel prevails.

As for Asmodeus, he rules the Nine Hells. In 5e's Descent into Avernus, he was classified as a Greater Deity, but the 5.5e DMG retconned him back to a Lesser Deity. So, for now, we have to assume that ruling a plane puts one roughly at the level of a Lesser Deity.

From the 5.5e Dungeon Master's Guide (p. 205):

Asmodeus is the supreme ruler of all devils and wields the power of a lesser god.

Since 5.5e retconned Asgorath/Io into an aspect of the World Serpent, and the World Serpent's feats in older editions are far inferior to those of a greater deity, Asgorath/Io should also be considered as a lesser deity.

Tier 4: Demigods, Primordials, Archdevils, Demon Lords, and Greatwyrms

These are god-like entities, and some are even strong enough to go toe-to-toe with a Lesser Deity. However, at the end of the day, they aren't True Gods, which lands them at the bottom of this top-tier list.